Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
I want to do two things:

1. I commend both JayUtah and Slowvehicle for their continued on-point dissection of what little argument Jabba presents. Moreover, they do this dispassionately and without bias, relying solely on evidence.

2. I emphasize that when pressed for his evidence, the list of allegedly expert opinion that is currently being discussed is what Jabba repeatedly falls back upon. Therefore, when it is shown to be sorely lacking, it will be a dismantlement of Jabba's best evidence. It is imperative that this not be let go; he will likely hold onto his insistence on weight of evidence in his favor and will somehow dismiss the fact that his best evidence is bunk. Don't let him.

:thumbsup:

I'd like to support Garrette's position.

It's the work that Jay & SF are doing that keep me returning to this train wreck.

Shame that Jabba can't get away from irrelevance, but I guess that would destroy his hugely unstable construct.
 
Follow: The [primary] problem with the M&P paper is not the quality of the "experts", not is it the level of their expertise. [T]he fact that the "experts" provide no evidentiary basis for their opinions, suppositions, surmises, and conjectures is enough, in itself (דַּיֵּנוּ) to obviate any potential value as evidence of the existence of an "invisible" reweave...

It is, in my opinion, both. The foundation of expert opinion stands upon many legs. All the legs must be present for the foundation to stand. I don't disagree with a characterization that puts primacy on one leg, so long as the proponent understands he can't rehabilitate the primary leg and carry on if other legs are missing too.

We have defined many times the legs that create the foundation for expertise. You are correct in that Jabba, through his authors and ending at Delorenzi, cannot show that Delorenzi presents any evidence to support his "impression." The authors do not provide any evidence to support either Delorenzi's impression or their connection of it to the hypothesis of an invisible patch. And there is no attempt to reconcile it with counterevidence in the form of a detailed, properly conducted examination of the cloth with the specific goal of discovering a patch and nevertheless failed to disclose one. An evidentiary basis is a necessary leg. If in this thread we give it primacy, I will not object.

Another leg, however, is the predication of the opinion upon suitable and articulable expertise. In this case Delorenzi is not an expert in any of the fields that pertain to ancient clothmaking. His judgment cannot be considered to derive from an appropriate study of the field. Further, even were he to be an expert, he does not articulate what knowledge from that field, such as would be known among experts, support the judgment he has drawn. Even were Delorenzi to muster a set of facts, such as photographs of suspect areas of the cloth, he is not in a position to interpret those facts to support the conclusion that different clothmakers were employed, or (in the fanciful reinterpretation of the authors) that any of that labor was necessarily anachronistic.

Jabba must build all the legs of the foundation to support expert testimony if that foundation is to be accepted. The failure of any one of them dooms that testimony and renders it nonprobative.
 
It is, in my opinion, both. The foundation of expert opinion stands upon many legs. All the legs must be present for the foundation to stand. I don't disagree with a characterization that puts primacy on one leg, so long as the proponent understands he can't rehabilitate the primary leg and carry on if other legs are missing too.

We have defined many times the legs that create the foundation for expertise. You are correct in that Jabba, through his authors and ending at Delorenzi, cannot show that Delorenzi presents any evidence to support his "impression." The authors do not provide any evidence to support either Delorenzi's impression or their connection of it to the hypothesis of an invisible patch. And there is no attempt to reconcile it with counterevidence in the form of a detailed, properly conducted examination of the cloth with the specific goal of discovering a patch and nevertheless failed to disclose one. An evidentiary basis is a necessary leg. If in this thread we give it primacy, I will not object.

Another leg, however, is the predication of the opinion upon suitable and articulable expertise. In this case Delorenzi is not an expert in any of the fields that pertain to ancient clothmaking. His judgment cannot be considered to derive from an appropriate study of the field. Further, even were he to be an expert, he does not articulate what knowledge from that field, such as would be known among experts, support the judgment he has drawn. Even were Delorenzi to muster a set of facts, such as photographs of suspect areas of the cloth, he is not in a position to interpret those facts to support the conclusion that different clothmakers were employed, or (in the fanciful reinterpretation of the authors) that any of that labor was necessarily anachronistic.

Jabba must build all the legs of the foundation to support expert testimony if that foundation is to be accepted. The failure of any one of them dooms that testimony and renders it nonprobative.

Beautifully said, especially in the light of Mr. Savage's blithe attempt to prop up the tilting stool:

Slowvehicle,
- But note that the only part I got wrong was about the relevance of Delorenzi's expertise, and even there, you seemed to be accepting its relevance. Otherwise, you did seem to be accepting his expertise, and that he had indeed studied the shroud to some extent -- though, if only in its frame, that extent must be minimal.

SSDD...
 
Beautifully said, especially in the light of Mr. Savage's blithe attempt to prop up the tilting stool:



SSDD...
I believe -- and I say this without meaning it as a joke -- that it is part of two rules of Jabba's Truly Effective Debate.

1. If you speak in a manner that Jabba can in any way whatsoever claim to be "not polite enough" then your critique can be ignored

2. If -- by dint of following rule #1 -- you do not immediately provide the devastatingly vicious critique of Jabba's links that they deserve, then Jabba can reinterpret your professionally articulated comments as some form of agreement
 
The odd thing is that Jabba has indicated a need to have the SOT authentic to buttress his faith, but then goes through so much twisted logic and make-believe to argue that the SOT "might" be authentic in the face of such overwhelming evidence that it is not. How can this process ever yield a strong enough conclusion in Jabba's own mind to support his faith? He has, in fact, admitted that even he finds his own conclusions very weak and indirect.

-I thought I would reword and repeat, given that Jabba claims to seldom read past the first sentence or two of other people's posts, what to me is the biggest mystery in this entire thread.

Just believe, Jabba, if that is your goal. The more you seek the support of science, and require other people to buy in to your "scientific" arguments, the more you will undermine your own faith.
 
Last edited:
Evidence - Expert Judgment

...Follow: The [primary] problem with the M&P paper is not the quality of the "experts", not is it the level of their expertise. Even if we allow the assumption for the sake of the argument (and ONLY for the sake of the argument) that the "experts" were the world's superlatives, a gathering of intellectual prowess unequaled since "Thomas Jefferson ate lunch alone", the fact that the "experts" provide no evidentiary basis for their opinions, suppositions, surmises, and conjectures is enough, in itself (דַּיֵּנוּ) to obviate any potential value as evidence of the existence of an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, an "undetectable" repair, or even "...some patching" wrought upon the sampled area of the CIQ.
Slowvehicle,
- I see your point (or at least, a point -- I shouldn't put words in your mouth) -- but, one Entry at a time...

- Entry #1 offers the opinion of Prof Enzo Delorenzi who was involved in the scientific studies of 69 and 73. To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility. Not a whole lot, but some... And, were I on a jury judging the possibility of a repair in the sample (or, near enough to affect the dating?), I would add Delorenzi's impression to the pro pan. As things stand, I just wouldn't give it much weight.

- M&P do provide some extra info, from those involved in 69 and 73, supportive of Delorenzi's opinion.
- In a paper trying to cover such a spectrum of info as does this one by M&P, can we really expect any more elaboration than they give?
- Though, superficially at least, M&P should have told us what Delorenzi's expertise was in, what he was looking for and what specifically led him to the opinion he offered. Maybe they didn't because it would have undercut his credibility...
 
- Entry #1 offers the opinion of Prof Enzo Delorenzi who was involved in the scientific studies of 69 and 73. To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility. Not a whole lot, but some... And, were I on a jury judging the possibility of a repair in the sample (or, near enough to affect the dating?), I would add Delorenzi's impression to the pro pan.


Why? What, exactly, did Delorenzi say about repairs in the sample?
 
the fact that the "experts" provide no evidentiary basis for their opinions, suppositions, surmises, and conjectures is enough, in itself (דַּיֵּנוּ) to obviate any potential value as evidence of the existence of an "invisible" reweave,

Jabba needs to watch A Few Good Men. Where the doctor comes on the stand and testifies that Willy Santiago died from poisoning on the rag. There is no evidence of poison on the rag ("there are countless undetectable poisons") and there are other factors that can also explain why he died, but the doctor stands by his baseless assertion that it was poison. Kevin Bacon pulls out the "expert" card, and says, "In your expert opinion, was William Santiago poisoned?" He hesitates, and then says yes.

Now, if you watch the movie, the point is pretty clear that the guy is full of it. He may be an "expert" but his opinion is baseless. In fact, the movie presents him to be an arrogant imbecile. But this is they guy Jabba is hitching his cart to.
 
- Entry #1 offers the opinion of Prof Enzo Delorenzi who was involved in the scientific studies of 69 and 73. To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility. Not a whole lot, but some... And, were I on a jury judging the possibility of a repair in the sample (or, near enough to affect the dating?), I would add Delorenzi's impression to the pro pan. As things stand, I just wouldn't give it much weight.

Even if there was a repair (there is no evidence for one in the tested area) all it would do is cast doubt on the 14th Century date - it would provide no evidence for a first century date. How does this help the "Pro" argument at all ?
 
Even if there was a repair (there is no evidence for one in the tested area) all it would do is cast doubt on the 14th Century date - it would provide no evidence for a first century date. How does this help the "Pro" argument at all ?

Well, The Don, you need to understand that in the Jabbaverse the burden of proof has been reversed. Apparently the default position is authentic unless proven otherwise. This is why he doesn't require evidence in favor of authenticity, he simply believes that any doubt about the C14 date means the CIQ is real. Cool, huh?
 
Slowvehicle,
- I see your point (or at least, a point -- I shouldn't put words in your mouth) -- but, one Entry at a time...

- Entry #1 offers the opinion of Prof Enzo Delorenzi who was involved in the scientific studies of 69 and 73. To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility. Not a whole lot, but some... And, were I on a jury judging the possibility of a repair in the sample (or, near enough to affect the dating?), I would add Delorenzi's impression to the pro pan. As things stand, I just wouldn't give it much weight.

- M&P do provide some extra info, from those involved in 69 and 73, supportive of Delorenzi's opinion.
- In a paper trying to cover such a spectrum of info as does this one by M&P, can we really expect any more elaboration than they give?
- Though, superficially at least, M&P should have told us what Delorenzi's expertise was in, what he was looking for and what specifically led him to the opinion he offered. Maybe they didn't because it would have undercut his credibility...

You could at least pretend to read other people's posts.

Opinions are useless. Credibility is useless. Evidence is everything. You have none. You lost.

Everyone knows your position is based on faith alone. You know it too. Be an honest christian and admit it. Wouldn't your alleged deity want you to be honest?
 
Slowvehicle,
- I see your point (or at least, a point -- I shouldn't put words in your mouth) -- but, one Entry at a time...

Really? Is that why you dumped a pdf with over twenty points into the discussion, without apparently reading it yourself, and then proceeded to ignore the detailed dismissal of all the points?
 
Slowvehicle,
- I see your point (or at least, a point -- I shouldn't put words in your mouth) -- but, one Entry at a time...

- Entry #1 offers the opinion of Prof Enzo Delorenzi who was involved in the scientific studies of 69 and 73. To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility. Not a whole lot, but some... And, were I on a jury judging the possibility of a repair in the sample (or, near enough to affect the dating?), I would add Delorenzi's impression to the pro pan. As things stand, I just wouldn't give it much weight.

- M&P do provide some extra info, from those involved in 69 and 73, supportive of Delorenzi's opinion.
- In a paper trying to cover such a spectrum of info as does this one by M&P, can we really expect any more elaboration than they give?
- Though, superficially at least, M&P should have told us what Delorenzi's expertise was in, what he was looking for and what specifically led him to the opinion he offered. Maybe they didn't because it would have undercut his credibility...

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Happy Thanksgiving Day!

I will be off to a Thanksgiving Day celebration here, shortly. I may be somewhat inactive today.

What evidence (you know the mantra that goes here) does Prof. Delorenzi offer for his "impression"? That is they key point. What does Prof. Delorenzi, himself, offer as the reason for his supposition? Upon what does the Good Professor base his conjecture?

Please do not point to M&P's special pleading and circular reasoning. Tell me what, in your opinion, Prof. Delorenzi says...and why he says it.

Did you ever investigate Prof. Delorenzi's area of expertise?

Did you ever repair the gross deficiencies in your "map"?
 
Last edited:
To me, that by itself suggests a little bit of credibility.

No. You have been told the criteria for credibility for expert testimony. Do not try to invent softer ones on the fly.

M&P do provide some extra info, from those involved in 69 and 73, supportive of Delorenzi's opinion.

Asked and answered. They speculatively try to close the gap between Delorenzi's "impression" and their desired conclusion. Not probative.

In a paper trying to cover such a spectrum of info as does this one by M&P, can we really expect any more elaboration than they give?

This is the material you insist should be taken as evidence. If it is deficient you have the burden to do the homework to fill in the gaps. You do not get to beg your critics to lower the standard just because it's the only material you have in hand or feel like looking up. If it is deficient as evidence, you lose. That's how this works.

Though, superficially at least, M&P should have told us what Delorenzi's expertise was in, what he was looking for and what specifically led him to the opinion he offered. Maybe they didn't because it would have undercut his credibility...

Exactly. This is why it is anti-consilient. Delorenzi's opinion is disqualified for the reasons already given. You have not addressed those reasons. You have simply stated that you want Delorenzi "somehow" to be a credible witness anyway. He is not. Move on.
 
Now, if you watch the movie, the point is pretty clear that the guy is full of it. He may be an "expert" but his opinion is baseless. In fact, the movie presents him to be an arrogant imbecile. But this is they guy Jabba is hitching his cart to.

The play extends the doctor's testimony a bit longer. But the movie version is not a good example of allowable expert testimony. Which of course is your point. In the real world (not Aaron Sorkin's), for court purposes, all the work an expert does in preparing for his testimony is discoverable. The lack of any such work would be grounds for opposing counsel to argue lack of foundation.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom