Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
I know you aren't. I've been over the previous threads, and I'm not in a hurry to revisit prior claims. For now, Jabba seems to think casting aspersions on 14C findings is what he wants to do. It's necessary, as I outline above, but by no means probative -- especially of authenticity. A claim of authenticity fails by contradiction according to the carbon dating. A claim of authenticity fails by starvation if it lacks any affirmative proof.


And yet Jabba continues to insist that anything that, in his opinion, casts doubt on the carbon dating should be added to his mythical "pro-authenticity pan", when if he could somehow completely discredit the carbon dating all it would do would be to remove the carbon dating from the "anti-authenticity pan".
 
And yet Jabba continues to insist that anything that, in his opinion, casts doubt on the carbon dating should be added to his mythical "pro-authenticity pan", when if he could somehow completely discredit the carbon dating all it would do would be to remove the carbon dating from the "anti-authenticity pan".

Hey Jabba, you could latch onto this and ignore the current failed topic. Got to be worth another 15 pages of this subject.
 
Last edited:
- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before. In their addendum, they don't even include the Delorenzi impression.

http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/addendum.pdf

Good Evening, Mr. Savage:

Here is an opportunity for you to learn:

Item #1 makes an unsubstantiable claim about something Dr. McCrone is alleged to have said; then proceeds with the not-unexpected smears against the Good Doctor. (Notice: "...supposedly proved his theory...", and, even more typically, "...[McCrone] believed that the area from which the sample was actually taken, might have contained repairs...") (Italics added)
What is lacking? Evidence. Evidence along the lines of, "here is the rent; there the repair; these the egregious threads."

Not to mention the fact, as has been poinited out to you, that smearing the 14C dating does not advance your idea that the linen of the CIQ must be ~2000 years old. It is still true that the reason you think it must be ~2000 years old is that you decided, before you began your investigations, that the CIQ was the "True Shroud" (despite all of the problems unrelated to the 14C dating that have been pointed out to you.

You might find this interesting...

Do consider dropping this rearguard action,and addressing whatever positive evidecen you have that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
 
Item #1 makes an unsubstantiable claim...

As long as you're jumping the gun, let me jump with you. :D

The sources to which Marino and Prior refer are, broadly speaking, mostly self-published books written by people who were not directly involved in the scientific testing of the cloth, but who have various theories and speculations about the problems it engendered. The face-palming moment comes when you realize that these authors have incompatible theories for what happened with the carbon dating. The Marino-and-Prior indirection allows Jabba to pretend there are a couple dozen reasons to distrust the dating. But in fact they are not a coherent or harmonious whole. They cannot in any way, shape, or form be considered a body of consilience because they argue different scenarios for what happened. They in fact contradict each other on such fundamental reasons such as why the date arrived at the 14th Century.
 
Last edited:
As long as you're jumping the gun, let me jump with you. :D

The sources to which Marino and Prior refer are, broadly speaking, mostly self-published books written by people who were not directly involved in the scientific testing of the cloth, but who have various theories and speculations about the problems it engendered. The face-palming moment comes when you realize that these authors have incompatible theories for what happened with the carbon dating. The Marino-and-Prior indirection allows Jabba to pretend there are a couple dozen reasons to distrust the dating. But in fact they are not a coherent or harmonious whole. They cannot in any way, shape, or form be considered a body of consilience because they argue different scenarios for what happened. They in fact contradict each other on such fundamental reasons such as why the date arrived at the 14th Century.

Beautifully said.

I would only add, as emphasis, that the reason the "theories" are all over the map, disagreeing with each other willy-nilly, is not that threre is evidence that must be explained, but that the 14C dating came back with the "wrong" date.

It's special pleading all the way down...
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment/M&P/Addendum

- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before. In their addendum, they don't even include the Delorenzi impression.

http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/addendum.pdf

Zoo,
- I suspect that they came to agree (in part) with you guys -- that there was no 'meat' in some of their previous entries -- and dropped those entries in their addendum. The Delorenzi entry was one of the entries dropped.
 
Zoo,
- I suspect that they came to agree (in part) with you guys -- that there was no 'meat' in some of their previous entries -- and dropped those entries in their addendum. The Delorenzi entry was one of the entries dropped.

So you're saying you're clutching at straws.
 
Zoo,
- I suspect that they came to agree (in part) with you guys -- that there was no 'meat' in some of their previous entries -- and dropped those entries in their addendum. The Delorenzi entry was one of the entries dropped.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Please indicate which of the entries in the "addemdum" comprises, in your opinion, the best evidence that the sized and gessoed linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

Sincerely yours,

&ct.
 
Zoo,
- I suspect that they came to agree (in part) with you guys -- that there was no 'meat' in some of their previous entries -- and dropped those entries in their addendum. The Delorenzi entry was one of the entries dropped.

And this helps the case for authenticity how?
 
Zoo,
- I suspect that they came to agree (in part) with you guys -- that there was no 'meat' in some of their previous entries -- and dropped those entries in their addendum. The Delorenzi entry was one of the entries dropped.

You didn't answer the question I asked, which was in response to the section of your post which I quoted, not the whole post. Why did you decide to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum? Why did you not continue with the items in the main paper?
 
You didn't answer the question I asked, which was in response to the section of your post which I quoted, not the whole post. Why did you decide to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum? Why did you not continue with the items in the main paper?
I suspect Jabba thinks that the Addendum is a more defensible list which has had problematic entries dropped from it. He doesn't realise that both lists consist entirely of utterly worthless entries which can be as easily demolished as the Delorenzi one was.
 
Evidence/Repair/Consilience/M&P

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Please indicate which of the entries in the "addemdum" comprises, in your opinion, the best evidence that the sized and gessoed linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

Sincerely yours,

&ct.
- Accepting that no single entry is especially 'meaty,' I want to work my way through each entry to see if I can develop some meaningful consilience. I'll have to go back over your different objections and see if I can answer them. I'll start with #1 in the addendum.
 
- Accepting that no single entry is especially 'meaty,' I want to work my way through each entry to see if I can develop some meaningful consilience. I'll have to go back over your different objections and see if I can answer them. I'll start with #1 in the addendum.

You forgot to tell us how little time you have and how you'll be back.
 
- Accepting that no single entry is especially 'meaty,' I want to work my way through each entry to see if I can develop some meaningful consilience. I'll have to go back over your different objections and see if I can answer them. I'll start with #1 in the addendum.


My Dear Mr. Savage:

You could start here:

Good Evening, Mr. Savage:

Here is an opportunity for you to learn:

Item #1 makes an unsubstantiable claim about something Dr. McCrone is alleged to have said; then proceeds with the not-unexpected smears against the Good Doctor. (Notice: "...supposedly proved his theory...", and, even more typically, "...[McCrone] believed that the area from which the sample was actually taken, might have contained repairs...") (Italics added)
What is lacking? Evidence. Evidence along the lines of, "here is the rent; there the repair; these the egregious threads."

Not to mention the fact, as has been pointed out to you, that smearing the 14C dating does not advance your idea that the linen of the CIQ must be ~2000 years old. It is still true that the reason you think it must be ~2000 years old is that you decided, before you began your investigations, that the CIQ was the "True Shroud" (despite all of the problems unrelated to the 14C dating that have been pointed out to you.

You might find this interesting...

Do consider dropping this rearguard action,and addressing whatever positive evidecence you have that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

Sincerely yours,

&ct.
 
I suspect that they came to agree (in part) with you guys...

The question asked why are you changing horses. You don't know anything about Marino and Prior's motives, and we're not interested in your speculation about it. You do know your reasons for suddenly abandoning their paper, and we'd like to hear them.

If it was because, as you suggest, their evidence was too weak to matter, then I think we agree. Which raises the next question: why would you consider other works by those same authors?

And after your suspension is up, please answer this post, which you seem to have overlooked.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom