Jabba
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2012
- Messages
- 5,613
Evidence - Expert Judgment
- I'll take that back. My bad.
- Apparently, I wasn't reading your responses carefully enough, nor remembering my own questions/comments specifically enough...
- As I now understand things, your positions are that
1. The 'experts'' expertise is not well established.
2. Their arguments are weak.
3. The expertise of Marino and Prior is not well established.
4. The Marino/Prior arguments are weak.
5. Consequently, their papers lack any meaningful consilience.
6. I have been equivocal.
- Where am I not understanding your positions?
- So far, I still disagree with what I'm understanding as your positions above -- but, I need to review them one at a time.
Jay,
- No. I just think that if you answer my questions directly, your answers will show that I am not "equivocating," that the entries given by Marino and Prior are consilient, and that you just don't think much of the expertise, nor arguments, of the researchers quoted in the different entries.
Jay,I have answered your questions directly, in some case more than once. You keep trying to turn the answers into others that you are more prepared to address...
- I'll take that back. My bad.
- Apparently, I wasn't reading your responses carefully enough, nor remembering my own questions/comments specifically enough...
- As I now understand things, your positions are that
1. The 'experts'' expertise is not well established.
2. Their arguments are weak.
3. The expertise of Marino and Prior is not well established.
4. The Marino/Prior arguments are weak.
5. Consequently, their papers lack any meaningful consilience.
6. I have been equivocal.
- Where am I not understanding your positions?
- So far, I still disagree with what I'm understanding as your positions above -- but, I need to review them one at a time.