Edited by kmortis:
Removed off topic material
- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.
My Dear Mr. Savage:
Here is an opportunity to learn:
Prof. Delorenzi was, in fact, a Radiologist; he did, in fact, undertake the radiological examination of many works of art. He even, in fact suggested that a radiological examination of the CIQ would be valuable. On the ohter hand, he did not undertake such an examination of the CIQ. He cannot be said to have brought his expertise to bear upon the CIQ. There is, in fact, no record I can find of his being allowed to handle the CIQ, or to examine it other than in its frame.
Further (and more injurious to your case), the quote you offer does not refer to "invisible" reweaving, or "near-invisible" reweaving, or "undetecable" repair, nor even "...some
patching" at the sampling site; instead, it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ (that M&P mis-dated).
What is missing from the third-hand account of Prof. Delorenzi's conjecture is...evidence.
Never mind that you, yourself, provided links that demonstrated that the "invisible" (or "French") reweave technique uses threads form the original cloth being rewoven (which means that such a repair could not alter the date, but would, in fact, make the sample even more representative of the whole cloth). Never mind that "invisible" repair uses minimal added thread (which means, of course, that there would not be enough egregious thread to skew the date).
What is important is that Prof. Delorenzi offered a conjecture, outside his area of expertise, without any evidence.
Had the good Professor been able to say, "
Guarda,
here is the rent in the CIQ that was repaired:
Oservare,
these are the modern threads that are bollixing the date," this would be a different argument. However, he did not. Instead, he got an "impression", an impression in line with his commitment to the authenticity of the CIQ.
On to the next.
Bring it.