Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slowvehicle,

- I'll look through this list more carefully and provide what I think is the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
- My immediate response, however, is that the real strength of this article is the amount of supportive non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

- Though, keep in mind that, in my opinion, these different arguments support the likelihood of a particular interim conclusion. I.e., they support the IC that the sample was not sufficiently representative of the greater shroud in order to provide a reliable dating.
- This would be just one small step towards an ultimate conclusion that the shroud is probably ~2000 years old.


This is one of the main leaps of logic that Jabba continually makes. Assuming his IC is true (that the sample was not representative of the remaining shroud) it does not put him one step closer to the shroud probably being ~2000 years old. It doesn't even say the shroud is probably not ~700 years old. All it says is that it can't tell us the age of the shroud. That's it.

Of course we've already been over the evidence that the sample was indeed representative of the rest of the shroud. Hypotheticals are interesting, but the actual evidence is even more so.
 
I thought we were done with IC’s and UC’s and scales and "small steps".

All Jabba-approved avenues have failed. It’s time to either admit your position is faith-based, or make with the evidence.

By the way: “Such and such a scientist believes such and such” is anecdotal at best. Only actual evidence must be presented at this point.
 
Slowvehicle,

- I'll look through this list more carefully and provide what I think is the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
- My immediate response, however, is that the real strength of this article is the amount of supportive non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

- Though, keep in mind that, in my opinion, these different arguments support the likelihood of a particular interim conclusion. I.e., they support the IC that the sample was not sufficiently representative of the greater shroud in order to provide a reliable dating.
- This would be just one small step towards an ultimate conclusion that the shroud is probably ~2000 years old.

No it is not. We've been through this again and again and again.

ETA: and again and again and again.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,

- I'll look through this list more carefully and provide what I think is the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
- My immediate response, however, is that the real strength of this article is the amount of supportive non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

- Though, keep in mind that, in my opinion, these different arguments support the likelihood of a particular interim conclusion. I.e., they support the IC that the sample was not sufficiently representative of the greater shroud in order to provide a reliable dating.
- This would be just one small step towards an ultimate conclusion that the shroud is probably ~2000 years old.

Mr. Savage:

Please be aware that, in this case, your opinion flies in the face of established ideas about knowledge.

it is not the case that a myriad of anecdotes that do not, any of them, even address the actual age of the CIQ (but instead, attempt to calumniate the 14C dating for no other reason that it returned the "wrong date"), DO NOT "sum up to" evidence that the CIQ is in fact, ~2000 years old; not do they "sum up to" evidence that there is an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible" reweave; any kind of "repair"; nor even "..."some patching" in the sampled corner of the CIQ.

It is up to you to provide actual, direct, empirical, testable, non-anecdotal, non-magical, objective evidence. Without special pleading.

I eagerly await your doing so, in a substantive and timely manner.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Mr. Savage:

It is up to you to provide actual, direct, empirical, testable, non-anecdotal, non-magical, objective evidence. Without special pleading.

I eagerly await your doing so, in a substantive and timely manner.

Bring it.

Jabba - FYI:

As far as I understand it, "Because I want it to be true" has never been part of the scientific method.
 
Slowvehicle,

- I'll look through this list more carefully and provide what I think is the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
Surely you should have done that BEFORE you posted that noxious pdf? Did you not?
- My immediate response, however, is that the real strength of this article is the amount of supportive non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
Except all of it has been debunked right here. Anomalous sample, invisible reweave, C-14 innacuraccy, the lot. You have yourself conceded these as invalid. Now, you simply seek a fringe reset for no reason other than to prolong your own rhetoric. Guess again, Jabba.


- Though, keep in mind that, in my opinion, these different arguments support the likelihood of a particular interim conclusion. I.e., they support the IC that the sample was not sufficiently representative of the greater shroud in order to provide a reliable dating.
Been there, done that, not doing it again.

I do not accept that you have simply forgotten what went before i this thread, it is my opinion that you are intentionally gaming at this point.

- This would be just one small step towards an ultimate conclusion that the shroud is probably ~2000 years old.
No. It wouldn't. The reasons that it would not have been explained to you. Ad nauseum. I reject outright the notion that you are "too stupid" or "too forgetful" to recognise the paucity of your arguments as presented. It can only be intentional duplicity.
 
Surely you should have done that BEFORE you posted that noxious pdf? Did you not?
Except all of it has been debunked right here. Anomalous sample, invisible reweave, C-14 innacuraccy, the lot. You have yourself conceded these as invalid. Now, you simply seek a fringe reset for no reason other than to prolong your own rhetoric. Guess again, Jabba.


Been there, done that, not doing it again.

I do not accept that you have simply forgotten what went before i this thread, it is my opinion that you are intentionally gaming at this point.

No. It wouldn't. The reasons that it would not have been explained to you. Ad nauseum. I reject outright the notion that you are "too stupid" or "too forgetful" to recognise the paucity of your arguments as presented. It can only be intentional duplicity.
If he stayed true to form, he just got the list from somewhere, counted all the entries, said "oooo that's a lot of words" and posted a link. I expect he now needs to read it and find out what argument he just made.
 
Evidence that the C14 dating is suspect is not evidence that the shroud is 2000 years old.

That's like saying that my birth certificate looks fake, therefore I was born in Kenya in 1066.
 
I suggest we wait for Jabba to actually provide evidence for any of these points. Assumptions and allegations are not good enough.

The C14 report, publishes in a highly respected, peer reviewed science magazine clearly specifies that the samples were taken in a position without any repairs. Three reputable laboratories put their names on this report.

Thus it is not enough that some people think there could be repairs. We need positive evidence that such repairs actually existed.

Hans
 
Person A: How old is that thing there? I'd guess it is 2000 years old.

Person B: I don't know. I'd guess it is 700 years old. Let's measure it to find out.

Person A: OK.

Person B: The measurement is done, it says the thing is about 700 years old.

Person A: Oh look, I think there was a mistake made during the measurement. ....That means the thing is 2000 years old! I was right!

Person B: ??
 
Slowvehicle,

- I'll look through this list more carefully and provide what I think is the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
- My immediate response, however, is that the real strength of this article is the amount of supportive non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

- Though, keep in mind that, in my opinion, these different arguments support the likelihood of a particular interim conclusion. I.e., they support the IC that the sample was not sufficiently representative of the greater shroud in order to provide a reliable dating.- This would be just one small step towards an ultimate conclusion that the shroud is probably ~2000 years old.


Jabba,
- You've been told this before, but it appears you need to be told it again: Stuff that is not evidence that the cloth is 2,000 years old is not evidence that the cloth is 2,000 years old, even if there's a lot of it.
 
If I had evidence that the CIQ was 2000 years old, I would present it right about now.

If I had no evidence that the CIQ was 2000 years old, I would not keep referring to pro-authenticity sites of dubious veracity. :-)
 
Last edited:
Person A: How old is that thing there? I'd guess it is 2000 years old.

Person B: I don't know. I'd guess it is 700 years old. Let's measure it to find out.

Person A: OK.

Person B: The measurement is done, it says the thing is about 700 years old.

Person A: Oh look, I think there was a mistake made during the measurement. ....That means the thing is 2000 years old! I was right!

Person B: ??

Or it is the burial shroud of Xenu and something like 66 million years old. Because "what it is not" opens a whole new universe of possibilities and belief is what staples the selection of choice.

Jabba won't convince me it isn't the shroud of Xenu, kept and transported from Turkey to Italy by the Etruscan. I think I have a map that proves it (about two hours, until it reaches the size of a hot air baloon).

I'll be back.
 
Discussion Format

Mr. Savage:

Please be aware that, in this case, your opinion flies in the face of established ideas about knowledge.
it is not the case that a myriad of anecdotes that do not, any of them, even address the actual age of the CIQ (but instead, attempt to calumniate the 14C dating for no other reason that it returned the "wrong date"), DO NOT "sum up to" evidence that the CIQ is in fact, ~2000 years old; not do they "sum up to" evidence that there is an "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible" reweave; any kind of "repair"; nor even "..."some patching" in the sampled corner of the CIQ.

It is up to you to provide actual, direct, empirical, testable, non-anecdotal, non-magical, objective evidence. Without special pleading.

I eagerly await your doing so, in a substantive and timely manner.

Bring it.
Slowvehicle,
- Here, you're telling me that my way of arriving at probabilistic conclusions is not valid. Obviously, I think you're wrong.
- Consequently, the natural -- and probably, appropriate -- first step in response to your post is to effectively explain why I think you're wrong...
- But since I don't really understand your objection -- why you should think that what I was doing is illogical -- this may take awhile.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom