Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic material and responses to same


- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc.
Sorry, but no. You do not disrespectfully get to dismiss with a mere handwave all of the actual facts about Enzo, his statement and his area of expertise.

You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
Really? How disrespectful. Every participant in this thread managed to trivially find this data with one exception...you. None of us here is your personal internet slave. That you would suggest such is, at least to me, a most scurrilous notion. I suspect I am not alone in this feeling.


- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology
You don't say. We have all been telling you this forever.

-- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
Well, it might, had the guy ever x-rayyed the cloth, but he never did so the point is moot.

- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
What you should actually be doing is conceding that point #1 has been thoroughly demolished and moving on to point #2.

But I bet you won't.

- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.
Really? If he had claimed the saw a mermaid riding a unicorn would you say that we should give that claim any consideration?

Here is a summation for you Jabba...

1. Enzo is/was a consultant medical radiologist.
2. Enzo never subjected the CIQ to any radiological examination
3. Enzo's chosen metier is thus rendered moot.
4. Enzo's baseless opinion that more hands were involved in the visible patches is A) a non expert opinion and B) utterly irrelevant to the question of authenticity.

Now, let me put on my tinfoil hat here, Jabba, and make some predictions:

1. You will initially ignore this post.
2. When confronted with this, you will seek some sentence or phrase which you will wilfully misconstrue as an insult in some way shape or form.
3. You will then declare victory, Pyrrhic as it may be.
4. You will repeat this disrespectful behaviour with regard to every other respondent.

How might I know this, you might ask of me, Jabba. I can answer that. Evidence. You have a four year history in this very thread of this very behaviour, all documented, all recorded.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.

Did he have magical x-ray eyes? That might have been useful. Maybe there's a link that tells you about this?
 
By doing so, you could speed things up.

Correct placement of the burden of proof outweighs that concern. Further, if time was so much of the essence, why didn't you do your homework before being graded on it? Your preparation (or obvious lack thereof) is part of the argument, and may be cause to decided it against you. This isn't a group effort where we work together to discover the truth. You are being evaluated and judged according to your ability to present and defend your arguments. Behave accordingly.

Also, in this case, you'd be providing your evidence for your claims.

Actually his "claims" are pretty much the null hypothesis. Delorenzi is your witness. You have the burden to show he is everything he needs to be in order for his statement to be valid as the evidence you claim it is. It is your responsibility to discover what facts, if any, the "impression" is based on. Someone else noting that no such facts are evident is not a "claim" -- it is merely to state the status quo of any unsupported claim. It is your responsibility to discover what expertise your witness actually possesses. Someone else noting that he appears to be qualified only in an unrelated field is not a "claim." And you should be alarmed that you know far less about your witnesses than do your critics. It is a fairly strong indictment of your methods and reasoning. It is your responsibility to tie Delorenzi's statement to the conclusion you say it supports. Someone else noting that no such connection has yet been established is not a "claim."

In other words, it should be abundantly apparent to you at this juncture that none of your critics here is going to accept a burden of proof that rightly belongs to you, and no one is going to let you shift it away from you under any pretext. So in order to speed things up, please stop all of these rhetorical shenanigans and stick to the point.
 
Last edited:
Why would I want to speed things up? I am perfectly happy with where we are: the SOT is a fake. And I don't see any hint that we are even pointed in another future direction.

Any evidence to the contrary would be Jabba's to find and provide.
 
Why would I want to speed things up?

Agreed. I would rather have Jabba take a six-month hiatus and return having researched all of Marino & Prior's claims to the point where he felt confident he could present and defend them in a hostile forum. The way it stands, he can write off some eventual defeat as a product of his unpreparedness, and that the conclusions themselves are still plausible. Jabba has confessed reasons to distrust those authors.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment/Delorenzi

Because that is what the quote says. It refers to 'the repairs' that were carried out by the Poor Clares, the blessed Valfre and the Princess Clotilde, and his (Delorenzi's) impression of more hands involved in them.

I expect that you still have access to the pdf of M&P's paper, so you can see the reference for yourself.
- OK...
- You guys have convinced me that I am probably wrong about the Delorenzi 'evidence.'
- I'll be back.
 
You guys have convinced me that I am probably wrong about the Delorenzi 'evidence.'

I'm afraid we're going to need more commitment than that. Is your new conviction strong enough for us to leave point no. 1 behind and move on to point no. 2? We have to ask because it's just as likely you're trying to squelch criticism for now, with every intent to "reset" Delorenzi at some later time. Zooterkin was right in cautioning me above: we have to make sure you don't try to retread the same ground later. Therefore we're going to need a clear answer that we can link back to in the unfortunate event you try to reset the argument.
 
- OK...
- You guys have convinced me that I am probably wrong about the Delorenzi 'evidence.'
- I'll be back.

Good, now, can you learn from it?

Because remember, you didn't come up with that source on your own. It was from a different source. THEY were the ones who were peddling Delorenzi, and you just parroted their recommendation without thinking about it.

However, now you discover that this source that they were peddling turned out to be a bust. Yes, it tells you that he is probably not a good source. BUT it ALSO tells you that your other source, the one you relied upon in the first place, is also suspect. They are demonstrably misleading. They lied to you.

Now, if you are honest, you will admit that it is not just Delorenzi who you can't believe, you also can't believe the source that tried to use Delorenzi in the first place. Anyone who holds Delorenzi up as an expert witness has not done adequate analysis, and therefore cannot be considered reliable in this, nor in anything. Every claim they make has to be verified independently, which means they are worthless as a source.

That's the lesson of this encounter. Will you learn it?
 
- OK...
- You guys have convinced me that I am probably wrong about the Delorenzi 'evidence.'
- I'll be back.

Well, not bad, that, ... for someone who generally accepts "probably", "maybe", and "possibly" as strong evidence....

OK, next.

Hans
 
Bet the dropping of Delorenzi with accurate reason why does not make the fantasy map on Jabba's website.
 
Jabba said:
...snip...
Edited by jsfisher: 
Moderated content redacted.

Please move on to point 2 of your latest evidence of authenticity
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Vacations and sabbaticals too.

The subject here is The Miracle of the Shroud. Jabba will be back to post any imaginable claim or twisted logic to support authenticity on this, The Miracle of the Shroud thread.

It will almost always be a waste of electrons, but it will always be on the topic of The Miracle of the Shroud - except when it isn't.

So back on topic: Has anyone got compelling evidence for the authenticity of the CIQ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom