Jabba
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2012
- Messages
- 5,613
Evidence - Expert Judgment/M&P/Repair/#2
- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.
Slowvehicle,My Dear Mr. Savage:
It is distressingly clear that you did not, in fact, read the .pdf to which I provided you a link. I am, I admit, disappointed.
Let's try again.
Mme. F-L, whose opinions it pleases you to revile, examined the CIQ in great detail, by hand, in multiple light sources; according to her (and to others who have actually handled the CIQ) there is no evidence of any kind of "invisible" repair; nor yet a "near-invisible" repair, nor even "...some patching", as she (for instance) states, unambiguously.
In the .pdf to which I directed you, Mme. F-L says, "...Where exactly had the patch been attached? How big was it? Was it so small that it covered only the sample area? Answers to these questions are lacking in the hypothesis of Benford/Marino and Rogers. They can only be given in a competent way by textile experts. One of them, who was present when the sample was taken, the late Gabriel Vial, confirmed repeatedly that the sample was taken from the original cloth!"
Notice that the testimony of two fabric experts, experts who actually handled the CIQ (and examined it, front and back, in various light sources, including backlighting), is that there is no evidence of the "...patching..." sidonists so desperately try to assume into existence.
I encourage you, yet again, to consider why the possibility of "...some patching"; the conjecture of an "invisible" repair; the assumption that there "must be" something of the sort is raised.
Is it evidence, along the lines of, "...behold! there the linen was rent; see! here the "repair" was wrought; look here! these the modern threads admixed with the original linen"?
No.
The only reason the various repair stories have been concocted is that the most observed bit of 14C dating ever produced the "wrong" date; a date that did not align with the sidonists' presupposition that the CIQ must be "the True Shroud". Special pleading, circular argument, begging the question, assumed consequent; call it what you will, it is still faulty logic (and provides no evidence for any "...patching").
I will thank you not to try to put words in my mouth; not to try to frame a question so that you can pretend to an agreement I have repudiated.
In that light, have you repaired the egregious deficiencies in your "map"?
- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.