Slowvehicle
Membership Drive , Co-Ordinator,, Russell's Antin
Slowvehicle,
- Since I seem incapable of understanding what Jay is saying, I'll try addressing what you 're saying...
- I think that the key here lies is in the appropriate definition of "conjecture."
- There are slight variations between the different attempts to define "conjecture." One of those given is simply "guesswork."
- Then, from
https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&ie=UTF-8#q=conjecture definition, however, we get
- an opinion or conclusion formed on the basis of incomplete information.
- To me, what we find in the M/P papers are examples of the latter -- and, what's the difference between that kind of a conjecture and "judgment"?
- So, it seems to me that what we have in the M/P papers are a bunch of expert judgments. And, expert judgments are considered "evidence."
Good Evening, Mr. Savage:
This is (one of) the equivocal part(s) of your "effective debate".
JayUtah has done a very competent job calling you on your tendency to cherry-pick among dubiously equivalent meanings of a word, so I shall not re-plow his furrows.
I will, however, repeat this point, which I made earlier, and you ignored:
What is lacking is a basis for the conjectures you wish you could transmogrify into evidence by sheer weight of numbers.
As I have pointed out before, the only basis for the invention of the idea of the "invisible" reweave, or the "near-invisible" reweave, or the "undetectable" repair, or even "...some patching" is the annoying (to you) fact that the most-scrutinized bit of 14C dating ever undertaken triply-redundantly returned the "wrong" date--"wrong" because it disagreed with the sidonists' assumed consequent (an assumed consequent to which you, yourself, adhere) that the CIQ must be ~2000 years old.
What is lacking is evidence: "Look--here are anomalous fibers, where a repair was wrought; see--this is where the CIQ was rent, that a repair was needed; feel--these are the splices of the heretofore unsuspected compromise of the original integrity of the CIQ."
The conjectures you hope to amass into evidence are not based upon observation, but upon supposition: an attempt to explain away the "wrong" date without any other support than forlorn hope.
The result of adding empty assertions is not consilience.
The plural of "fervent, pious hope" is not "evidence"
No matter how often you repeat your unsupported assertions.
Have you repaired the gross deficiencies in your "map", yet?
