Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
This thread is a horrible mess of off-topic-ness. Please stop.

The topic is the authenticity of the Shroud of Turin. The topic is not the forum rules, who's violating them, and where they are to be found. The topic is not who's living in the basement of whom. The topic is not about posting the reasons the poster is not responding to another posters remarks.

Shroud of Turin. Not those other things.

The moderators will be delighted by your continued attention to the Membership Agreement and your compliance thereof.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jsfisher
 
This thread is a horrible mess of off-topic-ness. Please stop.

The topic is the authenticity of the Shroud of Turin. The topic is not the forum rules, who's violating them, and where they are to be found. The topic is not who's living in the basement of whom. The topic is not about posting the reasons the poster is not responding to another posters remarks.

Shroud of Turin. Not those other things.

The moderators will be delighted by your continued attention to the Membership Agreement and your compliance thereof.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jsfisher

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Please be so kind as to address item #2 in the M&P paper...

Thanks!
 
Agatha,
- Do you really need to fuss at me?

You know you don't need an excuse to stop discussing this topic, now that it's been shown that you have zero evidence, right? You could always silently leave if that's what you're going to do anyway.

Otherwise I suggest you address the question at hand, and stick to the topic.
 
Last edited:
Evidence - Expert Judgment/Delorenzi

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic material


- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What Delorenzi said referred to the number of hands (or people) whom he believed had worked on the visible and documented repairs. He had an "impression" that more than six people had worked on them; he did not refer to any undocumented repairs. I look forward to you discussing his quote and why M&P have interpreted it the way they have.

If trying to encourage you to return to the topic of the M&P paper that you introduced is "fussing at you", then I apologise for doing so.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic material


- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Here is an opportunity to learn:

Prof. Delorenzi was, in fact, a Radiologist; he did, in fact, undertake the radiological examination of many works of art. He even, in fact suggested that a radiological examination of the CIQ would be valuable. On the ohter hand, he did not undertake such an examination of the CIQ. He cannot be said to have brought his expertise to bear upon the CIQ. There is, in fact, no record I can find of his being allowed to handle the CIQ, or to examine it other than in its frame.

Further (and more injurious to your case), the quote you offer does not refer to "invisible" reweaving, or "near-invisible" reweaving, or "undetecable" repair, nor even "...some patching" at the sampling site; instead, it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ (that M&P mis-dated).

What is missing from the third-hand account of Prof. Delorenzi's conjecture is...evidence.

Never mind that you, yourself, provided links that demonstrated that the "invisible" (or "French") reweave technique uses threads form the original cloth being rewoven (which means that such a repair could not alter the date, but would, in fact, make the sample even more representative of the whole cloth). Never mind that "invisible" repair uses minimal added thread (which means, of course, that there would not be enough egregious thread to skew the date).

What is important is that Prof. Delorenzi offered a conjecture, outside his area of expertise, without any evidence.

Had the good Professor been able to say, "Guarda, here is the rent in the CIQ that was repaired: Oservare, these are the modern threads that are bollixing the date," this would be a different argument. However, he did not. Instead, he got an "impression", an impression in line with his commitment to the authenticity of the CIQ.

On to the next.

Bring it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic material


- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.

The whale analogy shows you have ignored everything your most patient interlocutors have said about statements by experts and in particular those by Delorenzli. If you are not going to have an intellectually honest approach to the discussion then don't bother coming back.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic material


- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.

If you didn't have all that, then why did you present it as evidence?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Further (and more injurious to your case), the quote you offer does not refer to "invisible" reweaving, or "near-invisible" reweaving, or "undetecable" repair, nor even "...some patching" at the sampling site; instead, it refers to the open and notorious patching on the rest of the CIQ (that M&P mis-dated).

What is missing from the third-hand account of Prof. Delorenzi's conjecture is...evidence.

Never mind that you, yourself, provided links that demonstrated that the "invisible" (or "French") reweave technique uses threads form the original cloth being rewoven (which means that such a repair could not alter the date, but would, in fact, make the sample even more representative of the whole cloth). Never mind that "invisible" repair uses minimal added thread (which means, of course, that there would not be enough egregious thread to skew the date).

What is important is that Prof. Delorenzi offered a conjecture, outside his area of expertise, without any evidence.


With respect, the important point about this quotation is the one I have hilighted above. It is simply not relevant to the age or authenticity of the cloth, or the reliability of the carbon dating. Please don't encourage Jabba to continue to filibuster by discussing the expertise or evidence behind this irrelevance.

Jabba, it's time for item #2. Item #1 is done.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic material


- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.


You should have vetted Delorenzi before trotting him out as an expert witness. His testimony is irrelevant because he was discussing the known, visible patching done by the Poor Clares. His expertise in radiology is irrelevant unless he were discussing some radiological evidence WRT the authenticity of the CIQ.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic material and response to same


- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
Do your own homework.

- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
Explain why.

- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.
Only the truely desperate would want to rally the testimony of drunken sailors.

Hans
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc.

Please tell us why you haven't already done this. Is it going to be your habit to misrepresent as "expert witnesses" people you know little or nothing about? Are you simply credulously parroting the words of your authors, who have now given you plenty of reasons to distrust them?

You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.

No. He's your witness. Do your own homework.

I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.

No.

I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.

Then for the reasons already elaborated -- at length -- Delorenzi remains disqualified until such time as you feel like rehabilitating him, which you seem not to want to do. Don't drag on so. Move on to no. 2, as nearly all your critics have admonished you to do.

He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.

We have, and for good reasons. Reasons you will not address, and reasons that have, in large part, to do with facts you cannot make go away by handwaving appeals to extend Delorenzi's expertise to cover the topic.
 
Jabba, it's time for item #2. Item #1 is done.

Agreed. However, from the opposite perspective, nos. 2 through whatever are not likely to fare well either. Having reluctantly agreed to a detailed examination of evidence he expected to stand alone on sheer weight of numbers. his moving on is anathema. But on the other hand, if the discussion bogs down on no. 1, then the rest of the points don't get examined and remain ambiguous. Dollars to donuts we'll be mired in Delorenzi until the critics drop away by attrition.
 
Only the truely desperate would want to rally the testimony of drunken sailors.

Jabba forgets he's trying to show consilience. The more he has to tap dance, cajole, and imaginatively interpret each point on his list, the more it can be said to be anti-consilient.

Jabba is still very much in the dark about what it means for something to be consilient. Because the concept was raised to him in response to a particular assertion, he has the wrong idea. Jabba's claim was that the number of points of testimony was important, and also that they agreed in support of his hypotheis. That together, says Jabba, makes a case. However, consilience deals almost exclusively with the latter, not the former. That is, while by definition it takes at least two lines of evidence to argue by consilience, the key concept is how they are developed in light of each other and the overall hypothesis. The qualitative development is the probative factor, not the number. Three points of consilient evidence is far more convincing than a dozen barely relevant ones.
 
Last edited:
...discovering anomalies in the weave.

Let me add that Delorenzi didn't claim to discover "anomalies in the weave." In fact you have no idea what physical observation, if any, led him to form his "impression." You must rely solely on what Delorenzi said and did, not what you imagine his testimony might mean.
 
- Instead, I'm going back to Delorenzi and further explore his expertise, etc. You guys could speed things up by telling me where you find your info about him.
- I did find out that his expertise was in radiology -- which seems to me like an expertise useful in discovering anomalies in the weave.
- I'll be back to further discuss Delorenzi's credibility, and what he said.
- He might be a drunken sailor, but he might be saying that he saw a whale, and we probably shouldn't be dismissing his testimony.
It seems like now might be a good time for us to set Delorenzi aside for a while, and see whether the other items on the list promise better results. If it turns out that items 2 and 3 are sufficient to establish consilience, that would save you a lot of time and effort trying to rehabilitate Delorenzi. And if not, you can always come back to Delorenzi once you have a better idea of how important he is relative to the other items.
 
I only wished to emphasize to Jabba that he is the one who seek to prove authenticity- withholding his evidence is not leverage that can be applied to the anti-authenticity posters. They don't belief your viewpoint and they don't even believe that you have any evidence to withhold. Threatening to withhold any pro-authenticity evidence that you might have only hurts your argument and re-enforces the anti-authenticity side.

If you have any non-debunked evidence of the authenticity of the SOT now would be the time to present it to strengthen your argument. If you don't present this pro-evidence the people following this thread will inevitably conclude that you have none, which I gather would not be what you are seeking. Please state your most convincing evidence first- your quote from a radiologist who glanced at the SOT from a distance and had the impression that multiple hands worked on the well known and highly visible patches was totally irrelevant and only further convinced the anti-authenticity side that you have no evidence- even indirect or circumstantial.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom