JayUtah
Penultimate Amazing
Why on earth does this matter? It's still not evidence.
As others have pointed out, he saw an opening to equivocate, so he did. He cherry-picked a phrase, "What experts provide is expert judgment, which is not considered conjecture..." (emphasis in original).
It is necessary to answer why the opinion of an expert is sometimes probative. In law, for example, experts are called upon to help the trier of fact interpret the meaning of facts that are outside the trier's natural ken. The principles of that field of expertise and the relevant facts must flow into that opinion. In law terms, the "foundation" of an expert's opinion must first be laid.
But a statement from an expert is not always probative, and not all statements made by experts are expert judgment. Statements made without foundation are not, even when made by an expert. For whatever purpose (and I'm sure you can guess which one), Jabba has parsed the statement above to mean that whatever experts provide can be considered judgment. The proper way to parse it, as is clear from the context, is that the property of expert judgment that makes it different from conjecture is its evident predication upon indisputable fact and upon the sound principles that prevail in the field. That predication -- that foundation -- not the bare identity of the speaker, is the distinction.
"Opinion" can be said to sit between "judgment" and "conjecture," It swings the needle, not with such finality as judgment, but with more justification than conjecture. so Jabba has chosen that as his equivocal pivot. But it's pointless, because the elements identified as conjecture in his thesis are conjecture by their nature and therefore no form of evidence. The difference between conjecture and expert judgment is qualitative. But if Jabba can make it seem like conjecture could be considered opinion, and opinions by experts can be considered evidence, then he can once again insist that it be considered probative.
It's a word game. Nothing more. And this appears to be the only form of argument Jabba knows.
