Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Evidence/Repair/Consilience

- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before. In their addendum, they don't even include the Delorenzi impression.

http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/addendum.pdf
 
- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before. In their addendum, they don't even include the Delorenzi impression.

http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/addendum.pdf

Unless I missed it, there's not a word in that addendum that supports the authenticity of the CIQ.

When are you ever going to learn that attacking the 14C dating is not enough to establish authenticity?
 
- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before. In their addendum, they don't even include the Delorenzi impression.

http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/addendum.pdf

There's no point, Jabba. You have already lost. If you had any evidence for the authenticity of the Shroud or any argument that put into doubt the C14 dating, you would've presented it already. The only you have is insinuation, slander and "possibilities".
 
- I'm going to switch over to considering the entries...

You based your argument for consilience on those "entries." If you are abandoning that now then you abandon your argument for consilience. You were told in no uncertain terms that such an argument could not hold without individualized examination of the lines of evidence. Therefore by your unwillingness to continue, you have conceded that argument.

...to M&P's Addendum for significant evidence-- something I should have done before.

The addendum is not original work by Marino and Prior. As with the document you've abandoned, it is a list of references to other published works. Since it has been observed by others and admitted by you that Marino and Prior did not represent their sources honestly and fairly in their other document, the question arises whether they have done so here.

Hence the question to you is how many of those original sources have you read? Later I will list them by name and I will ask you, for each book or publication on the list, to indicate whether you have actually read it. When we are suitably assured that you are not simply once again credulously reporting third hand, then we can consider your request to change horses.

Naturally if you intend to represent that this new document provides a consilient view of the available evidence, as before, then just as naturally you will be required to address each item in turn, in isolation. If you intend to represent the reported work as expert testimony, then we will judge it according to the established criteria and decide whether it qualifies and how credible it is. You will be expected to be familiar with those criteria and to be willing and able to satisfy them.
 
Unless I missed it, there's not a word in that addendum that supports the authenticity of the CIQ.

When are you ever going to learn that attacking the 14C dating is not enough to establish authenticity?

No matter how many times this is pointed out to him, Jabba still seems to think that the C14 dating is the only reason why we don't accept his authenticity claim. Unless and until he presents positive evidence in favor of authenticity there's no reason to consider it. So far he's tried "blood" and "scientists can't recreate it" as evidence but both have been demolished for a variety of reasons.
 
If he wants to make an affirmative claim that the cloth is the burial shroud of Jesus, then he still has to account for contrary evidence. That means he can't avoid the 14C evidence. So his present activity is not inappropriate. But it is absolutely correct that refuting that evidence does not establish authenticity. At best it would show that the cloth is slightly less likely to be a medieval forgery.

Jabba has said he is not aiming to prove the cloth is authentic. He says he's just "weighing evidence." In order to do that, he would have to provide evidence to weigh. Right now the only actual evidence comes down unanimously on the side of the cloth being a forgery.
 
If he wants to make an affirmative claim that the cloth is the burial shroud of Jesus, then he still has to account for contrary evidence. That means he can't avoid the 14C evidence. So his present activity is not inappropriate. But it is absolutely correct that refuting that evidence does not establish authenticity. At best it would show that the cloth is slightly less likely to be a medieval forgery.

Jabba has said he is not aiming to prove the cloth is authentic. He says he's just "weighing evidence."

Like any woo-slinger is Just Asking Questions when they know they don't have enough evidence to support an affirmative claim of their favorite woo.
 
Yeah, we know that's BS. He definitely IS aiming to show that it's authentic. The rest is just obfuscation because he knows he's in over his head.

Oh sure, I never believed his claim. I want to make clear that none of this posturing relieves him. Undermining a refutation doesn't prove the affirmative claim that was refuted. Weighing evidence is pointless if you have no evidence. Factor in the cherry-picking of this debate for rosy presentation at his own site, and you have the classic pattern of the fringe claimant: do everything one can to create the illusion of having survived rigorous examination without actually undergoing it.
 
If he wants to make an affirmative claim that the cloth is the burial shroud of Jesus, then he still has to account for contrary evidence. That means he can't avoid the 14C evidence. So his present activity is not inappropriate. But it is absolutely correct that refuting that evidence does not establish authenticity. At best it would show that the cloth is slightly less likely to be a medieval forgery.

Jabba has said he is not aiming to prove the cloth is authentic. He says he's just "weighing evidence." In order to do that, he would have to provide evidence to weigh. Right now the only actual evidence comes down unanimously on the side of the cloth being a forgery.

Well, he needs to provides some evidence in favor of authenticity if he wants to weigh the evidence. He's certainly been given ample opportunity to do so.
 
Oh sure, I never believed his claim. I want to make clear that none of this posturing relieves him. Undermining a refutation doesn't prove the affirmative claim that was refuted. Weighing evidence is pointless if you have no evidence. Factor in the cherry-picking of this debate for rosy presentation at his own site, and you have the classic pattern of the fringe claimant: do everything one can to create the illusion of having survived rigorous examination without actually undergoing it.

Just so you know, Jabba has tried to demonstrate the authenticity of the CIQ by claiming that Walter McCrone was difficult to work with. I only wish I were making this up.
 
Just so you know, Jabba has tried to demonstrate the authenticity of the CIQ by claiming that Walter McCrone was difficult to work with. I only wish I were making this up.

I know you aren't. I've been over the previous threads, and I'm not in a hurry to revisit prior claims. For now, Jabba seems to think casting aspersions on 14C findings is what he wants to do. It's necessary, as I outline above, but by no means probative -- especially of authenticity. A claim of authenticity fails by contradiction according to the carbon dating. A claim of authenticity fails by starvation if it lacks any affirmative proof.
 
Oh sure, I never believed his claim. I want to make clear that none of this posturing relieves him. Undermining a refutation doesn't prove the affirmative claim that was refuted. Weighing evidence is pointless if you have no evidence. Factor in the cherry-picking of this debate for rosy presentation at his own site, and you have the classic pattern of the fringe claimant: do everything one can to create the illusion of having survived rigorous examination without actually undergoing it.

If you want to see why everyone's patience is at an end:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10772681#post10772681

Agatha created a chart which was, unsurprisingly, ignored. He could have easily added some points into the chart, and subsequent lists to give some evidence in favor of authenticity, but he has ignored every request. Every attempt at discussion with him proved futile.
 
Jabba, here are the sources cited by Marino and Prior in the document ("Addendum") you say you wish to consider in lieu of their previous work which you have now abandoned. The Addendum consists of excerpts from these works, accompanied by the authors' comments, interpretations, and other arguments. We do not accept Marino and Prior as faithful reporters, for reasons we have already given and with which you explicitly agreed. Therefore if you are going to use their summaries and excerpts, we require you to be familiar yourself with their source material in order to rule out such unfair usage as has been seen in your authors' other pertinent work. Therefore for each source in this list, please indicate to what extent you have read it. Please do this before using the Addendum in any further argument.

Gove, H. Relic, Icon or Hoax: Carbon Dating the Turin Shroud.
Kersten, H., Gruber, E. The Jesus Conspiracy: The Turin Shroud and the Truth about the Resurrection.
Meacham, W. The Rape of the Turin Shroud: How Christianity’s Most Precious Relic Was Wrongly Condemned and Violated.
Rogers, R. A Chemist’s Perspective on the Shroud of Turin.

If you plan to cite items in the Addendum as expert testimony, then the source material becomes subject to the criteria needed to establish testimony as expert. This will require, for each citation, an affirmative underlayment of suitable foundation, including but not limited to: field of expertise of the cited authority, access of the cited authority to appropriate data, basis of the authority's statement in enumerable and particularized evidence, nature of the statement, and concordance among similarly qualified authorities. Do you agree those are reasonable expectations?
 
If you want to see why everyone's patience is at an end...

Indeed I would lose patience too. As Zooterkin noted, I'm a new poster in this topic, although not new to the larger debate. As such I have no need or desire to rehash previous tired claims. I'm looking at Jabba's claims in the here and now. As you can see, I'm perfectly willing to apply the larger perspective to see where the here-and-now fits. But replaying prior debate is neither necessary nor useful. Jabba's reputation is well established.
 
Indeed I would lose patience too. As Zooterkin noted, I'm a new poster in this topic, although not new to the larger debate. As such I have no need or desire to rehash previous tired claims. I'm looking at Jabba's claims in the here and now. As you can see, I'm perfectly willing to apply the larger perspective to see where the here-and-now fits. But replaying prior debate is neither necessary nor useful. Jabba's reputation is well established.

Missing all the fun, you will be. ;)
 
Missing all the fun, you will be. ;)

I know, I know. But as a long-time poster in many other threads, I'm very sensitive to endless resets and recycles. In fact, a few other contributors at ISF have as their signature quotes something I said to the effect that the aim of fringe claimants is not to achieve any sort of resolution to their claims, but to spin the debate endlessly. I'm sure no one is more acutely aware of that than those who have engaged Jabba over the past few years.
 
I know, I know. But as a long-time poster in many other threads, I'm very sensitive to endless resets and recycles. In fact, a few other contributors at ISF have as their signature quotes something I said to the effect that the aim of fringe claimants is not to achieve any sort of resolution to their claims, but to spin the debate endlessly. I'm sure no one is more acutely aware of that than those who have engaged Jabba over the past few years.

IIRC, I paraphrased that back up thread, a turn of phrase for which I will be ever grateful to you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom