Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Spend enough time among some of the die-hard Italian Catholics and you'll realize the reason for clinging has nothing to do with evidence. Some of the rural Italians I knew had such a warped and superstitious interpretation of Catholicism that it was sometimes scary.

I was speaking tongue-in-cheek earlier about the Holy Foreskin relics, but look: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Prepuce

My mother-in-law is devoutly Roman Catholic, and cites Nostradamus as though he were a saint.

My janitor-in-law (or whatever) is a devoted Buddhist, but has a home shrine for Shintoist deities. Rural Indians worship a blue god with an elephant proboscis, in a twisted interpretation of the deep philosophy of Hinduism.

You are simply not getting it, I mean, what religion is in a human scale. Your protestant backgrounds -be it personal or environmental- have brainwashed you. You're used to Catholicism "the """"American""""" way" (or Canadian, or Australian, or British), which is just "Catholicism under the spotlight of Protestantism" and has to do with Catholicism as much as Spanish spoken in the United States has to do with Spanish: one is a stereotyped, shaming, primitive, contaminated and generally limited set of dialects of the real deal.

Like many Atheist Jews -oxymoronic as it sounds- who don't believe a **** in Jehovah but love rituals and everything-Sionist, the levels of belief and their connection with main stream religions are in the real world pretty free and basically independent.

Jabba's lucky charm -the shroud- is just that. He's not claiming it's authentic (show me when he says "IT IS"). Phrases like "leaning towards authenticity" aren't a politically correct way to write down absolutes. They are, contradictory as they may sound, Jabba's hic et nunc: the present value the shroud has to him. I'm positive Jabba doesn't hold any structured belief about what God really is, afterlife and judgement. I'm positive he doesn't believe in a heaven that matches the epistemological level of a "real shroud of The Christ".
It wouldn't surprise me that he even might not believe in heaven or eternal life at all.

Believe me, the communicating vessels linking relics as lucky charms and Christian philosophy are way more twisted and clogged than you think. It's Christianity and Islam that invented and promoted the logic of "if there is one God, the other gods are false and their temples must be burnt" (reserving a secondary deity called "Devil" just to fill some gaps), but essential religiosity and magical thinking were partially preserved (like it happens everywhere else in the World).

It's Protestantism which in the Christian world introduced "it's me and my bible", "faith is enough" and a set of self-absorbed notions that has even created a culture where some say "only a bunch of us will get box in the heavenly theatre" or even "the bible doesn't say what I want; I'm gonna write my own one". ISIS is one of many mirroring counterparts in the Muslim world.

Don't dwell in such a perverse cultural frame. And if anyone is wrong, ask yourselves what are you doing here keeping warm this thread, waking Jabba's numen until it magically comes again to life the third day.
 
My tiny, unimportant prediction:

now that Jabba has been suspended for a few days, if he ever comes back he will complain about how unfair he was treated, despite all the evidence.

"The shroud is true, i was _sooo_ close to proving it by meticulous reserch, and then they cut me off"

Alternatively:

"Not only the users are rude there, but the mods as well! How can anyone have a fair deabte that way!"

If not here, he will put it that way elsewhere. Won't be the first time he misrepresented stuff. Heck, he can't even faithfully quote stuff, after all...

Greetings,

Chris

I checked yesterday and it doesn't look like he used his free time to declare victory by default in his site.
 
My tiny, unimportant prediction:

now that Jabba has been suspended for a few days, if he ever comes back he will complain about how unfair he was treated, despite all the evidence.

"The shroud is true, i was _sooo_ close to proving it by meticulous reserch, and then they cut me off"

That would be pretty inconsistent with his behavior here so far. The style is insinuation, not declaration or proclamation.
 
Studies of in-the-trenches Catholicism in the backward parts of Europe would be very interesting, and worth pursuing far beyond anything still remaining here in Jabbaland.
 
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove FMF content


- I tend to be slow in my thinking (Slow, but deep?), and in trying to speed up I make more mistakes than usual...
- Anyway, the M&P "Entries" add up to 57 altogether. At this point, I accept that if Entry #1 in the first paper is significant, M&P didn't support its validity well enough to allow it to be considered in consilience (that's probably not the correct way to describe what I'm thinking, but hopefully, you'll know what I mean).
- Let's see if #2 is any better.
- I'll be back.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove FMF content


Can you please provide some evidence of a 2000 YO CIQ before you get another time-out?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove FMF content


- I tend to be slow in my thinking (Slow, but deep?), and in trying to speed up I make more mistakes than usual...
- Anyway, the M&P "Entries" add up to 57 altogether. At this point, I accept that if Entry #1 in the first paper is significant, M&P didn't support its validity well enough to allow it to be considered in consilience (that's probably not the correct way to describe what I'm thinking, but hopefully, you'll know what I mean).
- Let's see if #2 is any better.
- I'll be back.

If you actually had any evidence for your beliefs it might help you stay on topic. When you are in a constant battle to avoid answering questions that paint you into a stark corner where you must admit this, off topic distraction is understandable. You may well think deep on other topics but it's clear your research and consideration on this subject is at the toddlers' end of the pool.

Looking forward to more abject failure on your point number two.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by Agatha: 
Edited to remove FMF content
Anyway, the M&P "Entries" add up to 57 altogether.

Asked and answered. Numbers do not make consilience. Consilience is a qualitative proposition. Further, you've all but conceded that your authors have padded their entries.

I accept that if Entry #1 in the first paper is significant, M&P didn't support its validity well enough...

Asked and answered. No one is interested in your speculation on why Marino and Prior changed horses. But given your admission that they are not good reporters, we have asked what you personally have done, prior to basing an argument on their other work, to ascertain that they have fairly reported their sources. Please describe in detail the process you used to verify your authors' reporting.

...to be considered in consilience (that's probably not the correct way to describe what I'm thinking, but hopefully, you'll know what I mean).

I don't think you know what you mean. You keep throwing around this new word you've learned as if it somehow salvages your argument. As already explained, you cannot make an argument by consilience from the Addendum. Do not attempt one without first addressing that explanation.

Let's see if #2 is any better.

As requested, please indicate your familiarity with your authors' source material before continuing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jay,

- I tend to be slow in my thinking (Slow, but deep?), Sluggish and shallow and in trying to speed up I make more mistakes than usual... [...].

- I'll be back.

It is hard to believe you could make more mistakes than you already do.
 
Mr Savage,

How is your Shroud Blog cleanup going? That is one disreputable example of a dog's breakfast if there ever was one.

Please give us progress reports as you work on cleaning-up that mess.
 
Another way to look at consillience would be if you had multiple independent lines of evidence to say the Shroud is inauthentic. If you had carbon dating, historical, typology, Anatomy all saying it was inauthentic....oh wait, we do have all that.
 
Another way to look at consillience would be if you had multiple independent lines of evidence to say the Shroud is inauthentic. If you had carbon dating, historical, typology, Anatomy all saying it was inauthentic....oh wait, we do have all that.

Hm. I agree with the thrust of this, but I think I'd frame it more as that consilience showing that the Shroud is indeed authentic- authentically medieval. Otherwise, you give someone like Jabba an opening to claim that you're trying to use consilience to prove a negative ("not authentic"). It's up to him to make his positive case for a 1st century origin, contra the positive case for a medieval one.
 
Hm. I agree with the thrust of this, but I think I'd frame it more as that consilience showing that the Shroud is indeed authentic- authentically medieval. Otherwise, you give someone like Jabba an opening to claim that you're trying to use consilience to prove a negative ("not authentic"). It's up to him to make his positive case for a 1st century origin, contra the positive case for a medieval one.

True, of course. However, for any ancient artefact, the null hypothesis is "age unknown, origin unknown". So any evidence that points to an age and/or origin is positive.

And in this light, it is indeed, as Jabba wants, it a question of weighing evidence in the case of conflicting hypotheses. Unfortunately for Jabba, all the weight turns out to be for a medieval origin.

Hans
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment/M&P/Repair/#2

From http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf
Entry: #2
Date: 1976
Data Category: Evidence of anomalous nature of C-14 corner & Possibility or direct evidence
of invisible reweaving
Evidence: Textile expert Gilbert Raes of Belgium, who extracted a sample in 1973 for analysis,
wrote in his report that he found cotton. Raes also noted, ―The thread used for sewing the two
pieces [designated ―Piece 1‖ and ―Piece 2‖] together is…twisted in an S-direction, whereas the
individual threads are twisted in a Z-direction.
Source: Raes, Gilbert. ―Appendix B – Analysis Report: Pl. II-III—Subject: Examination of the
‗Sindone‘‖. In Doyle, E., M.Green, Fr., & V. Ossola (Trans.) Report of Turin Commission on the
Holy Shroud (pp. 108-123), 1976. Unpublished. Translation of La S. Sindone: Ricerche e studi
della Commissione di Esperti nominate dall‘Arcivescovo di Torino, Card. Michele Pellegrino,
nel.
Comments: The Raes sample is highly significant due to its thorough examination and adjacent
location to the C-14 sample area. Given the stark differences between yarns found in the Raes‘
2
Pieces 1 and 2, combined with the existence of the sewing thread, which connected the two
disparate materials, Benford and Marino hypothesize that Piece 2 was the original Shroud
material/seam and Piece 1 was a cotton-containing patch made to resemble the original Shroud
cloth. (See: ―Surface Chemical Analysis of the Shroud of Turin Identifies Discrepancies in
Radiocarbon Dating Region‖ by M. Sue Benford and Joseph Marino, presented at the ―The
Shroud of Turin: Perspectives on a Multi-Faceted Enigma‖ conference in Columbus, Ohio on
August 14-17th
2008, which will be accessible online at www.ohioshroudconference.com by
January 1, 2009). Each piece exhibits different characteristics, such as cotton content, lignin
content at the growth nodes, and thread size, suggesting two different origins of the yarns. The
continuous, fully-observable sewing thread represents a significant change of technique, and
suggests this section of thread, which incorporated the Raes sample and C-14 sample areas, was
applied from the top instead of the reverse of the cloth. This further implies the two sections of
sewing threads (C-14 region versus main Shroud) were applied at different times and by different
artisans with the main Shroud stitching possibly from the same time period as a cloth from
Masada in Israel, dated to BC 40 to AD 73 [M. Flury-Lemberg, Mechthild, Sindon N.S. Quad. 16
(Dec 2001., pg. 60)]. Raes himself would not commit in his report to a specific time period for
the origin of the cloth. Regarding the S-direction versus the Z-direction, Raes is referring to the
connection between the fabric and the seam; the two different twists indicate the existence of two
different kinds of cloth. (See entry number 13 in this section.)

...
Entry#2 refers to the sewing thread used to join two pieces together, and notes that it's different from the cloth. Sewing thread is almost always different from the cloth on which it's being used. This does not refer to the sampled area...
Agatha,
- Do you accept that the results of the study on the Raes sample suggests that it had been repaired?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom