Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slowvehicle,

- I don't really understand your objection -- that's why I asked the above question.

- What is not practical, not empirical, not testable, not non-magical, not non-anecdotal or not objective about evidence that the shroud has been repaired?
- Are you saying that the results do not amount to evidence of repair?
- Are you saying that the claimed results of the various studies are not credible?
- Are you just saying that the existence of repair wouldn't mean that the shroud is ~2000 yrs old?
- Or, are you saying "all of the above"?

Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

Be so kind as to present this.

NB: "One way to explain the fact that the 14C dating demonstrated the "wrong date" is to assume that there must be an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching", enough to skew the date," IS NOT EVIDENCE. It is instead wishful thinking that barely rises to the level of special pleading.

Given that no one who has actually handled the CIQ in person has seen any indication of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching"; and

Given that Mme F-L and others specifically dismiss the possibility of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching"; an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching" for which they were looking, to avoid this very kind of argument; and,

Given that the sampled area was specificlly chosen to avoid any appearance of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching";

What do you offer in the way of concrete, testable, empirical, objective, non-magical, non-anecdotal physical evidence that there is an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching" anyway, despite all of the above?

Given the work of BS&G, what leads you to continue to hope that the sample area is different from the rest of the CIQ?

...to say nothing of the demonstrable fact that any such reweave would have had to have been done with threads form the rest of the CIQ, making it a better sample...

I eagerly await your presentation of this.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,

- I don't really understand your objection -- that's why I asked the above question.

- What is not practical, not empirical, not testable, not non-magical, not non-anecdotal or not objective about evidence that the shroud has been repaired?
- Are you saying that the results do not amount to evidence of repair?
- Are you saying that the claimed results of the various studies are not credible?
- Are you just saying that the existence of repair wouldn't mean that the shroud is ~2000 yrs old?
- Or, are you saying "all of the above"?

Ya know, it might just be easier to just present your evidence for a reweave or the age of the cloth.
 
Slow,
- Here you're telling me that my way of arriving at a probabilistic conclusion concerning the ability of puddles to generate puppies is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- I should explain why I think you're wrong.
- But I don't really understand what you're saying.
- So you should probably explain it to me again several times.
- Nevertheless, you are wrong.
- But try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors the theory that puppies spring spontaneously from puddles?
- Regardless of your response, I'm going to assume you do agree with that, because why wouldn't you?
- As a start, go to www.puppiesfrompuddles.notarealurl.com. Here you will find many stories of people who have seen puppies next to puddles. There are even some pictures and diagrams.
- I haven't read all of the above and don't know how well it actually supports my assertion, and I'm certainly not going to summarize the best evidence that puddles produce puppies.
- Please remember to respond with only one question or comment.
- If you respond with more than one question or comment, I will ignore all of them and only latch onto a bit of the most irrelevant one.
- I'll be back.

Well done.

Jabba, did you recognize yourself in Lucian's elucidation?
 
Slowvehicle,

- I don't really understand your objection -- that's why I asked the above question.

- What is not practical, not empirical, not testable, not non-magical, not non-anecdotal or not objective about evidence that the shroud has been repaired?
- Are you saying that the results do not amount to evidence of repair?
- Are you saying that the claimed results of the various studies are not credible?
- Are you just saying that the existence of repair wouldn't mean that the shroud is ~2000 yrs old?
- Or, are you saying "all of the above"?

- Jabba, I don't really understand your refusal to understand.
- Why are you being obtuse?
- Is it deliberate?
- Nobody could be as dense
- as you are pretending to be.
- I'll be back.
 
Last edited:
I wish, I really wish you hadn't put it that way. Because now it'll become Gospel Truth to Jabba, from everlasting to everlasting. He'll quote you right alongside Saint Rinderpest, or whoever's the patron saint of liars.

No thanks to you for underlining that point.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?
Instead of wasting people's time with your attempts to control the debate why not produce the evidence you claim to have?
 
Slowvehicle,

- I don't really understand your objection -- that's why I asked the above question.

- What is not practical, not empirical, not testable, not non-magical, not non-anecdotal or not objective about evidence that the shroud has been repaired?
We haven't seen any of this evidence for repair yet. Could you present some?


- Are you saying that the results do not amount to evidence of repair?
- Are you saying that the claimed results of the various studies are not credible?
- Are you just saying that the existence of repair wouldn't mean that the shroud is ~2000 yrs old?
- Or, are you saying "all of the above"?
One q/c only per post was your rule for everyone else; are you exempt? (Of course you need not answer that, as it is the second q/c of my post).
 
Discussion Format

Good Afternoon, Mr. Savage:

Be so kind as to present this.

NB: "One way to explain the fact that the 14C dating demonstrated the "wrong date" is to assume that there must be an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching", enough to skew the date," IS NOT EVIDENCE. It is instead wishful thinking that barely rises to the level of special pleading.

Given that no one who has actually handled the CIQ in person has seen any indication of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching"; and

Given that Mme F-L and others specifically dismiss the possibility of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching"; an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching" for which they were looking, to avoid this very kind of argument; and,

Given that the sampled area was specificlly chosen to avoid any appearance of an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching";

What do you offer in the way of concrete, testable, empirical, objective, non-magical, non-anecdotal physical evidence that there is an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", or "...some patching" anyway, despite all of the above?

Given the work of BS&G, what leads you to continue to hope that the sample area is different from the rest of the CIQ?

...to say nothing of the demonstrable fact that any such reweave would have had to have been done with threads form the rest of the CIQ, making it a better sample...

I eagerly await your presentation of this.

Bring it.
Slowvehicle,

- I ask questions rather than present evidence at this point because I don't really understand your objection, and consequently don't know how to answer. To satisfy your request, I need to understand what you're requesting...

- To the extent that I think that I do understand your objection, I think it should be overruled...
- One way to support the hypothesis that the dating is wrong is to show that there might be a near-invisible reweave/repair in the sample, sufficient to skew the date. That's what I'm trying to show.
 
We haven't seen any of this evidence for repair yet. Could you present some?

One q/c only per post was your rule for everyone else; are you exempt? (Of course you need not answer that, as it is the second q/c of my post).
Agatha,
- Why do you say that what I just presented by Marino and Prior is not evidence?
 
Slowvehicle,

- I ask questions rather than present evidence at this point because I don't really understand your objection, and consequently don't know how to answer. To satisfy your request, I need to understand what you're requesting...

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

If you have any evidence at all that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old, now is the time to present it.

NB: NOT claims that you are unhappy with the 14C dating; NOT claims that Dr. McCrone was "hard to work with:, NOT claims that Mme. F-L must have been in collusion, or fundamentally dishonest, or simply incompetent.

Evidence that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

Alternatively:
NOT claims that "...some patching" with modern threads would skew the dating; NOT assertions that there must be some sort of reweaving, because that's the only way you can discredit the 14C dating; NOT fantasies that "french reweave" could be performed with anything other than threads form the rest of the CIQ (making the dating, in fact more representative).

Evidence that the "invisible" reweaving, or the "near-invisible" reweaving, or the "undetectable repair", or "...some patching" exists. (Especially given the fact that no person who has actually handled the CIQ in person has detected any such thing.)

- To the extent that I think that I do understand your objection, I think it should be overruled...

You cannot "overrule" reality.

- One way to support the hypothesis that the dating is wrong is to show that there might be a near-invisible reweave/repair in the sample, sufficient to skew the date. That's what I'm trying to show.

Assertions that there "might be a near-invisible reweave/repair in the sample, sufficient to skew the date", are of a type with assertions that a burst of "resurrection energy" "transmuted" 14N in the linen of the CIQ into excess 14C.

You have, in fact, demonstrated that there do exist such unsupported assertions. What you have not done is demonstrate that the actual object of your assertions, that is the "invisible" reweave, or the "near-invisible" reweave, or the "undetectable" repair, or "...some patching", itself, as a physical object (rather than a bit of special-pleading fantasy) exists.

If you have any such evidence, you should present it.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Agatha,
- Why do you say that what I just presented by Marino and Prior is not evidence?

Good Morning (again), Mr. Savage:

(Obviously, I am not Agatha, but so be it...)

Which one of the arguments raised by Prior and Marino at http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf comprises, in your opinion, the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence of the actual existence of an actual, physical "invisible" reweave' "near-invisible" reweave, "undetectable" repair, (or even "...some patching") in the sampled area of the CIQ?

Be specific, if you would be so kind.

I anticipate your on-point response.
 
- One way to support the hypothesis that the dating is wrong is to show that there might be a near-invisible reweave/repair in the sample, sufficient to skew the date. That's what I'm trying to show.

No. That does not even support a hypothesis. It is simple speculation with nothing to support it.

In other words, it is a waste of time.


Hans
 
Agatha,
- Why do you say that what I just presented by Marino and Prior is not evidence?

Who are Marino and Prior? You've not mentioned them in this thread before.

You have also not presented any evidence that the shroud is 2000 years old. Perhaps you should try reading Agatha's posts, or Mojo's, or most of the other posters here. But you've admitted you won't.
 
Agatha,
- Why do you say that what I just presented by Marino and Prior is not evidence?
Entry #1 is someone conjecturing that he can determine how many pairs of hands made the visible repairs. Conjecture is not evidence, and this does not refer to the sampled area.

Entry#2 refers to the sewing thread used to join two pieces together, and notes that it's different from the cloth. Sewing thread is almost always different from the cloth on which it's being used. This does not refer to the sampled area.

Entry #3 The way this is written is hearsay, but setting that aside, this refers to cotton woven into the linen in the Raes sample sent to Rogers. The problems with the chain of custody and handling of these samples are well documented.

Entry#4 Once again this is written as hearsay. It begs the questions about paint and blood, and conjectures that McCrone's determination of pigments on the shroud were due to contaminants in the weaver's workshop. Conjecture is not evidence.

Entry #5 An expert on near-Eastern textiles is reported as raising the possibility that the sidestrip "....may derive from a later repair". I cannot find the full quote from which this is taken, nor can I find any evidence that the quoted expert has ever examined the shroud. Conjecture is not evidence.

I have to do something else for a little while, would anybody like to look at the next five entries on the pdf that Jabba presented? If not, I'll look at them later. So far, as evidence, we're 0 for 5.
 
Slowvehicle,

- I ask questions rather than present evidence at this point because I don't really understand your objection, and consequently don't know how to answer. To satisfy your request, I need to understand what you're requesting... I have no evidence or logic supporting my deeply felt need to believe in the authenticity of the CIQ
FTFY (that means Fixed That For You)

- To the extent that I think that I do understand your objection, I think it should be overruled...
- One way to support the hypothesis that the dating is wrong is to show that there might be a near-invisible reweave/repair in the sample, sufficient to skew the date. That's what I'm trying to show.

This is not a court of law.

Your only "Appeals Court" is another forum - presumably one void of logic, critical thinking, and science.

I'm sure you are already familiar with them.
 
Last edited:
Jabba, you should just accept that we are sticking to the scientific method here and not considering your preponderance of evidence approach. It will cause less confusion if you abandon that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom