Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- You guys are partially right. I did know that "...she examined the CIQ in situ, font and back, by hand an eye, in various light sources (including backlighting)." But otherwise, she's claiming that any repair (except for the real invisible repair using the original cloth) can be detected by the naked eye. Yet, the study presented in Entry #2 claimed that when single threads from the Raes sample and C14 sample were examined under the microscope, certain anomalies did show up.

You are not an expert in textiles. You do not know the best way to detect whether a cloth has been patched. You just beg the question that a microscopic examination of fibers is somehow more revealing or probative. Even in the best of circumstances, "anomalies" are not even remotely the same thing as "patch." Marino and Prior are simply once again extending flimsy findings far beyond what is possible to know from them.
 
- You guys are partially right. I did know that "...she examined the CIQ in situ, font and back, by hand an eye, in various light sources (including backlighting)." But otherwise, she's claiming that any repair (except for the real invisible repair using the original cloth ) can be detected by the naked eye. Yet, the study presented in Entry #2 claimed that when single threads from the Raes sample and C14 sample were examined under the microscope, certain anomalies did show up.
- Currently, I am doing the homework that everyone has suggested that I do, and I'll be back when I finish.
-

My Dear Mr. Savage:

This bit is, generously, an error. The very information you, yourself, provided about the "French" reweave (or the "invisible" reweave) stated outright that it could always be seen, by the naked eye, from the back of the fabric.

Perhaps you would be so kind as to quote, specifically, with citation, where Mme. F-L makes the claim that "...any repair (except for the real invisible repair using the original cloth ) can be detected by the naked eye. " I, for one, do not believe that she ever said that, or implied it.

Not to mention, do you know what in situ means?

If there were, in fact, "certain anomalies" between threads obsevred to be taken from a contiguous bit of the manifestly medieval linen, and threads removed form the linen and handled in various ways by numerous people, of which of the threads would an honest researched be more suspect?
 
...we humans (including Mme. F-L) are only human...

You don't get to simply insinuate that she must be in error. If you believe she erred in her findings, you must prove it. And judging from the past incarnations of this topic in this thread, you are patently unable to do so.

Further, the human errors (I daresay deliberate falsehoods) of your authors Marino and Prior have been belabored and acknowledged by you. Yet you resist any and all attempts to examine the authors you have postured as a credible summary of expert testimony. Your suspicion is flagrantly one-sided.

...and we 'seekers of the truth' shouldn't...

You behave in no way as a seeker of truth. You behave in every way like someone desperate to prove a certain point at any cost, and wild unfounded aspersions ignorantly cast seems to be one of your common tricks.

That sounds familiar...)

Elaborate.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Was she able to look at both sides before the carbon dating? I don't think she was...
- (I have to admit that if I find out that she wasn't, I'll make an unkind suggestion, but we humans (including Mme. F-L) are only human, and we 'seekers of the truth' shouldn't simply dismiss an unkind possibility about someone simply because it is unkind. That sounds familiar...)

My dear Mr. Savage:

Are you going to suggest that the sampled area was ALL "...some patching", and that ALL of the "...patching" was taken up in the sample, leaving NONE on the CIQ itself; that the ENTIRE SAMPLE consisted of "...patching", and that NO ONE NOTICED the "...patching" while handling the sample?

You sir, have admitted that you are not a weaver, and have demonstrated that you do not understand fabric. I am a weaver, and a seamster. I understand fabric. I assure you that, had there been the kind of tapered and lapped "invisible" reweaving you keel hoping for, the very act of cutting through it would have been texturally patent.

You are grasping at straws, demonstrating once again that you are not seeking the truth about the CIQ, but seeking to support your assumed consequent.

You might also question whether you have the experience, the expertise, and the knowledge (not to mention the impartiality) to comment on Mme. F-L's abilities. You have already reviled her. You have already accused her of scientific misconduct, personal dishonesty, stupidity, cupidity, and incompetence. It is clear that you dislike her findings. What is not clear is whether you understand why insulting her does your case for your assumed consequent no good at all.

I also find it odd that you, who are so invested in your punctillio that you cannot even bear to identify how you, personally, claim to have been insulted, seem to be relishing and anticipating the mere possibility of saying something "unkind" about Mme. F-L.

Why not spend your time marshaling, and presenting, any skerrick of evidence you have that positively indicates that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?
 
Jabba,

The following quote comes to mind:

There are none so blind as those who will not see.

In case you're wondering who I might be referring to here, it's you!

I thought for a moment you were saying the experts couldn't see the invisible patch as they were blinded by their Godless biases.
 
Jabba,

There are now 1,968 replies in this 4th iteration of the CIQ authenticity debate.

The best thing we have to look forward to is a fifth iteration, because you are getting nowhere.

Any response?
 
What's with the cryptic talk? Can you say what you mean and mean what you say?

Time is up. You've admitted you need a miracle, which means you have abandoned any scientific leanings. Admit your position is based on faith.

I understand you love the idea of a thread going on ad vitam aeternam, but as a self professed christian, you should set the right example and try honesty.

In Jabba's defence, he isn't a self-professed Christian. He is a wanna-be Christian. That is, he can only be a Christian if Jesus really was who he said he was. Jabba was never specific about what exactly Jesus said about himself, but I suppose it was the word, the truth, and the way thing, whatever that means. Jabba can correct me if I'm wrong.

From that and from Jabba's occasional self-confessional posts, I got the impression that he needs the resurrection story to be true because he has some end-of-life issues and really wants to believe that he is somehow going to survive his own death. After all, if Jesus did, then why can't he? (Insert some silly Bayesian mental gymnastics here).

I've been following this thread and its previous incarnations and offshoots since 2012 and have been vastly entertained and educated by it. Thank you to those who possess more patience and forbearance than I currently have.

Back to lurking.
 
In Jabba's defence, he isn't a self-professed Christian. He is a wanna-be Christian. That is, he can only be a Christian if Jesus really was who he said he was. Jabba was never specific about what exactly Jesus said about himself, but I suppose it was the word, the truth, and the way thing, whatever that means. Jabba can correct me if I'm wrong.

From that and from Jabba's occasional self-confessional posts, I got the impression that he needs the resurrection story to be true because he has some end-of-life issues and really wants to believe that he is somehow going to survive his own death. After all, if Jesus did, then why can't he? (Insert some silly Bayesian mental gymnastics here).

I've been following this thread and its previous incarnations and offshoots since 2012 and have been vastly entertained and educated by it. Thank you to those who possess more patience and forbearance than I currently have.

Back to lurking.

Before you go, has Jabba presented anything to make you think the shroud is authentic?
 
In Jabba's defence, he isn't a self-professed Christian. He is a wanna-be Christian. That is, he can only be a Christian if Jesus really was who he said he was. Jabba was never specific about what exactly Jesus said about himself, but I suppose it was the word, the truth, and the way thing, whatever that means. Jabba can correct me if I'm wrong.

From that and from Jabba's occasional self-confessional posts, I got the impression that he needs the resurrection story to be true because he has some end-of-life issues and really wants to believe that he is somehow going to survive his own death. After all, if Jesus did, then why can't he? (Insert some silly Bayesian mental gymnastics here).

I've been following this thread and its previous incarnations and offshoots since 2012 and have been vastly entertained and educated by it. Thank you to those who possess more patience and forbearance than I currently have.

Back to lurking.

I agree with what you said.

By now, Jabba should have realised that this "discussion" is doing him no good whatsoever personally.

For his own beliefs, this place is the wrong place...
 
Slowvehicle,
- Was she able to look at both sides before the carbon dating? I don't think she was...
- (I have to admit that if I find out that she wasn't, I'll make an unkind suggestion, but we humans (including Mme. F-L) are only human, and we 'seekers of the truth' shouldn't simply dismiss an unkind possibility about someone simply because it is unkind. That sounds familiar...)

We can safely dismiss any notion that you are seeking the truth.
 
Before you go, has Jabba presented anything to make you think the shroud is authentic?

No. I don't think he really does either, judging by all the waffling he does when he's really pressed to the wall. More than once I've seen him concede a point but then immediately retract it, sometimes even within the same sentence. It seems like such an odd thing to hang one's (wanna-be) religious hat on, when most of the religious people I know are content with something more personal like faith.

Back on topic, I was okay with the carbon-14 dating when it first came out, and other evidence presented in this thread and its previous incarnations have pretty much cemented my opinion that it's a medieval relic. It would take more than waffles to convince me otherwise.
 
No. I don't think he really does either, judging by all the waffling he does when he's really pressed to the wall. More than once I've seen him concede a point but then immediately retract it, sometimes even within the same sentence. It seems like such an odd thing to hang one's (wanna-be) religious hat on, when most of the religious people I know are content with something more personal like faith.

Back on topic, I was okay with the carbon-14 dating when it first came out, and other evidence presented in this thread and its previous incarnations have pretty much cemented my opinion that it's a medieval relic. It would take more than waffles to convince me otherwise.

Even if you could have waffles with anything? :)

Oh - and welcome!
 
:rolleyes:
No. I don't think he really does either, judging by all the waffling he does when he's really pressed to the wall. More than once I've seen him concede a point but then immediately retract it, sometimes even within the same sentence. It seems like such an odd thing to hang one's (wanna-be) religious hat on, when most of the religious people I know are content with something more personal like faith.

Yeah, welcome! :)

Actually, I don't for one moment believe that Jabba is trying to find Jesus this way. It's just the same tactics as others we have seen coming on here saying "I am a firm skeptic, but I just need an explanation for ......"

It just gets a bit stale after so long. Jabba is a firm believer and is looking for something he can use to impress people who doubt. Not with much success, I might add... :rolleyes:

Hans
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom