Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- I'm still thinking...

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.

Jabba, "circumstantial" evidence can never beat objective evidence.
The C14 measurement is objective evidence.
The anatomical impossibilty of the shroud image is objective evidence.
The lack of wrapping distortion on the image is objective evidence.

And, you don't actually HAVE any circumstantial evidence (at least you have yet to present any). All you have is conjecture. Conjecture can't even beat circumstantial evidence.

- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.

We know you think that. But you fail to convince enybody else.

- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.

Why?

Hans
 
- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.


No. All you have provided is evidence that, while consistent with authenticity, is also consistent with inauthenticity. It therefore cannot "tip" your metaphorical scales in either direction.
 
Nope: what you consider to be "significant evidence" of authenticity is nothing of the sort, because all if it (or at least, all that you have so far posted) is just as consistent with inauthenticity as it is with authenticity. It therefore cannot "tip the scales" towards authenticity.

Not to mention the fact that there is actual real evidence that does point at a 14th century date. Jabba has produced nothing that would lead it to be dismissed as invalid.
 
- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.


The image is inconsistent with a "real dead body". You have already had this pointed out to you many times, remember?
 
Not to mention the fact that there is actual real evidence that does point at a 14th century date. Jabba has produced nothing that would lead it to be dismissed as invalid.


Well, yes, in the face of the evidence we already have a claim of authenticity is the sort of claim that needs extraordinary evidence. Jabba has yet to even present any ordinary evidence for it.
 
- I'm still thinking...

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.
- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.
- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.

So what on your list counts as valid evidence, free of logical fallacies?

If it is a real dead body, why are the hands covering the genitals? Can a person laying the way the image depicts have there hands there with the elbows bent at such an angle? Even if it is a real dead body, are dead bodies in short supply?
 
- I'm still thinking...

This discussion has gone-on for nearly 4 years with no evidence that you think about what has gone-on before,.

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.

What you consider significant evidence is based on logical fallacies, fuzzy thinking, and sometimes outright slander.

- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.

It is your strongly-held, emotional desire to believe that makes you believe. You have presented no compelling argument in nearly 4 years,

- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.

Your interim conclusion is the same as your initial conclusion years before you examined any evidence, and is likely to be your final conclusion whatever evidence is provided in the future.

You are impervious to logic, reason, and any workable concept of evidence.
 
Last edited:
- I'm still thinking...

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.
- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.
- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.

This has been addressed before. It is being addressed now. What has never happened nor will ever happen is you engage with any of the criticism of your approach to evidence or what you offer as evidence. You will be back pointlessly.
 
- I'm still thinking...
I wish you would. All of the pseudo-claims in that document apply as well or better to your claimed 2,000 ya date.

Thus they add nothing to your imaginary scales at all.

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.
As noted, your indirect evidence also mitigates against a 2,000 ya date.

- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.
Wrong. If you claim (and you do) that the C14 sample was not representative of the cloth as a whole, then the Raes sample is equally tainted as not representative of the cloth as a whole.
- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.
And here we are right back to levitating radioactive jebus, whose front is longer that his back, who can assume anatomically impossible poses, who is absurdly a white european male and sufficiently mutant to appear as a Byzantine characature, whose hair and blood is immune to gravity, whose wounds, while described in the bible were somehow unknown to 14th century artists.

Do you really find this remotely plausible?
 
- I'm still thinking...

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.
- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.
- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.

Good Evening, Mr. Savage:

I accept your admission that you do not have, and do not know of, any actual evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old.

That should, in fact, end the thread, but I am aware that it will not.

As with the "immortality" thread, I will continue to explain your errors, as best I can, whether you are listening or not...

Your current conceit is that, by aggregating multiple claims, assertions, and assumptions, no single one of which constitutes evidence, you can somehow claim to have created evidence. Reality, of course, does not work that way. You are in the position of a man standing waist-deep in a pond, claiming to be able to make a hole in the water by scooping up bucketsful of water in front of him, and pouring them into the pond behind him...no single bucketful will make a hole in the water, but (he maintains) surely, the aggregate will eventually result in a hole, no?

Now that you have admitted that there is no evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old, what is the next issue you would like to address?
 
Last edited:
Good Evening, Mr. Savage:

I accept your admission that you do not have, and do not know of, any actual evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old.

That should, in fact, end the thread, but I am aware that it will not.

As with the "immortality" thread, I will continue to explain your errors, as best I can, whether you are listening or not...

Your current conceit is that, by aggregating multiple claims, assertions, and assumptions, no single one of which constitutes evidence, you can somehow claim to have created evidence. Reality, of course, does not work that way. You are in the position of a man standing waist-deep in a pond, claiming to be able to make a hole in the water by scooping up bucketsful of water in front of him, and pouring them into the pond behind him...no single bucketful will make a hole in the water, but (he maintains) surely, the aggregate will eventually result in a hole, no?
Now that you have admitted that there is no evidence that the CIQ is ~2000 years old, what is the next issue you would like to address?
Brilliant and entirely accurate.
 
The image is inconsistent with a "real dead body". You have already had this pointed out to you many times, remember?

....and even if it was, it's not like there was a shortage of dead bodies in Europe at the time.
 
-.
- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.

Has anyone ever reproduced the image on the shroud by laying a cloth over a body?

I find it really funny. You consistently harp on the fact that "no artist has been able to reproduce the shroud", holding reproductions to a perfect standard, including proper aging. Yet, your proposed conclusion is that it is an imprint of a real dead body, despite the fact that no one can even get the image to look right by doing that (wrapping a cloth over a body), much less reproduce the shroud.

Why don't you admit it, so we can end it now: you think it was a miracle. Admit it, and we can drop this whole discussion, because there is no way to continue rationally.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom