Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Monza,
- For this response, I'll have to focus on #2 -- and probably, it will be just the beginning of an answer.
- Over the years, I've provided various bits of what I consider to be evidence. The side you have offered to represent just doesn't think much of what I've provided. The Rogers' article is an example. If you wish, my next focus will be on digging up what evidence I can re-find.
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.



What does any of this have to do with anything? The Joe Nickell site referenced a paper, which is the object of interest here. He did not perform the analysis, write the paper, or have anything to do with it other than note its publication on his web site.

Joe is not a scientist.
But Marco Bella, Luigi Garlaschelli, and Roberto Samperi are scientists and they are the ones who wrote the paper.

The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal.
But the Thermochimica Acta is a peer-reviewed journal and that is where the paper was published.

You are being very rude and deliberately muddying the waters which prevents actual discussion and debate.
 
Monza,
That would be the dating given in the report, but it still might not be the actual age of the linen in the shroud. There could be other factors skewing the results.

And yet you have provided no evidence of any such factors.
 
Jabba's first instinct is to attempt to besmirch or even slander people, poison the well, and make similar logical fallacies.
 
Monza,
- For this response, I'll have to focus on #2 -- and probably, it will be just the beginning of an answer.
- Over the years, I've provided various bits of what I consider to be evidence. The side you have offered to represent just doesn't think much of what I've provided. The Rogers' article is an example. If you wish, my next focus will be on digging up what evidence I can re-find.
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.

What did Harry Grove say about McCrone? Please give the entire quote.
 
Monza,
- I need to make sure that I understand the part I've hilited. That would be the dating given in the report, but it still might not be the actual age of the linen in the shroud. There could be other factors skewing the results.

Good Evening, Mr. Savage!

I have been at a Professional Development Workshop all day (preliminary steps to TESOL certification...at my age!), so I'll be working my way through today's posts.

I wonder if you might actually explain what "other factors" might be "skewing" the results of the most-observed bit of 14C dating ever, especially n the light of this:

http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
 
Monza,
- For this response, I'll have to focus on #2 -- and probably, it will be just the beginning of an answer.
- Over the years, I've provided various bits of what I consider to be evidence. The side you have offered to represent just doesn't think much of what I've provided. The Rogers' article is an example. If you wish, my next focus will be on digging up what evidence I can re-find.
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.

How very sad. Instead of substance, you offer ad hominem suggestions of dishonesty.

What archaeologist worked with Rogers?

Who witnessed the chain of custody of the threads Rogers tested?

What other artifact has ever been dated, by anyone, using Rogers' "vanilin degradation protocol?

What reaction have you to the content of Nickell's article; that is, the work done by Marco Bella, Luigi Garlaschelli, and Roberto Samperi?

Further, you appear to have misspelled "calumniated" in point 6...
 
Last edited:
Jabba, What did Harry Gove say about McCrone? Please give the entire quote. Your credibility is already in the dumpster.

rakovsky, please pay close attention to Jabba's attention to these and other important questions. He is not capable of honest replies.
 
Last edited:
Carbon Dating Doubts/Banding

What does any of this have to do with anything? The Joe Nickell site referenced a paper, which is the object of interest here. He did not perform the analysis, write the paper, or have anything to do with it other than note its publication on his web site...
Monza,
- There are lots of arguments against the professionalism of that paper/editorial. See
http://shroudstory.com/2015/09/04/e...-and-samperi-on-rogers-2005-article/#comments.
 
Last edited:
Discussion Format

- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.
 
Last edited:
Monza,

- My alleged method for effective debate gives both sides the right to 'examine' as well as 'cross-examine.' So far, I've only been doing the cross-examining. Here, I'd like to do some examining.

- Take a look at http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.
- Do you accept that some of the banding comes from the backing cloth?

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

Before you change subjects, doesn't your own Effective DebateTM protocol require you to actually respond to the arguments raised? You have yet to address the actual article written by Marco Bella, Luigi Garlaschelli, and Roberto Samperi, and the points they make therein.
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to be in the ring with me at the same time...

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

As I have pointed out to you before, you have only one opponent: reality itself.

Suppose you address the findings of Marco Bella, Luigi Garlaschelli, and Roberto Samperi?
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.
This sounds very familiar - maybe from a couple or so months ago?

No progress was made then - why should it now jabba?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom