Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slowvehicle,
- Thanks. I had fixed it in my 'draft,' but had forgotten to "update.

Mr. Savage:

Your "map" still lists "13.(Slowvehicle-1018) Why ignoring me?", as if my only substantive comment were that you were ignoring me.

This is, to put it mildly, simply dishonest. For more than three years I have routinely pointed out that you ignore the substance of my posts. I have offered you help; I have sent you links (Even links that you asked for, that you thought supported your baseless assertions); I have examined, evaluated, and responded to, your links; and you have continued to act as if there were no objection being raised to your dissimilation; to your equivocation; to your circular reasoning and you poor handling of facts; to your entire tissue of specially-pled conjectures.

I call on you at this point to follow through: either list the substantive objections I have continually raised for more than three years, or remove my name (and the content of #13, above) from your "map".

Fix it.
 
Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

I am, to say the least, astounded by this temerity. In my experience, JayUtah is one of the posters here upon whose vocabulary you may make bank; and whose grammar and usage tend to be peerless.

Not to mention, you have yet to demonstrate the ability to read minds. I suggest you throw yourself on the mercy of the court, and apologize, unless and until you can provide a concrete example of JayUtah accusing you of prevarication.

On the other hand, you could accept from experience that he used the word he meant to use, in the way he meant to use it.

In the meantime, you have two tasks facing you.

1. Present the best bit of actual evidence form the Marino paper that, in your opinion, represents actual evidenro that teh CIQ is ~2000 years old (or admit that there is no such); and,

2. Go to the "map" on your blog and repair the errors which have been pointed our to you.

Do not presume to neglect the second. As it stands, your "map" is misleading, as well as outright dishonest.

Fix it.
Slowvehicle,
- I don't think that phrase means what you think it means.
- You don't think that I should "fix it". You think that I should "bring it".
- I'll be back.
- Come with me if you want to live.
- The phase plasma rifle in the 40 watt range.
- Nice night for a walk.
 
He has pdfs he hasn't read and won't read even when the people he is "effectively debating" demonstrate the absurdities contained therein
 
He has pdfs he hasn't read and won't read even when the people he is "effectively debating" demonstrate the absurdities contained therein


Reading the pdfs would be against his rules for Truly Effective DebateTM because the pdfs include more than one point. He is therefore obliged to post links to them without reading them.
 
Evidence - Expert Judgment

Amen. Conjecture is conjecture. What experts provide is expert judgment, which is not considered conjecture. It may be disputed by other similarly qualified experts, upon different lines of reasoning. Judgment is not absolute. But it must be predicated upon sound principles of the relevant sciences and adequate fact pertinent to them. Otherwise it carries no more probative value than some layman's opinion.
Jay,
- I agree. I just didn't have the right word at the time. My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating. The further point is that the more expert judgments (of different natures?) that are consistent with a particular conclusion, the more likely that conclusion is. For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...

No, they are speculating. "Conjecture" was the right word all along...
Jay,
- Do you accept their "speculation" as their opinion?
 
Jay,
- Do you accept their "speculation" as their opinion?

Jab, (do you mind if I call you Jab?)

- I'm not JayUtah, but I will interject this:

- Their "speculation" as offered was a half-baked opinion based on strongly-held emotional positions.

- Their "speculation" is much like yours. They should know better than to let emotions cloud their judgement. So should you.

- One reason why the scientific method has been so phenomenally successful is that it ultimately weeds-out ideological "speculation" inconsistent with observed evidence - Sindonology, for example.

- ETA: Did I use enough "scare quotes" , bullet points, and underlining ?
 
Last edited:
Jay,
- Do you accept their "speculation" as their opinion?

I take it this means you refuse to even acknowledge the time and effort put in by those posters who point by point refuted your paper, and are only going to deal with irrelevancies? That is amazingly disrespectful and dishonest.

(And, no, I'm not surprised. Just appalled by the pathetic debating tactic.)
 
Jay,
- Do you accept their "speculation" as their opinion?

We can't really know, can we? After all, they may be quoted out of context, and we don't really know how the wording came about.

What we DO know is that none of their statements provide any evidence, even circumstantial, to weaken the C14 test, just as they do not, in any way at all, support authenticy.

Hans
 
I accept their speculation as their speculation. If you want to call it an opinion that's fine but unsupported by experiments or data it has no evidentiary value.

The reason most of us don't accept this is that we know form experience that Jabba will use it to say "according to the opinion of experts ..."

That's the way he works.

Hans
 
Jabba, why is this so important to you?
I think because the answer to this specific question is the linchpin to the longest GOTCHA set up in the history of the internet. He has been patiently setting this up for over three years. Either that or he's still trying to divert because he has nothing.
 
Jay,
- Do you accept their "speculation" as their opinion?


Why on earth does this matter? It's still not evidence.

And, seriously, after at least three visits to this thread yesterday is this the best you can come up with?*

And why are you still ignoring Slowvehicle?**


*Rhetorical.

**Also rhetorical.***

***The first one isn't, and by your own rules that is the one that you must answer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom