Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Evidence - Expert Judgment

Jay,
- No. I just think that if you answer my questions directly, your answers will show that I am not "equivocating," that the entries given by Marino and Prior are consilient, and that you just don't think much of the expertise, nor arguments, of the researchers quoted in the different entries.

I have answered your questions directly, in some case more than once. You keep trying to turn the answers into others that you are more prepared to address...
Jay,

- I'll take that back. My bad.
- Apparently, I wasn't reading your responses carefully enough, nor remembering my own questions/comments specifically enough...

- As I now understand things, your positions are that
1. The 'experts'' expertise is not well established.
2. Their arguments are weak.
3. The expertise of Marino and Prior is not well established.
4. The Marino/Prior arguments are weak.
5. Consequently, their papers lack any meaningful consilience.
6. I have been equivocal.
- Where am I not understanding your positions?

- So far, I still disagree with what I'm understanding as your positions above -- but, I need to review them one at a time.
 
Jay,

- I'll take that back. My bad.
- Apparently, I wasn't reading your responses carefully enough, nor remembering my own questions/comments specifically enough...

- As I now understand things, your positions are that
1. The 'experts'' expertise is not well established.
2. Their arguments are weak.
3. The expertise of Marino and Prior is not well established.
4. The Marino/Prior arguments are weak.
5. Consequently, their papers lack any meaningful consilience.
6. I have been equivocal.
- Where am I not understanding your positions?

- So far, I still disagree with what I'm understanding as your positions above -- but, I need to review them one at a time.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I wonder why it is that my posts have disappeared from your cognizance once again...

At any rate, if you read this, be aware that the problem with the M&P paper is not, in my opinion, so much the level of expertise as the utter lack of evidence.

Speculation, even speculation by an "expert", is not evidence.

Conjecture, even conjecture by an "expert", is not evidence.

Special pleading, even special pleading by an "expert", is not evidence.

Circular reasoning, even circular reasoning by an "expert", is not evidence.

No amount of speculation, conjecture, special pleading, and circular reasoning can be added up to become evidence.

As I have said before, what is lacking is any actual indication of the existence, nature, and location of any "invisible" reweave, any "near-invisible" reweave, any "undetectable" repair, or even "...some patching" in the tested area of the CIQ.

The fact that sidonists don't like the 14C dating, because it came back with the "wrong date" is not evidence...

Have you repaired the gross deficiencies in your "map" yet?
 
Discussion Format

Slowvehicle,
- I'm having enough trouble trying to keep up with Jay. For now, it's his turn.
 
Slowvehicle,
- I'm having enough trouble trying to keep up with Jay. For now, it's his turn.

I'm interested in your answers to their questions too, so please answer all your critics, not just the ones you think you can prevail against. You chose the venue, and that's the nature of the venue.

You are not having trouble keeping up with me. You're having trouble making me follow your scripted argument. For three days you've made one post a day that simply reiterates the previous day, and that post -- in the guise of once again asking for clarification or summary -- rather ham-fistedly tries to put your words in my mouth.

Quit stalling and provide evidence.
 
An argument by consilience requires each of the items quoted in the post linked below to be addressed individually, without reference to the others, and not simply to be taken together.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10986866#post10986866

If your next post to me does not begin such an address, I will consider you willfully evasive, our conversation will be over, and I will consider you unwilling to prove your claim. Are my instructions clear enough to you now?
 
I will offer this unsolicited suggestion to the web-persona referred to as Jabba one more time for him to consider:

Jabba you have frequently indicated that you are having a lot of trouble participating in this thread: remembering posts, finding "evidence" that you know you had once, following the arguments of other posters, interpreting people's logic, organizing your arguments in convincing ways, keeping up with more than one poster or even more than one argument from a single poster at a time, etc. You have even asked the people who disagree with you to help you to present your side.

It is clear to everyone else here that this thread is going nowhere and if anything you have helped convince the others here of the evidence that the SOT is not authentic.

I gather you enjoy the give and take in the Forum. Select an easier topic and thread (or threads) for you to successfully argue your view of that topic. Let this thread die and move on to something more pleasant for you and easier for you to prove (I certainly do not recommend your justifiably abandoned reincarnation thread by the way). If you really need the SOT to be authentic for your belief, fine- trust that it is either on faith or for the arguments you made here but which everyone else has rejected. You clearly believe these arguments yourself- you are not going to convince anyone else here and you will only have your reasons for belief undermined.

Move on. Please.
 
An argument by consilience requires each of the items quoted in the post linked below to be addressed individually, without reference to the others, and not simply to be taken together.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10986866#post10986866

If your next post to me does not begin such an address, I will consider you willfully evasive, our conversation will be over, and I will consider you unwilling to prove your claim. Are my instructions clear enough to you now?

I wonder if Jabba in reality, consciously or not, wishes for the more hardened opponents to leave in disgust, so he might be left with one or two less seasoned debaters, whom he might be able to "defeat".

Two problems here, Jabba:

1) If you were left with an incompetent opposition and managed to "win" the discussion, it would not make your claims true.

2) It won't happen. There will always be some veteran ready to cut you down.

Hans
 
I wonder if Jabba in reality, consciously or not, wishes for the more hardened opponents to leave in disgust...

It wouldn't be the first (or the thousandth) time a fringe theorist has deployed the attrition-through-befuddlement tactic. It happens all the time. If you take three hours to set up a chess board, no one will wait that long to play against you. And you can walk away thinking you're undefeated.
 
I can't think of any poster who has ever posted in this thread who would have any difficulty disproving Jabba's claim (I was going to exclude Jabba himself, but even Jabba appears to periodically defeat Jabba's pro-authenticity claims).
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I wonder why it is that my posts have disappeared from your cognizance once again...

At any rate, if you read this, be aware that the problem with the M&P paper is not, in my opinion, so much the level of expertise as the utter lack of evidence.

Speculation, even speculation by an "expert", is not evidence.

Conjecture, even conjecture by an "expert", is not evidence...
Slowvehicle,

- Since I seem incapable of understanding what Jay is saying, I'll try addressing what you 're saying...

- I think that the key here lies is in the appropriate definition of "conjecture."
- There are slight variations between the different attempts to define "conjecture." One of those given is simply "guesswork."
- Then, from
https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&ie=UTF-8#q=conjecture definition, however, we get
- an opinion or conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information.
- To me, what we find in the M/P papers are examples of the latter -- and, what's the difference between that kind of a conjecture and "judgment"?

- So, it seems to me that what we have in the M/P papers are a bunch of expert judgments. And, expert judgments are considered "evidence."
 
Last edited:
Since you are consistently incapable of understanding fairly simple and well elucidated points, give up. I think you are being disingenuous about this though.
 
Since I seem incapable of understanding what Jay is saying...

I find it unlikely that someone who is so obsessed over nuance of meaning is incapable of understanding plain English. Deliberate obtuseness better explains your behavior. And I think it's more likely you're dumping me because I won't consent to play your games.

I think that the key here lies is in the appropriate definition of "conjecture."

More word play and equivocation. You evidently have no other argument.

One of those given is simply "guesswork."

That's the meaning we intend. Do not insinuate otherwise. Since the rest of your post is rendered moot by this clarification, please begin here as requested.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom