Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jay,

[snipped willful obtuseness]

4. Anyway, at the moment, I'm trying to show that the carbon dating does not disprove authenticity – that it is not sufficient to relieve us of the scientific obligation to consider other evidence. That the carbon dating does not close this case. It is not a slam dunk. There is still a reasonable possibility that the carbon dating is off by almost 1300 years.
do.

What do you mean "at the moment"? You've been doing this for nearly 4 years, with nothing to show for it.
 
Anyway, at the moment, I'm trying to show that the carbon dating does not disprove authenticity – that it is not sufficient to relieve us of the scientific obligation to consider other evidence. .

Right. But you need to provide strong scientific evidence in order to refute the carbon dating. So far everybody here is still waiting for it...

That the carbon dating does not close this case.

In the absence of scientific evidence that the carbon test failed for whatsoever reason, it clearly does.
 
Carl Sagan conjectured that there was life elsewhere in the universe. This is not evidence that there is life elsewhere in the universe.
 
Jay,

1. The reason that I keep asking questions is that in order to effectively address your criticisms, I need to understand them. And, so far, I don't.
...

Probably should've just stopped right there then, huh? I mean, instead of then writing that whole bit of nonsense that followed on the pretense that you did understand...
 
I notice JayUtah already replied, still---

Jay,

1. The reason that I keep asking questions is that in order to effectively address your criticisms, I need to understand them. And, so far, I don't.

If you cannot understand such things, what are you doing in a discussion forum?

3. Also, I don’t think you’ve shown how the different pieces of evidence presented by Marino and Pryor lack consiliency.

It is your job to show that they DO.

4. Anyway, at the moment, I'm trying to show that the carbon dating does not disprove authenticity – that it is not sufficient to relieve us of the scientific obligation to consider other evidence.

It does disprove authenticy. However, science never closes the book, so you are certainly free to keep considering evidence. The problem is that you don't seem to have any.

There is still a reasonable possibility that the carbon dating is off by almost 1300 years.

No. Not on the face of any arguments you have presented so far.

5. More specifically, I am currently trying to show that there is reason to believe that the particular sample has been repaired, and that the repair is sufficient to significantly affect the dating.

You have so far failed to show this.

7. Currently, I do think that the preponderance of evidence -- despite the implication of "supernatural" -- actually favors authenticity...

Then you should have no problem presenting such evidence, so what are you waiting for?

Hans
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

Jay,

1. The reason that I keep asking questions is that in order to effectively address your criticisms, I need to understand them. And, so far, I don't...

I don't believe this. Your behavior is far more consistent with someone trying to foist arguments by equivocation than with someone struggling to understand what his critics have said. You seem to believe your critics are too inattentive or too inexperienced to see the fairly obvious rhetorical purpose lurking behind your lines of questioning. You're not as good at this as you believe.
Jay,
- No. I just think that if you answer my questions directly, your answers will show that I am not "equivocating," that the entries given by Marino and Prior are consilient, and that you just don't think much of the expertise, nor arguments, of the researchers quoted in the different entries.
 
Jay,
- No. I just think that if you answer my questions directly, your answers will show that I am not "equivocating," that the entries given by Marino and Prior are consilient, and that you just don't think much of the expertise, nor arguments, of the researchers quoted in the different entries.

Support your lie that it's a 'reasonable possibility' that the Shroud's dating is off by 1300 years.
 
I just think that if you answer my questions directly...

I have answered your questions directly, in some case more than once. You keep trying to turn the answers into others that you are more prepared to address.

...your answers will show that I am not "equivocating," that the entries given by Marino and Prior are consilient, and that you just don't think much of the expertise, nor arguments, of the researchers quoted in the different entries.

Do not keep fishing for the answers you want. Deal with the answers I actually gave, without further attempt at evasion or cramming your words into my mouth.
 
Last edited:
If you cannot understand such things, what are you doing in a discussion forum?

Indeed the proponent's persistent inability to understand the rebuttals, where others plainly can, can be explained after a while at face value only by the proponent's incompetence. Otherwise we have to attribute it to deliberate obtuseness designed to evade meaningful debate.

It does disprove authenticity. However, science never closes the book, so you are certainly free to keep considering evidence. The problem is that you don't seem to have any.

A more pressing problem is that Jabba seems to equivocate endlessly over what "evidence" is. If you say the bare word, as you have above, then Jabba does a predictable tap dance: he acknowledges it's weak, unconvincing, speculative, unprobative, and generally unable actually to compel belief, but demands that it's still somehow technically "evidence," as if that categorization magically repeals all its sins and commands assent.

As I've said before, it's just foisted statements and word play. No actual argument.
 
Last edited:
Jabba, expert opinion is useless. Evidence is everything.

Since you've admitted you need to appeal to the paranormal, your scientific case is closed, as this thread should be.
 
Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

Jay,

1. The reason that I keep asking questions is that in order to effectively address your criticisms, I need to understand them. And, so far, I don't.

2. So far, I think that you’re really just arguing that the expertise of my ‘experts’ is minimal and that their explanations -- for their opinions -- are especially weak. I think that you accept that these witnesses are indeed “expert” (to some extent), and that they are, indeed, providing their opinions (judgments). You just don’t think much of their expertise or their arguments. Consequently, you think that their opinions deserve little, to no, consideration (weight)…

The problem is not that opinions are being provided.

The problem is that those opinions are based, not on evidence, but upon conjecture, calumny, and supposition.

What is missing is, "Look: here is the patch; see: these are the egregiouos threads."

What you have, instead, is, "There may be a repair; there might be some egregious threads; it is possible that reweaving might have been done somewhere along in here; dirven, not by any evidence, but by the perfervid conviction that the 14C date must be deficinent, because it is the "wrong" date.

3. Also, I don’t think you’ve shown how the different pieces of evidence presented by Marino and Pryor lack consiliency. Again, you just think that each piece (while independent and unrelated to the others) is very weak itself – and, when put together, their convergence doesn’t amount to much.

No amount of unsupported assertion combined with fanciful conjecture and buttressed by naught more than special pleading can be stacekd high enough to achieve consilience.

4. Anyway, at the moment, I'm trying to show that the carbon dating does not disprove authenticity – that it is not sufficient to relieve us of the scientific obligation to consider other evidence. That the carbon dating does not close this case. It is not a slam dunk. There is still a reasonable possibility that the carbon dating is off by almost 1300 years.

Unsupported assertion, calumny, and character assassination are not "reasonable". Where is your physical evidence?

5. More specifically, I am currently trying to show that there is reason to believe that the particular sample has been repaired, and that the repair is sufficient to significantly affect the dating. (I don’t just say that the repair is sufficient to affect the dating by 1300 years, because it could be that other events have also affected the dating.)

There is no evidence none, of any kind of "invisible" reweave, "near-invisible" reweave, "undetectable repair" not even "...some patching" no matter how much you try to wish it into being.

6. Keep in mind that I am not trying to prove that the shroud is authentic. I'm just trying to get the evidence weighed.
7. Currently, I do think that the preponderance of evidence -- despite the implication of "supernatural" -- actually favors authenticity...
8. Consequently, in trying to weight the evidence, I'm trying to represent the authenticity side, while you guys represent the in-authenticity side.

For your evidence to be "weighed" you would have to present some.

Bring it.

9. I started this synopsis a while back... I have some more catching up to do.

When do you intend to repair the egregious deficiencies in your "map"?

Fix it.
 
Jay,
- No. I just think that if you answer my questions directly, your answers will show that I am not "equivocating," that the entries given by Marino and Prior are consilient, and that you just don't think much of the expertise, nor arguments, of the researchers quoted in the different entries.

To paraphrase, the plural of "conjecture" is not "evidence"...
 
FFS! After all these years of excuses, where is the evidence of CIQ authenticity?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom