aleCcowaN
imperfecto del subjuntivo
Spend enough time among some of the die-hard Italian Catholics and you'll realize the reason for clinging has nothing to do with evidence. Some of the rural Italians I knew had such a warped and superstitious interpretation of Catholicism that it was sometimes scary.
I was speaking tongue-in-cheek earlier about the Holy Foreskin relics, but look: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Prepuce
My mother-in-law is devoutly Roman Catholic, and cites Nostradamus as though he were a saint.
My janitor-in-law (or whatever) is a devoted Buddhist, but has a home shrine for Shintoist deities. Rural Indians worship a blue god with an elephant proboscis, in a twisted interpretation of the deep philosophy of Hinduism.
You are simply not getting it, I mean, what religion is in a human scale. Your protestant backgrounds -be it personal or environmental- have brainwashed you. You're used to Catholicism "the """"American""""" way" (or Canadian, or Australian, or British), which is just "Catholicism under the spotlight of Protestantism" and has to do with Catholicism as much as Spanish spoken in the United States has to do with Spanish: one is a stereotyped, shaming, primitive, contaminated and generally limited set of dialects of the real deal.
Like many Atheist Jews -oxymoronic as it sounds- who don't believe a **** in Jehovah but love rituals and everything-Sionist, the levels of belief and their connection with main stream religions are in the real world pretty free and basically independent.
Jabba's lucky charm -the shroud- is just that. He's not claiming it's authentic (show me when he says "IT IS"). Phrases like "leaning towards authenticity" aren't a politically correct way to write down absolutes. They are, contradictory as they may sound, Jabba's hic et nunc: the present value the shroud has to him. I'm positive Jabba doesn't hold any structured belief about what God really is, afterlife and judgement. I'm positive he doesn't believe in a heaven that matches the epistemological level of a "real shroud of The Christ". It wouldn't surprise me that he even might not believe in heaven or eternal life at all.
Believe me, the communicating vessels linking relics as lucky charms and Christian philosophy are way more twisted and clogged than you think. It's Christianity and Islam that invented and promoted the logic of "if there is one God, the other gods are false and their temples must be burnt" (reserving a secondary deity called "Devil" just to fill some gaps), but essential religiosity and magical thinking were partially preserved (like it happens everywhere else in the World).
It's Protestantism which in the Christian world introduced "it's me and my bible", "faith is enough" and a set of self-absorbed notions that has even created a culture where some say "only a bunch of us will get box in the heavenly theatre" or even "the bible doesn't say what I want; I'm gonna write my own one". ISIS is one of many mirroring counterparts in the Muslim world.
Don't dwell in such a perverse cultural frame. And if anyone is wrong, ask yourselves what are you doing here keeping warm this thread, waking Jabba's numen until it magically comes again to life the third day.