Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hopefully Jabba can spend some of his vacation time trying to find positive evidence in favor of authenticity. My guess is, he'll come back with "blood!".
 
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)

Hans
 
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)


Perhaps if the holy sandal could be recovered, we could do a DNA comparison with the blood on the shroud. It wouldn't establish authenticity, but at least it could rule out it being Brian of Nazareth's shroud. Then he'd have one fewer person to rule out...

Basically, Jabba has set himself an impossible task. The chances of producing evidence connecting a particular piece of cloth of unknown provenance with a particular first-century preacher of unknown burial place is pretty much zero. And given the evidence suggesting a medieval origin for the cloth and the image on it, the anatomical impossibility, etc...
 
Last edited:
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)

Hans

Some things I would expect to see in support of such a possibility:
!. Reliable dating of the artifact to the correct period.
2. Identification of the material as consistent with the alleged source.
3. Identification of the production methods as consistent with the alleged source.
4. Demonstration of similarity to other such objects known to be from the same period and area.
 
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)

Hans

One person's opinion: Long before you get to whose shroud it is, there would have to be some evidence that it actually was a burial shroud for an actual person. For example, it would have to show the 3D characteristics that occur when a cloth is wrapped around a body.

Then there would have to be some evidence that would link it to the first century CE. It would need to be made of material similar to other materials for that time/place. There would need to be some reason to date it accordingly, and indicate that it could only have come from that time/place.

Once those requirements were met, you'd have to start demonstrating that Jesus actually existed, and was in fact buried wrapped in a one piece shroud (as opposed to the strips of linen that was the custom of the time, and is what is claimed in the bible.)

While this would still not be conclusive, it would at least give me a reason to consider it as a possibility.
 
Perhaps if the holy sandal could be recovered, we could do a DNA comparison with the blood on the shroud. It wouldn't establish authenticity, but at least it could rule out it being Brian of Nazareth's shroud. Then he'd have one fewer person to rule out...

Basically, Jabba has set himself an impossible task. The chances of producing evidence connecting a particular piece of cloth of unknown provenance with a particular first-century preacher of unknown burial place is pretty much zero. And given the evidence suggesting a medieval origin for the cloth and the image on it, the anatomical impossibility, etc...

Heretic!!! The gourd is the one true symbol!
 
Historical provenance traceable to the right time and place.
14C or other radiometric dating, or any hard physical data tracing it to the right time.
Similarity to other samples from the same period.
Evidence that it was an actual burial cloth.
Evidence that Jesus really existed.
Evidence that this cloth was Jesus' burial cloth -- like DNA-matching the many holy foreskins through the ages to this same cloth

And then, maybe.

ETA: I just had a thought: If Jabba were banned here, and somehow returned again on the third day, would he bring his own shroud?
 
Last edited:
Historical provenance traceable to the right time and place.
14C or other radiometric dating, or any hard physical data tracing it to the right time.
Similarity to other samples from the same period.
Evidence that it was an actual burial cloth.
Evidence that Jesus really existed.
Evidence that this cloth was Jesus' burial cloth -- like DNA-matching the many holy foreskins through the ages to this same cloth

And then, maybe.

I agree. The foreskins might not be authentic, so I would be willing to agree if the DNA was haploid, a homozygous diploid (two XXs I guess), or a human DNA combined with something very exotic.

Honestly, if we are only discussing what Jabba should work toward in his proof, then I would be happy if his initial sub-conclusions would at least be based on the first 5. If even that much was established, we could then work on ways that potentially might next identify the individual buried in the cloth as Jesus rather than as some other person of that era and location. I started to think of how that next step might be approached, but then realized that we would never get past #1.
 
Last edited:
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)

Hans

Well, first I'd want to see carbon dating placing the CIQ in the correct time period. Without dating evidence there's nothing. Next, I'd have to see some historical evidence indicating Jesus was an oddly shaped man who could lay on his back with his arms bent and still cover his penis. It's a little hard to imagine someone with arms that freakishly long as that not having that particular feature mentioned in a historical account.
 
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)

Hans

That would be extremely difficult, as the shroud doesn't conform with burial rituals of the time, both in the real world and the Bible.
 
That would be extremely difficult, as the shroud doesn't conform with burial rituals of the time, both in the real world and the Bible.

In that case, evidence needed could include the discovery of contemporary documents which did describe the manner of burial consistent with the Turin cloth.
 
In that case, evidence needed could include the discovery of contemporary documents which did describe the manner of burial consistent with the Turin cloth.

But wasn't there a report [referenced up-thread somewhere] where real burials and the Bible actually agreed - and they didn't match the CIQ?

But you're right - should such a discovery be made, it might/would add some doubt to the existing contrary evidence.
 
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)

Hans

As we are where we are, then the evidence to convince me would have to be pretty dramatic, probably entailing a change in the way we understand the laws of physics.

I remain open to other evidence concerning other old rags, I just don't have a need to believe in the CIQ.
 
Well, I agree with most, here. I hope this might make Jabba realize just how long his path is.

Hans
 
While we are waiting for the ... protagonist .. to return, perhaps we could undertake a typical skeptic exercise:

What evidence would convince you that the CIQ might actually be the authentic burial shroud of Jesus of Nazereth? (Note that the divinity of Jesus is not implied at this point, just that he existed as a human, was crucified and buried in the cloth.)

Hans

Just for a start, I would need to see some kind of secular paper (papyrus? parchment?) trail establishing the existence of Jesus, his career, and his execution.

I recall reading that Jesus is conspicuously absent from any contemporary secular histories, and that the Romans were great record keepers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom