Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carbon Dating Doubts/Re-weave/Banding

Dear Mr. Savage:

Suppose you address any one of the actual issues in the paper written by BG&S, without taking any more time to smear Nickell, who did not do the research nor write the paper.

Bring it.
Slowvehicle,
- OK. I'll be back.
 
- First, I suggested that there are reasons for not putting much faith in the Nickell article, and I told you that was just my beginning reaction to your request.
Which in no-way supports the "reweave hypothesis"; it's just more of you slander and well poisoning.
- Then, I presented extended debates showing how many reservations (from people who are well-read and knowledgable re shroud research)
People who've admitted to not reading the paper?
:rolleyes:
there have been to Bella, et al's paper. IOW, we shouldn't conclude that the non-representative, re-weave claim is closed.-- as Nickell and Bella argue.
Yes we should. There is no evidence for your desperate "reweave hypothesis" nonsense.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…
Stop wasting people's time with your pathetic attempts at diverting attention; present your evidence for the shroud's origin.
 
Slowvehicle,
- OK. I'll be back.

Wait, why do you need to come back? You've been pushing this reweave idea for a few days. Saying you will comeback is another way of saying, "I'm pushing this idea but I don't know why". If you had actually read the paper and had an argument for your reweave you'd just be able to present it.

Jabba, it's time you started preparing yourself for the unavoidable conclusion that there is no evidence for you cloth having been used for a burial shroud in the first century. You have provided no positive evidence for your beliefs. You throw stones at contradictory evidence and those who present it but that is not the same as evidence. This thread has gone on for years and you still can't support your beliefs.
 
I'm curious Mr. Jabba.
If somehow it could be proven (in a way that you could accept) that the shroud was not the real burial wrapping of Jesus, what would that mean to you?
Would you stop being a Christian?
 
I'm curious Mr. Jabba.
If somehow it could be proven (in a way that you could accept) that the shroud was not the real burial wrapping of Jesus, what would that mean to you?
Would you stop being a Christian?


IIRC Jabba claims that he is not a Christian, but would like to be and therefore wants the shroud to be authentic.

ETA: found it:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8215480#post8215480

Jabba said:
- I'm not a Christian, but I am a wannabe Christian, and would like to "believe in" Jesus. If I were convinced that the Shroud is authentic, I might be able to make the necessary "leap of faith."
 
Last edited:
Carbon Dating Doubts/Re-weave/Banding

Slowvehicle,
- OK. I'll be back.
- Previously, I hadn't noticed the date when the Bella et al paper would no longer be available for free. If someone has a copy, and it's legal to give me a copy, I'd be eternally grateful...
 
I posted this over three years ago!
As I see it, and I haven't gone back to count, a vast majority of your posts have been numbered and bulleted attempts to define what you should answer, what the subject should be, and who should be the one true voice to tell you what questions to respond to.

All I can compare it to is North Korean, South Korean, US, Chinese, and UN delegates to peace talks arguing about what chairs should be used at the table, then pretending incredible progress was made when the decision made was to continue chair negotiations during the next session. __________________
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=8585758#post8585758
 
- Previously, I hadn't noticed the date when the Bella et al paper would no longer be available for free. If someone has a copy, and it's legal to give me a copy, I'd be eternally grateful...


Bravely bold Sir Robin ran away.
 
- Previously, I hadn't noticed the date when the Bella et al paper would no longer be available for free. If someone has a copy, and it's legal to give me a copy, I'd be eternally grateful...

Why? Is your faith not worth 40 bucks? 30 pieces of silver perhaps?
 
- Previously, I hadn't noticed the date when the Bella et al paper would no longer be available for free. If someone has a copy, and it's legal to give me a copy, I'd be eternally grateful...


I think that you're years past the point of expecting people to help you with your homework. You should have read it before commenting on it. If I had a dozen public-domain copies, I wouldn't waste my time sending you one because I don't believe you would even read it.

Even if you did read it, and had a non-authenticity epiphany, you'd forget it as soon as your next fringe reset came along next week.
 
- Previously, I hadn't noticed the date when the Bella et al paper would no longer be available for free. If someone has a copy, and it's legal to give me a copy, I'd be eternally grateful...

WHAT!!?? You dismissed the paper and had not read it? This is the definition of intellectual dishonesty. Disgusting.
 
in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time.
Wait a moment... If we're supposed to go along with this idea of one person to a side, why should we be stuck with you?

There are far, far better opponents out there. Opponents who actually do their research and keep track of their evidence. Opponents who can make and respond to multiple 'sub-issues' in a single pass. Opponents whose body of work is almost entirely their arguments, in depth and in detail, and includes little to no promises to come back and make their argument some other time. Opponents who, apart from their desire to prove the authenticity of the shroud, are your opposite in every way that matters in this debate.

Why should we choose you as the representative of your 'side'? Indeed, I don't think we have chosen you. I think you have gravely misunderstood what role you play in these threads.
 
Wait a moment... If we're supposed to go along with this idea of one person to a side, why should we be stuck with you?

There are far, far better opponents out there. Opponents who actually do their research and keep track of their evidence. Opponents who can make and respond to multiple 'sub-issues' in a single pass. Opponents whose body of work is almost entirely their arguments, in depth and in detail, and includes little to no promises to come back and make their argument some other time. Opponents who, apart from their desire to prove the authenticity of the shroud, are your opposite in every way that matters in this debate.

Why should we choose you as the representative of your 'side'? Indeed, I don't think we have chosen you. I think you have gravely misunderstood what role you play in these threads.


Interesting point. Jabba didn't even start this series of shroud threads. IIRC, his first contribution was his complaining that he was slow, and that we should go easy on him and allow him to catch up. I also seem to recall him asking us to help him with his homework.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom