Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Slowvehicle,
- Thanks for asking, and for offering alternatives.
- I've been studying the 134 comments on the Porter blog. This serves to emphasize the tediousness of my proposal...
- One question from the abstract.
- I 'trip over' the use of the term "pseudoscience" in the abstract. Is that appropriate usage for a peer-reviewed, scientific journal?
If my question doesn't communicate, I'll try to explain.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

Given that "A pseudoscience is a set of ideas that presents itself as science, while it does not meet the criteria to properly be called such..."; and,

Given that there is no evidence, none, of any kind of "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching" in the sampled corner of the CIQ; and,

Given that the sampled area was chosen with much care; and,

Given that no one who has actually handled the CIQ has demonstrated the existence of any kind of "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching" anywhere on the CIQ; and, further,

Given that the very nature of the kind of reweaving you presented depends upon it being done with actual threads of the rest of the cloth (meaning that it could not change the 14C dating of the sample);

Then, yes, calling the (totally unsupported) claim that there must be some sort of "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching"; based on nothing more than special pleading, that is, the conviction that the 14 C dating produced the "wrong date", may be harsh, but it is neither inappropriate nor inaccurate.

It is certainly less offensive than unsupported allegations of incompetence, collusion, or outright fraud.

Unless the comments through which you are wading were written by scientists, with actual evidence that would refute BG&S's conclusion, you might have better ways to spend your time.

What evidence have you to offer, that the "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching" exists, other than special pleading?

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
I'm missing how obsessing on meaningless side issues is in anyway effective debate.

2hFtXLh.jpg
 
- I 'trip over' the use of the term "pseudoscience" in the abstract. Is that appropriate usage for a peer-reviewed, scientific journal?

Well let's look at the word in the context of the editorial in which it appeared:

In conclusion, the unspecific qualitative chemical tests presented by Rogers are in no way confirmed by instrumental analysis (mass spectrometry). No diagnostic peak in the pyrolysis mass spectra indicates a significant difference in the two samples, besides hydrocarbon-derived contamination. Therefore, none of the presented data supports the conclusion by Rogers.

The work of the late Dr. Rogers has been exploited to support a pseudoscientific hypothesis which is in no way confirmed by the reported data. Regardless of the debate on the hypothetical authenticity of the Shroud, the scientific community and the general public can only be misled by this paper.

Link: http://shroudstory.com/2015/09/04/e...laschelli-and-samperi-on-rogers-2005-article/

Given the context then yes, the hypothesis was pseudoscientific because it tried to pass itself off as scientific whilst lacking the required rigour.


Then again it's absent from the abstract:

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0040603115003093
 
Slowvehicle,
- Thanks for asking, and for offering alternatives.
- I've been studying the 134 comments on the Porter blog. This serves to emphasize the tediousness of my proposal...
- One question from the abstract.
- I 'trip over' the use of the term "pseudoscience" in the abstract. Is that appropriate usage for a peer-reviewed, scientific journal?

Why would it not be? It is a legitimate word in the English language. If context is important, then provide some.
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"/Bella's Paper

Slowvehicle,
- Thanks for asking, and for offering alternatives.
- I've been studying the 134 comments on the Porter blog. This serves to emphasize the tediousness of my proposal...
- One question from the abstract.
- I 'trip over' the use of the term "pseudoscience" in the abstract. Is that appropriate usage for a peer-reviewed, scientific journal?
If my question doesn't communicate, I'll try to explain.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

Given that "A pseudoscience is a set of ideas that presents itself as science, while it does not meet the criteria to properly be called such..."; and,

Given that there is no evidence, none, of any kind of "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching" in the sampled corner of the CIQ; and,

Given that the sampled area was chosen with much care; and,

Given that no one who has actually handled the CIQ has demonstrated the existence of any kind of "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching" anywhere on the CIQ; and, further,

Given that the very nature of the kind of reweaving you presented depends upon it being done with actual threads of the rest of the cloth (meaning that it could not change the 14C dating of the sample);

Then, yes, calling the (totally unsupported) claim that there must be some sort of "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching"; based on nothing more than special pleading, that is, the conviction that the 14 C dating produced the "wrong date", may be harsh, but it is neither inappropriate nor inaccurate.

It is certainly less offensive than unsupported allegations of incompetence, collusion, or outright fraud.

Unless the comments through which you are wading were written by scientists, with actual evidence that would refute BG&S's conclusion, you might have better ways to spend your time.

What evidence have you to offer, that the "invisible reweaving", "near-invisible reweaving", "repair", or "...some patching" exists, other than special pleading?

Bring it.
Slowvehicle,
- As a normal editorial it may be appropriate -- but, it is an emotion laden term, and to me, would seem to have no place in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Do you disagree that it is emotion-laden, or do you just think that emotion-laden terms are sometimes appropriate in scientific journals?
 
Slowvehicle,
- As a normal editorial it may be appropriate -- but, it is an emotion laden term, and to me, would seem to have no place in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Do you disagree that it is emotion-laden, or do you just think that emotion-laden terms are sometimes appropriate in scientific journals?

Once again, rather than address the topic at hand you veer off into banal irrelevancies as a dishonest tactic to avoid actually posting anything of substance.

"Pseudoscience", in this context, is not "emotion-laden" it is instead an accurate descriptor. The only emotion here is yours since you dislike the term being applied to YOU, despite having nailed your colours firmly to the masts of the good ship Pseudoscience.
 
Once again, rather than address the topic at hand you veer off into banal irrelevancies as a dishonest tactic to avoid actually posting anything of substance.

"Pseudoscience", in this context, is not "emotion-laden" it is instead an accurate descriptor. The only emotion here is yours since you dislike the term being applied to YOU, despite having nailed your colours firmly to the masts of the good ship Pseudoscience.

Yeah - some people just can't see the irrelevant in the room...
 
Slowvehicle,
- As a normal editorial it may be appropriate -- but, it is an emotion laden term, and to me, would seem to have no place in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Do you disagree that it is emotion-laden, or do you just think that emotion-laden terms are sometimes appropriate in scientific journals?



Your emotional response to the use of the term 'pseudoscience' is a purely personal issue, and has no place in a scientific discussion of the authenticity of the shroud. It's frankly inappropriate.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle,
- As a normal editorial it may be appropriate -- but, it is an emotion laden term, and to me, would seem to have no place in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Do you disagree that it is emotion-laden, or do you just think that emotion-laden terms are sometimes appropriate in scientific journals?

Its not a mere pejorative. The demarcation problem in the philosophy of science centres about the concept in the question as to what constitutes good science and what does not.

I like Richard Feynman's idea that honesty is the key thing lacking in pseudoscience. Perhaps you prefer his moniker of "cargo cult science." You have shown a complete lack of candour yourself during this discussion.
 
Last edited:
it is interesting what Jabba will postpone for a future post (evidence for example) versus what irrelevant tangent he will spend two posts discussing in hopes that we will follow him there. "What evidence do you have that the Shroud in 2000 years old?" "Look, squirrel!"
 
Slowvehicle,
- As a normal editorial it may be appropriate -- but, it is an emotion laden term, and to me, would seem to have no place in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Do you disagree that it is emotion-laden, or do you just think that emotion-laden terms are sometimes appropriate in scientific journals?

A) Doesn't matter. Answer the question.

B) It is not emotional if used in the context of describing something pseudoscientific.
 
Dear Dan,

I am going to get a couple more pages/days with a wild goose-chase regarding a semantic nit-pick!

Yours etc.
 
Slowvehicle,
- As a normal editorial it may be appropriate -- but, it is an emotion laden term, and to me, would seem to have no place in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Do you disagree that it is emotion-laden, or do you just think that emotion-laden terms are sometimes appropriate in scientific journals?

Dear Mr. Savage:

I am embarrassed to have to remind you of one of your own "rules" for "effective debate TM", to wit: One issue at a time.

in that light, what evidence do you have for the existence of a "reweave", and "invisible reweave", a "near-invisible reweave", a "repair", of "...some patching" at the location that the CIQ was tested?

Please keep in mind that your perfervid desire that there be such is predicated, not on evidence, but on the fact that, according to your assumed consequent, the 14C dating produced the "wrong" date. As such, it has no place in this discussion.

Your evidence.

Bring it.
 
Last edited:
Oh I was here all right all right!

...he once claimed victory precisely because everyone was ignoring him. He even pretended to the JREF challenge on that account.

He's free to do that. Mind, I don't say he's entitled to do that.
 
Not naming any names, of course

...if one insists on bringing in scientific arguments to booster that faith, then it is legitimate, indeed necessary, to discuss the scientific validity of those arguments,

This presumes of course that the persona of the Internet poster reflects their real life situation.

Okay, I agree with the first part, and I admit that you got me with your last sentence. Of course I don't know that the forum member in question is the poor creature I depicted in my post.

Over many years, I've watched a number of confused, unintelligent souls get abused out here in the playground. Yes, I've participated in the hounding; it's a shameful sort of fun; I'm worse than most of the people here, in fact.

It's just that eventually empathy rears its troublesome head. I don't know that anyone who maintains such a stubbornly irrational position for so long could be faking it. I think that the need to believe is real, and that the battering even of a quite silly but urgently required belief is painful. The destruction of such a belief might be seriously traumatic.

I don't mind being insulted and railed at on an internet forum; I think I rather get a bang out of it; the insulters and railers can smell my shoes. But being sobbed and sniveled at? Then playtime gets ugly, at least in my experience.

Who on earth really needs to triumph over -- oops, better not name any names.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom