Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
The distinction is that the goal is not to prove that any particular belief is true, but to claim that any belief may be true without any evidence.

That too is a pattern among fringe claimants. Most very quickly want to bog down in meta-debate over what evidence consists of and what are appropriate standards of proof. It takes a bit of experience to interpret this at the high level and recognize that the claimant is trying to contrive something that seems rigorous enough but avoids any meaningful scrutiny. He wants the standards set so low that even his flimsy nonsense is, by some circuitous construction, sufficient evidence.
 
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

My Dear Mr. Savage:

This is notbthe case, at all.

Two experts (one of whom you have reviled for years) examined the CIQ in situ, and determined that there was,no evidence, none, of an "invisible" reweave"; a "near-invisible" repair; nor even "...some patching; in fact, determined that the weave was undisturbed and contiguous (you, personally, admit that you lack this expertise)...
Slowvehicle,
- What exactly did these two experts do in their examination?
 
Slowvehicle,
- What exactly did these two experts do in their examination?

Jabba, try to get it: People are not likely to do your homework for you.

You are the one who wants to prove something; you do the work. Fair enough, isn't it?

Hans
 
Slowvehicle,
- What exactly did these two experts do in their examination?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

I find this remarkably disrespectful.

I thought you said you had read the .pdf.

It is clear you have not been reading my posts.

What part of "...examined in situ..." do you find opaque?

Go back, and read the .pdf, or the other sources on Mme. F-L that you claimed to be using when you claimed that she "doubted" the 14C dating. Or any one of my last several posts.

I remain,

Faithfully yours, &ct.
 
Last edited:
That's because you still don't recognize the difference between an inference and an observation. You're positioning Marino and Prior's speculation as if it were qualitatively on par with Flury-Lemberg's observation.

The order in which inference and observation occur is irrelevant; inferences made in defiance of established observation fail forthwith. To put this in the terms of the analogy, if you go out and stand on your dry sidewalk, hear thunder and infer it must be raining, then you're an idiot.
No, this is worse than that.

It's like you're standing on a dry sidewalk watching the clear blue skies, someone near you says they thought they heard distant thunder, and from that you infer that it must be raining right where you are.
 
This....

Slowvehicle,
- What exactly did these two experts do in their examination?

only serves to reaffirm this:

Apparently. Might have been. I think.

This is not the stuff of evidence; it is the stuff of speculation by a layman.

This topic is dead. It has ceased to be. It's not a Norwegian Blue, it's never going to come back, no matter how many volts you put through it.

What's more galling is we wouldn't have had to waste the past week getting to this point if you'd actually read the cited documents, before submitting them as evidence! I mean who does that? It's just intellectually, logically, and ethically bankrupt.
 
No, this is worse than that.

It's like you're standing on a dry sidewalk watching the clear blue skies, someone near you says they thought they heard distant thunder, and from that you infer that it must be raining right where you are.
And when you try to convince others that it's raining, they point out that that someone is deaf.
 
Discussion Format

If it's true you have reviled them for years, then you don't need to ask this question. You should already know.
Jay,
- I haven't reviled anyone. Ask Slowvehicle to provide examples.
 
Sideroxylon said:
Slowvehicle,
- What exactly did these two experts do in their examination?

- What exactly have you been doing over the course of your years researching the CIQ?
I do not say this in jest; it is an accurate description of all of Jabba's activities that have led him to believe that he is "the best man in the fight."

1. He has searched for headlines that indicated someone's ideas that the shroud is the authentic burial shroud of the biblical Jesus, avoided reading the actual material, and assumed it is true.

2. He has avoided searching for headlines indicating someone's actual research indicating that the shroud is not the authentic burial shroud of the biblical Jesus.

3. When he has, by chance, come across the items described in #2 despite trying to avoid them, he has avoided reading the actual material and assumed it is not true.
 
Jay,
- I haven't reviled anyone. Ask Slowvehicle to provide examples.

Ahem!
Walter McCrone. You said his work was suspect because he was difficult to work with.
Every 14C Scientists that worked on the CIQ. You called them dishonest and incompetent.
 
Last edited:
If it's true you have reviled them for years, then you don't need to ask this question. You should already know.

Oh, it's true. As Jabba has no evidence of a 2000 year old shroud impugning the reputation of the experts who have clearly demonstrated that the shroud is inauthentic (and scientists in general) was a favourite tactic a while ago. I dare say it'll come around again before too long.
 
This is an entirely valid question. From someone who is supposed to have spent a lot of time studying the CIQ, you don't seem to know much about it.

I haven't spent a great deal of time researching the TOS, but I believe I know more than Jabba about it.

It is an artwork from around 1300.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom