Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.

Should we expect your return?
 
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.

And once again you fixate on the irrelephant (and no, I like this one and it's not going away) in the room when you could be posting things that matter. How about posting something that supports the rag being 2000ish years old? That would actually contribute to the conversation. Instead you focus on the unimportant and communicate you are desperately holding onto beliefs you know you can't support.

It's time you accept the cloth could not have covered the person you think it did and this cornerstone of your beliefs is just a rag.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.

Dear Mr. Savage:

We had this very conversation, several different ways, in your "Immortality" thread.

Others, in this thread, have pointed out the paucity of your soi dissant "...way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions..." means that it is not, in fact, cannot be considered an evidence-driven approach.

I, personally, would prefer that you address my actual question:

What evidence do you have to present (actual, practical, non-magical, non-anecdotal, testable, empirical, objective, factual evidence) that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?

If you would rather, what evidence do you have to present (actual, practical, non-magical, non-anecdotal, testable, empirical, objective, factual evidence) that there is an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, a "repair", or even "...some patching" in the sampled area if the CIQ?
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.



BINGO!! Everybody has been telling you that.
 
Dear Mr. Savage:

We had this very conversation, several different ways, in your "Immortality" thread.

Others, in this thread, have pointed out the paucity of your soi dissant "...way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions..." means that it is not, in fact, cannot be considered an evidence-driven approach.

I, personally, would prefer that you address my actual question:

What evidence do you have to present (actual, practical, non-magical, non-anecdotal, testable, empirical, objective, factual evidence) that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?

If you would rather, what evidence do you have to present (actual, practical, non-magical, non-anecdotal, testable, empirical, objective, factual evidence) that there is an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, a "repair", or even "...some patching" in the sampled area if the CIQ?

He's not even trying to hold-up his side of the argument any more. He'll follow any tangent to avoid dealing with that fact.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid.
It's about time you noticed.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
Well, only if you wanted to avoid actually providing evidence to support your position, and in so doing give the impression that you'd rather talk about anything except that rather embarrassing lack.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.

Shouldn't this become a discussion in a new thread?
 
BINGO!! Everybody has been telling you that.

Hey-don't all gang up on him with the same point! He can only address one question at a time (if it is not too long, is not the same question asked by more than one poster, and if it is asked in exactly the way he demands). You are being unfair, like a billiards game in which a person is asked to sink more than one ball... Uh like a baseball game in which the batter has to face an entire team of fielders... Uh.. well it is unfair anyway- it is UNFAIR! That is an interim conclusion that, although completely untrue and irrelephant, will eventually (around the heat death of the Universe) be used as an argument to support the obvious falsehood that the Shroud is a fake. Bye for now.
 
Evidence that the C14 dating is suspect is not evidence that the shroud is 2000 years old.

That's like saying that my birth certificate looks fake, therefore I was born in Kenya in 1066.

It is worse than that, I'm afraid. It is like saying that sure, your birth certificate looks convincing, but I really, really want you to have been born in Kenya in 1066. So let's take another, closer look at your birth certificate. Sure everything looks good, but isn't it possible that an invisible patch was used to place your footprint over that of the real owner? And isn't is possible that the date on it has been changed? Sure I don't see any evidence of such a thing but perhaps some nuns using special ink (that has been lost in history) altered the date in a near-invisible (i.e. invisible) way? The fact you can't see it is only proof that it is invisible. And you may argue that there were no hospital births in 1066, which is further reason to suspect your birth certificate is not authentic, because it does have claim that you were born in Our Lady of Mercy Hospital and we know that you were born in 1066.

Oh, and by the way: I am going to use this scientific evidence that you were born in Kenya in 1066 to convince myself of the accuracy of fables that some people live to be 2000 years old, because otherwise I might have some doubts.
 
Last edited:
Discussion Format

Dear Mr. Savage:

We had this very conversation, several different ways, in your "Immortality" thread.

Others, in this thread, have pointed out the paucity of your soi dissant "...way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions..." means that it is not, in fact, cannot be considered an evidence-driven approach.

I, personally, would prefer that you address my actual question:

What evidence do you have to present (actual, practical, non-magical, non-anecdotal, testable, empirical, objective, factual evidence) that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?

If you would rather, what evidence do you have to present (actual, practical, non-magical, non-anecdotal, testable, empirical, objective, factual evidence) that there is an "invisible" reweave, a "near-invisible" reweave, a "repair", or even "...some patching" in the sampled area if the CIQ?
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

Do you plan to start for the first time with your next post? No reason to dawdle you know.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.

He's not even trying to hold-up his side of the argument any more. He'll follow any tangent to avoid dealing with that fact.



Yes, even to the point of Jabba telling Slowvehicle, "you're wrong... but I don't really understand your objection." Effective DebateTM at its finest.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

You've had almost 4 years to do that and have utterly, abysmally failed.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?


To do that you would have to address Slowvehicle's request for "What evidence do you have to present (actual, practical, non-magical, non-anecdotal, testable, empirical, objective, factual evidence) that the CIQ is ~2000 years old?".

You can't have a preponderance of the evidence if you don't actually provide evidence.

Also, a minor point, but you seem to have the steps backwards. A 2000 year old age of the shroud supports (but does not prove) authenticity. There's no point in doing it the other way 'round. In fact, a 2000 year old age of the shroud is probably one of the best arguments toward authenticity and is also a requirement for authenticity, which is why everyone has asked for such evidence.
 
Slowvehicle,

- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.

- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...

- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.


To understand you may want to go back a few pages to where I posed you a question.

Imagine a world where no 14C dating had been performed on the shroud. Where nobody had ever looked closely at the cloth to discover the gesso or considered whether the red was anything other than blood. A world in which there had never been one single solitary piece of research conducted that suggested the shroud was a forgery.

Now I ask you, how, in this world I just described, can we know if the shroud is the genuine article?

What evidence do you have for a 1st century origin?

Forget the evidence for a medieval origin, it doesn't exist.

That's what you need to do. Because arguing against the evidence for a medieval origin doesn't actually help your cause one iota. Even if you could utterly destroy all of that evidence it would simply render the shroud's origin as unknown.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Try this.
- Do you accept that it is valid for me to try to show that the preponderance of evidence favors authenticity (and consequently, ~2000 yrs)?

Go ahead and try. However, if you could do that, you would not have asked the question.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom