Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jabba,

Can you, with your so called "circumstantial evidence", make a case for authenticity without appealing to the paranormal?

Yes or no??
 
Slowvehicle,
- That is not what I admit.
- I admit that I have no significant direct evidence.
- You seem to be saying that circumstantial evidence is not real evidence. Is that what you're saying?

Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

I said this:
"I accept your admission that you do not have, and do not know of, any actual evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old..."

You said this:
"I admit that I have no significant direct evidence."

In other words, you admit that all you have is "insignificant, indirect evidence" of the existence of an "invisible" reweave", a "near-invisible" reweave, a "repair", or "...some patching".

You do not have physical evidence ("look right here: here is the rent in the warp, these are the added threads"); you have supposition ("the 14C dating makes it impossible that the CIQ is 'authentic', therefore the 14C dating must be wrong, because I have assumed the CIQ is 'authentic' ").

You do not have empirical evidence ("here are the places that egregious threads were added to the CIQ, in sufficient volume to skew the 14C dating"); you have supposition ("if there were an undetectable repair, that would explain why the 14C test resulted in the 'wrong date' ").

You do not have objective evidence ("anyone who handles the CIQ can see '...some patching', right here); you have character assassination ("McCrone was 'hard to work with', Mme F-L was incompetent, dishonest, or both").

Every one of your conjectures, suppositions, calumnies, hypotheticals, and accusations rests, not upon evidence, but upon your conclusion that the 14 date must be wrong; producing a textbook set of examples of desperate special pleading and circular argument.

You have admitted, in you own words, that you do not have, or are you aware of any, "...significant, direct..." evidence.

What is the next issue you would like to address?

I eagerly await your substantive response.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
- From Wikipedia:
Evidence, broadly construed, is anything presented in support of an assertion. This support may be strong or weak. The strongest type of evidence is that which provides direct proof of the truth of an assertion. At the other extreme is evidence that is merely consistent with an assertion but does not rule out other, contradictory assertions, as in circumstantial evidence.

Here is the problem...
 
Slowvehicle,
- I don't really understand all your included adjectives above, and I'll have to look harder to see if one of Marino and Priors arguments stands out in particular, but the general argument about the emotionallty involved in the process is probably the most impressive. No one is truly objective, and power does corrupt.

- Unfortunately, I had missed the fact that I had been looking at two different articles by Marino and Prior -- one, an addendum to the other. I'll need to contrast them before being more specific.

As I said earlier, your attempts at character assassination and accusations of dishonesty and incompetence are not, in fact, evidence of anything other than your special pleading.
 
- Except when it is conjecture by an expert.
- Our issue is really how much weight can be attached to such conjecture.

This is no more than a bald attempt to appeal to authority.

Conjecture is just that--conjecture. It may lead to the discovery of evidence (see above), but it is not, in and of itself, evidence.
 
Jabba,

Conjecture points to areas requiring further investigation. As most everyone else has stated, it is not evidence by itself, circumstantial or otherwise.
 
Conjecture works between the boundaries of what we know already, at times pushing those boundaries while fantasy runs rough shod.
 
This is no more than a bald attempt to appeal to authority.[...]

Mister Savage, Slowvehicle is correct. Please education yourself on logical fallacies.

Off the top of my head, Google Carl Sagan's Baloney Detection Kit as a good place to start. I assume you know what the verb "google" means. I'm done doing your homework.

It's from Dr. Carl Sagan of Cornell University. Cornell University is a highly esteemed center of learning. Dr. Carl Sagan was Jewish. Jesus was Jewish. Dr. Carl Sagan never endorsed the authenticity of the CIQ, and he's been published in more journals than the Whangers and their ilk.

All kidding aside, see if you can spot all the logical fallacies I made in this one post.
 
Last edited:
Evidence

Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

I said this:
"I accept your admission that you do not have, and do not know of, any actual evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old..."

You said this:
"I admit that I have no significant direct evidence."

In other words, you admit that all you have is "insignificant, indirect evidence" of the existence of an "invisible" reweave", a "near-invisible" reweave, a "repair", or "...some patching"...
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.
 
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.

Then please present it. So far all I have seen is purported evidence against the 14C dating. I still haven't seen any evidence to support a first century date, much less that it's the burial shroud of Jesus.
 
Evidence

Amen. Conjecture is conjecture. What experts provide is expert judgment, which is not considered conjecture. It may be disputed by other similarly qualified experts, upon different lines of reasoning. Judgment is not absolute. But it must be predicated upon sound principles of the relevant sciences and adequate fact pertinent to them. Otherwise it carries no more probative value than some layman's opinion.
Jay,
- I agree. I just didn't have the right word at the time. My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating. The further point is that the more expert judgments (of different natures?) that are consistent with a particular conclusion, the more likely that conclusion is. For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...
 
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.

I'm from Missouri. Show me. Don't promise to come back with it. Just show me.
 
Slowvehicle,
- To admit that I have no significant, direct evidence is not to admit that all I have is insignificant, indirect evidence. My admission doesn't rule out having significant, indirect evidence -- which is what I think that I have a lot of.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

Does your "significant, indirect" evidence consist of anything other than assertions that there must be an "invisible" reweave, a "near undetectable" repair, or "...some patching" evidenced only by your assumed conclusion that the 14C testing gave the "wrong" date?

Any actual evidence?

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Jay,
- I agree. I just didn't have the right word at the time. My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating. The further point is that the more expert judgments (of different natures?) that are consistent with a particular conclusion, the more likely that conclusion is. For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...

There's that stupid, inappropriate courtroom metaphor again.
 
Jay,
- I agree. I just didn't have the right word at the time. My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating. The further point is that the more expert judgments (of different natures?) that are consistent with a particular conclusion, the more likely that conclusion is. For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.
- I probably didn't say that quite right -- but, I suspect you can correct me...

Dear Mr. Savage:

What you have presented so far, and in your last link is, in fact, mere conjecture--special pleading fueled by the perfervid hope that the 14C date must be "wrong" because it returned the "wrong" date.

"Maybe", "could be", "might be", "...it can be assumed...".

No evidence.

Have you any actual evidence?

Bring it.
 
My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating.


None of that is evidence of a first century date.

The further point is that the more expert judgments (of different natures?) that are consistent with a particular conclusion, the more likely that conclusion is.


How many gold-free rocks would it take to convince you that my mine has gold in it?

For instance, if someone has the means, motive and opportunity, and no one else does, he probably did it.


You have tried to use this approach many times, but you always come up against this same problem: you completely fail to eliminate other possibilities. Are you seriously claiming to have established alibis for every other piece of cloth?
 
Jay,
- I agree. I just didn't have the right word at the time. My claim is that there are a lot of experts giving judgments that are at least consistent with repair of the sample and/or problems with the carbon dating.

No, they are speculating. "Conjecture" was the right word all along. I explained what constitutes expert judgment, and your putative experts aren't doing any of it. They're just making unsubstantiated excuses. Speculation about invisible repairs and vague accusations of misconduct are not evidence, and a layman can make those excuses just as easily as an expert.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom