Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, I agree with most, here. I hope this might make Jabba realize just how long his path is.

Hans

I'm uncertain that he will. All along, Jabba has considered that discrediting the evidence for a medieval date is sufficient to prove a 2kya date.

I have no idea why he thinks this is the case, in fact several over the course of this thread and it's former iterations have pointed out exactly why this is utterly useless. I would like to ask Jabba upon his return to address that very point, yet he has steadfastly refused to do so for all of those who have asked that very question, so why should I expect to be any different? For four years.
 
The historicity of Jesus of Nazareth (aside from any claims to divinity) is one leg of the proof. And while several scholarly works are available for that study, they fall short of being able to place Jesus at distinct times and places. Thus we don't have any basis to localize him in a time and place that allows for attribution of artifacts.

The provenance and propriety of the cloth is another leg. Provenance includes scientific dating and some verifiable story of how it came into our possession. Propriety includes fitting it into a cultural and artistic tradition that matches its purported origin. The real problem here is that the scientific dating of the cloth corresponds to a period of rampant forgery of relics. Now that is consilience. But in any case a successful proof must place the cloth at the appropriate time and place.

In the general case, the connection of a specific artifact with a specific figure centuries dead requires the artifact to be discovered with the corpse. Yes, if we find a dead cave man 15,000 feet up a remote mountain, and an archery bow 30 feet from the corpse, they're probably connected. But if you talk about one alleged rabble-rouser who lived 2,000 years ago in a big city and didn't become an iconic figure until much later, and a cloth that suddenly appeared in the medieval period, there is really no scientific basis upon which one could make a case for a connection.

It's a two-legged stool, with two very wobbly legs.
 
The historicity of Jesus of Nazareth (aside from any claims to divinity) is one leg of the proof. And while several scholarly works are available for that study, they fall short of being able to place Jesus at distinct times and places. Thus we don't have any basis to localize him in a time and place that allows for attribution of artifacts.

The provenance and propriety of the cloth is another leg. Provenance includes scientific dating and some verifiable story of how it came into our possession. Propriety includes fitting it into a cultural and artistic tradition that matches its purported origin. The real problem here is that the scientific dating of the cloth corresponds to a period of rampant forgery of relics. Now that is consilience. But in any case a successful proof must place the cloth at the appropriate time and place.

In the general case, the connection of a specific artifact with a specific figure centuries dead requires the artifact to be discovered with the corpse. Yes, if we find a dead cave man 15,000 feet up a remote mountain, and an archery bow 30 feet from the corpse, they're probably connected. But if you talk about one alleged rabble-rouser who lived 2,000 years ago in a big city and didn't become an iconic figure until much later, and a cloth that suddenly appeared in the medieval period, there is really no scientific basis upon which one could make a case for a connection.

It's a two-legged stool, with two very wobbly legs.

Regarding the highlighted sentence: this wording is unfortunate and excessively general. We can, for instance, say with some authority that Alfred the Great commissioned the Alfred Jewel although it was not buried with him. We know this because the Alfred Jewel is inscribed with the words "AELFRED MEC HEHT GEWYRCAN," which means, "Alfred ordered me to be made." Similarly, we have sufficient evidence to suggest that the Shroud belonged to Geoffroi de Charny in the 14th century and Margaret de Charny in the 15th.
 
Regarding the highlighted sentence: this wording is unfortunate and excessively general. We can, for instance, say with some authority that Alfred the Great commissioned the Alfred Jewel although it was not buried with him. We know this because the Alfred Jewel is inscribed with the words "AELFRED MEC HEHT GEWYRCAN," which means, "Alfred ordered me to be made." Similarly, we have sufficient evidence to suggest that the Shroud belonged to Geoffroi de Charny in the 14th century and Margaret de Charny in the 15th.

Regarding the Alfred Jewel, is the inscription just one tiny piece of evidence pointing at authenticity ? After all if anything else was "wrong" about it (like the wrong style or anachronistic features) then the inscription would be viewed as an attempt to fake authenticity.

After all, a laundry label saying "Burial shroud property of Jesus H Christ" on the shroud wouldn't be considered evidence of authenticity given how much else is wrong with it.
 
Regarding the Alfred Jewel, is the inscription just one tiny piece of evidence pointing at authenticity ? After all if anything else was "wrong" about it (like the wrong style or anachronistic features) then the inscription would be viewed as an attempt to fake authenticity.

After all, a laundry label saying "Burial shroud property of Jesus H Christ" on the shroud wouldn't be considered evidence of authenticity given how much else is wrong with it.

This is worth exploring.

For me, this particular CIQ cannot be rehabilitated. There are, simply, too many things that are "wrong" about it, from the representational Byzantine-styled features of the face and body; though the gravity-challenged "hair" and "blood", past the scriptural, anatomical, mechanical, and historical impossibilities; down to the provenance and history of the cloth itself; there does not seem to be a single factor that would allow the CIQ to be considered the "True Shroud", much less demonstrated so to be.
 
Regarding the Alfred Jewel, is the inscription just one tiny piece of evidence pointing at authenticity ? After all if anything else was "wrong" about it (like the wrong style or anachronistic features) then the inscription would be viewed as an attempt to fake authenticity.

After all, a laundry label saying "Burial shroud property of Jesus H Christ" on the shroud wouldn't be considered evidence of authenticity given how much else is wrong with it.
The shroud has its own fake laundry label in the form of the image.
 
This is worth exploring.

For me, this particular CIQ cannot be rehabilitated. There are, simply, too many things that are "wrong" about it, from the representational Byzantine-styled features of the face and body; though the gravity-challenged "hair" and "blood", past the scriptural, anatomical, mechanical, and historical impossibilities; down to the provenance and history of the cloth itself; there does not seem to be a single factor that would allow the CIQ to be considered the "True Shroud", much less demonstrated so to be.

That's one of the things I've learned from this thread. Beforehand I thought that the carbon dating was the key evidence because pretty much everything else was plausible or at least not implausible. Now I know about everything else, even if the carbon dating gave a first century date, I'd question it
 
That's one of the things I've learned from this thread. Beforehand I thought that the carbon dating was the key evidence because pretty much everything else was plausible or at least not implausible. Now I know about everything else, even if the carbon dating gave a first century date, I'd question it

...keepin' the "E" in ISF...
 
That's one of the things I've learned from this thread. Beforehand I thought that the carbon dating was the key evidence because pretty much everything else was plausible or at least not implausible. Now I know about everything else, even if the carbon dating gave a first century date, I'd question it

Hence the wobbly-stool analogy. A determination of authenticity is a judgment that has to stand on several sturdy legs in order to work. Shoring up one leg of it doesn't buy you anything. And Jabba isn't even doing that; he's kicking the guys who are inspecting the legs for sturdiness, apparently in the hopes that if they can't make their determination then no one will know just how wobbly it is.

As for overall plausibility, the claim is patently implausible on its face. From a community known to fake relics, in the period of frantic relic-faking, comes an artifact claiming to be the most intimately pertinent relic of all. Uh, right.
 
Regarding the Alfred Jewel, is the inscription just one tiny piece of evidence pointing at authenticity ? After all if anything else was "wrong" about it (like the wrong style or anachronistic features) then the inscription would be viewed as an attempt to fake authenticity.

After all, a laundry label saying "Burial shroud property of Jesus H Christ" on the shroud wouldn't be considered evidence of authenticity given how much else is wrong with it.

That's true, of course. In the case of the Alfred Jewel, all the evidence suggests that it is genuine and that it is Anglo-Saxon. Given that evidence, the inscription ties it firmly to Alfred's reign. Moreover, while it doesn't prove Alfred owned it, it provides reasonable evidence that he did indeed have it made. And although we're on slightly shakier ground here, it was probably made as part of Alfred's program of educational reform. Specifically, it and similar jewels from the same time period were probably used as pointers for reading. In the case of the Alfred Jewel, I believe we have consilience: different strands of evidence that strongly suggest that Alfred had the jewel made.

In the case of the shroud, we have many different strands of evidence that show that it was produced during the Middle Ages, centuries after the Alfred Jewel. I'm putting that in bold just so no one thinks that my comments about the authenticity of the Alfred Jewel could in any way be used to argue for the shroud's authenticity.

I used the Alfred Jewel as an example because it was the first thing that popped into my head that wasn't a medieval manuscript. I just wanted to point out that sometimes we do have evidence that a specific artifact belonged to/was associated with a specific long-dead individual, even if that evidence comes from the humanities instead of/as well as the sciences.
 
That's one of the things I've learned from this thread. Beforehand I thought that the carbon dating was the key evidence because pretty much everything else was plausible or at least not implausible. Now I know about everything else, even if the carbon dating gave a first century date, I'd question it

Absolutely! WIthout thinking much about it, before the carbon dating I thought that the total sums of evidence for vs. against authenticity were perhaps 30/70, or even 10/90, but I did assume that there must be some, perhaps ambiguous, evidence on the pro-authenticity "pan." I must ultimately thank Jabba for dragging out all the "pro-authenticity" arguments into the light. leaving me amazed to see that there was no pro-authenticity evidence at all, and that the only arguments made by the pro-authenticity advocates were entirely imaginative, made up of whole-cloth (sorry) attempts to desperately cast some doubt on the extra-ordinarily strong anti-authenticity evidence. And unbelievably this has continued even after the definitive carbon dating results. Sure, the isotopic date is all wrong, the weave of the clothe is wrong, the image is impossible if based on a 3D person, the chemical analysis is consistent with the use of pigment, the is no written record establishing the current SOT as coming from the time of Christ, the Church itself denounced it as a fake, etc. Yet we have multiple people wasting their lives to come up with some imagined doubt in each of these pieces of evidence, generally along the lines "Well, isn't possible that the one region tested was an invisible (even under a microscope) patch made with Middle Ages cloth that just had precisely the same look as the original under lighting not available in the Middle Ages, and thus totally unlike the overt patches in the other parts of the cloth."

It is really fairly sad that people are so desperate to make it a holy object despite all evidence to the contrary.

So thank you Jabba, and of course thanks to the rest of you here, for clarifying the true "balance" of evidence here. The thread educated me, and also made me much less willing in general to assume that where there is smoke there must be a least a tiny bit of fire.
 
Last edited:
I'll add my voice to those above. I thought that there must be some compelling reason the think CIQ was authentic, or else people wouldn't cling to that idea so tenaciously.

Having examined the best Jabba has to offer, I have no doubt that it is a medieval artifact made either to deceive, or as a prop for worship ceremonies.
 
I thought that there must be some compelling reason the think CIQ was authentic, or else people wouldn't cling to that idea so tenaciously.

Spend enough time among some of the die-hard Italian Catholics and you'll realize the reason for clinging has nothing to do with evidence. Some of the rural Italians I knew had such a warped and superstitious interpretation of Catholicism that it was sometimes scary.

Umberto Eco mocks this a bit in The Name of the Rose. The hero is impressing his young apprentice with his knowledge of relics, and tells him he has seen the skull of John the Baptist at age 12. The apprentice is at once impressed, then reconsiders: "But the Baptist was executed at a much more advanced age." The hero responds, "The other skull must be at some other monastery."
 
Spend enough time among some of the die-hard Italian Catholics and you'll realize the reason for clinging has nothing to do with evidence. Some of the rural Italians I knew had such a warped and superstitious interpretation of Catholicism that it was sometimes scary.

Umberto Eco mocks this a bit in The Name of the Rose. The hero is impressing his young apprentice with his knowledge of relics, and tells him he has seen the skull of John the Baptist at age 12. The apprentice is at once impressed, then reconsiders: "But the Baptist was executed at a much more advanced age." The hero responds, "The other skull must be at some other monastery."

I've heard that.

I was speaking tongue-in-cheek earlier about the Holy Foreskin relics, but look: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Prepuce

My mother-in-law is devoutly Roman Catholic, and cites Nostradamus as though he were a saint.

Go figure.
 
My tiny, unimportant prediction:

now that Jabba has been suspended for a few days, if he ever comes back he will complain about how unfair he was treated, despite all the evidence.

"The shroud is true, i was _sooo_ close to proving it by meticulous reserch, and then they cut me off"

Alternatively:

"Not only the users are rude there, but the mods as well! How can anyone have a fair deabte that way!"

If not here, he will put it that way elsewhere. Won't be the first time he misrepresented stuff. Heck, he can't even faithfully quote stuff, after all...

Greetings,

Chris
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom