Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jabba, this is from the citation Slowvehicle provided above:

Where exactly had the patch been attached? How big was it? Was it so small that it covered only the sample area? Answers to these questions are lacking in the hypothesis of Benford/Marino and Rogers. They can only be given in a competent way by textile experts. One of them, who was present when the sample was taken, the late Gabriel Vial, confirmed repeatedly that the sample was taken from the original cloth!
 
- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before. In their addendum, they don't even include the Delorenzi impression.

http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/addendum.pdf

Why did you say that when you promptly did this?
From http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf
Entry: #2
Date: 1976
Data Category: Evidence of anomalous nature of C-14 corner & Possibility or direct evidence
of invisible reweaving
<snip for brevity>
 

You were asked to indicate your familiarity with Marino and Prior's source material before proceeding. You were told several times why that was desirable. Are you simply ignoring that request? Shall we assume from your by-now deliberate avoidance of the question that the answer is the one least favorable to your position -- i.e., that you are unfamiliar with the sources?
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment/M&P/Repair/#2

Why did you say that when you promptly did this?
Abaddon,
- I don't do anything promptly.
- I screwed up there. I won't bother explaining, but for now, I'll put M&P's Addendum aside.
 
- Accepting that no single entry is especially 'meaty,' I want to work my way through each entry to see if I can develop some meaningful consilience. I'll have to go back over your different objections and see if I can answer them. I'll start with #1 in the addendum.

- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before. In their addendum, they don't even include the Delorenzi impression.

http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/addendum.pdf

Abaddon,
- I don't do anything promptly.
- I screwed up there. I won't bother explaining, but for now, I'll put M&P's Addendum aside.


So, what did all that achieve?
 
2rdjgc0.gif
 
Abaddon,
- I don't do anything promptly.
Perhaps one might consider the word "promptly" to be hyperbole given the glacial nature of this thread. Nevertheless, having had point #1 and Delorenzi thoroughly eviscerated, you abandoned the chronology document like the proverbial hot potato, instead preferring to move on to the addendum document which entirely ignores the Delorenzi fiasco. Fine, you have set aside the chronology document.


- I screwed up there.
Well colour me in a rainbow of surprise.
I won't bother explaining,
My unicorn needs diapers.

but for now, I'll put M&P's Addendum aside.
So now, not only have you set aside the chronology document, you have set aside the addendum as well and are vaguely, without explanation trying to rehabilitate the chronology by stealth.

Sorry, Jabba, you choose to throw the chronology document under the bus. Everyone agreed to address it point by point. We got as far as #1 and then you moved on to the addendum.

Now you are attempting to throw the addendum under the bus in the hopes of reviving the still twitching corpse of the chronology document.
 
Follow the little ball in #1871 and you'll get the answer.

Are you attempting to Escher the thread?

Here is where we are at. I will number these because Effective DebateTM
1. Jabba proposes that the chronology document is somehow authoritative.
-1.1 Jabba proposes that the points contained therein be addressed one at a time.

- 1.2 We all start with point #1 and show #1 to be utterly without merit.

- 1.3 Jabba abandons without moving along to #2.

2.0 Jabba decides to move to the addendum.

- 2.1 The addendum gets similarly debunked for the rot it is.

- 2.2 Jabba abandons the addendum.

- 2.3 Jabba declines to provide any explanation.

3.0 Jabba returns to the chronology document as though nothing at all happened.

Now, Jabba, before you start complaining, this is an accurate description of what actually happened right here in this very thread composed according to those rules that you seek to impose yet refuse to follow.

So I ask you, what is one to do with this as an honest poster?
 
Don't forget that Jabba justified his decision to abandon the chronology for the addendum with the hypothesis that Marino and Prior also realized the chronology lacked rigor.
 
Are you attempting to Escher the thread?

Here is where we are at. I will number these because Effective DebateTM
1. Jabba proposes that the chronology document is somehow authoritative.
-1.1 Jabba proposes that the points contained therein be addressed one at a time.

- 1.2 We all start with point #1 and show #1 to be utterly without merit.

- 1.3 Jabba abandons without moving along to #2.

2.0 Jabba decides to move to the addendum.

- 2.1 The addendum gets similarly debunked for the rot it is.

- 2.2 Jabba abandons the addendum.

- 2.3 Jabba declines to provide any explanation.

3.0 Jabba returns to the chronology document as though nothing at all happened.

Exactly what the animation depicts. When you say "he abandons" I only see him changing planes -not the ones with wings-. He has managed to derail this thread repeatedly by turning 90 Escherian degrees to the right and addressing other poster in order to set the fake debate into its new direction to in turn do the same again. He derails the thread not by being not responsive or ambiguous, which is not a violation of the MA per se, but by making false promises deliberately: he feigns to yield and offers a promise of an argumentation just to repeat what he has spammed before -also a MA violation- to turn course again when he is being entrapped by his own empty argumentation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom