Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

You already tried. What you showed was that it was only possible with very special definitions of "preponderance" and "evidence".
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

In order to have a preponderance of evidence favoring authenticity, you have to have SOME evidence that supports authenticity in the first place. You've been asked, and you have nothing.

And let's make it clear: "No artist can replicate the shroud" is NOT evidence for "authenticity". If it were even true (it's not), it is only evidence against medieval. The reason it is not evidence for authenticity is because no one also has been able to replicate even the image on the shroud (much less the shroud itself) by wrapping a cloth around a body, either. So "no one can replicate" does not favor authenticity.

Similarly, "the C14 date is suspect because there could be an invisible patch", even if true (again, there is no evidence for an invisible patch, and the concept is ludicrous on the face of it), it would not be evidence for authenticity. Only evidence that discounts the C14 data.

Provide real evidence FOR authenticity. Not "asserted evidence against a medieval creation." If you had a preponderance of actual evidence for authenticity, we could accept that. However, given that you haven't ever presented anything that requires it to be authentic to explain, it's really hard to assert a preponderance of evidence.
 
And why are we abandoning the Scientific Method? What's so special about this rag that we should be adopting a preponderance of evidence approach? This is as bad as the Shroudies creating this new discipline they call Shroud Science, as if one artifacts rates that.
 
And why are we abandoning the Scientific Method? What's so special about this rag that we should be adopting a preponderance of evidence approach? This is as bad as the Shroudies creating this new discipline they call Shroud Science, as if one artifacts rates that.

They call it Shroud Science[TM] because it hurts their feelings if you call it what it is - pseudoscience.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

Do you have any evidence in favour of authenticity? So far, the answer appears to be that you do not.
 
To understand you may want to go back a few pages to where I posed you a question.

Imagine a world where no 14C dating had been performed on the shroud. Where nobody had ever looked closely at the cloth to discover the gesso or considered whether the red was anything other than blood. A world in which there had never been one single solitary piece of research conducted that suggested the shroud was a forgery.

Now I ask you, how, in this world I just described, can we know if the shroud is the genuine article?

What evidence do you have for a 1st century origin?

Forget the evidence for a medieval origin, it doesn't exist.

That's what you need to do. Because arguing against the evidence for a medieval origin doesn't actually help your cause one iota. Even if you could utterly destroy all of that evidence it would simply render the shroud's origin as unknown.

Jabba: I realize that you won't read this post as it's not from your current correspondent. I also realize that you won't read it because it has more than one q/c. But you really should read it and should really try hard to understand what Wollery is saying. Because it's something that's been brought up many times by many posters and you've refused to acknowledge it in any way.
 
In order to have a preponderance of evidence favoring authenticity, you have to have SOME evidence that supports authenticity in the first place. You've been asked, and you have nothing.

And let's make it clear: "No artist can replicate the shroud" is NOT evidence for "authenticity". If it were even true (it's not), it is only evidence against medieval. The reason it is not evidence for authenticity is because no one also has been able to replicate even the image on the shroud (much less the shroud itself) by wrapping a cloth around a body, either. So "no one can replicate" does not favor authenticity.

Similarly, "the C14 date is suspect because there could be an invisible patch", even if true (again, there is no evidence for an invisible patch, and the concept is ludicrous on the face of it), it would not be evidence for authenticity. Only evidence that discounts the C14 data.

Provide real evidence FOR authenticity. Not "asserted evidence against a medieval creation." If you had a preponderance of actual evidence for authenticity, we could accept that. However, given that you haven't ever presented anything that requires it to be authentic to explain, it's really hard to assert a preponderance of evidence.

Jabba: I realize that you won't read this post as it's not from your current correspondent. I also realize that you won't read it because it has more than one q/c. But you really should read it and should really try hard to understand what pgwenthold is saying. Because it's something that's been brought up many times by many posters and you've refused to acknowledge it in any way.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

What evidence (practical, empirical, testable, non-magical, non-anecdotal, objective evidence) do you have that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

"Authenticity" is a different issue; if the CIQ IS NOT ~2000 years old, then it cannot be the "True ShroudTM".

(Note the non-reciprocal nature of that fact: The CIQ could, in fact, be ~2000 years old, and still NOT be "authentic"*; however, if the CIQ IS NOT ~2000 years old, then it cannot be said [in any honest way] to be "authentic".)

It has been pointed out to you, multiple times, by multiple posters, that you are trying to "blame the puppy on the puddle".

I ask again: What evidence do you offer that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?

*see previous discussions anent the nature and quality of the image; including, but not in any way limited to, the problems with scriptural inaccuracy; with historical inaccuracy; with anatomical impossibility; and all the rest (be sure to consider such things as "Shroudinger's Fe2O3...)
 
Last edited:
Forget the evidence for a medieval origin, it doesn't exist.

That's what you need to do. Because arguing against the evidence for a medieval origin doesn't actually help your cause one iota. Even if you could utterly destroy all of that evidence it would simply render the shroud's origin as unknown.


When SezMe was Jabba's MFP (Most Favored Poster), SezMe allowed Jabba to assume all his ICs were true, thus negating all the evidence for medieval. SezMe asked Jabba to show how the ICs led logically to a conclusion of 2000yo/authenticity. Jabba explicitly agreed to this approach, played the "gosh, I'm not sure I understand" game for a few weeks and when pressed abruptly revoked SezMe's MFP status. Having seen all along, IMO, that that line of reasoning ended with him trapped in a box canyon of logic.

My cynicism grows with each new page; still, best of luck.
 
This can't really still be going on can it!?

Has any credible evidence been actually presented as yet?
 
Discussion Format and Puppy-Spawning Puddles

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

What evidence (practical, empirical, testable, non-magical, non-anecdotal, objective evidence) do you have that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

"Authenticity" is a different issue; if the CIQ IS NOT ~2000 years old, then it cannot be the "True ShroudTM".

(Note the non-reciprocal nature of that fact: The CIQ could, in fact, be ~2000 years old, and still NOT be "authentic"*; however, if the CIQ IS NOT ~2000 years old, then it cannot be said [in any honest way] to be "authentic".)

It has been pointed out to you, multiple times, by multiple posters, that you are trying to "blame the puppy on the puddle".

I ask again: What evidence do you offer that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?

*see previous discussions anent the nature and quality of the image; including, but not in any way limited to, the problems with scriptural inaccuracy; with historical inaccuracy; with anatomical impossibility; and all the rest (be sure to consider such things as "Shroudinger's Fe2O3...)

Slow,
- Here you're telling me that my way of arriving at a probabilistic conclusion concerning the ability of puddles to generate puppies is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- I should explain why I think you're wrong.
- But I don't really understand what you're saying.
- So you should probably explain it to me again several times.
- Nevertheless, you are wrong.
- But try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors the theory that puppies spring spontaneously from puddles?
- Regardless of your response, I'm going to assume you do agree with that, because why wouldn't you?
- As a start, go to www.puppiesfrompuddles.notarealurl.com. Here you will find many stories of people who have seen puppies next to puddles. There are even some pictures and diagrams.
- I haven't read all of the above and don't know how well it actually supports my assertion, and I'm certainly not going to summarize the best evidence that puddles produce puppies.
- Please remember to respond with only one question or comment.
- If you respond with more than one question or comment, I will ignore all of them and only latch onto a bit of the most irrelevant one.
- I'll be back.
 
Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

I accept this as perfectly valid. Indeed, I think it can even be accomplished using the scientific method of hypotheses and testable predictions. For example:

Hypothesis: The Shroud is authentic.

From this hypothesis, we can make a number of predictions:

Prediction 1: If the Shroud is authentic, then the weave will match contemporary examples.

Prediction 2: If the Shroud is authentic, then carbon dating of the material will show it to be ~2000 years old.

Prediction 3: If the Shroud is authentic, then the image will be reproducible by following the process claimed to have produced the original image.

Etc.

We can then make tests of these predictions, and use the test results as evidence for or against the hypothesis.

Test of P1: Fails. The weave does not match any contemporary examples.

Test of P2: Fails. Carbon dating shows the shroud to be only ~1400 years old.

Test of P3: Fails. The image cannot be reproduced using the claimed method.

Etc.

Finally, we can weigh up the preponderance of evidence provided by the tests, and reach a conclusion about the hypothesis. In this case, the preponderance of evidence supports the conclusion that the hypothesis is false. The evidence shows that the Shroud is very likely not authentic.














Another thing to consider is that not all predictions are of equal value. For example, consider the prediction that the image can be reproduced by the claimed method. This prediction is also consistent with the hypothesis that the Shroud was created at a different time, with another subject, by the claimed method. Any prediction that is consistent with competing hypothesis cannot be used to prefer one hypothesis over the other. If the prediction is tested successfully, it means only that both hypotheses are equally likely to be true. If the test fails, it means only that both hypotheses are likely to be false. Thus, we know from the test of this prediction that the Shroud was probably not created by the claimed method, neither ~2000 years ago nor ~1400 years ago.
 
When SezMe was Jabba's MFP (Most Favored Poster), SezMe allowed Jabba to assume all his ICs were true, thus negating all the evidence for medieval. SezMe asked Jabba to show how the ICs led logically to a conclusion of 2000yo/authenticity. Jabba explicitly agreed to this approach, played the "gosh, I'm not sure I understand" game for a few weeks and when pressed abruptly revoked SezMe's MFP status. Having seen all along, IMO, that that line of reasoning ended with him trapped in a box canyon of logic.

My cynicism grows with each new page; still, best of luck.
This. There is no shred of intellectual honesty or integrity in any of Jabba's posts here.
 
Discussion Format

Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

What evidence (practical, empirical, testable, non-magical, non-anecdotal, objective evidence) do you have that the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

"Authenticity" is a different issue; if the CIQ IS NOT ~2000 years old, then it cannot be the "True ShroudTM".

(Note the non-reciprocal nature of that fact: The CIQ could, in fact, be ~2000 years old, and still NOT be "authentic"*; however, if the CIQ IS NOT ~2000 years old, then it cannot be said [in any honest way] to be "authentic".)

It has been pointed out to you, multiple times, by multiple posters, that you are trying to "blame the puppy on the puddle".

I ask again: What evidence do you offer that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?

*see previous discussions anent the nature and quality of the image; including, but not in any way limited to, the problems with scriptural inaccuracy; with historical inaccuracy; with anatomical impossibility; and all the rest (be sure to consider such things as "Shroudinger's Fe2O3...)
Slowvehicle,

- I don't really understand your objection -- that's why I asked the above question.

- What is not practical, not empirical, not testable, not non-magical, not non-anecdotal or not objective about evidence that the shroud has been repaired?
- Are you saying that the results do not amount to evidence of repair?
- Are you saying that the claimed results of the various studies are not credible?
- Are you just saying that the existence of repair wouldn't mean that the shroud is ~2000 yrs old?
- Or, are you saying "all of the above"?
 
Last edited:
Slow,
- Here you're telling me that my way of arriving at a probabilistic conclusion concerning the ability of puddles to generate puppies is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- I should explain why I think you're wrong.
- But I don't really understand what you're saying.
- So you should probably explain it to me again several times.
- Nevertheless, you are wrong.
- But try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors the theory that puppies spring spontaneously from puddles?
- Regardless of your response, I'm going to assume you do agree with that, because why wouldn't you?
- As a start, go to www.puppiesfrompuddles.notarealurl.com. Here you will find many stories of people who have seen puppies next to puddles. There are even some pictures and diagrams.
- I haven't read all of the above and don't know how well it actually supports my assertion, and I'm certainly not going to summarize the best evidence that puddles produce puppies.
- Please remember to respond with only one question or comment.
- If you respond with more than one question or comment, I will ignore all of them and only latch onto a bit of the most irrelevant one.
- I'll be back.

:D
 
Slowvehicle,

- I don't really understand your objection -- that's why I asked the above question.

- What is not practical, not empirical, not testable, not non-magical, not non-anecdotal or not objective about evidence that the shroud has been repaired?
- Are you saying that the results do not amount to evidence of repair?
- Are you saying that the claimed results of the various studies are not credible?
- Are you just saying that the existence of repair wouldn't mean that the shroud is ~2000 yrs old?
- Or, are you saying "all of the above"?

Why are you not responding to Slowvehicle's first question?
 
...Forget the evidence for a medieval origin, it doesn't exist....

I wish, I really wish you hadn't put it that way. Because now it'll become Gospel Truth to Jabba, from everlasting to everlasting. He'll quote you right alongside Saint Rinderpest, or whoever's the patron saint of liars.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom