Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Agatha,
- Why do you say that what I just presented by Marino and Prior is not evidence?

We've been through this before. Quote their evidence for authenticity concisely. Don't post another link to a Shroud-Bleever site. Post a concise description of their evidence, followed by a link to said evidence, and don't change the subject again!

Remember - challenging the 14C date is not evidence of a 2000 year old date, nor is it evidence of authenticity.
 
Jabba, you should just accept that we are sticking to the scientific method here and not considering your preponderance of evidence approach. It will cause less confusion if you abandon that.

You know what? Even Dan Porter's blog is more objective and logical than anything posted by Jabba.


Jabba,

Nobody from Dan Porter's blog has come to your defense even after you issued an SOS at ShroudStory.com.

Do you realise that it's time to re-evaluate your position on the authenticity of the CIQ, and the paucity of evidence supporting that position?
 
Here's the next five pieces of 'evidence' to which Jabba linked:

Entry#6. In entirety, this says "Italian author Richard Gervasio identified various researchers who identified various anomalies that suggest that undocumented repairs were made on the Shroud."
This is not evidence of anything other than that Richard Gervasio made some kind of list of researchers. These people are not named, the anomalies they claim to have identified are not listed, and the link between 'anomalies' and undocumented repairs is not made. It's third-hand hearsay, and is certainly not evidence for repair.

Entry#7 refers once again to cotton fibres found within the linen, and claims that this is at variance with the main body of the shroud. However nowhere can I find any claim that the cotton fibres are not found in the linen of the main body of the shroud. Without testing of the main body of the shroud, something the Vatican resists, a claim that these cotton fibres are anomalous fails.

Entry#8 is essentially a repeat of entry#7, this time claiming that Riggi, who cut into the testing area, found "fibres of other origins". Once again, without testing of the main body of the shroud, this is not evidence of an anomaly.

Entry#9 is once again a punt at showing the tested area might be anomalous. This time the objections are that the tested area was small and 'may' contain a selvedge. As sufficient material for testing was removed, the first objection fails. A selvedge is the long edges of the fabric, and it is not explained why a selvedge, which is just part of the fabric made entirely from the warp and weft threads, might affect the testing.

Entry#10 This is a short extract from a press release by some shroud-authenticity group, claiming that there are unanswered questions about "the contamination of the sample, the position of it, the lack of controls and the evidence for antiquity", and this means the mediaeval date may not be tenable. It's a claim based on conjecture, and conjecture is not evidence.

The comment under entry#10 is priceless, though. It refers to Ockham's razor and suggests that the simplest explanation for the mediaeval date is an invisible reweave in this tiny and unimportant area.

As any fule kno, Ockham's razor charges us not to multiply entities unnecessarily. Following his razor would lead us to the conclusion that the simplest explanation for the mediaeval date is that the cloth is actually mediaeval.

We're up to 10 entries out of the 32 given in this pdf, and so far none of the entries refer to actual evidence. There's conjecture and hearsay, but nothing more than that.

Can I really force myself to look at the other 22? Probably not, but I make no promises.

So far, Jabba, you really haven't presented any actual evidence for this impossible undocumented invisible reweave/repair/patch.
 
Last edited:
I have to do something else for a little while, would anybody like to look at the next five entries on the pdf that Jabba presented? If not, I'll look at them later. So far, as evidence, we're 0 for 5.


I'll play:

6. Speculation of repair based on hearsay, based also in part on the assumption Jesus existed and was resurrected

7 Speculation, claim of "rogue" fibers in the C14 samples when a few foreign fibers would almost have to be present in a room where weaving was done. Also misstates meaning of 95% confidence interval for dating results saying it means there's only a 95% chance the date is medieval

8. Claims contamination by "foreign" fibers, this is contradicted by same logic as other contamination claims; namely that the mass of contamination required to shift from 30 AD to 1300 AD would be several times the mass of the sample itself. This last applies to #7 also

9 "Sample was small"; the size of sample was completely sufficient for the analytical method used. The method used was chosen in part because it needed just a small sample.

10. Authenticist group ASSIST says C14 results "may" be wrong because claims listed above. Ends with desperate misuse of Occam's Razor
 
Good Morning (again), Mr. Savage:

(Obviously, I am not Agatha, but so be it...)

Which one of the arguments raised by Prior and Marino at http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf comprises, in your opinion, the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence of the actual existence of an actual, physical "invisible" reweave' "near-invisible" reweave, "undetectable" repair, (or even "...some patching") in the sampled area of the CIQ?

Be specific, if you would be so kind.

I anticipate your on-point response.
Slowvehicle,
- I'll need to review the list, and also Agatha's reactions to the list.
- I'll be back.
 
Slowvehicle,
- I'll need to review the list, and also Agatha's reactions to the list.
- I'll be back.

You never come back with anything of substance - just promises and childishly transparency avoidance tactics. Don't bother.
 
OK, I'll take a turn:

#11: Dr. Stuart Fleming, Late of Oxford and currently at the University of Pennsylvania, is quoted as asserting that a restorer “could certainly have re-woven a damaged edge to a standard not visible to the naked eye". There is no record of Dr, Fleming ever having examined the CIQ directly, himself; further, Dr. Fleming is not, in fact, a "textile expert"; his area of expertise appears to be ceramics, and glass.

Supposition (perhaps even misrepresentation) but no evidence of any "repair".

#12: Bill Meacham, an Archaeologist, is quoted as asserting that "...it is possible that the area was re-woven by a mideaval resorer...", but that assertion is presented without evidence. Meacham's book, The Rape of the Shroud, is mentioned; however, it is not made clear that the "rape" in the title is the "secret restoration project" undertaken in 2002 by "...engineered by a small clique around the archbishop of Turin..."

A further assertion is made that the "British Museum" regrets participating in the "current " project.

Supposition, assertion, and calumny, but no evidence of any "repair".

#13: Gilbert Raes "believes" that the cotton he examined is from inside the QIC threads.

Assertion, but (surprise) no evidence of any "repair".

#14: Jaques Evin, ( Carbon-Dating specialist not a "fabric expert"), is quoted as saying: "... if the weave was rewoven with threads from modern restoration, this would be reflected in more modern results...”

Note that Evin's quote simply sidesteps the issue that an "invisible" reweave could not be done with "...threads form modern restoration..."; it is the very nature of the type of reweave proposed that, in order to blend in with the repaired cloth, it is done with threads form the original cloth.

Supposition and misstatement. No evidence of any "repair".

#15: A Belgian Chemist is quoted as asserting that the chi-square value of the 14C results indicates that the samples tested were not all taken from the same cloth.

This is an assertion of dishonesty and complicity, but does not provide any evidence that the actual samples were taken form a "repaired" area--if true, this is an indication that the samples were not taken from the CIQ at all.

Supposition and calumny; no evidence of any "repair".
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- I'll need to review the list, and also Agatha's reactions to the list.
- I'll be back.

Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

Tragically, it seems that you are saying that you have not read (or, at the very least, are not familiar with the claims made in the link you posted as containing evidence of a "repair".

Again I ask: Which of the points raised in http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf comprises, in your opinion, the best evidence for an "invisible" reweave", a "near-invisible" reweave, and undetectable repair, or even "...some patching" done to the sampled area of the CIQ?

Hint: None of the first 15 entries do so...(se above)

I eagerly await your substantive response.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- I'll need to review the list, and also Agatha's reactions to the list.
- I'll be back.

You should have reviewed it before presenting it as evidence. But no, that would require you to behave like an erudite - if amateur - scientist. We couldn't have that, could we?

You'll be back, but you will never come back to address this or any other objection to your mindless faith in the CIQ. Prove me a liar.
 
The "I'll be back" thing is getting a little tired. Is it too much to ask that you'll actually respond to things when you get back, Jabba?

Entry#11 "there are no absolute dates [in C14 dating]". Well, duh. You get a range of dates. This does nothing to counteract the mediaeval dates, which was given, as we all remember, as a range from 1290 to 1360.

Entry#12 this suggests that other evidence should be taken into account a well a the C14 dating. Well, yes. Like, um, the high gothic appearance of the figure, the anatomical impossibility, the appearance of the shroud in historical records, the d'Arcis memo, the mismatch of the shroud to Biblical accounts and Jewish burial practices (and other evidence) all of which support the mediaeval date.

Entry#13 suggests that despite being the most tightly controlled C14 test in history, more labs and secondary techniques should have been used. This is not evidence, it's conjecture that maybe more testing might, in some bizarro world, yield the result that the Shroudies want.

Entry#14 is an identical re-run of entry #12.

Entry#15 is a rerun of entry#13, calling for more labs. "If three labs give a result we don't like, let's go with seven!" It's like the child who is losing 3-0 in a game of rock paper scissors insisting that if they could just play best of 7 then surely they would win. It's conjecture, since there is no real reason to think more labs would yield different answers, and most C14 dating is done in just the one lab.

Entry#16 This is an extended whine that STURP didn't get their own way over the cutting of the sample. It's not evidence for either a reweave or that the testing was flawed in any way. The Vatican owns the cloth and it has the final say (and it should be noted that if the shroud were found to be authentic, the Vatican would be overjoyed).

Entry#17 This is a criticism that sometimes C14 dating gives erroneous dates, claiming that an error of +/- 400 years was made in dating the Lindow Man. This appears to be a misinterpretation of the results of dating the peat of Lindow Moss and the body of Lindow II; the peat is (unsurprisingly) older than the body deliberately buried in it.

Entry#18 is a re-run of entry#12, this time positing that a researcher who said that the 1532 fire must be taken into account means that an imaginary impossible undocumented invisible reweave ought also to be taken into account.

Entry#19 This says that sometimes C14 labs might make mistakes, and charges that the Zurich lab made several erroneous datings. As the only evidence I can find of this comes from shroudie sites. I'm putting this down to hearsay and conjecture pending more actual evidence. However, three labs were used and so far no mistakes seem to have been laid at the door of the other two labs.

Entry#20 Gove is credited with being the originator of the C14 technique used to date the shroud, which is strange as Willard Libby came up with the technique in the 1940s and won a Nobel prize for it. Let's be generous and say that ascribing the technique to Gove is a mistake on the part of the authors. The entry calls for multiple sites and suggests that because all the samples came from one area, there must be that [imaginary impossible undocumented invisible] reweave. It's conjecture, not evidence.

Only 12 points left to go and we're 0 for 20.

Any comments yet, Jabba?
 
Let's not forget Jabba's appeal to The Undocumented History of the Shroud

I have to smile when I see that. Wasn't that a series on the "History Channel" a few years back?
 
Jabba: when you said you didn't understand our objections to your "reasoning" I asked you:

Do you understand why lots of little misdeeds do not sum up to one big good deed?

Do you get it now? Let me spell it out for you: It doesn't matter how many little bits of speculation, conjecture and outright slander you can find they will never add up to even a tiny bit of evidence, let alone a preponderance of it.
 
...continuing:

# 21 is no more than an assertion, by the Whangers, that threads form the "seam" were included in the samples tested (ignoring, as is always done, the amount of anomalous matrial that would have had to have been accidentally included in the samples to skew teh date by 14 centuries...)

A structure of conjectures, but no evidence of any "repair".

#22 is a creative assertion that because debris lifted from the surface of the CIQ with "sticky tapes" differs in composition from fabric samples cut form the fabric of the CIQ in their entirety, the "lifted" surface samples must be more representative of the CIQ than the actual whole-cloth samples CIQ.

Conjecture about sampling techniques; no evidence of any "repair".

#23 is a rehash of the "gradient" in 14C samples; a rehash that has been dealt with in other places.

A complete misuse of range-of-error, but no evidence of any "repair".

#24 begins with the typical assertion that, since the samples were "...taken from a rewoven edge...", then there must have been some reweaving. The supposed spectrographic differences addressed by the BS&G paper are mentioned, as is the lack of any historical evidence that there was not a repair done to the sampled site.

Desperate conjecture, circular argument, special pleading; no evidence of any "repair".

#25 is a claim that "...Thomas Ferguson & Co. Ltd, world-renowned makers of Double Damask Linen, was blindly shown a photograph of the Zurich C-14 sample..."; and that from the photograph, unnamed observers came to the conclusion that the Zurich sample "...had been touched up to prevent unravelling...", and that, although the twill pattern could be clearly seen, there was "...something different about the left and right sides..."

Conjecture (and atrocious investigative technique), but no evidence of any "repair".

Time and again: "...the possibility of...", "...might be...", "...could be..."; but no evidence. Almost a textbook on special pleading.

I will leave the last 7 for someone else. Agatha deserves much praise for determination...
 
Last edited:
#26: Someone allegedly representing one lab that was not chosen to do testing thinks that is a catastrophe. He does not explain why, but his sentiment might hint at the reason this lab was not chosen. No evidence for any fault of the C14 date.

#27: Someone allegedly representing the Tucson lap (which WAS one of the chosen) says he wishes all seven labs had been used (seven was the number originally considered). Presumably it would be nice to spread the controversy, and he can afford to be generous.

#28: Someone (a clergyman) claims that one of the labs not chosen had more experience than the other 6 together. I don't know how he comes to the evaluation. Either you are competent ot you are not. No evidence for any fault of the C14 date.

#29: "
The Pontifical Academy of Science, the scientific body connected with the Roman
Catholic Church and which has a high reputation in the world of science, was excluded fromofficial participation in the C-14 testing."​

Come on! They can't all be in on it. No evidence for any fault of the C14 date.

#30: A rehash of the quarrels leading up to the test. Again, for a pro lab to let that influence them to flat out lie about the result (the only way they could be presenting a wrong date since the equipment does not care about quarrels) is simply slanderous. They should be glad nobody decided to sue them. No evidence for any fault of the C14 date.

31: A link to the final Nature report and a circular claim that considering the above "evidence" it must be faulty. No evidence for any fault of the C14 date.

Jabba, we have now been far too generous. Next time I suggest we only consider Jabba's first Q/C.

Hans
 
Carbon Dating Doubts

- I'm still thinking...

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.
- Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence. Again, I think that when all the evidence (that I know about) is placed on the scales, the scales tip towards authenticity.
- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.
 
- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.

The problem with all that inferential argumentation is that in requires the reader to, well, infer. You want to guide the reader to a particular inference from among the many that are possible. And in this case it is an extremely monumental, far-reaching, extraordinary inference. And everything that's extraordinary about it lies between the end of the evidence and your conclusion, in that vast inferential gulf you ask your readers to leap.

In other words, for the kind of claims made about the shroud, you need far more than that kind of evidence in order to be convincing.

Also, It's the combination of evidence that makes me believe that the shroud is probably authentic -- not any single piece of evidence.

Okay, you're trying to make an argument from consilience. That's reasonably convincing if done correctly. Doing it correctly means showing, in each separate evidentiary case, that the interpretation of that point of evidence that favors the authenticity of the shroud is the best interpretation on its merits. That results in a collection of disparate evidence whose individually best interpretation points to authenticity, and whose arrival thereat by accident is considered collectively unlikely.

Unfortunately a lot of people don't construct the argument correctly and produce what others have termed anti-consilience. An argument is anti-consilient if the interpretation of each evidentiary point is guided by the overall desired outcome. It most often arises when a preferred belief is asserted, and then backfilled by cherry-picked, preferentially interpreted evidence.

It's often favored where the debate proponent wants to keep everything at a broad-strokes, high-altitude level of discourse and not delve into details. Usually those details don't favor the proponent.

- Right now, my interim conclusion that the image is some sort of an imprint of a real dead body is what most makes me tend to believe that the shroud is authentic.

And Catholic relic-peddlers of the 14th century wouldn't have had access to a real dead body?
 
- I'm still thinking...

- Remember that I never claimed to have significant "direct" evidence that the shroud is ~2000 years old. What I consider significant evidence is all "circumstantial," or indirect.


Nope: what you consider to be "significant evidence" of authenticity is nothing of the sort, because all if it (or at least, all that you have so far posted) is just as consistent with inauthenticity as it is with authenticity. It therefore cannot "tip the scales" towards authenticity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom