Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Has anyone ever reproduced the image on the shroud by laying a cloth over a body?

I find it really funny. You consistently harp on the fact that "no artist has been able to reproduce the shroud", holding reproductions to a perfect standard, including proper aging. Yet, your proposed conclusion is that it is an imprint of a real dead body, despite the fact that no one can even get the image to look right by doing that (wrapping a cloth over a body), much less reproduce the shroud.

Why don't you admit it, so we can end it now: you think it was a miracle. Admit it, and we can drop this whole discussion, because there is no way to continue rationally.

Excellent point. Why would the fact that the image on the Shroud looks nothing like what happens when you put cloth over a body be evidence for authenticity?
 
Excellent point. Why would the fact that the image on the Shroud looks nothing like what happens when you put cloth over a body be evidence for authenticity?

Easy. It's a miracle.

Seriously, gang, that's what this is coming to. He's kind of gone there already, but that's going to be the answer. It's a miracle.
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"

Good Evening, Mr. Savage:

I accept your admission that you do not have, and do not know of, any actual evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old...
Slowvehicle,
- That is not what I admit.
- I admit that I have no significant direct evidence.
- You seem to be saying that circumstantial evidence is not real evidence. Is that what you're saying?
 
Slowvehicle,
- That is not what I admit.
- I admit that I have no significant direct evidence.
- You seem to be saying that circumstantial evidence is not real evidence. Is that what you're saying?

You don't have any of that either.
 
The problem with all that inferential argumentation is that in requires the reader to, well, infer. You want to guide the reader to a particular inference from among the many that are possible. And in this case it is an extremely monumental, far-reaching, extraordinary inference. And everything that's extraordinary about it lies between the end of the evidence and your conclusion, in that vast inferential gulf you ask your readers to leap.

In other words, for the kind of claims made about the shroud, you need far more than that kind of evidence in order to be convincing.



Okay, you're trying to make an argument from consilience. That's reasonably convincing if done correctly. Doing it correctly means showing, in each separate evidentiary case, that the interpretation of that point of evidence that favors the authenticity of the shroud is the best interpretation on its merits. That results in a collection of disparate evidence whose individually best interpretation points to authenticity, and whose arrival thereat by accident is considered collectively unlikely.

Unfortunately a lot of people don't construct the argument correctly and produce what others have termed anti-consilience. An argument is anti-consilient if the interpretation of each evidentiary point is guided by the overall desired outcome. It most often arises when a preferred belief is asserted, and then backfilled by cherry-picked, preferentially interpreted evidence.

It's often favored where the debate proponent wants to keep everything at a broad-strokes, high-altitude level of discourse and not delve into details. Usually those details don't favor the proponent.



And Catholic relic-peddlers of the 14th century wouldn't have had access to a real dead body?
Jay,
- One argument I'm having with Slowvehicle and others is that while my 'evidence' is not "direct," and may be weak, it is still "evidence" -- circumstantial evidence. Wouldn't you agree?
 
How can we know? You have yet to present it.

Hans
 
Last edited:
Evidence

- From Wikipedia:
Evidence, broadly construed, is anything presented in support of an assertion. This support may be strong or weak. The strongest type of evidence is that which provides direct proof of the truth of an assertion. At the other extreme is evidence that is merely consistent with an assertion but does not rule out other, contradictory assertions, as in circumstantial evidence.
 
Jay,
- One argument I'm having with Slowvehicle and others is that while my 'evidence' is not "direct," and may be weak, it is still "evidence" -- circumstantial evidence. Wouldn't you agree?

Do not attempt to equivocate. I explained exactly why your evidence was not convincing. Address that.
 
Jay,
- One argument I'm having with Slowvehicle and others is that while my 'evidence' is not "direct," and may be weak, it is still "evidence" -- circumstantial evidence. Wouldn't you agree?

You haven't presented any yet. Calling Walter McCrone a grouch and 14C scientists dishonest and incompetent doesn't even rise to the level of circumstantial evidence of authenticity.
 
- You seem to be saying that circumstantial evidence is not real evidence. Is that what you're saying?

Asked and answered. Circumstantial evidence requires significantly broad inference in order to be probative. As such, circumstantial evidence is insufficient to support a conclusion that is patently improbable on its face.
 
Slowvehicle,
- That is not what I admit.
- I admit that I have no significant direct evidence.
- You seem to be saying that circumstantial evidence is not real evidence. Is that what you're saying?

But you haven't even provided that. You've lowered the bar and failed to meet it. Instead of hiding behind process, why don't you just present your circumstantial evidence?
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"

Good Morning (again), Mr. Savage:

(Obviously, I am not Agatha, but so be it...)

Which one of the arguments raised by Prior and Marino at http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf comprises, in your opinion, the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence of the actual existence of an actual, physical "invisible" reweave' "near-invisible" reweave, "undetectable" repair, (or even "...some patching") in the sampled area of the CIQ?

Be specific, if you would be so kind.

I anticipate your on-point response.
Slowvehicle,
- I don't really understand all your included adjectives above, and I'll have to look harder to see if one of Marino and Priors arguments stands out in particular, but the general argument about the emotionallty involved in the process is probably the most impressive. No one is truly objective, and power does corrupt.

- Unfortunately, I had missed the fact that I had been looking at two different articles by Marino and Prior -- one, an addendum to the other. I'll need to contrast them before being more specific.
 
- From Wikipedia:
Evidence, broadly construed, is anything presented in support of an assertion. This support may be strong or weak. The strongest type of evidence is that which provides direct proof of the truth of an assertion. At the other extreme is evidence that is merely consistent with an assertion but does not rule out other, contradictory assertions, as in circumstantial evidence.
Except that all that you've done is made assertions. You haven't presented anything beyond conjecture that actually supports these assertions. Conjecture is not evidence. Conjecture is just making stuff up. All you've got are assertions with absolutely no evidence to support them.
 
- From Wikipedia:
Evidence, broadly construed, is anything presented in support of an assertion.


By that definition, you have some. The problem is that what you have presented in support of your assertion doesn't actually support it.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- I don't really understand all your included adjectives above, and I'll have to look harder to see if one of Marino and Priors arguments stands out in particular, but the general argument about the emotionallty involved in the process is probably the most impressive. No one is truly objective, and power does corrupt.

- Unfortunately, I had missed the fact that I had been looking at two different articles by Marino and Prior -- one, an addendum to the other. I'll need to contrast them before being more specific.

And once again you've found the irrelephant in the room. If emotionality impacted the results that would be evident in the findings, not the other way around. In itself the emotionality (which seems largely confined to STRUP) is unimportant.
 
Evidence

Asked and answered. Circumstantial evidence requires significantly broad inference in order to be probative. As such, circumstantial evidence is insufficient to support a conclusion that is patently improbable on its face.
Jay,
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration, as does the opinion that the conclusion is patently ridiculous.
 
Jay,
- OK, but the amount of circumstantial evidence must be a consideration, as does the opinion that the conclusion is patently ridiculous.

Incorrect. Only the valid evidence needs to be considered. A lot of yak vomit is still yak vomit. The vomit is not more valuable because there is more of it.

The ridiculousness of your belief is not an opinion. It's is a quantifiable conclusion.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom