Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Evidence

Incorrect. Only the valid evidence needs to be considered. A lot of yak vomit is still yak vomit. The vomit is not more valuable because there is more of it.
Craig,
- But, is it really yak vomit? That's an opinion.
 
Jay,
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration,

No because, as your own source states:

At the other extreme is evidence that is merely consistent with an assertion but does not rule out other, contradictory assertions, as in circumstantial evidence.

So since other, contrary assertions are not ruled out, you cannot add it up.

as does the opinion that the conclusion is patently ridiculous.

Ehh?? Which conclusion?

Hans
 
Jabba: remember when we were trying to get you to provide positive evidence in favor of authenticity? Remember why were wanted you to do that? It's because casting aspersions on the character of a given scientist or a scientific finding says nothing in favor of authenticity. You have not presented a single pice of evidence in favor of authenticity. We don't have to prove the shroud isn't authentic, that's the default position. The closest you've come is blood, on which you struck out badly. Further, it is irrelevant as it says nothing about when blood might have been applied. If you have any evidence in favor of authenticity, please present it now.
 
Jay,
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration...

No.

I covered this already at length. You want to assert that the vast body of circumstantial evidence is consilient and therefore probative. But I told you what has to happen in order for an argument by consilience to be convincing, and it has very much to do with how each individual avenue of evidence is developed, and the quality of that development. Your argument contains none of that.

No matter how much you try to dress it up, you're simply arguing that a whole lot of vague handwaving ought to be proof of something. It is not, for the reasons that have been belabored.
 
It's time you stopped wasting energy on making the cloth something it's not and started figuring how you are going to deal with the reality that your belief is nothing.
 
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration...


You don't even have much in the way of circumstantial evidence. If you could establish a first century origin in the middle east, then that would be circumstantial evidence for authenticity. The actual circumstances are that the cloth first turned up in Italy in the Middle Ages, and the actual age of the cloth and the weave used are consistent with this and not a first century origin. The circumstantial evidence is against you. Since you have already admitted you don't have any direct evidence either, it's probably time for you to pound the table and yell. Or maybe for another fringe reset.
 
No it is not. You provided a list of could be maybe and it's possible. That's not evidence. I don't care how many entries your list has. If it's not evidence it's not evidence.

As I explained earlier, that's how people who aim for consilience miss the target. We went through this at some length trying to show Robert Harris how to navigate his evidence.

Consilience occurs when you have several avenues of evidence, developed in different ways. Very different ways. Fingerprint evidence, for example, is of a different form, and developed differently, than video surveillance evidence. Granted that uncertainty accompanies each finding, you nevertheless develop it "in a vacuum," essentially and take the objectively best interpretation on its merits, as evaluated within the rules of that avenue of evidence.

If the preponderance of those different avenues, evaluated separately, point to a single conclusion, then the body of evidence can be said to support the conclusion by consilience. The belief is that such a concordance is very unlikely to have arisen by chance from the uncertainty in each avenue. This is because they are presumed to be qualitatively dissimilar. Errors in face recognition from video arise differently from the method, and work on different forms of data, than errors in fingerprint identification. The chances of them both erring so as to indict the same innocent man are considered astronomically remote.

But this is not how the "mud-against-the-wall" claimants work. Instead of considering each constituent evidence on its merits and resolving uncertainty in a vacuum toward that meritorious conclusion, they simply let the desired conclusion drive the interpretation and resolve the uncertainty -- not unsurprisingly -- toward that predetermination. They wrongly believe that because some evidence can in some nebulous sense be interpreted to support X, some vast number of such examples constitutes that much more evidence for X. That's simply not how consilience works. That's how repetitive preconception works.
 
Nope. Conjecture by an expert (even by an appropriate expert) is still conjecture.

Amen. Conjecture is conjecture. What experts provide is expert judgment, which is not considered conjecture. It may be disputed by other similarly qualified experts, upon different lines of reasoning. Judgment is not absolute. But it must be predicated upon sound principles of the relevant sciences and adequate fact pertinent to them. Otherwise it carries no more probative value than some layman's opinion.
 
Jay,
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration, as does the opinion that the conclusion is patently ridiculous.

Re-read what Jay is saying. The amount of circumstantial evidence is only a consideration after each piece of circmstantial evidence has been examined independently to determine what conclusion it supports. You'll need to look at each piece of evidence on your list on its own, before you can gather them together and present the bundle as evidence in its own right.
 
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration...


It doesn't matter how much there is if none of it is actually evidence for your claim, and all of it is just as consistent with inauthenticity.

Say I claim to have found a gold mine and ask you to invest in it. You ask to see evidence that the mine has gold in it before you will invest. I fetch a small piece of rock from the mine; it contains no gold. This is entirely consistent with there being gold somewhere in the mine. Do you give me the money?

How about if I bring you 500 rocks from the mine, none of which shows any sign of bearing gold? Are you any more impressed?
 
- Except when it is conjecture by an expert.
- Our issue is really how much weight can be attached to such conjecture.
No, conjecture (even by an expert) is not evidence.

OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration,

A great deal of the 'circumstantial evidence' that you have provided is not in fact circumstantial evidence at all, such as the long list of conjectures. Much of what you provide is consistent with the mediaeval date - for example the supposed blood on the cloth, and the notion that the image was made by wrapping cloth around a body.

as does the opinion that the conclusion is patently ridiculous.
Which conclusion?
 
Ehh?? Which conclusion?

Which conclusion?


Jabba has somehow managed to jump from Jay talking about an improbable conclusion to attacking a claim that it is ridiculous:

Asked and answered. Circumstantial evidence requires significantly broad inference in order to be probative. As such, circumstantial evidence is insufficient to support a conclusion that is patently improbable on its face.
Jay,
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration, as does the opinion that the conclusion is patently ridiculous.


I smell straw.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom