Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why on earth does this matter? It's still not evidence.

As others have pointed out, he saw an opening to equivocate, so he did. He cherry-picked a phrase, "What experts provide is expert judgment, which is not considered conjecture..." (emphasis in original).

It is necessary to answer why the opinion of an expert is sometimes probative. In law, for example, experts are called upon to help the trier of fact interpret the meaning of facts that are outside the trier's natural ken. The principles of that field of expertise and the relevant facts must flow into that opinion. In law terms, the "foundation" of an expert's opinion must first be laid.

But a statement from an expert is not always probative, and not all statements made by experts are expert judgment. Statements made without foundation are not, even when made by an expert. For whatever purpose (and I'm sure you can guess which one), Jabba has parsed the statement above to mean that whatever experts provide can be considered judgment. The proper way to parse it, as is clear from the context, is that the property of expert judgment that makes it different from conjecture is its evident predication upon indisputable fact and upon the sound principles that prevail in the field. That predication -- that foundation -- not the bare identity of the speaker, is the distinction.

"Opinion" can be said to sit between "judgment" and "conjecture," It swings the needle, not with such finality as judgment, but with more justification than conjecture. so Jabba has chosen that as his equivocal pivot. But it's pointless, because the elements identified as conjecture in his thesis are conjecture by their nature and therefore no form of evidence. The difference between conjecture and expert judgment is qualitative. But if Jabba can make it seem like conjecture could be considered opinion, and opinions by experts can be considered evidence, then he can once again insist that it be considered probative.

It's a word game. Nothing more. And this appears to be the only form of argument Jabba knows.
 
An opinion based on speculation is nothing more than speculation.

Correct; because it has no foundation. Jabba wants me to reinterpret my statement to name the expert himself as the foundation, and therefore all that flows from it evidence. Naturally I will not. That's not how evidence works.
 
Finally, of course, expert opinion is only that if it is in the relevant field of expertice. Of the 31 points that Jabba tries to exploit, only a handful seem to come from persons with even partly relevant expertice.

Hans
 
Jay,
- Do you accept their "speculation" as their opinion?

Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

In the words of the immortal bard: "Opinions are like vermiform appendages--everyone has them..."

An "opinion" based upon "speculation", or upon "conjecture", is just that--an opinion. It is not evidence; it is certainly not objective, concrete, empirical, non-anecdotal, non-magical, non-circular evidence. "Opinions" are not "facts".

Which of the points in the Marino paper comprise, in your opinion, actual, direct, objective, non-speculative, non-anecdotal, empirical evidence of the existence of an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, an "undetectable" repair, or even "...some patching" in the sampled area of the CIQ?

Bring it.

On another note, have you repaired the deficiencies in your "map" that have been pointed out to you?
 
As others have pointed out, he saw an opening to equivocate, so he did. He cherry-picked a phrase, "What experts provide is expert judgment, which is not considered conjecture..." (emphasis in original).

It is necessary to answer why the opinion of an expert is sometimes probative. In law, for example, experts are called upon to help the trier of fact interpret the meaning of facts that are outside the trier's natural ken. The principles of that field of expertise and the relevant facts must flow into that opinion. In law terms, the "foundation" of an expert's opinion must first be laid.

But a statement from an expert is not always probative, and not all statements made by experts are expert judgment. Statements made without foundation are not, even when made by an expert. For whatever purpose (and I'm sure you can guess which one), Jabba has parsed the statement above to mean that whatever experts provide can be considered judgment. The proper way to parse it, as is clear from the context, is that the property of expert judgment that makes it different from conjecture is its evident predication upon indisputable fact and upon the sound principles that prevail in the field. That predication -- that foundation -- not the bare identity of the speaker, is the distinction.

"Opinion" can be said to sit between "judgment" and "conjecture," It swings the needle, not with such finality as judgment, but with more justification than conjecture. so Jabba has chosen that as his equivocal pivot. But it's pointless, because the elements identified as conjecture in his thesis are conjecture by their nature and therefore no form of evidence. The difference between conjecture and expert judgment is qualitative. But if Jabba can make it seem like conjecture could be considered opinion, and opinions by experts can be considered evidence, then he can once again insist that it be considered probative.

It's a word game. Nothing more. And this appears to be the only form of argument Jabba knows.

:bigclap
 
As others have pointed out, he saw an opening to equivocate, so he did. He cherry-picked a phrase, "What experts provide is expert judgment, which is not considered conjecture..." (emphasis in original).

It is necessary to answer why the opinion of an expert is sometimes probative. In law, for example, experts are called upon to help the trier of fact interpret the meaning of facts that are outside the trier's natural ken. The principles of that field of expertise and the relevant facts must flow into that opinion. In law terms, the "foundation" of an expert's opinion must first be laid.

But a statement from an expert is not always probative, and not all statements made by experts are expert judgment. Statements made without foundation are not, even when made by an expert. For whatever purpose (and I'm sure you can guess which one), Jabba has parsed the statement above to mean that whatever experts provide can be considered judgment. The proper way to parse it, as is clear from the context, is that the property of expert judgment that makes it different from conjecture is its evident predication upon indisputable fact and upon the sound principles that prevail in the field. That predication -- that foundation -- not the bare identity of the speaker, is the distinction.

"Opinion" can be said to sit between "judgment" and "conjecture," It swings the needle, not with such finality as judgment, but with more justification than conjecture. so Jabba has chosen that as his equivocal pivot. But it's pointless, because the elements identified as conjecture in his thesis are conjecture by their nature and therefore no form of evidence. The difference between conjecture and expert judgment is qualitative. But if Jabba can make it seem like conjecture could be considered opinion, and opinions by experts can be considered evidence, then he can once again insist that it be considered probative.

It's a word game. Nothing more. And this appears to be the only form of argument Jabba knows.
Lemme guess: Your firm doesn't let you talk to jurors, right? ;)
 
Nor I. Having any contact with jurors is verbotten when one is cited as a witness in any shape.

This. I have been called as a wtness a few times - expert and otherwise. The concept of talking to jurors was never discussed. My firm had no policy and no say in the matter, except for my billing rates (payable in advance).
 
This. I have been called as a wtness a few times - expert and otherwise. The concept of talking to jurors was never discussed. My firm had no policy and no say in the matter, except for my billing rates (payable in advance).
All which I have been wheeled out as an expert have been criminal matters. You are told on no uncertain terms that any contact with the jury will bork the prosecution and give grounds for appeal.
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...

Jabba, I have just read your "discussion map". It is a completely unstructured jumble of seemingly random picked statements.

If this is all you get from these debates, why do we bother?

Hans
 
Nor I. Having any contact with jurors is verbotten when one is cited as a witness in any shape.
All which I have been wheeled out as an expert have been criminal matters. You are told on no uncertain terms that any contact with the jury will bork the prosecution and give grounds for appeal.
This. Unless it's in court and a juror asks a direct question.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

Do not equivocate. The difference between conjecture and expert judgment was explained to you. What you are attempting to include as evidence is plainly conjecture.
Jay,

1. The reason that I keep asking questions is that in order to effectively address your criticisms, I need to understand them. And, so far, I don't.

2. So far, I think that you’re really just arguing that the expertise of my ‘experts’ is minimal and that their explanations -- for their opinions -- are especially weak. I think that you accept that these witnesses are indeed “expert” (to some extent), and that they are, indeed, providing their opinions (judgments). You just don’t think much of their expertise or their arguments. Consequently, you think that their opinions deserve little, to no, consideration (weight)…
3. Also, I don’t think you’ve shown how the different pieces of evidence presented by Marino and Pryor lack consiliency. Again, you just think that each piece (while independent and unrelated to the others) is very weak itself – and, when put together, their convergence doesn’t amount to much.

4. Anyway, at the moment, I'm trying to show that the carbon dating does not disprove authenticity – that it is not sufficient to relieve us of the scientific obligation to consider other evidence. That the carbon dating does not close this case. It is not a slam dunk. There is still a reasonable possibility that the carbon dating is off by almost 1300 years.
5. More specifically, I am currently trying to show that there is reason to believe that the particular sample has been repaired, and that the repair is sufficient to significantly affect the dating. (I don’t just say that the repair is sufficient to affect the dating by 1300 years, because it could be that other events have also affected the dating.)

6. Keep in mind that I am not trying to prove that the shroud is authentic. I'm just trying to get the evidence weighed.
7. Currently, I do think that the preponderance of evidence -- despite the implication of "supernatural" -- actually favors authenticity...
8. Consequently, in trying to weight the evidence, I'm trying to represent the authenticity side, while you guys represent the in-authenticity side.

9. I started this synopsis a while back... I have some more catching up to do.
 
The reason that I keep asking questions is that in order to effectively address your criticisms, I need to understand them. And, so far, I don't.

I don't believe this. Your behavior is far more consistent with someone trying to foist arguments by equivocation than with someone struggling to understand what his critics have said. You seem to believe your critics are too inattentive or too inexperienced to see the fairly obvious rhetorical purpose lurking behind your lines of questioning. You're not as good at this as you believe.

So far, I think that you’re really just arguing that the expertise of my ‘experts’ is minimal...

No. I'm arguing that the statements you attribute to experts is plainly conjecture, not expert judgment. I have explained the relevant qualitative difference numerous times. Please address it.

Also, I don’t think you’ve shown how the different pieces of evidence presented by Marino and Pryor lack consiliency.

You have the burden to show they are consilient. So far you have shown only that they are numerous. I have explained at least twice the difference between consilience and mere convergence. Now address it.

There is still a reasonable possibility that the carbon dating is off by almost 1300 years.

Insufficient. You must show the data are wrong in order to refute it, not merely speculation that they might be. You are being asked to prove that hypothesis, not merely repeat it. Please begin your proof.

More specifically, I am currently trying to show that there is reason to believe that the particular sample has been repaired...

You haven't shown any reason to believe it. You've just merely listed the names of people who have formulated a hypothesis to that effect. Testable evidence of the repair is required. Please provide it.

Currently, I do think that the preponderance of evidence -- despite the implication of "supernatural" -- actually favors authenticity...

Asked and answered.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom