Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slowvehicle,

- Since I seem incapable of understanding what Jay is saying, I'll try addressing what you 're saying...

- I think that the key here lies is in the appropriate definition of "conjecture."
- There are slight variations between the different attempts to define "conjecture." One of those given is simply "guesswork."
- Then, from
https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&ie=UTF-8#q=conjecture definition, however, we get
- an opinion or conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information.
- To me, what we find in the M/P papers are examples of the latter -- and, what's the difference between that kind of a conjecture and "judgment"?

- So, it seems to me that what we have in the M/P papers are a bunch of expert judgments. And, expert judgments are considered "evidence."

Good Evening, Mr. Savage:

This is (one of) the equivocal part(s) of your "effective debate".

JayUtah has done a very competent job calling you on your tendency to cherry-pick among dubiously equivalent meanings of a word, so I shall not re-plow his furrows.

I will, however, repeat this point, which I made earlier, and you ignored:

What is lacking is a basis for the conjectures you wish you could transmogrify into evidence by sheer weight of numbers.

As I have pointed out before, the only basis for the invention of the idea of the "invisible" reweave, or the "near-invisible" reweave, or the "undetectable" repair, or even "...some patching" is the annoying (to you) fact that the most-scrutinized bit of 14C dating ever undertaken triply-redundantly returned the "wrong" date--"wrong" because it disagreed with the sidonists' assumed consequent (an assumed consequent to which you, yourself, adhere) that the CIQ must be ~2000 years old.

What is lacking is evidence: "Look--here are anomalous fibers, where a repair was wrought; see--this is where the CIQ was rent, that a repair was needed; feel--these are the splices of the heretofore unsuspected compromise of the original integrity of the CIQ."

The conjectures you hope to amass into evidence are not based upon observation, but upon supposition: an attempt to explain away the "wrong" date without any other support than forlorn hope.

The result of adding empty assertions is not consilience.

The plural of "fervent, pious hope" is not "evidence"

No matter how often you repeat your unsupported assertions.

Have you repaired the gross deficiencies in your "map", yet?
 
[snippety]

expert judgments are considered "evidence."

-No, no, and seventy times no. Expert judgement is worthless unless it is itself based on solid evidence.

-Opinions, even those of experts, do not constitute evidence.
-Where in the world would you get such a fanciful idea?

-Get real. Evidence is all that should be discussed. You have none.

-You must admit your position is based on faith. You already admitted you need to appeal to paranormal events, might as well be honest with yourself and accept the truth.
 
Last edited:
Jabba's responses have now degenerated into posting dictionary definitions. And when there are multiple definitions for a word (which all essentially mean the same thing), he agonizes and nitpicks over which definition he should use. Jabba has now done more research into the definitions of a few words than he's done on the shroud itself. Amazing.
 
Last edited:
*snip*

- So, it seems to me that what we have in the M/P papers are a bunch of expert judgments. And, expert judgments are considered "evidence."

Let's have a look at this while we wait (and wait, and wait ...):

(Sorry to address you in 3rd person here, Jabba, but since you don't seem to read my posts ....)

Here, we have another example of equivocation. There is an expert who seems to express an opinion, so Jabba claims we have an "expert opinion", which is evidence.

However, as many other terms, 'expert opinion' has more than one meaning.

The cases Jabba quotes seem (pending evidence to the contrary) to be opinions from people who may or may not be relevant experts. This is really at best just the opinions of experts, and is conjecture, not evidence.

There is another kind of expert opinon, which IS evidence: Here you request (and nearly always pay for, sometimes dearly) an expert to investigate a case and deliver, normally in writing, an expert judgement on what evidence exists and the weight and credibility of that evidence. This kind of 'expert opinion' is much akin to a formal witness statement, and can indeed be presented on court as such. I have made some of those myself (in my own area of expertice).

Obviously, none of the statements referred by Jabba are of the latter kind.

In fact most of them aren't even of the first type, since the persons are not experts in a relevant field.

However, I'm sure we are ready to address each of them in some detail, should Jabba wish to do so.

Hans
 
To summarise so far. Jabba has completely failed to dent the mountain of evidence that the shroud is a medieval fake. In fact he's refused to even address most of it.

Historical: the lack of evidence for the shroud's existence prior to the mid fourteenth century; further it's emergence during the 'holy relic' craze (along with some forty other such burial shrouds); lack of mention of a miraculously imaged Shroud in any early Christian writings; the distinct changes in the shroud, e.g. fading of colour, since its first exposure.

Physiological: the lack of resemblance of the shroud image to an actual human body; likewise the position of the body with hands folded across the genitals isn't possible for a body lying flay (the arms aren't long enough).

Textile: the weave pattern of the shroud does not match anything known from first century Mid East but matches medieval Europe well; no example of the complex herringbone twill weave has even been shown to come from the first century Mid East.

Testimony: the d'Arcis Memo indicates the shroud was created around 1354 and was a held to be a known fake not many year later.

Artistic: the face of the image resembles medieval Byzantine style, with Gothic elements; the unnaturally elongated body shape and extremities are typical of the elongated style the Late Medieval/High Gothic period.

Reproducibility: contrary to the claims of shroudies the image can and has been reproduced using medieval techniques.

Analytic: examination, microscopic (including electron microscopy) and chemical testing show the shroud image is made from common artistic pigments of the period of its origin. Further the cloth was subjected to an extraordinarily comprehensive radiocarbon dating that produced an age value in accordance with the other evidence.

Cultural: the shroud does not match with what is known of first century Jewish burial practices (including the only actual sample of such cloths) or the only extant sample of such burial cloths; nor does the shroud match the biblical accounts; nor are there any demonstrated artifacts of the putative Jesus extant today; nor does the supposed historical background indicate that such a cloth would have been preserved, certainly without much publicity prior to ~1355.

Or, for those who prefer pictures;

 
Let's see here. I am an expert liquid chromatographer, and have been published in a peer-reviewed journal for pesticide residue analysis. I work for the largest private laboratory system in the world.

I say that the CIQ is an artifact from the middle ages. So according to Jabba, I'm giving my expert opinion. The case is closed.


ETA: Unlike most sindonologists, I followed the evidence listed here http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10996627&postcount=1606 before I came to any conclusions.
 
Last edited:
<respectful snip for focus>

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I'm about to go make multiple pies for a Thanksgiving Day celebration to which I have been invited, tomorrow, but before the storm, I wonder if you might indulge me a question. To what faith, or faith tradition, do you belong?

I have just finished reading Phyllis Pickle's useful little book, The Great Emergence. I highly recommend it to you. One concept, in particular, cast light for me; she calls it "orthonomy": "...to Emergents [emergent christians] the Virgin Birth [for example] is so beautiful it has to be true, whether it happened or not."

It seems that is the stance you take toward the CIQ: that it is so beautiful to you that it has to be true, whether it happened or not.

That is the only reason I am curious about the flavor of organized belief to which you confess. PM me if you would rather not say in public...I will not share it.
 
Last edited:
<respectful snip for focus>
There is another kind of expert opinon, which IS evidence: Here you request (and nearly always pay for, sometimes dearly) an expert to investigate a case and deliver, normally in writing, an expert judgement on what evidence exists and the weight and credibility of that evidence. This kind of 'expert opinion' is much akin to a formal witness statement, and can indeed be presented on court as such. I have made some of those myself (in my own area of expertice).
<respectful snip>
Hans
highlighting added by JFSVH

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

Please be so good as to read, and reflect upon, and absorb, this excellent bit.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

Good Evening, Mr. Savage:

This is (one of) the equivocal part(s) of your "effective debate".

JayUtah has done a very competent job calling you on your tendency to cherry-pick among dubiously equivalent meanings of a word, so I shall not re-plow his furrows.

I will, however, repeat this point, which I made earlier, and you ignored:

What is lacking is a basis for the conjectures you wish you could transmogrify into evidence by sheer weight of numbers...
Slowvehicle,
- OK. Let's take one entry at a time.

Entry: #1
Date: 1976
Data Category: General possibility of repairs
Evidence: Enzo Delorenzi, a member of the Turin Commission that studied the Shroud in 1969
and 1973, wrote: ―…I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records (the four Clarissas of Chambery, the Blessed Valfre and the Princess
Clotilde).‖
Source: Delorenzi, Enzo: 1976. ―Observations on the Patches and Darns in the Holy Shroud.‖
In Doyle, E., M.Green, Fr., & V. Ossola (Trans.) Report of Turin Commission on the Holy
Shroud (pp. 108-123). Unpublished. Translation of La S. Sindone: Ricerche e studi della
Commissione di Esperti nominata dall‘Arcivescovo di Torino, Card. Michele Pellegrino, nel.
Comments: This indicates that the Shroud could have received undocumented repairs in its
history. The report describes various documented repairs in the C-14 sample area, including a
repair by the Poor Clare Nuns in 1973 after the Raes sample extraction (piece extracted by
Belgian textile expert Gilbert Raes). These repairs may or may not have appeared in part or in
whole in the adjacent sample used for the C-14 test in 1988. The person responsible for
extracting this sample, Italian scientist Giovanni Riggi, never mentions these threads as
specifically being eliminated from the sample. However, a drawing by Riggi (found in BonnetEymard,
Bruno, ―The Carbon 14 Dating,‖ Catholic Counter-Reformation in the 20th Century,
April 1991, No.238, pg. 2), and a statement by Riggi demonstrate some recognition that darning
may have overlapped part of the sample and that he attempted to cut a portion of the threads out.
(See entry number 8 in this section.)


- You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent). One of his conclusions was, "I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records."
- I see this as "expert opinion." I just wouldn't accord it a whole lot of weight, without more info -- i.e., the subject of Delorenzi's expertise, to what extent he studied the shroud and to what extent (if any) he explained his impression.
 
- I see this as "expert opinion."

It is not. You were told what constituted expert opinion, and it is not linguistical legerdemain.

I just wouldn't accord it a whole lot of weight, without more info

It has no probative value whatsoever without evidence, such as what specific and objective observation led to his "impression." Delorenzi is a radiologist, not an expert in textiles or weaving. He is not a relevant expert. He cannot be assumed to be so familiar with ancient clothmaking techniques that his mere "impression" proves the conclusion he draws. His opinion therefore lacks the elements of foundation and is worthless as proof.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- OK. Let's take one entry at a time.

Entry: #1<snip for space>

- You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent).

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Be so kind as not to put words in my mouth, as in the highlighted
In what area, specifically, do you consider Pro. Delorenzi to be an "expert"?

Further, as far as is recorded, Prof. Delorenzi did not, in fact, handle the CIQ, but observed it in its frame.

One of his conclusions was, "I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records."

That is not a "conclusion", no matter how much you want to play word games (about which, BTW, you may be pulling too long a bow...). That is, at best, a "surmise", or a "conjecture". Nowhere does Prof. Delorenzi justify his "impression" with concrete evidence (of the kind I described for you, above). Nor does his "impression" bear upon his area of expertise...

- I see this as "expert opinion." I just wouldn't accord it a whole lot of weight, without more info -- i.e., the subject of Delorenzi's expertise, to what extent he studied the shroud and to what extent (if any) he explained his impression.

No, this is, at best, a "surmise" by someone who may be considered an "expert" in a field other than textile technique.

Go discover for yourself the area in which Prof. Delorenzi may be considered an "expert".

As far as is recorded, Prof. Delorenzi observed the CIQ in situ, without handling it; and suggested tests consonant with his area of expertise.

Prof. Delorenzi provided no support for his "impression"; nor did (for instance) Mme F-L when she handled the CIQ and examined it from both sides.

In short, Prof. Delorenzi's "impression" is not the opinion of an expert, in his field of expertise, supported by evidence.

Prof. Delorenzi's "impression" has no probative value, and cannot be considered to contribute even a sucre toward consilience.
 
Last edited:
I want to do two things:

1. I commend both JayUtah and Slowvehicle for their continued on-point dissection of what little argument Jabba presents. Moreover, they do this dispassionately and without bias, relying solely on evidence.

2. I emphasize that when pressed for his evidence, the list of allegedly expert opinion that is currently being discussed is what Jabba repeatedly falls back upon. Therefore, when it is shown to be sorely lacking, it will be a dismantlement of Jabba's best evidence. It is imperative that this not be let go; he will likely hold onto his insistence on weight of evidence in his favor and will somehow dismiss the fact that his best evidence is bunk. Don't let him.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- OK. Let's take one entry at a time.

Entry: #1
Date: 1976
Data Category: General possibility of repairs<snip>

Recycled rubbish that's been done to death in this thread previously. The site selected for the radiocarbon sampling was examined prior to the sample being removed, there was no magic patch there. Further the subsequent examination of the shroud, including the removal of the backing cloth, also showed no patch was present.

Time to accept the reality of the fourteenth century origin of the shroud.
 
I commend both JayUtah and Slowvehicle for their continued on-point dissection of what little argument Slowvehicle [Jabba] presents. Moreover, they do this dispassionately and without bias, relying solely on evidence.

FTFY, and thanks!

I emphasize that when pressed for his evidence, the list of allegedly expert opinion that is currently being discussed is what Jabba repeatedly falls back upon. Therefore, when it is shown to be sorely lacking, it will be a dismantlement of Jabba's best evidence. It is imperative that this not be let go; he will likely hold onto his insistence on weight of evidence in his favor and will somehow dismiss the fact that his best evidence is bunk. Don't let him.

I agree this is likely; thank you for keeping the idea fresh. The Motte and Bailey approach regarding scope and quality of data is a well established pattern in fringe argumentation. For another example, go back a few years ago to Robert Prey in the JFK debate. He claimed some large number of witnesses testified to the location of the fatal head wound. The strength of his case was, as you guess, in the alleged quantity of evidence. When examined indivdiually, of course, each individual's testimony fell apart. But Prey brushed all that aside and insisted we focus on the ponderance of that evidence.

If a putative expert is disqualified, as Delorenzi has been, then he should be struck from the list, never to be heard about again in the debate.
 
FTFY, and thanks!
Thanks. I fixed it in the original, too, and credited godless dave who pm'd me.


JayUtah said:
I agree this is likely; thank you for keeping the idea fresh. The Motte and Bailey approach regarding scope and quality of data is a well established pattern in fringe argumentation. For another example, go back a few years ago to Robert Prey in the JFK debate. He claimed some large number of witnesses testified to the location of the fatal head wound. The strength of his case was, as you guess, in the alleged quantity of evidence. When examined indivdiually, of course, each individual's testimony fell apart. But Prey brushed all that aside and insisted we focus on the ponderance of that evidence.

If a putative expert is disqualified, as Delorenzi has been, then he should be struck from the list, never to be heard about again in the debate.
Yes. I face the tactic a lot. In one instance it was even admitted and insisted upon by the woo slinger who said something to the effect of:

"You're focusing on the individual pieces. Stop doing that! You need to look at it as a whole!"

There's not a lot to say to that. I came back with some analogy about making sure there are spark plugs and a full tank of gas before I believe your claim that the car will run.
 
I want to do two things:

1. I commend both JayUtah and Slowvehicle for their continued on-point dissection of what little argument Jabba presents. Moreover, they do this dispassionately and without bias, relying solely on evidence.

2. I emphasize that when pressed for his evidence, the list of allegedly expert opinion that is currently being discussed is what Jabba repeatedly falls back upon. Therefore, when it is shown to be sorely lacking, it will be a dismantlement of Jabba's best evidence. It is imperative that this not be let go; he will likely hold onto his insistence on weight of evidence in his favor and will somehow dismiss the fact that his best evidence is bunk. Don't let him.

TY, sir! Just keeping the "E" in... um... ISF...
 
We previously had near invisible patches that were invisible, and now we have documentation of undocumented repairs. The only thing they have in common is that there is no (zero, none, neoni, naught, nil) evidence of either- just statements that such things "might have happened." Well, I might have been my brother, but I was not. I understand that there is a new movie from a Philip Dick novel in which Nazi Germany won WW II. That was possible at one time, but it did not happen. To state on that basis that it is possible that the flag of the USA has a swastika in the middle doesn't make it true, a fact, evidence, or tilt the scales in any way (are we no longer doing sports metaphors?). It does not. The SOT is not the burial clothe of Christ, even more convincingly than the USA flag doesn't have a swastika in it.

Finally I feel compelled to state that I am probably viewed as an expert in biochemistry. But if I were to say Peter Rubens was a noted artist born in France I would be wrong. In fact if I were to say that glucose is joined to chloride during normal oxidative phosphorylation, an area within my own field of expertise, I also would be wrong. It wouldn't tilt the scales in favor of glucose-chloride a bit, a nanometer, or a fraction of a degree; it would still be absolutely, completely wrong. Such a statement would damage my reputation as an expert in biochemistry; it would not provide evidence of glucose-chloride as a product of Ox-Phos.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- OK. Let's take one entry at a time.

Entry: #1
Date: 1976
Data Category: General possibility of repairs
Evidence: Enzo Delorenzi, a member of the Turin Commission that studied the Shroud in 1969
and 1973, wrote: ―…I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records (the four Clarissas of Chambery, the Blessed Valfre and the PrincessClotilde)
The partial quote supplied suggests that Delorenzi believed he could identify the darning skills of more than six separate people. That is the only thing that the quote is saying.1

Comments: This indicates that the Shroud could have received undocumented repairs in its history. The report describes various documented repairs in the C-14 sample area, including a repair by the Poor Clare Nuns in 1973 2 after the Raes sample extraction (piece extracted by Belgian textile expert Gilbert Raes). [snip stuff about the Raes sample]
No. Delorenzi does not claim that there are other repairs on the cloth other than those documented - at least not in the quote supplied. He claims only that there were more people involved in making the documented repairs.

The comments, which are Marino and Prior's interpretation of a (possibly out of context) quote, go much further than Delorenzi's words and add in a conjecture which is completely unsupported by the actual quote.

- You accept that Delorenzi is an expert, probably a relevant expert and that he studied the actual shroud (to at least some extent). One of his conclusions was, "I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records."
- I see this as "expert opinion." I just wouldn't accord it a whole lot of weight, without more info -- i.e., the subject of Delorenzi's expertise, to what extent he studied the shroud and to what extent (if any) he explained his impression.
Delorenzi's quote is not a conclusion, it's a claim. It's a claim, without evidence, that he has an "impression" about how many people have worked on the cloth in the past. It is not (at least as published in that pdf) a claim about there being more repairs than those very obvious and well documented ones.

Marino and Prior have gone much further in interpreting the quote to support their preferred conclusion than the quote from Delorenzi warrants. If I were feeling uncharitable, I would call their interpretation dishonest.

1. It is, in my educated-in-needlework-opinion, unlikely that he could actually pick out more than six different darning styles and say with confidence that none of those darns was done by the same person using a different technique, but I am giving him the benefit of the doubt and taking his comment at face value.

2. I suspect a translation error, as I am sure nobody is really contending that the repairs done by the Poor Clare nuns was done in 1973. However, later Marino and Prior contend that the C14 dating method was invented by Gove, rather the actual inventor and Nobel winner Willard Libby. Maybe M and P are just really bad at fact checking?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom