I once read a passage in a novel (by Evelyn Waugh? can’t remember) in which a pious old lady is broken in heart and spirit by hearing a very modern sermon by a very modern clergyman, in which he discusses the Christ myth and its historical improbability; we aren’t given the text, but apparently it’s an effective set of arguments. After the service, in the porch of the church, she cries out, weeping, “He has taken my Lord Jesus!” and is inconsolable at the loss of her faith; now, near the end of her life, she’s been plundered of her only hope, her only consolation on the brink of the final gulf.
Well, it’s just a satire (on the Church of England! jeeze, who’d bother?) , and a fiction, but it made me think about discussions we’re had here and on the old forum, in which the consensus seemed to be that the only good use for religion is to comfort the dying.
Sometimes people lose their faith; they fail at last to scale the Himalaya of evidence against their beliefs. Or, to change the metaphor, they try one more time to refresh themselves with a draft of doctrine, and suddenly, at last, they see that the chalice is empty, dry, and rusted out.
For some people, most people I suspect, the loss of faith is experienced as a liberation. Some of our fellow-posters here have described it that way. But not everybody is like that; the fictional old lady sobbing at the loss of her Lord Jesus has real-life exemplars. After all, religion is a matter not of reason, but of feeling; in fact, it’s entirely feeling and emotion, experienced far outside and beneath the life of rationality; and it’s powerful!
So: Suppose some poor aged man clinging to a religious security blanket finally lost his grip on it; suppose that some of us were responsible for loosening his ill-coordinated old fingers. Then we might well be confronted with a weeping elderly person crying out – and from the edge of that final gulf – that we have taken away his lord, his sure and certain hope. Would that be a gratifying sight?
Of course, we don’t choose our chew-toys here on the forum: they damn well come rolling in and volunteer, and they get what they’ve bought and paid for. But let’s reflect on the possible consequences of our long-continued (and somewhat bullying) opposition. There might be times when it’s better just to give over and let them patter their nonsense into a compassionate silence.