Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Evidence - Expert Judgment

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Happy Thanksgiving Day!

I will be off to a Thanksgiving Day celebration here, shortly. I may be somewhat inactive today.

What evidence (you know the mantra that goes here) does Prof. Delorenzi offer for his "impression"? That is they key point. What does Prof. Delorenzi, himself, offer as the reason for his supposition? Upon what does the Good Professor base his conjecture?...
- Thanks. You too.

- I don't know. Do you? So far, I haven't been able to find his explanation. Maybe, it had to do with cotton.
 
Well, The Don, you need to understand that in the Jabbaverse the burden of proof has been reversed. Apparently the default position is authentic unless proven otherwise.

In this case that is appropriate. When considering artifacts from antiquity that are at least plausible to some degree of observable detail, claims of fraudulence bear the burden of proof. That burden has been met. There is clear, consilient, and convincing proof the cloth was manufactured in the 14th century.

This is why he doesn't require evidence in favor of authenticity, he simply believes that any doubt about the C14 date means the CIQ is real. Cool, huh?

He would not need direct proof of authenticity to stand against evidence of fraud. But what he is doing is to propose a different reason why the evidence for fraud came out the way it did. That is an affirmative rebuttal and it bears a burden of proof. Not the burden to prove the cloth is authentic, but the burden to prove the tests were compromised by and for the reasons he suggests. Merely speculating on ways it might have been compromised doesn't even come close to it. Affirmative rebuttals and defenses carry the burden of proof even in a court.
 
I don't know. Do you? So far, I haven't been able to find his explanation.

Then you may not present it as expert opinion.

Maybe, it had to do with cotton.

Your speculation is not expert opinion or probative in any way. Further, even if you are correct, you have not established Delorenzi as an expert in cotton or any other kind of textile.

Delorenzi is disqualified. Move on. If you are able later to rehabilitate him via further research on your part then it would be appropriate to refer again to him. But for now it's clear you don't know enough about Delorenzi or his testimony to posture his opinion as probative expert testimony. Move on.
 
- Thanks. You too.

- I don't know. Do you? So far, I haven't been able to find his explanation. Maybe, it had to do with cotton.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It is not, in any way, my job to bolster, buttress, or support your "expert". You offered up the Good Professor; it is up to you to provide his bona fides (which ought to be more than, you simply finding his conjecture simpatico. "Maybe" offers nothing; no more than any other unsupported supposition.

If you, yourself, do not know upon what Prof. Delorenzi based his "impression", it has no probative value in your argument. None. It is worth no more than the conjecture of any other committed sidonist.

Have you discovered Prof. Delorenzi's area of expertise?

Have you repaired the egregious deficiencies in your "map"?

(FWIW, this will be my last post until evening.)
 
Last edited:
In this case that is appropriate. When considering artifacts from antiquity that are at least plausible to some degree of observable detail, claims of fraudulence bear the burden of proof. That burden has been met. There is clear, consilient, and convincing proof the cloth was manufactured in the 14th century.



He would not need direct proof of authenticity to stand against evidence of fraud. But what he is doing is to propose a different reason why the evidence for fraud came out the way it did. That is an affirmative rebuttal and it bears a burden of proof. Not the burden to prove the cloth is authentic, but the burden to prove the tests were compromised by and for the reasons he suggests. Merely speculating on ways it might have been compromised doesn't even come close to it. Affirmative rebuttals and defenses carry the burden of proof even in a court.

Really? All of the shrouds out there are presumed authentic until proven otherwise? What about all the nails? Or foreskins? Without any reason to think it's authentic (especially as it doesn't even match up with the customs of the times or the biblical story) why should we possibly consider it to be authentic?
 
Really? All of the shrouds out there are presumed authentic until proven otherwise?

No, let me elaborate and clarify.

By "authentic" we don't necessarily mean every bit of claptrap someone can claim for a bit of antique garbage. A nail may be an authentic 1st Century nail. But to claim further that it's one of those used to nail Jesus to a cross is patently implausible. That falls under "plausible to some degree of observation" qualification. No, you don't have to assume the Coth In Question is authentic up to and including what the faithful Catholics have to say about it.

Let me restate more carefully what I said earlier in haste. (Trying to brine my turkey here.) If a claim of fraudulence is on the table (and one is), then the presumption in that investigation is that the cloth is authentic -- at least in terms of being a 1st Century burial shroud. Claims of fraudulence are affirmative claims. Such claims bear the burden of proof, hence the presumption -- for that purpose only. Fraudulence generally involves specific lines of evidence such as proof of age, or alternatively may uncover the presence of specific markers indicating a fraudulent means of production (e.g., evidence of chemical processes used to artificially age an artifact).

The burden of proof for fraudulence has been carried. The evidence is consistent with the cloth being a 14th Century manufacture. Therefore, obviously, it cannot be authentic.
 
No, let me elaborate and clarify.

By "authentic" we don't necessarily mean every bit of claptrap someone can claim for a bit of antique garbage. A nail may be an authentic 1st Century nail. But to claim further that it's one of those used to nail Jesus to a cross is patently implausible. That falls under "plausible to some degree of observation" qualification. No, you don't have to assume the Coth In Question is authentic up to and including what the faithful Catholics have to say about it.

Let me restate more carefully what I said earlier in haste. (Trying to brine my turkey here.) If a claim of fraudulence is on the table (and one is), then the presumption in that investigation is that the cloth is authentic -- at least in terms of being a 1st Century burial shroud. Claims of fraudulence are affirmative claims. Such claims bear the burden of proof, hence the presumption -- for that purpose only. Fraudulence generally involves specific lines of evidence such as proof of age, or alternatively may uncover the presence of specific markers indicating a fraudulent means of production (e.g., evidence of chemical processes used to artificially age an artifact).

The burden of proof for fraudulence has been carried. The evidence is consistent with the cloth being a 14th Century manufacture. Therefore, obviously, it cannot be authentic.

Thanks, and understand that I meant no offense. Your contributions are highly valued from this poster's perspective. I agree with all of the above, but would only point out that even without fraud, there is no reason to consider a first century date, let alone Jabba's claim of authenticity. Which is why I insist that the claimant needs to provide some evidence that would point in the direction of authenticity, and of course none has been offered. In the absence of such evidence, refuting the C14 date does nothing to advance his claim. Enjoy your T-day!
 
You. Are. Amazing.

It wouldn't be the first time a fringe claimant has tried to charm his way out of a burden of proof by insinuating that his debate is just a cordial fireside chat among friends. If some piece of knowledge is missing, then we'll just all put our heads together and figure it out. Because that's what friends do. We're all just trying to find the truth, right?

Sorry, Jabba, it doesn't work like that. No one but you has any obligation to discover and present information in favor of your claim.

Your latests posts effectively admit that you have recklessly posted Delorenzi's statement as "expert testimony," when you yourself had no knowledge of the witness's actual expertise. And no knowledge or understanding of any study or argument Delorenzi may have made to give his "impression" any expert credibility.

Delorenzi is disqualified until such time, if any, as you can rehabilitate him according to the established criteria for expert judgment.
 
Thanks, and understand that I meant no offense. Your contributions are highly valued from this poster's perspective.

Thank you, and no offense was taken. Sometimes it takes a few posts for me or anyone else to make a point clearly.

[E]ven without fraud, there is no reason to consider a first century date, let alone Jabba's claim of authenticity.

Correct. There are many reasons why the cloth is not especially consistent with its purported origin. And many reasons not to believe the claims of the faithful. One doesn't blindly accept things as authentic when there are red flags like those that apply to this cloth.
 
Slowvehicle,
[...]
- Though, superficially at least, M&P should have told us what Delorenzi's expertise was in, what he was looking for and what specifically led him to the opinion he offered. Maybe they didn't because it would have undercut his credibility...

BINGO! Are you finally beginning to get the picture!!!???!!!
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It is not, in any way, my job to bolster, buttress, or support your "expert". You offered up the Good Professor; it is up to you to provide his bona fides (which ought to be more than, you simply finding his conjecture simpatico. "Maybe" offers nothing; no more than any other unsupported supposition.

If you, yourself, do not know upon what Prof. Delorenzi based his "impression", it has no probative value in your argument. None. It is worth no more than the conjecture of any other committed sidonist.
- What do you mean by "committed sidonist"? I probably disagree.

Have you discovered Prof. Delorenzi's area of expertise?
- Yes.

Have you repaired the egregious deficiencies in your "map"?
- Which ones?
 
- Thanks. You too.

- I don't know. Do you? So far, I haven't been able to find his explanation. Maybe, it had to do with cotton.

Why in blue blazes are you offering his [Prof. Delorenzi] unexamined jibber-jabber as evidence? Maybe it has to do with your utter inability to hold up your side of this conversation.
 
Last edited:
- What do you mean by "committed sidonist"? I probably disagree.

- Yes.

- Which ones?

Typical woomeister MO. Address the least relevant points and ignore embarrassing questions.

You have no evidence. You lost.


Admit your position is based on faith, and not on evidence. We all know it; It's just better for your soul of you're honest.

As to your blog, you should simply close it for good. It contains nothing relevant.
 
In this case that is appropriate. When considering artifacts from antiquity that are at least plausible to some degree of observable detail, claims of fraudulence bear the burden of proof. That burden has been met. There is clear, consilient, and convincing proof the cloth was manufactured in the 14th century.



He would not need direct proof of authenticity to stand against evidence of fraud. But what he is doing is to propose a different reason why the evidence for fraud came out the way it did. That is an affirmative rebuttal and it bears a burden of proof. Not the burden to prove the cloth is authentic, but the burden to prove the tests were compromised by and for the reasons he suggests. Merely speculating on ways it might have been compromised doesn't even come close to it. Affirmative rebuttals and defenses carry the burden of proof even in a court.


Yes, but the quotation Jabba posted is not even relevant to the question of whether the dating is compromised. Here's the quotation he posted: "I should like to mention the impression I received during the course of my examination, namely, that more pairs of hands have carried out the darning than is suggested in the historical records". It isn't saying that he got the impression that there are undetected or undocumented repairs, it is saying that he got the impression that the darning was done by more people than had been documented. And surely he could not have received such an impression unless the darnings in question was sufficiently visible for him to see differences between them. It says nothing about undetected patching or repairs anywhere on the cloth.
 
Yes, but the quotation Jabba posted is not even relevant to the question of whether the dating is compromised.

Agreed. The burden of proof for fraudulence is a one scope of inquiry. Within that, the applicability of some particular statement is another scope. People who claim the cloth is a fraud have the burden to prove it. They have. The proponents for authenticity maintain the science was compromised. That is a subsequent affirmative claim that incurs the next burden of proof. In fine, the quote's irrelevance is just one of several reasons why that burden is not carried in this case.
 
The play extends the doctor's testimony a bit longer. But the movie version is not a good example of allowable expert testimony. Which of course is your point. In the real world (not Aaron Sorkin's), for court purposes, all the work an expert does in preparing for his testimony is discoverable. The lack of any such work would be grounds for opposing counsel to argue lack of foundation.

But he's an expert, and so the court will hear his opinion! Regardless of how baseless it is!
 
In fine, the quote's irrelevance is just one of several reasons why that burden is not carried in this case.


The quote's irrelevance means that we don't need to worry about the qualifications of its source, or the evidence on which it might be based. It can be dismissed simply because it is irrelevant.

Jabba, next point please.
 
- Thanks. You too.

- I don't know. Do you? So far, I haven't been able to find his explanation. Maybe, it had to do with cotton.

Wait. You threw him out as an expert and offered what he said as evidence and you don't even know what he said exactly? You didn't think maybe you should figure out why he said what he did?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom