Mojo
Mostly harmless
Even if the C14 date were wrong...
he has no evidence of that, even if all his claims about it are true; all he would have is a conclusion that it is not reliable. It could still be correct.
Even if the C14 date were wrong...
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence.
My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence --
...which is what I think that I have a lot of.
Jay,You affirmatively stated that your evidence is indirect. That was the word you yourself used. You characterized your evidence as "circumstantial," and the definition you insisted upon specifically qualified that kind of evidence as weak, for the reason that it fails to rule out competing alternatives.
Your argument changes words more than a racing car changes tires. It conveys the impression that you don't want the nature of your argument pinned down in any way. What exactly, in your opinion, does "significant" mean in terms of the evidence you have presented?
Asked and answered. Your evidence can be consilient only after you've shown it to be. Volume does not count until then.
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...
- I will try to do that.
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion
Is it the sort of map that gets you lost consistently?
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158.
You have ascribed the 'yak vomit' comment to me (and incidentally out of context); it was not me who posted that.- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...
Jay,
- I agree. I just didn't have the right word at the time. My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating. The further point is that the more expert judgments (of different natures?) that are consistent with a particular conclusion, the more likely that conclusion is. For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...
Jay,For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...
Is it the sort of map that gets you lost consistently?
You have ascribed the 'yak vomit' comment to me (and incidentally out of context); it was not me who posted that.
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.
You should see how he translates the phrase, "Can you direct me to the station?"