Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wasn't there amazed speculation amongst the pathologically credulous about the fusion bomb neutron equivalent necessary to produce this image? And no crater!
 
I still don't understand why some have to go to such incredible lengths to negate the enormous mass of actual evidence that the Shroud is not authentic, just to be able to conclude that the "evidence" proves the miracle of Christ's death snd resurrection. If it was a miracle then why try to prove it happened using science? Especially if all the actual science strongly indicates that "This is not the clothe you are looking for."

Honestly because I don't think faith works as well as people pretend it does, even for the faithful.

I don't think a lot of people really have faith in the sense of the "Faith is all I need" level where they actually are not looking for evidence for what they believe in. What they have is this vaguer low faith + higher level rationalization thing going on.

I've long said that the faithful (in general) are not as dependant on their faith as they claim to be. If tommorow the news broke that they have found... the wreckage of the literal Noah's Ark or if Jesus literally returned tommorow or if any other event that objectively proved or gave strong evidence for a traditonal religious "miracle" story was found not a single mainstream, non-crazy religious person would shrug and go "Don't care. Don't need evidence. Got my faith. This introduction of evidence does not increase my stance in the accuracy of my statements because I don't need evidence, I already had faith." No they would grasp at that straw like a drowning man because no matter what they've told themselves the faith was never really enough.

This is why apologetics bothers me far more than traditional "faith" does. Pure, raw faith is actually pretty rare and marginalized, mainly because it's indistinguisable from pure insanity. What is far more common and far more dangerous are people with a little bit of core faith who have become masters of convincing themselves that actual objective evidence supports their faith.
 
Last edited:
In my opinion, the shroud dates before the carbon dating tests' proposed date of c. 1290 AD. This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century. According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.

The Turin shroud came to early 14th century Turin from Lirey, France, from a French Crusader treasury. It's probably no coincidence that over a century previously the Crusaders were recorded as taking the shroud from Constantinople, which was occupied by the French.

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.



Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.

[qimg]http://greatshroudofturinfaq.com/images/shroud-map.jpg[/qimg]

Can you tie that shroud to the Shroud of Turin?
 
Honestly because I don't think faith works as well as people pretend it does, even for the faithful.

I don't think a lot of people really have faith in the sense of the "Faith is all I need" level where they actually are not looking for evidence for what they believe in. What they have is this vaguer low faith + higher level rationalization thing going on.

I've long said that the faithful (in general) are not as dependant on their faith as they claim to be. If tommorow the news broke that they have found... the wreckage of the literal Noah's Ark or if Jesus literally returned tommorow or if any other event that objectively proved or gave strong evidence for a traditonal religious "miracle" story was found not a single mainstream, non-crazy religious person would shrug and go "Don't care. Don't need evidence. Got my faith. This introduction of evidence does not increase my stance in the accuracy of my statements because I don't need evidence, I already had faith." No they would grasp at that straw like a drowning man because no matter what they've told themselves the faith was never really enough.

This is why apologetics bothers me far more than traditional "faith" does. Pure, raw faith is actually pretty rare and marginalized, mainly because it's indistinguisable from pure insanity. What is far more common and far more dangerous are people with a little bit of core faith who have become masters of convincing themselves that actual objective evidence supports their faith.

Haven't you ever had a dream you wouldn't want waking up from or wouldn't mind getting back to? For me these cultivators of peculiar metaphysics basically work that way. They are commanded by a sense of wonder and the avoidance of frustration, and little else. That's why either they present here their puerile theories and go away once they confirm their shiny balloons are in danger among so many nails, or, like el que te jedi*, persist in ritualistic repetition or eventually provide poor recapitulations when they are firing in all cylinders.

* "the one I told you about", an indirect form of calling those whose names you don't want to pronounce for lucky reasons.
 
I don't want to derail the conversation with Jabba but as a semi-lurker I couldn't let this post stand (although I realise other posters have already had a go)...

In my opinion, the shroud dates before the carbon dating tests' proposed date of c. 1290 AD. This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century. According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.

Do you have may evidence to support this assertion ?

Earlier in this thread it was shown that "shrouds" were commonplace as altar pieces to represent the shroud of Christ. It was clear that these shrouds were symbolic. Given that Europe and Asia Minor was probably awash with "shrouds"

  • Where is your evidence about the early history of the shroud ?
  • Where are these "many records" ?
  • Even if Constantinople had a "shroud", where is your evidence that this is the same shroud that's currently in Turin ?


The Turin shroud came to early 14th century Turin from Lirey, France, from a French Crusader treasury. It's probably no coincidence that over a century previously the Crusaders were recorded as taking the shroud from Constantinople, which was occupied by the French.

Where is your evidence for this beguiling story ?

Specifically, where is the evidence of the shroud being taken ? Where is the evidence that it's the same shroud that's currently in Turin ? Where is the evidence that the shroud, allegedly taken from Constantinople, was old ?

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else

No, the best way to explain the carbon dating evidence is that the shroud is approximately that old and was made in the 13th or 14th century.

There is no evidence that the section dated was from a repair patch.

(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.

Err no, that's been covered in excruciating detail in this, and previous iterations of this thread. Whist chemical processes could account for a small error in the dating, there is no plausible way that it could have introduced an error as large as the one you have suggested.

Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.

If you're going to ignore all kinds of reliable dating evidence:

- Carbon dating
- Weave analysis
- Contemporary evidence of the appearance of the shroud

Then I suppose that no date or narrative for the shroud can be completely ruled out. Trouble is that there is all that reliable dating evidence.

.....<pointless map deleted>.....
 
I'm still waiting for the right moment to return to the chickens, but this unsavory flurry of on-topic posts has left me somewhat discombobulated.
 
In my opinion, the shroud dates before the carbon dating tests' proposed date of c. 1290 AD.
Your unsupported opinion is worthless.
This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century.
No, actually it can't.
<snippage of various made-up nonsense>
The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time
Rubbish. The sampled area was examined microscopically before and after the sampling by textile experts, there was no patch.
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.
Also rubbish. You are obviously unaware of the amount of contaminant material that would be necessary and of the decontamination techniques used by the testing laboratories.
Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.
This rubbish is ruled out by the evidence. The image is anatomically impossible, painted on a cloth not found in the first century Middle East, conflicts with Jewish funerary practices, comes into existence in the fourteenth century during the relic craze (one of more than forty such shrouds), was investigated by the church and found to be a fake, and stylistically in keeping with medieval Byzantine style with Gothic elements.

It's a fake.

 
Wasn't there amazed speculation amongst the pathologically credulous about the fusion bomb neutron equivalent necessary to produce this image? And no crater!
Yes some of the more pathetically desperate believers preach about magical "resurrection energy" that transmuted elements in the fabric.
It's utter rubbish of course.
 
[snip]
Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.

One of the posters here had jokingly suggested that the entire S of T was a patch. This statement actually advances just such an idea: the current S of T was not a Middle Ages forgery but was a Middle Ages copy of the original shroud, which was since lost.

Oddly I am okay with this (although as posted by others any documentation of your facile statements as to the history of "the real shroud" would be very nice). But if believers would like to convince themselves that the S of T is a xerox of the "real shroud" then fine by me! At least that wouldn't negate the known facts, although lacking any factual basis supporting it.
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"/Banding

Yes, I'm not trying to confuse the situation. I'm pointing out that the logic is pretty simple. There is a mathematical property that says if A = B and B = C, then A = C. If the sample was dated to the 13th century, and the sample is representative of the shroud, then the shroud is dated to the 13th century. In fact, the basics of this logic were the reason the C14 testing was performed in the first place....
Monza,
- I need to make sure that I understand the part I've hilited. That would be the dating given in the report, but it still might not be the actual age of the linen in the shroud. There could be other factors skewing the results.
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"/Banding

Yes, I'm not trying to confuse the situation. I'm pointing out that the logic is pretty simple. There is a mathematical property that says if A = B and B = C, then A = C. If the sample was dated to the 13th century, and the sample is representative of the shroud, then the shroud is dated to the 13th century. In fact, the basics of this logic were the reason the C14 testing was performed in the first place.

Back to our summary....


1)You admit that this test was performed on a sample in order to determine the age of the shroud.
Jabba> Yes.
2) There is no evidence that the sample was not representative of the shroud
as a whole.
Jabba> No. There is some evidence.

3)In fact, the evidence indicates that the sample area was indeed part of the original weave of the shroud.
Jabba> So far, mostly, it does.

4a) The three independent labs measured the age of the sample to be ~1260-1390 AD,
Jabba> No. There is still room for doubt.

4b) ...ergo the shroud linen was made ~1260-1390 AD.
Jabba> You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is probably true.)

5)Do you agree with this logic?
Jabba> I basically agree.


For #2, it would be nice to see this evidence especially in light of the link I included in my previous post.

For #4a, note that this says nothing of where the sample was taken from, if it was a patch, etc. It only states that the 3 labs tested the sample they were given and came up with a result, and that these 3 results were in general agreement. If there is doubt here, you need to address what it is. Do you doubt the ability of the machines to measure C14, the calibration, the cleaning process used, something else?

For #4b and #5, I don't understand the equivocation.
Monza,
- For this response, I'll have to focus on #2 -- and probably, it will be just the beginning of an answer.
- Over the years, I've provided various bits of what I consider to be evidence. The side you have offered to represent just doesn't think much of what I've provided. The Rogers' article is an example. If you wish, my next focus will be on digging up what evidence I can re-find.
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.
 
Last edited:
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
So what? Will you be addressing the points made, or continuing to evade them?
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
Again, so what?
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
Again, so what?
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
Irrelevant.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
Irrelevant aspersion casting.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.
Untrue.
 
Monza,
- For this response, I'll have to focus on #2 -- and probably, it will be just the beginning of an answer.
- Over the years, I've provided various bits of what I consider to be evidence. The side you have offered to represent just doesn't think much of what I've provided. The Rogers' article is an example. If you wish, my next focus will be on digging up what evidence I can re-find.
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.

What a surprise that you've focused on Nickell, and failed to notice the article to which he's referring. Don't suppose you read this paragraph?

Their abstract explains: “A close-up analysis of the pyrolysis mass spectra reported in the original paper [by Rogers] reveals that the differences found between the samples coming from different parts of the Shroud are just due to the presence of a contaminant with a long aliphatic chain. Except for the presence of the contaminant, the two pyrolysis-mass spectra look alike rather than different. Therefore, the pseudoscientific theory stating that the C14 sample might come from a ‘medieval invisible mending’ remains unsupported by evidence.” (See Thermochimica Acta 617 [2015]: 169–171.)
 
According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.


Dear God, not the Pray manuscript again. The rectangular object with a herringbone-type pattern is the lid of the tomb - the small piece of drapery lying on top of it represents the burial clothes. And if you look closely you can find 'holes' in the form of tiny circles used purely for decoration on the bystanders' clothing and the angel's wings.
 
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.


I notice that you are unable to address any of the actual arguments.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom