Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Once again the discussion goes like this:

Q: What's the evidence that the sample taken for carbon dating was a patch?

A: Criticism of a paper claiming there was no patch.

Which is very similar to:

Q: What's the evidence there is blood on the cloth?

A: Criticism of work showing there was no blood on the cloth.
 
- But, Nickell did fill his own article with opinion and slant.

And that's evidence for a re-weave how, exactly, even if he had?
Monza,
- For this response, I'll have to focus on #2 -- and probably, it will be just the beginning of an answer.
- Over the years, I've provided various bits of what I consider to be evidence. The side you have offered to represent just doesn't think much of what I've provided. The Rogers' article is an example. If you wish, my next focus will be on digging up what evidence I can re-find.
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.

Are you familiar with the term ad hominem? Oddly enough, what you seem to think are negative points I think are positive. Then again, I've actually met him which might mean I'm biased.
 
Monza,
- For this response, I'll have to focus on #2 -- and probably, it will be just the beginning of an answer.
- Over the years, I've provided various bits of what I consider to be evidence. The side you have offered to represent just doesn't think much of what I've provided. The Rogers' article is an example. If you wish, my next focus will be on digging up what evidence I can re-find.
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.

Hey Jabba,

I'm curious - in what discipline is your Phd?
 
Yeah, of course "You can't believe a thing he says."

In science I've actually found that the people who are difficult to work with are often the most demanding in terms of the accuracy and precision of their own work. They are difficult to work with because they have high standards and demand that those around them have the same high standards. The people to be more concerned about: the scientists who are easy going both in their personal interactions and in how they approach scientific evidence.


I was thinking the same thing. If I had to ignore the results from people who were difficult to work with in my field (engineering) then there would be precious little left over. I can think of a couple very difficult and demanding engineers, but the quality of their work was absolutely top notch. Not a coincidence in my experience.
 
Discussion Format

- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.

Why is it, then, that you routinely ignore my posts?

Dear Mr. Savage:

Bring it.

Suppose you address the findings of Marco Bella, Luigi Garlaschelli, and Roberto Samperi?
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

Nonsense. All you need to do is produce some evidence. However, as both you and we know, you have none, while there is plenty of evidence for the age of the cloth which makes it more than a millennium too young to be what you think it is.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

Your fantasies about the magic shroud have brimmed over and now you are in a self-exalted mode. All of it, nonsense from a logical point of view. It's just the arbitrariness of your faith that makes you have a god for certain and you a winner here as if you had ever debated instead of dodging.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

He did, in the very post you quoted. Does this look familiar?
Suppose you address the findings of Marco Bella, Luigi Garlaschelli, and Roberto Samperi?
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

- Just because you said something, that doesn't make it true. Your record for veracity is not inspiring, to put it gently.

- You don't have to 'fight' anybody here. A logical discussion would be plenty. It would be a refreshing change too!

- Don't make promises that everybody here knows you won't keep.



ETA:
- Anyone who slanders the honesty and competence of an entire class of experts (14C scientists), and slurs other experts by name (McCrone) with no evidence, has no room to complain about not getting a 'fair fight'.

You've got a lot of temerity.
 
Last edited:
- Just because you said something, that doesn't make it true. Your record for veracity is not inspiring, to put it gently.

- You don't have to 'fight' anybody here. A logical discussion would be plenty. It would be a refreshing change too!

- Don't make promises that everybody here knows you won't keep.



ETA:
- Anyone who slanders the honesty and competence of an entire class of experts (14C scientists), and slurs other experts by name (McCrone) with no evidence, has no room to complain about not getting a 'fair fight'.

You've got a lot of temerity.

It is indeed amazing that the word "fair" could be used given the strategies and styles of the posts originating from Jabba. Has anyone else noticed what I see as a further tendency in Jabba's posts to outright besmirch the anti-authenticity experts? "If you have the facts on your side than pound on the facts, if you have the law pound on the law, if you have only the table pound on the table. If you have nothing, pound on the personal reputations of the experts." I understand that some of the 14C experts probably had sex before they got married- why is Jabba ignoring this key point that calls into doubt all of their work?
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

Dear Mr. Savage:

Suppose you address any one of the actual issues in the paper written by BG&S, without taking any more time to smear Nickell, who did not do the research nor write the paper.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.


If we must use this metaphor: you haven't been fighting anyone; you have just been telling people you are going to fight them, then running away.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

As far as I can tell, no one here is trying to give you a fair fight. That's not really how science works. You need to present your evidence and arguments and then they get ripped apart. You're the one making an assertion, you need to defend it.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

You've been Mr Magoo fighting Mohammed Ali. It's just bullying at this stage.
 
If we must use this metaphor: you haven't been fighting anyone; you have just been telling people you are going to fight them, then running away.

We've basically spent the last near 4 years still at the "Pre-fight weight in trash talking" stage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom