Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
I just skimmed it so far. I see lot of support for Rogers and lots and frequent uses of the word possible. Didn't notice too much from people working in disciplines relevant to the subject. There's one bit in there about an ionizing radiation impact the C14 decay or something; that was kind of funny.
 
I just skimmed it so far. I see lot of support for Rogers and lots and frequent uses of the word possible. Didn't notice too much from people working in disciplines relevant to the subject. There's one bit in there about an ionizing radiation impact the C14 decay or something; that was kind of funny.

Ah yes. The Holy Nuclear Reaction inside the crucified body of Christ. It forms the image, and skews the 14C results. There's certainly plenty of evidence for that kind of shenanigans. NOT!
 
Ah yes. The Holy Nuclear Reaction inside the crucified body of Christ. It forms the image, and skews the 14C results. There's certainly plenty of evidence for that kind of shenanigans. NOT!

It looks pretty much like believers preaching to the choir and smells of desperation.
 
Slowvehicle,
- This looks like a good place to start.
- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I have read the .pdf at the link.

Which one of the arguments raised is, in your opinion, the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

Be specific, if you would be so kind.

I anticipate your on-point response.

Bring it.
 
It looks pretty much like believers preaching to the choir and smells of desperation.

And is sounds vaguely... familiar. As is we have heard these arguments many before and they have been debunked many times.

But then again- there is no evidence presented that the Shroud is 2000 years old even among these debunked arguments. So it really doesn't matter. But perhaps I am wrong, so I await Jabba's reply to Slowvehicle's question as to which arguments Jabba sees as evidence of the authenticity age of the Shroud.
 
Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I have read the .pdf at the link.

Which one of the arguments raised is, in your opinion, the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

Be specific, if you would be so kind.

I anticipate your on-point response.

Bring it.

Prediction: There are too many word-thingies in the above to elicit a response.
 
And is sounds vaguely... familiar. As is we have heard these arguments many before and they have been debunked many times.

But then again- there is no evidence presented that the Shroud is 2000 years old even among these debunked arguments. So it really doesn't matter. But perhaps I am wrong, so I await Jabba's reply to Slowvehicle's question as to which arguments Jabba sees as evidence of the authenticity age of the Shroud.

Well that is the big problem; it's all about the C14 and nothing dating the Shroud. With the fawning over Rogers I suspect they would hang their hat on the unsupported vanillian test.

Once again, Jabba focuses on the irrelephant in the room.
 
Well that is the big problem; it's all about the C14 and nothing dating the Shroud. With the fawning over Rogers I suspect they would hang their hat on the unsupported vanillian test.

Once again, Jabba focuses on the irrelephant in the room.

ill-elephant?
 
Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I have read the .pdf at the link.

Which one of the arguments raised is, in your opinion, the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

Be specific, if you would be so kind.

I anticipate your on-point response.

Bring it.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I have read the .pdf to which you linked yet a second time.

Be so kind as to explain which of the points raised in the .pdf constitutes, in your opinion, practical, physical, objective, non-anecdotal, non-magical evidence for any kind of "reweaving", "repair", or "some patching" to the sampled corner of the CIQ.

I eagerly anticipate your substantive response.

Bring it.
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

I have read the .pdf at the link.

Which one of the arguments raised is, in your opinion, the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old?

Be specific, if you would be so kind.

I anticipate your on-point response.

Bring it.
Slowvehicle,

- I'll look through this list more carefully and provide what I think is the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
- My immediate response, however, is that the real strength of this article is the amount of supportive non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

- Though, keep in mind that, in my opinion, these different arguments support the likelihood of a particular interim conclusion. I.e., they support the IC that the sample was not sufficiently representative of the greater shroud in order to provide a reliable dating.
- This would be just one small step towards an ultimate conclusion that the shroud is probably ~2000 years old.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,

- I'll look through this list more carefully and provide what I think is the best piece of non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.
- My immediate response, however, is that the real strength of this article is the amount of supportive non-anecdotal, non-specially-pled, practical, testable, empirical, objective evidence that the linen of the CIQ is, in fact, ~2000 years old.

- Though, keep in mind that, in my opinion, these different arguments support the likelihood of a particular interim conclusion. I.e., they support the IC that the sample was not sufficiently representative of the greater shroud in order to provide a reliable dating.
- This would be just one small step towards an ultimate conclusion that the shroud is probably ~2000 years old.

So, no evidence at all for a 2000 year old cloth. Please try harder.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom