Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm reminded of a scene in Blackadder IV - General Melchett is looking at a map of the trenches.

Melchett: God, it's an awful desert out there!

Captain Darling: Er, no sir. That's the back of the map...


Captain Darling: [pointing to a patch of grass sitting on the table] And here is the land that our troops conquered today.

Melchett: Very good. What scale is this map then?

Captain Darling: Uhm... one-to-one, sir.
 
"My hovercraft is full of eels." ?
Mine, too!
My wife insisted it would never catch on, but I told her, I says to her, sez I "Just you wait! Eels in your hovercraft, missus, it'll be the next big thing!"

I've sold my shroud stock for a portion of HCE, Inc.
 
Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

It seems that, in your map, you have included one (and only one) of the (literally) dozens and dozens of times that I have asked why it is that you feel free to rudely ignore me, as if it were a substantive point in your soi dissant "debate".

I offer you the choice of removing the mention, or correcting it. No other option is acceptable.

There's a lad.
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...

Why are some of the unhelpful bullet points followed by three asterisks? I was expecting footnotes. There are no footnotes. Also, I note that the comments section is headed, "4 THOUGHTS ON “'9. MAP (11/17/15),'” but all the comments are from 2012. Is this evidence of psychic powers?
 
Last edited:
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...

:dl:
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.
- For the moment, over here, I'm trying to respond to Slowvehicle, Agatha and Jay. If you guys would rather not visit my site, but would like to add your comments, I'll do it for you.
- If you go there, you should expect some disarray...

The chessboard graphic could do with a pigeon.
 
Why are some of the unhelpful bullet points followed by three asterisks? I was expecting footnotes. There are no footnotes. Also, I note that the comments section is headed, "4 THOUGHTS ON “'9. MAP (11/17/15),'” but all the comments are from 2012. Is this evidence of psychic powers?

He should assume that not everyone will come here to look at the posts. A little context would be good. I'm not just saying that because my one entry is misattributed and only says "yak vomit".
 
Gee, Jabba, I noticed your first item was the inability to reproduce it. And you have completely ignored the other items (Stradavarius) that can't be reproduced which makes your point moot. What a shock.
 
Jabba,

When are you going to correct those misattributed quotes that I predicted, and Agatha and Craig4 confirmed (the ak vomit)?
 
Gee, Jabba, I noticed your first item was the inability to reproduce it. And you have completely ignored the other items (Stradavarius) that can't be reproduced which makes your point moot. What a shock.

And the Sistine Chapel ceiling. And the Allman Brothers at the Fillmore East, for that matter.
 
That and his first item isn't an argument for authenticity. If other bodies don't leave marks on cloth like the image on the CIQ, then why would the fact that you can't replicate it by laying it over a body count as evidence for authenticity?
 
- Just to let y'all know, I'm trying to develop a map of our Discussion over at http://shrouddebates.com/?page_id=158. Right now, it's more like an outline... Any of you can go over there and make comments.

I think you need to get better at cartography.

It seems that you're using that page as a way of replaying the arguments and attempting to have them come out in your favour. So much wasted effort on things like this instead of presenting your evidence to support the c2000 year old age of the shroud (which is not the same as trying to pick holes in the c700 year old dating).

Trying to find fault in the argument that something is a duck doesn't make it any more of a unicorn.
 
Gee, Jabba, I noticed your first item was the inability to reproduce it. And you have completely ignored the other items (Stradavarius) that can't be reproduced which makes your point moot. What a shock.

Let's get a more relevant example: no one has been able to reproduce the image on the shroud (much less the shroud itself) by laying a cloth over a body, either, which, if you will recall, is his preferred origin right now.

This has been pointed out to him many, many times, and he ignores it.

It's because he thinks it is a miracle, and, ultimately, that is what he is trying to show.
 
Let's get a more relevant example: no one has been able to reproduce the image on the shroud (much less the shroud itself) by laying a cloth over a body, either, which, if you will recall, is his preferred origin right now.

This has been pointed out to him many, many times, and he ignores it.

It's because he thinks it is a miracle, and, ultimately, that is what he is trying to show.

But why won't he say so outright, instead of making appeals to pseudoscience? /rhetorical
 
That and his first item isn't an argument for authenticity. If other bodies don't leave marks on cloth like the image on the CIQ, then why would the fact that you can't replicate it by laying it over a body count as evidence for authenticity?

None of his items are arguments for authenticity.
 
But why won't he say so outright, instead of making appeals to pseudoscience? /rhetorical
Because -- on the doubtful assumption he isn't either trolling, gaming, or simply incapable of thinking about this -- he believes it is the logical conclusion and is attempting to lead us to it. His argument is as follows, and he thinks we will eventually see it and say "Eureka."


A shroud not disproven as authentic and which is also unreplicable must have been miraculously produced

This shroud has not been disproven as authentic and is unreplicable

Therefore, this shroud was miraculously produced


From there he would have a similar argument saying that a miraculously produced shroud must have been formed during the resurrection.

Were anyone to succeed in getting Jabba to address this, he would quibble by saying that, no, he would insert "likely" into the syllogism. He would never address the substance.
 
Because -- on the doubtful assumption he isn't either trolling, gaming, or simply incapable of thinking about this -- he believes it is the logical conclusion and is attempting to lead us to it. His argument is as follows, and he thinks we will eventually see it and say "Eureka."


A shroud not disproven as authentic and which is also unreplicable must have been miraculously produced

This shroud has not been disproven as authentic and is unreplicable

Therefore, this shroud was miraculously produced


From there he would have a similar argument saying that a miraculously produced shroud must have been formed during the resurrection.

Were anyone to succeed in getting Jabba to address this, he would quibble by saying that, no, he would insert "likely" into the syllogism. He would never address the substance.

or "probably"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom