Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
But why won't he say so outright, instead of making appeals to pseudoscience? /rhetorical

Because he knows that as soon as he admits that, everyone will dismiss him. He has to pretend to have a rational discussion or no one will pay any attention.
 
Evidence/Repair

You affirmatively stated that your evidence is indirect. That was the word you yourself used. You characterized your evidence as "circumstantial," and the definition you insisted upon specifically qualified that kind of evidence as weak, for the reason that it fails to rule out competing alternatives...
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives.

That's why your argument is unconvincing. The alternatives are far more plausible than your claim. In order to convince people, you need to rule out competing alternatives.

At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.

That's not enough. You have to show that's what happened, not that it's a "possibility." What you're doing is merely hypothesization. It has no proof value.
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.

You have failed miserably at demonstrating that possibility. Just sayin.
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.

When are you going to correct the misquotes on that dog's breakfast of a website of yours?
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.

Perhaps you should start by trying to figure out how to show that the "repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating" hypothesis is out of the "laughably stupid" realm.

You haven't so far.

What is this nearly invisible mending technique that they used? Considering that 1) there is no moderntechnology capable of doing it (aka, "no one has been able to replicate it", your favorite argument), 2) to the extent "invisible patches" are possible, they require the use of authentic fibers, and would not affect the date, 3) there was no way that primitive technology could even know about banding that is observed outside the visible region, much less replicate it, 4) it's bugger all belief that if such a patching technique was known, that they would have used it to repair an obscure corner of the shroud and not use it in the middle of the image; they never showed any motivation to try to make repairs unnoticeable.

There is no basis for suggesting that there must be a "nearly invisible patch." And this is all irrespective of the fact that actual experts who examined the cloth, those who know about patching techniques, say that there's no patch there.

It's total nonsense.
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

You have presented no "reasonable possibility". In the face of textile experts who have actually handled the CIQ, and who have stated, unequivocally, that there is not kind of patching or repair in the sampled area, you raise vague conjectures about "could-have-beens". What drives your assertions is not evidence of any kind; but instead only the conviction that the 14C date must be "wrong" since it does not agree with your assumed consequent.

In a different issue, have you fixed any of the problems pointed out with your website and its contents?

Bring it.
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.

So, when will you start?

Hans
 
Third time only?
You caught me. I meant three times in a row from me.

First, Jabba thinks if it's paranormal, it's just something science hasn't caught up with yet. And we'll never get a clear "yes" because then it's game over. He wants to claim miracles and also claim they're not miracles.
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.

Doesn't matter. Show us evidence for what did happen.
 
I've been absent for five days and I am 200 posts behind. Has something happened different to the following list?

  • Jabba has started feigning a reply for a slightly different question to the one he chose to address
  • Jabba seems confused and keeps asking if he should address the speck on the egg or the tip of the chicken's feather first.
  • No matter what others say to Jabba or what they dialogue among themselves this thread continues to clearly be a "place of faith" where logic is an welcome only if it doesn't opposes to the first. No matter what the words say and which value they have from a logical standpoint the sounds continue to be subdued like in a temple (the MA is doing well for him) and the air smells more to incense than to nosense (which is what Jabba intended from the very beginning: others decided to win the argument, he decided to keep the podium -the fake Italian phrase is a hint- and so far he's doing well)
 
I've been absent for five days and I am 200 posts behind. Has something happened different to the following list?

  • Jabba has started feigning a reply for a slightly different question to the one he chose to address
  • Jabba seems confused and keeps asking if he should address the speck on the egg or the tip of the chicken's feather first.
  • No matter what others say to Jabba or what they dialogue among themselves this thread continues to clearly be a "place of faith" where logic is an welcome only if it doesn't opposes to the first. No matter what the words say and which value they have from a logical standpoint the sounds continue to be subdued like in a temple (the MA is doing well for him) and the air smells more to incense than to nosense (which is what Jabba intended from the very beginning: others decided to win the argument, he decided to keep the podium -the fake Italian phrase is a hint- and so far he's doing well)

If all that means Jabba is moving goal posts and hiding behind process, then yes.
 
Jay,
- I am not trying to rule out competing alternatives. At this point, I am just trying to show that there is reasonable possibility of repair in the sample, and repair sufficient to have a significant effect upon the dating.
This is one of those rare instances in life where you can literally look with your own eyes and see that THERE IS NO REPAIR. It's literally right in front of your face, Jabba. Instead of looking at what's plain as day to all of us here, you've willfully chosen ignorance by burying your head in the sand, covering your eyes and switching off your brain. Stop for a second AND JUST LOOK. Jabba, do you SEE a patch?
 
This is one of those rare instances in life where you can literally look with your own eyes and see that THERE IS NO REPAIR. It's literally right in front of your face, Jabba. Instead of looking at what's plain as day to all of us here, you've willfully chosen ignorance by burying your head in the sand, covering your eyes and switching off your brain. Stop for a second AND JUST LOOK. Jabba, do you SEE a patch?

But that's the problem. When Jabba looks, he does not see a patch.

Since it's an invisible patch, not seeing it is proof that it exists.

JED (Jabba Erat Demonstratum)
 
This is one of those rare instances in life where you can literally look with your own eyes and see that THERE IS NO REPAIR. It's literally right in front of your face, Jabba. Instead of looking at what's plain as day to all of us here, you've willfully chosen ignorance by burying your head in the sand, covering your eyes and switching off your brain. Stop for a second AND JUST LOOK. Jabba, do you SEE a patch?

Let's not forget that Jabba emailed someone who sells "invisible repairs," the reply said such a repair would be readily discernible from at least one side and an expert would be able to see from the "outside."
 
But that's the problem. When Jabba looks, he does not see a patch.

Since it's an invisible patch, not seeing it is proof that it exists.

JED (Jabba Erat Demonstratum)


He's given up on the invisible reweave, but is holding out for a "near-invisible" reweave which nobody can see.
 
Last edited:
I've been absent for five days and I am 200 posts behind. Has something happened different to the following list?

  • Jabba has started feigning a reply for a slightly different question to the one he chose to address
  • Jabba seems confused and keeps asking if he should address the speck on the egg or the tip of the chicken's feather first.
  • No matter what others say to Jabba or what they dialogue among themselves this thread continues to clearly be a "place of faith" where logic is an welcome only if it doesn't opposes to the first. No matter what the words say and which value they have from a logical standpoint the sounds continue to be subdued like in a temple (the MA is doing well for him) and the air smells more to incense than to nosense (which is what Jabba intended from the very beginning: others decided to win the argument, he decided to keep the podium -the fake Italian phrase is a hint- and so far he's doing well)
You missed one.

Jabba is reposting members posts in this thread on his own blog without permission, and wilfully misattributing them, misrepresenting them and refusing to correct these errors when they are pointed out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom