Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Evidence - Expert Judgment/M&P/Repair/#2

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It is distressingly clear that you did not, in fact, read the .pdf to which I provided you a link. I am, I admit, disappointed.

Let's try again.

Mme. F-L, whose opinions it pleases you to revile, examined the CIQ in great detail, by hand, in multiple light sources; according to her (and to others who have actually handled the CIQ) there is no evidence of any kind of "invisible" repair; nor yet a "near-invisible" repair, nor even "...some patching", as she (for instance) states, unambiguously.

In the .pdf to which I directed you, Mme. F-L says, "...Where exactly had the patch been attached? How big was it? Was it so small that it covered only the sample area? Answers to these questions are lacking in the hypothesis of Benford/Marino and Rogers. They can only be given in a competent way by textile experts. One of them, who was present when the sample was taken, the late Gabriel Vial, confirmed repeatedly that the sample was taken from the original cloth!"

Notice that the testimony of two fabric experts, experts who actually handled the CIQ (and examined it, front and back, in various light sources, including backlighting), is that there is no evidence of the "...patching..." sidonists so desperately try to assume into existence.

I encourage you, yet again, to consider why the possibility of "...some patching"; the conjecture of an "invisible" repair; the assumption that there "must be" something of the sort is raised.

Is it evidence, along the lines of, "...behold! there the linen was rent; see! here the "repair" was wrought; look here! these the modern threads admixed with the original linen"?

No.

The only reason the various repair stories have been concocted is that the most observed bit of 14C dating ever produced the "wrong" date; a date that did not align with the sidonists' presupposition that the CIQ must be "the True Shroud". Special pleading, circular argument, begging the question, assumed consequent; call it what you will, it is still faulty logic (and provides no evidence for any "...patching").

I will thank you not to try to put words in my mouth; not to try to frame a question so that you can pretend to an agreement I have repudiated.

In that light, have you repaired the egregious deficiencies in your "map"?
Slowvehicle,
- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.
 
Slowvehicle,
- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.


YES. IT. DOES! Entry#2 has been eviscerated. The pro-repair pan is empty.
 
Slowvehicle,
- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It seems to me that you are saying that the unsupported conjecture about superficial bits of cotton should be taken at greater value than the expert physical examination of the CIQ itself, in situ, which revealed no evidence of any kind of "...patching...".

You are grasping at straws.

#2 provides no support for your hopes.

I remain,

Faithfully yours &ct.
 
Slowvehicle,
- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.
Untrue. Your desperate need to believe doesn't alter reality. There is no magic patch.
 
Slowvehicle,

- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.


Whilst M. Flury-Lemberg's paper does not contain a direct response to "entry #2", it does address the issue. She stated quite clearly and unequivocally that there is no patching or repair of any kind in the area that was tested.

This is the conclusion of a world renowned expert in ancient and mediaeval textiles who got to examine the cloth in painstaking detail. This conclusion was backed up by by Vial, another textiles expert, who was present when the sample was cut.

The Raes sample was from a different area of the cloth, close by, but not the piece that was used for Carbon dating. Also, Raes' observations relate to a side strip which was clearly sewn on to the main cloth, which is not the case for the Carbon tested sample.

So, no, Entry #2 cannot go in the pro- repair pan, it goes in the waste pan.
 
- I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2. That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.


Even without the Flury-Lemberg paper, it doesn't go in the "pro-repair pan"* because you're jumping from "there might have been a patch near the sample" to "the sample was patched".



*On the positive side, at least you seem to have stopped pretending that evidence in favour of repairs is evidence in favour of authenticity.
 
I have read M. Flury-Lemberg's paper, but as far as I can tell, she doesn't address the issues raised by Entry #2.

Straw man. The citation to Flury-Lemberg was not intended as a direct response to Marino and Prior, as you seem to believe. It is intended to convey observations made by subject-matter experts that are incompatible and inconsistent with the tenuous inferences drawn by your authors.

You were told the difference between an inference and observation. The Flury-Lemberg paper is a direct affirmative rebuttal -- observational evidence that the conjectured conclusion cannot be true.

That being the case, Entry #2 should remain in the pro-repair pan.

No. Your unwillingness to listen to the rebuttal does not make it go away.

Observations that directly contradict inferences drawn by your authors do not let those inferences stand. Those observations have been shown to you, and you have no answer for them except denial.

Further, your point fails for reasons other than those mentioned in Flury-Lemberg, not the least of which is your admission that you aren't competent yourself to determine whether it's viable evidence. You may not demand that your critics have a lower standard of proof that you do yourself for your own claims.

Other reasons include the obvious conjecture propounded by Marino and Prior -- authors you estimate to be poor (nay, even deceptive) reporters of fact. It is that conjecture once again, not any finding by the cited experts, that forms the only connection between the data reported and the alleged claim of a repair.

In addition, your authors make no tenable argument for their claim the allegedly variant area was included in the carbon-dated sample. They simply conclude, on no stronger basis than their fervent wish, that it's reasonable to believe the two areas are related. Toward that end you've tried to soften the conclusion in no. 2 to make it easier for you to prove. Now you ask only that your critics agree the area is "unusual" or "different," as if that proposition had any rational relation to your assertive claims of repair. Changing horses in that fashion is intellectually dishonest.

You are simply trying the same lame rehabilitation you attempted with Delorenzi. When the facts clearly show your authors' claims to be unfounded, you assert that their speculation should "somehow" still be considered evidence. If your blatant begging of the question is to be your sole defense of this paper, then save us all the trouble and abandon it again.

I grow tired of asking why, in light of the doubt you express in the honesty and trustworthiness of Marino and Prior, you have not allayed the suspicion by indicating your familiarity with their source material before continuing to present their claims as fact. It is highly insulting for you to persistently evade intellectual responsibility in this fashion.
 
Carbon Dating/Doubts/Repair?/M&P/Entry #2

The problem is not understanding the difference between an inference and an observation. Raes notes what he believes is cotton. From that, Marino and Prior infer that a patch may have been applied. It's one of several things that could have happened to explain traces of cotton on the sample. However, Flury-Lemberg observes that there is no patch. Observation trumps inference.

A simpler example: Let's say you're at home and you hear thunder. You infer that it must be raining, and further that if it's raining then your sidewalk may be wet. These are not unreasonable inferences. But if you open your front door and observe that, despite the rumblings, it is not raining and your sidewalk is not wet, then your inferential argument for sidewalk-wetness is conclusively refuted. It doesn't matter how clever the inference was.

Marino and Prior are not even clever. Once again they take what has been observed by others, and conjure up a conjectural connection to the desired conclusion out of thin air. (I was going to say "out of whole cloth," but I think that pun's been done to death.)
Jay,

- It seems to me that the example you give about hearing thunder is not analogous to finding cotton in the sample.

- In the thunder example you have one person hearing thunder and inferring that it might be raining. When he actually goes outside, he perceives no rain and no wetness. Unless there is something wrong with his perception, which seems very unlikely, he can dismiss his previous speculation.
- In the entry #2 example, we've already had two experts looking closely at the shroud, and from their perception infer that the shroud has not been repaired in the sample. Then, we have experts apparently looking more closely at the sample, perceiving something the previous experts did not perceive, and inferring from their new perceptions, that the sample was -- or at least, might have been -- repaired.

- I think that giving titles to the sections and subsections of our complicated debate could be very useful, but at this point, I don't know how to do it effectively. I think I should have been more careful laying out the groundwork.
 
Jay,

- It seems to me that the example you give about hearing thunder is not analogous to finding cotton in the sample.

- In the thunder example you have one person hearing thunder and inferring that it might be raining. When he actually goes outside, he perceives no rain and no wetness. Unless there is something wrong with his perception, which seems very unlikely, he can dismiss his previous speculation.
- In the entry #2 example, we've already had two experts looking closely at the shroud, and from their perception infer that the shroud has not been repaired in the sample. Then, we have experts apparently looking more closely at the sample, perceiving something the previous experts did not perceive, and inferring from their new perceptions, that the sample was -- or at least, might have been -- repaired.

- I think that giving titles to the sections and subsections of our complicated debate could be very useful, but at this point, I don't know how to do it effectively. I think I should have been more careful laying out the groundwork.

Do you even phrase your sentences in a way that implies any sort of certainty?
 
Jay,

- It seems to me that the example you give about hearing thunder is not analogous to finding cotton in the sample.

- In the thunder example you have one person hearing thunder and inferring that it might be raining. When he actually goes outside, he perceives no rain and no wetness. Unless there is something wrong with his perception, which seems very unlikely, he can dismiss his previous speculation.
- In the entry #2 example, we've already had two experts looking closely at the shroud, and from their perception infer that the shroud has not been repaired in the sample.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

This is notbthe case, at all.

Two experts (one of whom you have reviled for years) examined the CIQ in situ, and determined that there was,no evidence, none, of an "invisible" reweave"; a "near-invisible" repair; nor even "...some patching; in fact, determined that the weave was undisturbed and contiguous (you, personally, admit that you lack this expertise).

Mme F-L even raised some of the very points I have raised, and others have raised, about the non-existence of any of the adulterations for which you so desperately wish.

Then, we have experts apparently looking more closely at the sample,

I invite you to present evidence of this.

perceiving something the previous experts did not perceive, and inferring from their new perceptions, that the sample was -- or at least, might have been -- repaired.

1. "Might have been" does not outweigh "there is no evidence for"; no matter how fervently you wish.

2. Mme. F-L "did not perceive" that there "might have been" the "repair" you need to support your unhappiness with the most observed bit of 14C dating ever, because she saw that there was no evidence of such at all. She observed that the sample was an authentic, representative, and integral part of the CIQ.

- I think that giving titles to the sections and subsections of our complicated debate could be very useful, but at this point, I don't know how to do it effectively. I think I should have been more careful laying out the groundwork.

I think you should actually produce evidence, and stop trying to imply support for your assumed consequent.

I remain,

Faithfully yours, &ct.
 
Whilst M. Flury-Lemberg's paper does not contain a direct response to "entry #2", it does address the issue. She stated quite clearly and unequivocally that there is no patching or repair of any kind in the area that was tested.

This is the conclusion of a world renowned expert in ancient and mediaeval textiles who got to examine the cloth in painstaking detail. This conclusion was backed up by by Vial, another textiles expert, who was present when the sample was cut.

The Raes sample was from a different area of the cloth, close by, but not the piece that was used for Carbon dating. Also, Raes' observations relate to a side strip which was clearly sewn on to the main cloth, which is not the case for the Carbon tested sample.

So, no, Entry #2 cannot go in the pro- repair pan, it goes in the waste pan.

Quoted because Jabba ignored this.
 
Jay,

- It seems to me that the example you give about hearing thunder is not analogous to finding cotton in the sample.

- In the thunder example you have one person hearing thunder and inferring that it might be raining. When he actually goes outside, he perceives no rain and no wetness. Unless there is something wrong with his perception, which seems very unlikely, he can dismiss his previous speculation.
- In the entry #2 example, we've already had two experts looking closely at the shroud, and from their perception infer that the shroud has not been repaired in the sample. Then, we have experts apparently looking more closely at the sample, perceiving something the previous experts did not perceive, and inferring from their new perceptions, that the sample was -- or at least, might have been -- repaired.

- I think that giving titles to the sections and subsections of our complicated debate could be very useful, but at this point, I don't know how to do it effectively. I think I should have been more careful laying out the groundwork.


Jabba,

I'm having a more and more difficult time deciding if you really do have difficulty understanding or are deliberately being combative. Your statement above is grossly unrepresentative of the situation. Jay's analogy was spot on. F-L is equivalent to the person going outside to look at the sidewalk. She handled and observed the cloth and specifically looked for the presence of repairs. M&P did not observe any repairs. They only inferred this based on the presence of cotton. Observation trumps inference.
 
Jay,

- It seems to me that the example you give about hearing thunder is not analogous to finding cotton in the sample.

Jabba, that just simply increases your burden of proof. You now have to not only claim but demonstrate that not a single one of the centuries of caretakers at any time deposited cotton fibres on the cloth.
 
It seems to me that the example you give about hearing thunder is not analogous to finding cotton in the sample.

That's because you still don't recognize the difference between an inference and an observation. You're positioning Marino and Prior's speculation as if it were qualitatively on par with Flury-Lemberg's observation.

The order in which inference and observation occur is irrelevant; inferences made in defiance of established observation fail forthwith. To put this in the terms of the analogy, if you go out and stand on your dry sidewalk, hear thunder and infer it must be raining, then you're an idiot.

...that the sample was -- or at least, might have been -- repaired.

Marino and Prior's hypothesis that Raes et al.'s findings are best explained by a repair is an inference. Flury-Lemberg's findings that no repair is visible is an observation.

Raes did not say the cloth was patched in the way Marino and Prior insinuate. He was looking at a part of the cloth where sewing was expected as part of its original manufacture. Marino and Prior, who are not experts and who did not examine the material themselves, characterize Raes' findings as anomalies and concoct a purely wishful hypothesis to explain those anomalies as evidence of a repair. As you have been told many times, such speculation is no kind of evidence. Your argument fails both as a matter of fact and a matter of logic.

The other aspect of Mme. Flury-Lemberg's findings you haven't considered is its effect on your desire to posture Marino and Prior's chronology as a consilient set of evidence. Remember that consilience is a qualitative measure, not a scoreboard. And the qualitative aspect of a line of evidence that is to be taken as consilient is the development of it in isolation such that the overall proposition arises from it as the most independently viable interpretation.

Here the overall proposition doesn't arise from it at all. It is ham-fistedly pasted onto it by Marino and Prior, and you have already conceded you are not able to argue its fitness. Hence you have already conceded that this point is anti-consilient. And after estimating Marino and Prior to be less-than-honest reporters, and advancing the notion that they considered their chronology debunked enough for you to abandon it, you have yet to explain why your critics should esteem it at all.

Finally, how do you advise me to interpret your ongoing insolence in failing to disclose your proficiency with Marino and Prior's source materials?
 
Last edited:
Then, we have experts apparently looking more closely at the sample,

I invite you to present evidence of this.
And this ("experts"--I couldn't figure out how to highlight in a different color), assuming we're talking about Marino and Prior versus Flury-Lemberg. What expertise does Marino have? I see he used to monk professionally at St. Louis Priory. I have friends who went to school there. I asked them what he taught. He didn't teach; he worked in the library. When he gave up monking, he became a library associate at Ohio State University. A library associate is not a librarian or a research librarian. Generally, they are required to have a bachelor's degree in...some field or other. So, if I understand this correctly, Marino hasn't inspected the shroud and isn't a specialist in any field. If Jabba has more information on Marino's area of expertise, I'd be thrilled to hear it.
 
And this ("experts"--I couldn't figure out how to highlight in a different color), assuming we're talking about Marino and Prior versus Flury-Lemberg.

I assumed he was talking about Rogers and Raes. In any case it's the same hair-split as before. Some authority says something, and it is Marino and Prior who warp it into something that seems to support their contention of an invisible repair. The operant claim comes from the inexpert Marino, while the irrelevant information (and assumed authority) come from someone else.

This is actually a fairly common pattern in fringe argumentation.
 
I assumed he was talking about Rogers and Raes. In any case it's the same hair-split as before. Some authority says something, and it is Marino and Prior who warp it into something that seems to support their contention of an invisible repair. The operant claim comes from the inexpert Marino, while the irrelevant information (and assumed authority) come from someone else.

This is actually a fairly common pattern in fringe argumentation.

Further deserving of continued emphasis is the fact that none of the conjectures and wishes about any kind of adulteration are dirven by the presence of any "...patching..." but by the desperate need to invent some way to discredit the 14C dating, since it returned the "wrong" date.
 
I assumed he was talking about Rogers and Raes. In any case it's the same hair-split as before.
You assumed in error. Jabba appears not to care. And this is despite you, me and all the other heathens telling him out front that none this has any effect on whichever flavour of deity he elects to believe in.

If Jabba were to declare that he believed in Thor, or unicorns, or dragons or flower fairies, would the discussion change in any way? Nope.

The distinction is that the goal is not to prove that any particular belief is true, but to claim that any belief may be true without any evidence.

Taking Jabba's arguments at face value, all of them are true.
 
Jay,

- It seems to me that the example you give about hearing thunder is not analogous to finding cotton in the sample.

- In the thunder example you have one person hearing thunder and inferring that it might be raining. When he actually goes outside, he perceives no rain and no wetness. Unless there is something wrong with his perception, which seems very unlikely, he can dismiss his previous speculation.
- In the entry #2 example, we've already had two experts looking closely at the shroud, and from their perception infer that the shroud has not been repaired in the sample. Then, we have experts apparently looking more closely at the sample, perceiving something the previous experts did not perceive, and inferring from their new perceptions, that the sample was -- or at least, might have been -- repaired.

- I think that giving titles to the sections and subsections of our complicated debate could be very useful, but at this point, I don't know how to do it effectively. I think I should have been more careful laying out the groundwork.

Apparently. Might have been. I think.

This is not the stuff of evidence; it is the stuff of speculation by a layman.

This topic is dead. It has ceased to be. It's not a Norwegian Blue, it's never going to come back, no matter how many volts you put through it.

What's more galling is we wouldn't have had to waste the past week getting to this point if you'd actually read the cited documents, before submitting them as evidence! I mean who does that? It's just intellectually, logically, and ethically bankrupt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom