Slowvehicle
Membership Drive , Co-Ordinator,, Russell's Antin
Slowvehicle,
- I don't really understand your objection -- that's why I asked the above question.
- What is not practical, not empirical, not testable, not non-magical, not non-anecdotal or not objective about evidence that the shroud has been repaired?
- Are you saying that the results do not amount to evidence of repair?
- Are you saying that the claimed results of the various studies are not credible?
- Are you just saying that the existence of repair wouldn't mean that the shroud is ~2000 yrs old?
- Or, are you saying "all of the above"?
Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:
Be so kind as to present this.
NB: "One way to explain the fact that the 14C dating demonstrated the "wrong date" is to assume that there must be an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching", enough to skew the date," IS NOT EVIDENCE. It is instead wishful thinking that barely rises to the level of special pleading.
Given that no one who has actually handled the CIQ in person has seen any indication of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching"; and
Given that Mme F-L and others specifically dismiss the possibility of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching"; an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching" for which they were looking, to avoid this very kind of argument; and,
Given that the sampled area was specificlly chosen to avoid any appearance of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching";
What do you offer in the way of concrete, testable, empirical, objective, non-magical, non-anecdotal physical evidence that there is an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching" anyway, despite all of the above?
Given the work of BS&G, what leads you to continue to hope that the sample area is different from the rest of the CIQ?
...to say nothing of the demonstrable fact that any such reweave would have had to have been done with threads form the rest of the CIQ, making it a better sample...
I eagerly await your presentation of this.
Bring it.
Last edited: