Slowvehicle,
- All I know about Flury-Lemberg's various studies is that they involved the whole shroud, itself, and that she is an esteemed textile expert. Do you know what tests or implements her examinations included?
My Dear Mr. Savage:
I admit to curiosity about
this question.
Since, as you have admitted, you do not have any expertise with textiles; and since, as you have admitted, you do not understand the process of
14C dating; and since, as you have admitted, you do not understand why Rogers'
qualitative (as opposed to quantitative) vanilin degradation protocol, performed unobserved (and unrepeatably) in his home kitchen (on specimens of dubious provenance) is probative of almost nothing; why is it that you are asking about
what "tests or instruments" Mme. F-L employed?
It is enough, for your purposes, to know that (among other things) Mme. F-L
handled the actual CIQ; and
looked at the manifestly medieval linen
from both sides (in multiple light sources, and even backlit). Her
purpose in doing so was, among other things, to
look for the evidence of any kind of patching, repair, reweave, or adulteration.
As you, yourself, admitted, even a so-called "invisible" reweaving leaves
visible traces
on the back of the rewoven fabric (the places where threads overlap, the places where the original threads are severed). That (among other things) is the kind of thing Mme. F-L was looking for.
Of course, all of that is made moot, for your purposes, by the fact ( a fact that you, yourself, provided) that an "invisible" reweave
must be wrought with threads
from the original cloth; which means that,
even if an "invisible" reweave had been wrought it would not have, could not have, influenced the
14C dating (except to make the sample even more representative of the whole CIQ). All of this time you have spent hoping to be able to claim that some "expert" or another
conjectures that there "may have been" some kind of repair has
missed the point that such a "repair" wpould not have,could not have, affected the
14C dating.
Further, even if the
14C dating were as lame, halt, and invalid as you have wished for, you would still have to overcome the historical, scriptural, anatomical, postural, and physics-related inadequacies of the respresentational image presented on the
sized and
gessoed surface of the CIQ.
Here is a thought: instead of continuing to try to impugn the
14C dating, why not spend your energy presenting any evidence you can find that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?
Through it all, I patiently remain,
Faithfully yours, &ct.