Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Evidence - Expert Judgment/Delorenzi

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Here is an opportunity to learn:

Prof. Delorenzi was, in fact, a Radiologist; he did, in fact, undertake the radiological examination of many works of art. He even, in fact suggested that a radiological examination of the CIQ would be valuable. On the ohter hand, he did not undertake such an examination of the CIQ. He cannot be said to have brought his expertise to bear upon the CIQ. There is, in fact, no record I can find of his being allowed to handle the CIQ, or to examine it other than in its frame...
Slowvehicle,
- Can you give me the links you used?
 
- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.

Please read my above post. Also I would point out that the proper analogy is that Deloenzi was a Nebraska farmer who claimed to see a tiger in the wheat on his farm; he neighbors interpreted that to state that he probably had seen a whale in the wheat. Wrong expertise and a statement that had nothing to do with the invisible patch you need to establish to discredit the 14 C evidence, which as pointed out multiple times, would still leave you without any proof of the authenticity of the SOT.

Continuing with Delorenzi would have to be interpreted as a clear attempt to avoid any substantial discussion of the authenticity of the SOT. It would not be doing your viewpoint a favor. Please let us know if this is the best evidence you have so that we can weigh your arguments appropriately.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment/Delorenzi

...
Further (and more injurious to your case), the quote you offer does not refer to "invisible" reweaving, or "near-invisible" reweaving, or "undetecable" repair, nor even "...some patching" at the sampling site; instead, it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ (that M&P mis-dated)...
- Why do you say that it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ?
 
- Why do you say that it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ?

Probably because he did not write that he saw a patch in the area of the 14C test, and because he could not see from his distance from the SOT the "near invisible patch" that you require to negate the 14C evidence; you know, the "patch" that was not seen under a microscope by the experts who were chosen by the Vatican to find a patch free area.
 
- Why do you say that it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ?

Please show us some evidence that the CIQ is authentic before you get the whole classroom in trouble again.
 
Last edited:
- Why do you say that it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ?


Because the quotation from Delorenzi that you have provided says nothing about any previously undetected and undocumented repairs; it just says that he got the impression that more people had been involved in the repairs than had been documented. That is not a statement that he thinks that there are more repairs than had been identified. He is clearly talking about repairs that are visible enough for differences in the needlework to be apparent.

Can you provide a quotation from Delorenzi in which he says that he thinks there might be previously undetected and undocumented repairs on the shroud?

ETA: Let's go back to the gold mine analogy. If I provide you with a lot of gold-free rocks that I say have been extracted from the mine with a pick axe, you are not going to consider that to be evidence that there is gold in the mine. Are you really going to be any more impressed if I get a radiologist to say that he gets the impression that some of them were extracted using a hammer and chisel?
 
Last edited:
- Why do you say that it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ?
Because that is what the quote says. It refers to 'the repairs' that were carried out by the Poor Clares, the blessed Valfre and the Princess Clotilde, and his (Delorenzi's) impression of more hands involved in them.

I expect that you still have access to the pdf of M&P's paper, so you can see the reference for yourself.
 
Last edited:
- Why do you say that it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Did you read the quote from the Good Professor, in the record as item 1 in the M&P paper?

Did you read Agatha's posts about it? (ETA: Including, but by no mean limited to, the most recent, just above?)

Sincerely,

&ct.
 
Last edited:
Evidence - Expert Judgment/Delorenzi

My Dear Mr. Savage:

-Can you explain to me why I should do your homework...yet another time?

Sincerely,

&ct.
- Yeah.
- By doing so, you could speed things up.
- Also, in this case, you'd be providing your evidence for your claims.
 
- Yeah.
- By doing so, you could speed things up.
- Also, in this case, you'd be providing your evidence for your claims.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

What an odd thing for you to say. The irony is almost palpable.

...if I provide you the source I used, will you read it? Will you read all of it? (Unlike the last times I took some pains to provide sources for you...)

I mean, honestly: You have not even read your own sources.

Now, about this "providing evidence for your claims" idea; suppose you do so?

On to item #2, if you would...

Sincerely,

&ct.
 
Last edited:
- Yeah.
- By doing so, you could speed things up.
- Also, in this case, you'd be providing your evidence for your claims.


Jabba, what would speed things up would be for you to admit that your quotation from Delorenzi says nothing about undetected repairs to the sampled area, or indeed anywhere on the cloth. It doesn't matter what his qualifications are or how he arrived at his "impression"; it cannot support your case. It is not relevant here.

Item #1 is done. Please move on to item #2.
 
My Dear Mr. Savage:

-Can you explain to me why I should do your homework...yet another time?

Sincerely,

&ct.


Indeed. Why should anyone do a certain person's homework on the authenticity of the CIQ- which is the topic of this thread - when this certain person won't do his own homework?
 
- Yeah.
- By doing so, you could speed things up.
- Also, in this case, you'd be providing your evidence for your claims.
It's your claim, Jabba, you have the burden of proof. You brought Delorenzi's quote (and M&P's strange interpretation of it in their error ridden paper) into the discussion.

If you can explain how, reading the quote and only the words of the quote, you can get it to refer to invisible or undocumented repairs, then do so.
 
- Yeah.
- By doing so, you could speed things up.
- Also, in this case, you'd be providing your evidence for your claims.

- 1. I hardly think it's possible. You have made zero progress in 4 years. If 40 years were to pass, I still don't think we'd see any evidence of you supporting your claims.

- 2. The a priori claims are yours, and you have never provided an iota of respectable evidence in all this time.

Get busy! Best of luck!

ETA: We don't want to get called for being off topic, so please, Jabba, will you at long-last present some supporting evidence that the CIQ is authentic?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom