Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- But, Nickell did fill his own article with opinion and slant.

If the Skeptical Inquirer article was the sole source of that information then you'd have a point BUT it's based on a paper published in a peer reviewed journal.
 
- But, Nickell did fill his own article with opinion and slant.

Good morning, Mr. Savage:

Why is it that you are focusing on the messenger, rather than the message?

Instead of calumniating Nickell, I challenge you to respond the the actual work done by Marco Bella, Luigi Garlaschelli, and Roberto Samperi.

Bring it.
 
Dear Dan Porter,

Look, I have made the thread over at the ISF a bit longer and I only posted a few words with no real substance. I am doing Jebus' work

Yours

etc
 
I've heard of the logical fallacy of "poisoning the well" but this is "poisoning someone else's well to discredit evidence from a different well."

The idea appears to be to try discredit a scientific finding that is presented in a closely studied and peer-reviewed scientific journal by trying to discredit not the finding, but (in a defamatory and unjust way) a reporter who only cited that finding at a news website. A very disgusting and fallacious argument, but fits in with the general "logic" of the posts that Jabba has presented here.
 
I've heard of the logical fallacy of "poisoning the well" but this is "poisoning someone else's well to discredit evidence from a different well."

The idea appears to be to try discredit a scientific finding that is presented in a closely studied and peer-reviewed scientific journal by trying to discredit not the finding, but (in a defamatory and unjust way) a reporter who only cited that finding at a news website. A very disgusting and fallacious argument, but fits in with the general "logic" of the posts that Jabba has presented here.

Well, you know, Walter "was hard to work with"...
 
Well, you know, Walter "was hard to work with"...
Yeah, of course "You can't believe a thing he says."

In science I've actually found that the people who are difficult to work with are often the most demanding in terms of the accuracy and precision of their own work. They are difficult to work with because they have high standards and demand that those around them have the same high standards. The people to be more concerned about: the scientists who are easy going both in their personal interactions and in how they approach scientific evidence.
 
Last edited:
Carbon Dating Doubts/Re-weave/Banding

Monza,
- There are lots of arguments against the professionalism of that paper/editorial. See
http://shroudstory.com/2015/09/04/e...-and-samperi-on-rogers-2005-article/#comments.

Which ones do you find particularly effective?

I was wondering the same thing. The first two comments start with "I haven’t read this paper yet" and "I’m not a chemist", but he apparently finds this compelling.
Monza,

- You had asked me to provide some evidence supportive of the reweave hypothesis, in light of the Nickell article.
- First, I suggested that there are reasons for not putting much faith in the Nickell article, and I told you that was just my beginning reaction to your request.
- Then, I presented extended debates showing how many reservations (from people who are well-read and knowledgable re shroud research) there have been to Bella, et al's paper. IOW, we shouldn't conclude that the non-representative, re-weave claim is closed.-- as Nickell and Bella argue.
 
Last edited:
Monza,

- You had asked me to provide some evidence supportive of the reweave hypothesis, in light of the Nickell article.
- First, I suggested that there are reasons for not putting much faith in the Nickell article, and I told you that was just my beginning reaction to your request.
- Then, I presented extended debates showing how many reservations (from people who are well-read and knowledgable re shroud research) there have been to Bella, et al's paper. IOW, we shouldn't conclude that the non-representative, re-weave claim is closed.-- as Nickell and Bella argue.

People who admittedly haven't read the relevant papers are well-read and knowledgeable?

The re-weave issue IS closed. You just won't accept that fact.
 
Monza,

- You had asked me to provide some evidence supportive of the reweave hypothesis, in light of the Nickell article.
- First, I suggested that there are reasons for not putting much faith in the Nickell article, and I told you that was just my beginning reaction to your request.
- Then, I presented extended debates showing how many reservations (from people who are well-read and knowledgable re shroud research) there have been to Bella, et al's paper. IOW, we shouldn't conclude that the non-representative, re-weave claim is closed.-- as Nickell and Bella argue.

Perhaps this would be convincing if you would provide some evidence for the presence of a reweave.
 
Monza,

- You had asked me to provide some evidence supportive of the reweave hypothesis, in light of the Nickell article.
- First, I suggested that there are reasons for not putting much faith in the Nickell article, and I told you that was just my beginning reaction to your request.
- Then, I presented extended debates showing how many reservations (from people who are well-read and knowledgable re shroud research) there have been to Bella, et al's paper. IOW, we shouldn't conclude that the non-representative, re-weave claim is closed.-- as Nickell and Bella argue.

Dear Mr. Savage:

In your ongoing attempts to dismiss the work of Bella, Garlaschelli, & Samperi (hereafter BG&S) on the grounds that you do not like Nickell's personality, or that you do not like BG&S's results, what you have failed to do is provide the least scintilla of factual evidence as to why their work can be ignored.

BG&S's work supports McCrone's findings; Mme. F-L's findings, the 14C dating, and the historical record. What factual counter-evidence do you offer?

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Monza,

- You had asked me to provide some evidence supportive of the reweave hypothesis, in light of the Nickell article.
- First, I suggested that there are reasons for not putting much faith in the Nickell article, and I told you that was just my beginning reaction to your request.
- Then, I presented extended debates showing how many reservations (from people who are well-read and knowledgable re shroud research) there have been to Bella, et al's paper. IOW, we shouldn't conclude that the non-representative, re-weave claim is closed.-- as Nickell and Bella argue.


What you are saying here is that Monza asked you to provide some evidence supportive of the reweave hypothesis, and first you didn't, and then you didn't.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom