Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- Previously, I hadn't noticed the date when the Bella et al paper would no longer be available for free. If someone has a copy, and it's legal to give me a copy, I'd be eternally grateful...

Too bad. Why don't you just pick another subject, then?

Hans
 
There's a more significant date you seem to have missed: 1260-1390 CE, with 95% confidence.
Pardon to Dumb and Dumber:

Lloyd Christmas: What do you think the chances are of a guy like you and a girl like me... ending up together?
Mary Swanson: Well, Lloyd, that's difficult to say. I mean, we don't really...
Lloyd Christmas: Hit me with it! Just give it to me straight! I came a long way just to see you, Mary. The least you can do is level with me. What are my chances?
Mary Swanson: Not good.
Lloyd Christmas: You mean, not good like one out of a hundred?
Mary Swanson: I'd say more like one out of a million.
[pause]
Lloyd Christmas: So you're telling me there's a chance... YEAH!
 
It is difficult to have a "fair" debate when one side has all the evidence and the other side has none, has not even read the evidence-less arguments for authenticity, and indeed doesn't remember what those pro- (and anti)-authenticity arguments might have been. "Fair" presumably would mean discarding all the anti-authenticity evidence and require both "sides" (sides imply opponents, which I reject) to base their arguments on feelings, undocumented rumors, unsupported conjectures, and innuendos, which indeed Jabba has proposed more than once without any success.

I would also add that "fair" does not involve ignoring entire posters and their arguments when they bring up valid points for which there is no counter-argument. "Fair" does not include requiring that a personally-generated debate format be followed, let alone deep-sixing the format within days of having the request actually granted.

One might even question whether this is a debate at all.
 
A pause to reflect

I once read a passage in a novel (by Evelyn Waugh? can’t remember) in which a pious old lady is broken in heart and spirit by hearing a very modern sermon by a very modern clergyman, in which he discusses the Christ myth and its historical improbability; we aren’t given the text, but apparently it’s an effective set of arguments. After the service, in the porch of the church, she cries out, weeping, “He has taken my Lord Jesus!” and is inconsolable at the loss of her faith; now, near the end of her life, she’s been plundered of her only hope, her only consolation on the brink of the final gulf.

Well, it’s just a satire (on the Church of England! jeeze, who’d bother?) , and a fiction, but it made me think about discussions we’re had here and on the old forum, in which the consensus seemed to be that the only good use for religion is to comfort the dying.

Sometimes people lose their faith; they fail at last to scale the Himalaya of evidence against their beliefs. Or, to change the metaphor, they try one more time to refresh themselves with a draft of doctrine, and suddenly, at last, they see that the chalice is empty, dry, and rusted out.

For some people, most people I suspect, the loss of faith is experienced as a liberation. Some of our fellow-posters here have described it that way. But not everybody is like that; the fictional old lady sobbing at the loss of her Lord Jesus has real-life exemplars. After all, religion is a matter not of reason, but of feeling; in fact, it’s entirely feeling and emotion, experienced far outside and beneath the life of rationality; and it’s powerful!

So: Suppose some poor aged man clinging to a religious security blanket finally lost his grip on it; suppose that some of us were responsible for loosening his ill-coordinated old fingers. Then we might well be confronted with a weeping elderly person crying out – and from the edge of that final gulf – that we have taken away his lord, his sure and certain hope. Would that be a gratifying sight?

Of course, we don’t choose our chew-toys here on the forum: they damn well come rolling in and volunteer, and they get what they’ve bought and paid for. But let’s reflect on the possible consequences of our long-continued (and somewhat bullying) opposition. There might be times when it’s better just to give over and let them patter their nonsense into a compassionate silence.
 
Interesting point. Jabba didn't even start this series of shroud threads. IIRC, his first contribution was his complaining that he was slow, and that we should go easy on him and allow him to catch up. I also seem to recall him asking us to help him with his homework.

Poster "X" started this series. From the first shroud thread, Jabba's first post was post 17 on 06 March 2012:

- Have any of you guys studied the alleged evidence?

Subsequent posts (the start of this mess) can be found at:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=226761

Just posting here for newer participants to easily find the start of this.
 
[...]

Of course, we don’t choose our chew-toys here on the forum: they damn well come rolling in and volunteer, and they get what they’ve bought and paid for. But let’s reflect on the possible consequences of our long-continued (and somewhat bullying) opposition. There might be times when it’s better just to give over and let them patter their nonsense into a compassionate silence.

Has there ever been a time when Jabba was not given opportunity to patter his nonsense?

Maybe you weren't here, but he once claimed victory precisely because everyone was ignoring him. He even pretended to the JREF challenge on that account.
 
Has there ever been a time when Jabba was not given opportunity to patter his nonsense?

Maybe you weren't here, but he once claimed victory precisely because everyone was ignoring him. He even pretended to the JREF challenge on that account.

A funny thing that, Jabba's "victories". Perhaps you would like to explain, Jabba?

Suppose you had only one opponent, and that one opponent was a less experienced debater than most of us here. - Maybe you could actually "win" the debate, that is, you might push your opponent into a corner where he or she could not find a way to counter you.

... But so what? Do you imagine that the shroud of Turin would get any more (or less) authentic from that?

The binary option here is that the shroud is either the real burial shroud of Jesus Christ, or it is something else. Whatever we say or do, the real fact is that it is one of these two. All a sensible debate can achieve is to lay out the evidence for each option. The existing evidence, mind you. If we should then find that it hangs in the balance, that it could go either way, one can work towards further research, or simply take a personal stand.

None of it would, however, change facts.

At it stands, the situation is that there is heavy objective evidence pointing to the shroud being a 14th century artefact, and none that could only be explained by it being authentic.

In fact there is no evidence supporting a sufficient age. There isn't even any evidence that is a burial shroud at all, of anybody.

So, Jabba, what is the kind of victory you are seeking, by trying to impose certain debate rules, etc?

Hans
 
- Previously, I hadn't noticed the date when the Bella et al paper would no longer be available for free. If someone has a copy, and it's legal to give me a copy, I'd be eternally grateful...

:idea:

Ahh, perhaps you are looking for an emergency exit? "Unfortunately, my evidence is behind a paywall, I am poor man so I can't pay for it, and my opponents won't help me out, so I can't continue. :v:"

Fine! By all means, be my guest. Your evil opponent (in this case me) will not pay for your research. - Sooo sorry. :cool:


Hans
 
Monza,

- You had asked me to provide some evidence supportive of the reweave hypothesis, in light of the Nickell article.
- First, I suggested that there are reasons for not putting much faith in the Nickell article, and I told you that was just my beginning reaction to your request.
- Then, I presented extended debates showing how many reservations (from people who are well-read and knowledgable re shroud research) there have been to Bella, et al's paper. IOW, we shouldn't conclude that the non-representative, re-weave claim is closed.-- as Nickell and Bella argue.

In other words you did not answer the request.

As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time.

More lies. Besides, it's not a fair fight even when you have no one to debate. You defeat yourself.

You should really stop making excuses for your failures. You're not a child anymore.
 
Jabba, you need to consider that the real reason you aren't doing well in this debate is because you don't have an argument. This is a side effect of trying to make the Shroud something it's not.
 
I once read a passage in a novel (by Evelyn Waugh? can’t remember) in which a pious old lady is broken in heart and spirit by hearing a very modern sermon by a very modern clergyman, in which he discusses the Christ myth and its historical improbability; we aren’t given the text, but apparently it’s an effective set of arguments. After the service, in the porch of the church, she cries out, weeping, “He has taken my Lord Jesus!” and is inconsolable at the loss of her faith; now, near the end of her life, she’s been plundered of her only hope, her only consolation on the brink of the final gulf.

Well, it’s just a satire (on the Church of England! jeeze, who’d bother?) , and a fiction, but it made me think about discussions we’re had here and on the old forum, in which the consensus seemed to be that the only good use for religion is to comfort the dying.

Sometimes people lose their faith; they fail at last to scale the Himalaya of evidence against their beliefs. Or, to change the metaphor, they try one more time to refresh themselves with a draft of doctrine, and suddenly, at last, they see that the chalice is empty, dry, and rusted out.

For some people, most people I suspect, the loss of faith is experienced as a liberation. Some of our fellow-posters here have described it that way. But not everybody is like that; the fictional old lady sobbing at the loss of her Lord Jesus has real-life exemplars. After all, religion is a matter not of reason, but of feeling; in fact, it’s entirely feeling and emotion, experienced far outside and beneath the life of rationality; and it’s powerful!

So: Suppose some poor aged man clinging to a religious security blanket finally lost his grip on it; suppose that some of us were responsible for loosening his ill-coordinated old fingers. Then we might well be confronted with a weeping elderly person crying out – and from the edge of that final gulf – that we have taken away his lord, his sure and certain hope. Would that be a gratifying sight?

Of course, we don’t choose our chew-toys here on the forum: they damn well come rolling in and volunteer, and they get what they’ve bought and paid for. But let’s reflect on the possible consequences of our long-continued (and somewhat bullying) opposition. There might be times when it’s better just to give over and let them patter their nonsense into a compassionate silence.

I've had many of the thoughts you've expressed and considered the issues raised. But I concluded that many people here has have proposed multiple times that one's continued belief based on faith would be fine and would end the discussion. But if one insists on bringing in scientific arguments to booster that faith, then it is legitimate, indeed necessary, to discuss the scientific validity of those arguments,

This presumes of course that the persona of the Internet poster reflects their real life situation.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As I said, in order to have a fair ‘fight,’ I shouldn’t have to fight more than one opponent at a time. I’ve been fighting Monza.
- I would like to ‘take you on,’ but if you pose more than one Q/C at a time, I’ll only address the first one. Give me your best shot…

Dear Mr. Savage:

Suppose you address any one of the actual issues in the paper written by BG&S, without taking any more time to smear Nickell, who did not do the research nor write the paper.

Bring it.

Slowvehicle,
- OK. I'll be back.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

The above exchange happened three days ago. Have you any progress to report?

I understand that you are having problems finding an actual copy of the BG&S paper. Feel free to respond the the abstract. Failing that, feel free to propose a different issue to pursue.

I am eager to read your substantive response.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

The above exchange happened three days ago. Have you any progress to report?

I understand that you are having problems finding an actual copy of the BG&S paper. Feel free to respond the the abstract. Failing that, feel free to propose a different issue to pursue.

I am eager to read your substantive response.

Bring it.
Slowvehicle,
- Thanks for asking, and for offering alternatives.
- I've been studying the 134 comments on the Porter blog. This serves to emphasize the tediousness of my proposal...
- One question from the abstract.
- I 'trip over' the use of the term "pseudoscience" in the abstract. Is that appropriate usage for a peer-reviewed, scientific journal?
If my question doesn't communicate, I'll try to explain.
 
Slowvehicle,
- Thanks for asking, and for offering alternatives.
- I've been studying the 134 comments on the Porter blog. This serves to emphasize the tediousness of my proposal...
Or you could, you know, actually look for evidence.
- One question from the abstract.
- I 'trip over' the use of the term "pseudoscience" in the abstract. Is that appropriate usage for a peer-reviewed, scientific journal?
I guess it depends whether what they're talking about is pseudoscience or not. What's the context?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom