Slowvehicle,
- That is not what I admit.
- I admit that I have no significant direct evidence.
- You seem to be saying that circumstantial evidence is not real evidence. Is that what you're saying?
Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:
I said this:
"I accept your admission that you do not have, and do not know of, any actual evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old..."
You said this:
"I admit that I have no
significant direct evidence."
In other words, you admit that all you have is "
insignificant, indirect evidence" of the existence of an "invisible" reweave", a "near-invisible" reweave, a "repair", or "...some patching".
You do not have physical evidence ("look right here:
here is the rent in the warp,
these are the added threads"); you have supposition ("the
14C dating makes it
impossible that the CIQ is 'authentic', therefore the
14C dating
must be wrong, because I have
assumed the CIQ is 'authentic' ").
You do not have empirical evidence ("
here are the places that egregious threads were added to the CIQ, in sufficient volume to skew the
14C dating"); you have supposition ("
if there were an undetectable repair, that would explain why the
14C test resulted in the 'wrong date' ").
You do not have objective evidence ("anyone who handles the CIQ can see '...some
patching', right
here); you have character assassination ("McCrone was 'hard to work with', Mme F-L was incompetent, dishonest, or both").
Every one of your conjectures, suppositions, calumnies, hypotheticals, and accusations rests, not upon evidence, but upon your conclusion that the
14 date
must be wrong; producing a textbook set of examples of desperate special pleading and circular argument.
You have admitted, in you own words, that you do not have, or are you aware of any, "...significant, direct..." evidence.
What is the next issue you would like to address?
I eagerly await your substantive response.
Bring it.