Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Exactly what the animation depicts. When you say "he abandons" I only see him changing planes -not the ones with wings-. He has managed to derail this thread repeatedly by turning 90 Escherian degrees to the right and addressing other poster in order to set the fake debate into its new direction to in turn do the same again. He derails the thread not by being not responsive or ambiguous, which is not a violation of the MA per se, but by making false promises deliberately: he feigns to yield and offers a promise of an argumentation just to repeat what he has spammed before -also a MA violation- to turn course again when he is being entrapped by his own empty argumentation.
These conceptual twists and turns reassure me that Jabba's claims of a poor memory and poor posting skills are overly self-critical and much overstated. His posts suggest a much more discerning approach and a more strategic vision than he is willing to give himself credit for. After some uncertainty I now believe that Jabba is able to advance his goals here even though convincing no one of the authenticity of the Shroud (or even "achieving" the opposite). Don't ever sell yourself short, Jabba!
 
These conceptual twists and turns reassure me that Jabba's claims of a poor memory and poor posting skills are overly self-critical and much overstated. [...]

It's nothing more than a random walk. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Random_walk

Mr Savage keeps bouncing around between the boundaries of his paradigm, defying laws of physics and logic. He never makes a point. He never makes progress.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment/M&P/Repair/#2

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I strongly recommend that you ever read this source, as a starting point.

Sincerely,

Yours, &ct.
Slowvehicle,
- As far as I can tell, the Flury-Lemberg paper does not specifically address the claims made in Entry #2 of the first M&P paper. While, M. Flury-Lemberg does present evidence against repair in her paper, she does not explain the evidence, apparently for repair, presented by M&P in Entry #2.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As far as I can tell, the Flury-Lemberg paper does not specifically address the claims made in Entry #2 of the first M&P paper. While, M. Flury-Lemberg does present evidence against repair in her paper, she does not explain the evidence, apparently for repair, presented by M&P in Entry #2.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Mme. F-L, whose opinions it pleases you to revile, examined the CIQ in great detail, by hand, in multiple light sources; according to her (and to others who have actually handled the CIQ) there is no evidence of any kind of "invisible" repair; nor yet a "near-invisible" repair, nor even "...some patching", as she (for instance) states, unambiguously (did you read the .pdf?).

Your "Entry #2" does not contain, or reference, or refer to, any evidence for any kind of "invisible" repair; nor yet a "near-invisible" repair, nor even "...some patching"; instead, it contains the speculation that there might be a supportable supposition that there may have been something of the sort.

What drives the supposition is not evidence, but the conviction that had there been some egregious inclusion in the 14C sample, that would explain why the 14C dating came back with the "wrong" date ("wrong" in the sense that the resulting date does not support ]he sidonist conviction that the CIQ must be the "true Shroud; ignoring all the other problems with the image on the sized and gessoed surface of the manifestly medieval linen).

Have you, in fact, any actual evidence?

I remain, faithfully,

Yours, &ct.
 
As far as I can tell, the Flury-Lemberg paper does not specifically address the claims made in Entry #2 of the first M&P paper.

Why is the first Marino and Prior paper now suddenly relevant again? You have not explained why you rejected it on the grounds it likely lacked rigor, but now seem to think it's okay again.

While, M. Flury-Lemberg does present evidence against repair in her paper, she does not explain the evidence, apparently for repair, presented by M&P in Entry #2.

Marino and Prior are not the relevant experts. Raes is the relevant expert. The argument for late-date "invisible" repair comes from Marino and Prior's commentary that (as with the previous entry) tries to bridge the huge gulf between what the expert Raes actually found and what they have claimed. As with the previous entry, you are simply passing off inexpert speculation as evidence. The Flury-Lemberg paper reinforces that Marino and Prior's inexpert imagination is both inapplicable and not likely to be correct.

Further, you previously expressed distrust in Marino and Prior as accurate reporters. Pursuant to that, you were asked to describe your familiarity with their sources so that your readers here could gauge your ability to defend the claims made in the paper according to the original sources. Can you please explain why you have not done that yet?
 
This thread is like a soap opera of the absurd. What preposterousness will Jabba pull next?
Well...

Slowvehicle,
- As far as I can tell, the Flury-Lemberg paper does not specifically address the claims made in Entry #2 of the first M&P paper. While, M. Flury-Lemberg does present evidence against repair in her paper, she does not explain the evidence, apparently for repair, presented by M&P in Entry #2.

Consider your question answered.

Jabba,

Raes was debunked by Gabriel Vial who found that the cotton, such as it was, was entirely superficial, by the fact that mixed fibers were verbotten in Israel 2kya and so forth.

We have done this to death already. Not to mention that you agreed that the M&P paper was unreliable just a few posts back.
 
Follow the little ball in #1871 and you'll get the answer.

That is the most irritating animated graphic I've ever seen. The guy who invented that is absolutely a genius at being tiresome.

And Jabba could give him aces and picture-cards and still come out way, way ahead.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment/M&P/Repair/#2

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Mme. F-L, whose opinions it pleases you to revile, examined the CIQ in great detail, by hand, in multiple light sources; according to her (and to others who have actually handled the CIQ) there is no evidence of any kind of "invisible" repair; nor yet a "near-invisible" repair, nor even "...some patching", as she (for instance) states, unambiguously (did you read the .pdf?).

Your "Entry #2" does not contain, or reference, or refer to, any evidence for any kind of "invisible" repair; nor yet a "near-invisible" repair, nor even "...some patching"; instead, it contains the speculation that there might be a supportable supposition that there may have been something of the sort...
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about weaving has been learned during the last few years --discussing the shroud. I've forgotten a lot of that, and another batch of it I never understood anyway... Consequently, at this point, I can't really judge the extent to which the info in this entry supports the notion of repair, or even just that something unusual has happened to the weave in this area.
- To a novice, such as myself, the info here does significantly suggest that there is something different about this area. You (and Agatha) seem to know a lot more about this stuff than do I -- so, I'll ask you a question similar to the one I asked Agatha. Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that something unusual has happened to the weave in that area?
 
Consequently, at this point, I can't really judge the extent to which the info in this entry supports the notion of repair...

Then your burden of proof remains unsatisfied.

To a novice, such as myself, the info here does significantly suggest that there is something different about this area.

No. You are not an expert, and this lay question-begging is entirely unprobative. And the disingenuous softening of position from "repair" to "different" or "unusual" did not go unnoticed. Do not attempt motte-and-bailey tactics or otherwise backpedal.

Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that something unusual has happened to the weave in that area?

I do not.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about weaving has been learned during the last few years --discussing the shroud. I've forgotten a lot of that, and another batch of it I never understood anyway... Consequently, at this point, I can't really judge the extent to which the info in this entry supports the notion of repair, or even just that something unusual has happened to the weave in this area.
- To a novice, such as myself, the info here does significantly suggest that there is something different about this area. You (and Agatha) seem to know a lot more about this stuff than do I -- so, I'll ask you a question similar to the one I asked Agatha. Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that something unusual has happened to the weave in that area?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It is distressingly clear that you did not, in fact, read the .pdf to which I provided you a link. I am, I admit, disappointed.

Let's try again.

Mme. F-L, whose opinions it pleases you to revile, examined the CIQ in great detail, by hand, in multiple light sources; according to her (and to others who have actually handled the CIQ) there is no evidence of any kind of "invisible" repair; nor yet a "near-invisible" repair, nor even "...some patching", as she (for instance) states, unambiguously.

In the .pdf to which I directed you, Mme. F-L says, "...Where exactly had the patch been attached? How big was it? Was it so small that it covered only the sample area? Answers to these questions are lacking in the hypothesis of Benford/Marino and Rogers. They can only be given in a competent way by textile experts. One of them, who was present when the sample was taken, the late Gabriel Vial, confirmed repeatedly that the sample was taken from the original cloth!"

Notice that the testimony of two fabric experts, experts who actually handled the CIQ (and examined it, front and back, in various light sources, including backlighting), is that there is no evidence of the "...patching..." sidonists so desperately try to assume into existence.

I encourage you, yet again, to consider why the possibility of "...some patching"; the conjecture of an "invisible" repair; the assumption that there "must be" something of the sort is raised.

Is it evidence, along the lines of, "...behold! there the linen was rent; see! here the "repair" was wrought; look here! these the modern threads admixed with the original linen"?

No.

The only reason the various repair stories have been concocted is that the most observed bit of 14C dating ever produced the "wrong" date; a date that did not align with the sidonists' presupposition that the CIQ must be "the True Shroud". Special pleading, circular argument, begging the question, assumed consequent; call it what you will, it is still faulty logic (and provides no evidence for any "...patching").

I will thank you not to try to put words in my mouth; not to try to frame a question so that you can pretend to an agreement I have repudiated.

In that light, have you repaired the egregious deficiencies in your "map"?
 
Last edited:
Let's try again.

The problem is not understanding the difference between an inference and an observation. Raes notes what he believes is cotton. From that, Marino and Prior infer that a patch may have been applied. It's one of several things that could have happened to explain traces of cotton on the sample. However, Flury-Lemberg observes that there is no patch. Observation trumps inference.

A simpler example: Let's say you're at home and you hear thunder. You infer that it must be raining, and further that if it's raining then your sidewalk may be wet. These are not unreasonable inferences. But if you open your front door and observe that, despite the rumblings, it is not raining and your sidewalk is not wet, then your inferential argument for sidewalk-wetness is conclusively refuted. It doesn't matter how clever the inference was.

Marino and Prior are not even clever. Once again they take what has been observed by others, and conjure up a conjectural connection to the desired conclusion out of thin air. (I was going to say "out of whole cloth," but I think that pun's been done to death.)
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about weaving has been learned during the last few years --discussing the shroud. I've forgotten a lot of that, and another batch of it I never understood anyway... Consequently, at this point, I can't really judge the extent to which the info in this entry supports the notion of repair, or even just that something unusual has happened to the weave in this area.

Then stop offering poorly-informed opinions about topics you don't understand. You're going to catch a lot of flak when you continue to do that. You're going to catch even more when you call acknowledged experts in the fields incompetent liars. You must have figured that out by now.

I would recommend asking non-loaded questions rather than making unevidenced claims, but I know you'll be back in a few days making more asinine, discredited assertions with no supporting evidence as if the last 4 years of Educating Jabba had never taken place.

[...] one I asked Agatha. Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that something unusual has happened to the weave in that area?

NO!
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about weaving has been learned during the last few years --discussing the shroud. I've forgotten a lot of that, and another batch of it I never understood anyway... Consequently, at this point, I can't really judge the extent to which the info in this entry supports the notion of repair, or even just that something unusual has happened to the weave in this area.
- To a novice, such as myself, the info here does significantly suggest that there is something different about this area. You (and Agatha) seem to know a lot more about this stuff than do I -- so, I'll ask you a question similar to the one I asked Agatha. Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that something unusual has happened to the weave in that area?

Hold on one cotton pickin' moment.

Back up the truck just a bit.

You are flat out asserting that you have not the faintest expertise yet everyone should accept your blesséd opinion as though it were remotely deliveréd from <insert deity of choice>.

You are flat out stating that in this regard you admit that you are innocent of any knowledge whatsoever and might as well be staring into a bush.

Is that now your claim?

Your answer is a resounding "No". Address Gabby Vial's findings.
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about weaving has been learned during the last few years --discussing the shroud. I've forgotten a lot of that, and another batch of it I never understood anyway... Consequently, at this point, I can't really judge the extent to which the info in this entry supports the notion of repair, or even just that something unusual has happened to the weave in this area.
- To a novice, such as myself, the info here does significantly suggest that there is something different about this area. You (and Agatha) seem to know a lot more about this stuff than do I -- so, I'll ask you a question similar to the one I asked Agatha. Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that something unusual has happened to the weave in that area?


Jabba, if you have an ounce of integrity, you will include this post on that embarrassing piece of work you call your 'map' on your website.:)
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about weaving has been learned during the last few years --discussing the shroud. I've forgotten a lot of that, and another batch of it I never understood anyway... Consequently, at this point, I can't really judge the extent to which the info in this entry supports the notion of repair, or even just that something unusual has happened to the weave in this area.
- To a novice, such as myself, the info here does significantly suggest that there is something different about this area. You (and Agatha) seem to know a lot more about this stuff than do I -- so, I'll ask you a question similar to the one I asked Agatha. Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that something unusual has happened to the weave in that area?

Nope.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom