Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
We previously had near invisible patches that were invisible, and now we have documentation of undocumented repairs. The only thing they have in common is that there is no (zero, none, neoni, naught, nil) evidence of either- just statements that such things "might have happened." Well, I might have been my brother, but I was not.

Finally I feel impelled to state that I am probably viewed as an expert in biochemistry. But if I were to say Peter Rubens was a noted artist born in France I would be wrong. In fact if I were to say that glucose is joined to chloride during normal oxidative phosphorylation, an area within my own field of expertise, I also would be wrong. It wouldn't tilt the scales in favor of glucose-chloride a bit, a nanometer, or a fraction of a degree; it would still be absolutely, completely wrong.
I like this. I can be considered at least a minor expert in a couple of fields. I know they are not remotely related to textiles or art or theology or religious history or medieval history, but that apparently doesn't matter.

My examination of the shroud leads me to conclude that it might be of medieval origin. My examination of the evidence confirms my conclusion.
 
- OK. Let's take one entry at a time.

Entry: #1
Date: 1976
Data Category: General possibility of repairs
Evidence: Enzo Delorenzi, a member of the Turin Commission that studied the Shroud in 1969
and 1973, wrote: ―…I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records (the four Clarissas of Chambery, the Blessed Valfre and the Princess
Clotilde).‖
Source: Delorenzi, Enzo: 1976. ―Observations on the Patches and Darns in the Holy Shroud.‖
In Doyle, E., M.Green, Fr., & V. Ossola (Trans.) Report of Turin Commission on the Holy
Shroud (pp. 108-123). Unpublished. Translation of La S. Sindone: Ricerche e studi della
Commissione di Esperti nominata dall‘Arcivescovo di Torino, Card. Michele Pellegrino, nel.



If his impression was correct, there is still no evidence here that the sampled part of the cloth had been repaired. He doesn't opine that there were more repairs than are visible or documented, just that he got the impression that more people had been involved in the repairs than had been documented.

Next.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Be so kind as not to put words in my mouth, as in the highlighted
In what area, specifically, do you consider Pro. Delorenzi to be an "expert"?

Further, as far as is recorded, Prof. Delorenzi did not, in fact, handle the CIQ, but observed it in its frame...
Slowvehicle,
- I didn't mean to misrepresent you when I said, "You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent)."
- Back in 1562, you said, "At any rate, if you read this, be aware that the problem with the M&P paper is not, in my opinion, so much the level of expertise as the utter lack of evidence."
- You're right, I assumed too much...
- Can you tell me where you got your info on Delorenzi?
 
- Can you tell me where you got your info on Delorenzi?

I can but I won't. This is homework you should already have done before introducing these witnesses, and although I have done your homework for you, I will not let you benefit from the fruits of my labor. He is your witness and it is your responsibility to establish that he really is the expert you need him to be. If you don't know whether Delorenzi is a relevantly qualified expert, then you don't get to present him as one.

As a matter of fact, Delorenzi's educational and professional qualifications are quite easy to find. If you haven't done even that level of research on your sources, then I'd say you have quite a lot of work to do before revisiting the list of people you claim are experts.
 
- Back in 1562, you said, "At any rate, if you read this, be aware that the problem with the M&P paper is not, in my opinion, so much the level of expertise as the utter lack of evidence."


Have these threads really been going on that long, or does it just feel like it?
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

Slowvehicle,
- I didn't mean to misrepresent you when I said, "You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent)."
- Back in 1562, you said, "At any rate, if you read this, be aware that the problem with the M&P paper is not, in my opinion, so much the level of expertise as the utter lack of evidence."
- You're right, I assumed too much...
- Can you tell me where you got your info on Delorenzi?
Slowvehicle,
- But note that the only part I got wrong was about the relevance of Delorenzi's expertise, and even there, you seemed to be accepting its relevance. Otherwise, you did seem to be accepting his expertise, and that he had indeed studied the shroud to some extent -- though, if only in its frame, that extent must be minimal.
 
Have these threads really been going on that long, or does it just feel like it?

Jabba just likes to be off by several centuries. Perhaps an invisible patch in the calendar has skewed the results. Then again, since the thread has never been reproduced, it's 2000 years old.
 
Slowvehicle,
- But note that the only part I got wrong was about the relevance of Delorenzi's expertise, and even there, you seemed to be accepting its relevance. Otherwise, you did seem to be accepting his expertise, and that he had indeed studied the shroud to some extent -- though, if only in its frame, that extent must be minimal.

All this is utterly irrelevant. Expert opinion is nothing. Evidence is everything.

You have no evidence. You lost.
 
Slowvehicle,
- I didn't mean to misrepresent you when I said, "You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent)."
- Back in 1562, you said, "At any rate, if you read this, be aware that the problem with the M&P paper is not, in my opinion, so much the level of expertise as the utter lack of evidence."
- You're right, I assumed too much...
- Can you tell me where you got your info on Delorenzi?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

At its heart, this is another דַּיֵּנוּ ("It would have been enough") argument.

Follow: The [primary] problem with the M&P paper is not the quality of the "experts", not is it the level of their expertise. Even if we allow the assumption for the sake of the argument (and ONLY for the sake of the argument) that the "experts" were the world's superlatives, a gathering of intellectual prowess unequaled since "Thomas Jefferson ate lunch alone", the fact that the "experts" provide no evidentiary basis for their opinions, suppositions, surmises, and conjectures is enough, in itself (דַּיֵּנוּ) to obviate any potential value as evidence of the existence of an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, an "undetectable" repair, or even "...some patching" wrought upon the sampled area of the CIQ.

Actual textile experts, who have actually handled the CIQ, and examined it from both sides (under multiple light sources, including backlighting) saw no evidence, none, of any such thing. Supposition, surmise, opinion, and conjecture to the contrary, without evidence, is simply calumny.

I am no longer surprised that you would present a person as an "expert", third-hand, without having any idea of their expertise.

For the record, I do not accept Prof. Delorenzi as a "relevant" expert. To avoid poisoning the well, I will simply suggest you do a web search about his qualifications.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- I didn't mean to misrepresent you when I said, "You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent)."
- Back in 1562, you said, "At any rate, if you read this, be aware that the problem with the M&P paper is not, in my opinion, so much the level of expertise as the utter lack of evidence."
- You're right, I assumed too much...
- Can you tell me where you got your info on Delorenzi?

He is a Medical Radiologist.

Please explain what exact insight or expertise this gives him in textiles?
 
If his impression was correct, there is still no evidence here that the sampled part of the cloth had been repaired. He doesn't opine that there were more repairs than are visible or documented, just that he got the impression that more people had been involved in the repairs than had been documented.

Next.

Thank you for catching this. I had to reread Jabba's post carefully to realize exactly where the Delorenzi quote ended and Jabba's totally unrelated conclusions began!

I really have trouble not seeing this as a sly deceptive trick rather than just poor typography. Interestingly, it wouldn't matter even if Delorenzi's quote did include Jabba's words too, although that would have further demeaned Delorenzi as an "expert" in my eyes. In fact, Jabba's posts appear to now not only insult the experts who have convincingly determined the SOT as not authentic, but also the experts who for personal religious reasons still favor authenticity.

Once again the odd thing is that Jabba has indicated a need to have the SOT authentic to buttress his faith, but then goes through so many exercises in twisted logic to deny the obvious and argue that the SOT "might" be authentic. What on Earth is the point? When he is done twisting and turning and denying in regard to the SOT, how can what little is left (zero IMHO) support his faith? An imaginary bucket, let alone one with enormous holes in it, will not bail out your boat.
 
Slowvehicle,
- But note that the only part I got wrong was about the relevance of Delorenzi's expertise, and even there, you seemed to be accepting its relevance. Otherwise, you did seem to be accepting his expertise, and that he had indeed studied the shroud to some extent -- though, if only in its frame, that extent must be minimal.

My Dear (if somewhat obdurate) Mr. Savage:

No, no, no, no, no; I say thee nay.

You did not "get wrong" Prof. Delorenzi's "area of expertise"; you "got wrong" the fact that he provided not a sniff, not a skerrick, not a scruple, not a sucre of EVIDENCE for his "impression" that the CIQ was "darned by more hands than recorded", דַּיֵּנוּ, he did nothing to demonstrate the existence of an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, an "undetectable" repair, nor even "...some patching" anywhere on the CIQ, to say nothing of in or around the sampled corner.

No probative value.

No possibility of consilience.
 
Last edited:
My Dear Mr. Savage:

At its heart, this is another דַּיֵּנוּ ("It would have been enough") argument.
Follow: The [primary] problem with the M&P paper is not the quality of the "experts", not is it the level of their expertise. Even if we allow the assumption for the sake of the argument (and ONLY for the sake of the argument) that the "experts" were the world's superlatives, a gathering of intellectual prowess unequaled since "Thomas Jefferson ate lunch alone", the fact that the "experts" provide no evidentiary basis for their opinions, suppositions, surmises, and conjectures is enough, in itself (דַּיֵּנוּ) to obviate any potential value as evidence of the existence of an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, an "undetectable" repair, or even "...some patching" wrought upon the sampled area of the CIQ.

Actual textile experts, who have actually handled the CIQ, and examined it from both sides (under multiple light sources, including backlighting) saw no evidence, non, of any such thing. Supposition, surmise, opinion, and conjecture to the contrary, without evidence, is simply calumny.

I am no longer surprised that you would present a person as an "expert", third-hand, without having any idea of their expertise.

For the record, I do not accept Prof. Delorenzi as a "relevant" expert. To avoid poisoning the well, I will simply suggest you do a web search about his qualifications.

I own the very robe worn by Pharaoh from Exodus! It shows some frogs impacts, water damage, and a few matzoh crumbs on it, but I can sell it to you for a small sum (the documentation, as you might expect, is a bit poor given the rush of events at the time).
 
Thank you for catching this. I had to reread Jabba's post carefully to realize exactly where the Delorenzi quote ended and Jabba's totally unrelated conclusions began!

I really have trouble not seeing this as a sly deceptive trick rather than just poor typography. Interestingly, it wouldn't matter even if Delorenzi's quote did include Jabba's words too, although that would have further demeaned Delorenzi as an "expert" in my eyes. In fact, Jabba's posts appear to now not only insult the experts who have convincingly determined the SOT as not authentic, but also the experts who for personal religious reasons still favor authenticity.

Once again the odd thing is that Jabba has indicated a need to have the SOT authentic to buttress his faith, but then goes through so many exercises in twisted logic to deny the obvious and argue that the SOT "might" be authentic. What on Earth is the point? When he is done twisting and turning and denying in regard to the SOT, how can what little is left (zero IMHO) support his faith? An imaginary bucket, let alone one with enormous holes in it, will not bail out your boat.

...but such is the "beauty" of the bucket that it must be "true" even if it could not have happened...(pace Phyllis Pickle).
 
No possibility of consilience.

Indeed, clear evidence of anti-consilience. The authors Jabba relies upon are the ones who interpret Delorenzi's guess that more workers worked on the shroud than were documented as evidence of a patch. As Agatha has eloquently noted, there is no rational reason to connect Delorenzi's belief to that conclusion. Clearly the line of evidence has been interpreted using the desired conclusion as a driver.
 
I own the very robe worn by Pharaoh from Exodus! It shows some frogs impacts, water damage, and a few matzoh crumbs on it, but I can sell it to you for a small sum (the documentation, as you might expect, is a bit poor given the rush of events at the time).

"We alreddy hev one of our own! Now goe ewwey, silly English pig-dog kunniggit!"
 
The partial quote supplied suggests that Delorenzi believed he could identify the darning skills of more than six separate people. That is the only thing that the quote is saying.1


No. Delorenzi does not claim that there are other repairs on the cloth other than those documented - at least not in the quote supplied. He claims only that there were more people involved in making the documented repairs.

The comments, which are Marino and Prior's interpretation of a (possibly out of context) quote, go much further than Delorenzi's words and add in a conjecture which is completely unsupported by the actual quote.

Delorenzi's quote is not a conclusion, it's a claim. It's a claim, without evidence, that he has an "impression" about how many people have worked on the cloth in the past. It is not (at least as published in that pdf) a claim about there being more repairs than those very obvious and well documented ones.

Marino and Prior have gone much further in interpreting the quote to support their preferred conclusion than the quote from Delorenzi warrants. If I were feeling uncharitable, I would call their interpretation dishonest.

1. It is, in my educated-in-needlework-opinion, unlikely that he could actually pick out more than six different darning styles and say with confidence that none of those darns was done by the same person using a different technique, but I am giving him the benefit of the doubt and taking his comment at face value.

2. I suspect a translation error, as I am sure nobody is really contending that the repairs done by the Poor Clare nuns was done in 1973. However, later Marino and Prior contend that the C14 dating method was invented by Gove, rather the actual inventor and Nobel winner Willard Libby. Maybe M and P are just really bad at fact checking?

I know Jabba won't read this, but I just wanted to thank you for your continued thoughtful efforts throughout this train wreck.
 
Indeed, clear evidence of anti-consilience. The authors Jabba relies upon are the ones who interpret Delorenzi's guess that more workers worked on the shroud than were documented as evidence of a patch. As Agatha has eloquently noted, there is no rational reason to connect Delorenzi's belief to that conclusion. Clearly the line of evidence has been interpreted using the desired conclusion as a driver.

*gasp*
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom