Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence.

You affirmatively stated that your evidence is indirect. That was the word you yourself used. You characterized your evidence as "circumstantial," and the definition you insisted upon specifically qualified that kind of evidence as weak, for the reason that it fails to rule out competing alternatives.

My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence --

Your argument changes words more than a racing car changes tires. It conveys the impression that you don't want the nature of your argument pinned down in any way. What exactly, in your opinion, does "significant" mean in terms of the evidence you have presented?

...which is what I think that I have a lot of.

Asked and answered. Your evidence can be consilient only after you've shown it to be. Volume does not count until then.
 
Effective Debate

- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...
 
You affirmatively stated that your evidence is indirect. That was the word you yourself used. You characterized your evidence as "circumstantial," and the definition you insisted upon specifically qualified that kind of evidence as weak, for the reason that it fails to rule out competing alternatives.



Your argument changes words more than a racing car changes tires. It conveys the impression that you don't want the nature of your argument pinned down in any way. What exactly, in your opinion, does "significant" mean in terms of the evidence you have presented?



Asked and answered. Your evidence can be consilient only after you've shown it to be. Volume does not count until then.
Jay,
- I will try to do that.
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...

Why?
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...

I haven't decided whether I'll visit your site or not, but I don't want you quoting me. I'm convinced that you will put words in other peoples mouth without hesitation.
 
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.

Your punctuation rules out the possibility that you have significant indirect evidence. When you say you have "no significant, direct evidence," you imply that any evidence that you may have is neither significant nor direct. If you leave out the comma, you are saying that you have no direct evidence that is significant. That leaves the possibility that you have insignificant direct evidence and/or significant indirect evidence. I suspect most of us believe that your punctuation was correct: your "evidence" is neither significant nor direct.
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158.

Well, don't. If your plan is simply to copy over whatever parts of this debate you find relevant, then it is merely your spin on the debate. That's unnecessary at best, and dishonest at worst. The debate is happening here and now. If you find its content applicable, then your blog should just link to it and let your readers decide for themselves whether you have a point. If you instead decide what parts of it your readers will see and what parts they won't, then the criteria you use for that decision will be forever questionable.
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...
You have ascribed the 'yak vomit' comment to me (and incidentally out of context); it was not me who posted that.
 
Jay,
- I agree. I just didn't have the right word at the time. My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating. The further point is that the more expert judgments (of different natures?) that are consistent with a particular conclusion, the more likely that conclusion is. For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...

If you must use that analogy, the case stands like this:

Means: The faker had all necessary means (even if it should be an imprint of a body, that would be no problem for him).

Motive: The faker had a very good motive (relics were all the rage in his age and faking then was standard procedure).

Opportunity: The faker had the support of very powerful clerics.

Added to this, the faker left his fingerprints (the "imprint" is anatomically impossible), and his DNA (the C14 dating).

All the other side has are some character withnesses and second hand rumors.

Frankly, I think he's gonna hang.

Hans
 
Changing the argument and the venue? That's one way to avoid the inevitable.

Oh, wait. No, it's not.
 
Jay,For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...

I'm going to correct the whole wrong-headed statement. "Means, motive, and opportunity" may be how things work on bad television detective shows. But it's not at all how things work in real life. If someone has the means to kill his wife, motive to do it, and (clearly) the opportunity, you still don't get to accuse him of killing his wife if the wife is not, in fact, dead.

Let's put this in more applicable terms. You can insinuate that scientists running C-14 dating had a motive to doctor the tests: they want science to win out over religion, or were paid off by skeptics or whatever. And those scientists would certainly have the means and opportunity, right? So they must have done it.

Well, no. First you have to prove that it was done at all. This you have not done. You've tried to paint a picture of alleged fact by purely indirect, suppositional means. That never has the ability to establish fact. This is why "indirect" evidence is so flatly unconvincing. You first have to show facts that indicate the test was incorrect before you can start wondering who did it and why.

This nonsensical "indirect" method of argument is the one used almost universally by many brands of fringe claimants. Nearly everyone who imagines a conspiracy against them can't show any actual products of the conspiracy (other than a reality that violates their expectation). All they can ever come up with is the notion that it "must" have happened because evil people wanted it to happen.

Your job is to explain how your argument avoids that very obvious fallacy. If in fact it does.
 
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.

It doesn't beat significant, direct evidence, though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom