Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
My Dear Mr. Savage:

I find this remarkably disrespectful.

I thought you said you had read the .pdf.

It is clear you have not been reading my posts.

What part of "...examined in situ..." do you find opaque?

Go back, and read the .pdf, or the other sources on Mme. F-L that you claimed to be using when you claimed that she "doubted" the 14C dating. Or any one of my last several posts.

I remain,

Faithfully yours, &ct.
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?
 
I beg to differ, if it was a deliberate work of art it then the art would be a lot better than it is. It's a slapdash bit of work by a huckster on the make.
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

You're the researcher into the shroud, you tell us
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

Jabba, this is deeply insulting! You are asking the opposition to dig up information and evidence for you! Are you totally mad?

Of all your antics, this takes the prize.

Hans
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

Why you expect anyone here to do your homework after 4 years of your shenanigans is beyond me.
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

So why do you think the CIQ is 2000 years old? You don't know any details about it.
 
All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies...

You've already confessed your incompetence. We don't need a detailed recitation of your failure to do the research required to understand your claims.

Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

He does, and he's given you the reference to the document that discusses it, which you obviously have not read. You get no more assistance than that. No one can press your face to the screen and make your eyeballs follow the text.

I have repeatedly asked you to what extent you are familiar with the sources used by your vaunted authors Marino and Prior. You have rudely ignored me. This latest intransigence all but confirms your deliberate unwillingness to acknowledge or answer that question. Since I've asked it several times, in posts you've quoted, I can't accept that you simply missed it. I have to conclude you don't want to answer it because, just as with the sources describing Flury-Lemberg, you're utterly unacquainted with them. You're relying upon those authors to do your homework for you, just as you're begging others here to do your homework for you.

There is no shortcut to erudition. You are not properly equipped to have this debate.
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Why, yes, I do know some of what Mme. F-L did when she examined the CIQ in situ, font and back, by hand an eye, in various light sources (including backlighting). Why do you ask? Much of her examination was discussed in the very source you used to pretend that Mme. F-L had "doubts" about the 14C dating (back when you were inverting the certainty of percentage).

One of the results of her tests is that Mme. F-L has stated, unequivocally, that the sampled area is part and parcel of the CIQ; that there is no evidence of the "...patching...", the invention of which you have embraced to try to rescue the manifestly medieval bit of linen from the "wrong" date resulting from the most observed instance of 14C dating ever.

As to reviling her, you (who have no experience with textiles at all) have accused her of incompetence, dishonesty, carelessness, duplicity, and complicity in nefarious conspiracy. How is that not more insulting than whatever secret you are keeping about however it is you claim I "insulted" you?

Through it all, I remain,

Faithfully yours, &ct.
 
You've already confessed your incompetence. We don't need a detailed recitation of your failure to do the research required to understand your claims.



He does, and he's given you the reference to the document that discusses it, which you obviously have not read. You get no more assistance than that. No one can press your face to the screen and make your eyeballs follow the text.

I have repeatedly asked you to what extent you are familiar with the sources used by your vaunted authors Marino and Prior. You have rudely ignored me. This latest intransigence all but confirms your deliberate unwillingness to acknowledge or answer that question. Since I've asked it several times, in posts you've quoted, I can't accept that you simply missed it. I have to conclude you don't want to answer it because, just as with the sources describing Flury-Lemberg, you're utterly unacquainted with them. You're relying upon those authors to do your homework for you, just as you're begging others here to do your homework for you.
There is no shortcut to erudition. You are not properly equipped to have this debate.

QFT
 
Slowvehicle said:
You've already confessed your incompetence. We don't need a detailed recitation of your failure to do the research required to understand your claims.



He does, and he's given you the reference to the document that discusses it, which you obviously have not read. You get no more assistance than that. No one can press your face to the screen and make your eyeballs follow the text.

I have repeatedly asked you to what extent you are familiar with the sources used by your vaunted authors Marino and Prior. You have rudely ignored me. This latest intransigence all but confirms your deliberate unwillingness to acknowledge or answer that question. Since I've asked it several times, in posts you've quoted, I can't accept that you simply missed it. I have to conclude you don't want to answer it because, just as with the sources describing Flury-Lemberg, you're utterly unacquainted with them. You're relying upon those authors to do your homework for you, just as you're begging others here to do your homework for you.
There is no shortcut to erudition. You are not properly equipped to have this debate.

QFT
Balderdash. I have my Facebook newsfeed. Works wonders. As proof I offer the fact that sometimes people Like what I post.
 
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

I admit to curiosity about this question.

Since, as you have admitted, you do not have any expertise with textiles; and since, as you have admitted, you do not understand the process of 14C dating; and since, as you have admitted, you do not understand why Rogers' qualitative (as opposed to quantitative) vanilin degradation protocol, performed unobserved (and unrepeatably) in his home kitchen (on specimens of dubious provenance) is probative of almost nothing; why is it that you are asking about what "tests or instruments" Mme. F-L employed?

It is enough, for your purposes, to know that (among other things) Mme. F-L handled the actual CIQ; and looked at the manifestly medieval linen from both sides (in multiple light sources, and even backlit). Her purpose in doing so was, among other things, to look for the evidence of any kind of patching, repair, reweave, or adulteration.

As you, yourself, admitted, even a so-called "invisible" reweaving leaves visible traces on the back of the rewoven fabric (the places where threads overlap, the places where the original threads are severed). That (among other things) is the kind of thing Mme. F-L was looking for.

Of course, all of that is made moot, for your purposes, by the fact ( a fact that you, yourself, provided) that an "invisible" reweave must be wrought with threads from the original cloth; which means that, even if an "invisible" reweave had been wrought it would not have, could not have, influenced the 14C dating (except to make the sample even more representative of the whole CIQ). All of this time you have spent hoping to be able to claim that some "expert" or another conjectures that there "may have been" some kind of repair has missed the point that such a "repair" wpould not have,could not have, affected the 14C dating.

Further, even if the 14C dating were as lame, halt, and invalid as you have wished for, you would still have to overcome the historical, scriptural, anatomical, postural, and physics-related inadequacies of the respresentational image presented on the sized and gessoed surface of the CIQ.

Here is a thought: instead of continuing to try to impugn the 14C dating, why not spend your energy presenting any evidence you can find that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

Through it all, I patiently remain,

Faithfully yours, &ct.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

I'm glad you recognize her as "an esteemed textile expert," but your question about "tests or implements" makes me curious. Are you suggesting that if she simply made a careful examination of the shroud sans backing cloth without performing some sort of scientific test using "implements" that she didn't properly "do a science"? The labs at Arizona, Oxford, and Zurich performed tests on the shroud using an accelerated mass spectrometer, which, as I understand it, is quite an impressive "implement," and you don't like those results at all.
 
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?

...He does, and he's given you the reference to the document that discusses it, which you obviously have not read. You get no more assistance than that. No one can press your face to the screen and make your eyeballs follow the text...

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Why, yes, I do know some of what Mme. F-L did when she examined the CIQ in situ, font and back, by hand an eye, in various light sources (including backlighting). Why do you ask? Much of her examination was discussed in the very source you used to pretend that Mme. F-L had "doubts" about the 14C dating (back when you were inverting the certainty of percentage)...
- You guys are partially right. I did know that "...she examined the CIQ in situ, font and back, by hand an eye, in various light sources (including backlighting)." But otherwise, she's claiming that any repair (except for the real invisible repair using the original cloth) can be detected by the naked eye. Yet, the study presented in Entry #2 claimed that when single threads from the Raes sample and C14 sample were examined under the microscope, certain anomalies did show up.
- Currently, I am doing the homework that everyone has suggested that I do, and I'll be back when I finish.
-
 
- You guys are partially right. I did know that "...she examined the CIQ in situ, font and back, by hand an eye, in various light sources (including backlighting)." But otherwise, she's claiming that any repair (except for the real invisible repair using the original cloth) can be detected by the naked eye. Yet, the study presented in Entry #2 claimed that when single threads from the Raes sample and C14 sample were examined under the microscope, certain anomalies did show up.
- Currently, I am doing the homework that everyone has suggested that I do, and I'll be back when I finish.
-
This is something that I explained (from personal experience in my my work) in one of the previous incarnations of this thread, but it, along with all the evidence on this thread, has been ignored.
 
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

...It is enough, for your purposes, to know that (among other things) Mme. F-L handled the actual CIQ; and looked at the manifestly medieval linen from both sides (in multiple light sources, and even backlit). Her purpose in doing so was, among other things, to look for the evidence of any kind of patching, repair, reweave, or adulteration...
Slowvehicle,
- Was she able to look at both sides before the carbon dating? I don't think she was...
- (I have to admit that if I find out that she wasn't, I'll make an unkind suggestion, but we humans (including Mme. F-L) are only human, and we 'seekers of the truth' shouldn't simply dismiss an unkind possibility about someone simply because it is unkind. That sounds familiar...)
 
Slowvehicle,
- Was she able to look at both sides before the carbon dating? I don't think she was...
- (I have to admit that if I find out that she wasn't, I'll make an unkind suggestion, but we humans (including Mme. F-L) are only human, and we 'seekers of the truth' shouldn't simply dismiss an unkind possibility about someone simply because it is unkind. That sounds familiar...)

What's with the cryptic talk? Can you say what you mean and mean what you say?

Time is up. You've admitted you need a miracle, which means you have abandoned any scientific leanings. Admit your position is based on faith.

I understand you love the idea of a thread going on ad vitam aeternam, but as a self professed christian, you should set the right example and try honesty.
 
[...]
- Currently, I am doing the homework that everyone has suggested that I do, and I'll be back when I finish.
-

I'll believe it when I see it. After all, why start now after 4 years of flying blind?

It's more likely that you'll come back with another red-herring.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Was she able to look at both sides before the carbon dating? I don't think she was...
- (I have to admit that if I find out that she wasn't, I'll make an unkind suggestion, but we humans (including Mme. F-L) are only human, and we 'seekers of the truth' shouldn't simply dismiss an unkind possibility about someone simply because it is unkind. That sounds familiar...)

You've slandered people in the past without any reluctance. Why change that pattern now?

For the record, you've never been a seeker of the truth in regard to the CIQ. You've been a seeker of anything to support your pre-conceived conclusion of authenticity.
 
- You guys are partially right. I did know that "...she examined the CIQ in situ, font and back, by hand an eye, in various light sources (including backlighting)." But otherwise, she's claiming that any repair (except for the real invisible repair using the original cloth) can be detected by the naked eye. Yet, the study presented in Entry #2 claimed that when single threads from the Raes sample and C14 sample were examined under the microscope, certain anomalies did show up.
- Currently, I am doing the homework that everyone has suggested that I do, and I'll be back when I finish.
-

Again you are grotesquely dishonest. You asked someone who carries out "invisible repairs" and they told you that the repairs use the original thread and, not "or," AND are detectable from the front under careful study and are bleeding obvious from the back.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom