Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.

Except you have a tendency to punch yourself in the nose, run out of the ring then claim a points victory.
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.

Nobody is stopping you from only responding to one poster.
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.

This isn't a boxing match. A lot of the time, you complain about having many opponents, but what is happening is several people asking you the same question like "where is your evidence for a 2000 year old cloth?". Answer it once and you've answered it 20 times.
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.

A demonstrable lie.
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.

Jabba, had this been a boxing match, you would have been in hospital now. Even with only one opponent.

Fortunately, sticks and stones .... etc.

However, several of us have volunteered to be the one opponent, and you would have been free to ignore every one else, but somehow that hasn't worked for you, either.

I'm happy to take you on, all alone. :rolleyes:
Pick your subject. :D

- Obviously, we can't forbid every one else to pitch in, and I'll use their contributions as info collection, just as you have your background suppoeters.

And of course, I'll gladly let anybody else have a try.;)

Hans
 
Monza,

- My alleged method for effective debate gives both sides the right to 'examine' as well as 'cross-examine.' So far, I've only been doing the cross-examining. Here, I'd like to do some examining.

This is just gibberish. In a court-room and in any efficient debate, all that counts is evidence.

- Take a look at http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.
- Do you accept that some of the banding comes from the backing cloth?

Jabba, the banding phenomenon is a property of the weaving process. Perhaps modern industrial cloth will not show it, but anything hand-woven will. So of course, the backing cloth will ALSO exhibit banding. So what?

Hans
 
- For now, I'll just present my immediate reactions to your post.
1. The Skeptical Inquirer is not a peer-reviewed journal. It has the primary goal of appealing to skeptics. That's how it makes its money.
2. That's how Joe Nickell makes his money. He is paid to provide skeptic-friendly articles.
3. Joe is not a scientist. His Phd is in English. From Wikipedia: Nickell has worked professionally as a stage magician, carnival pitchman, private detective, blackjack dealer, riverboat manager, university instructor, author, and paranormal investigator, listing over 1000 personae on his website. Since the early 1980s, he has researched, written, co-authored and edited books in many genres.
4. According to Barrie Schwortz (phone), Joe had one debate with him on radio, but refused any more.
5. Just as theists have their biases, skeptics have theirs.
6. McCrone has been discredited by many of those studying the shroud -- including Harry Gove.

- There are lots of arguments against the professionalism of that paper/editorial. See
http://shroudstory.com/2015/09/04/e...-and-samperi-on-rogers-2005-article/#comments.


This is really impressive: in less than 24 hours you have gone from trying to dismiss the paper because you are dissatisfied with the qualifications of someone who commented on it and the lack of peer-review of the journal where he commented, to linking to the comments on a blog post as your argument against it.
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.

That is a lie
 
Why do you all bother? For me it's as simple as Jabba "winning the debate" and "taking out opponents" is another fantasy of him, not different than the fantasy the shroud is the real shroud of a real Jesus who really resurrected. The fact that what comes after the latter use of shroud is collectively shared by many is just a matter of having a modicum of common sense and how a real personal concoction would be regarded by the rest of the society.

The matter is you all already know that. I wonder which is the mechanism that makes you find replying Jabba's nonsense today is more attractive than not replying at all, when the only rational approach is just insisting in Jabba replying previous question he avoided before moving to the next step.
 
Why do you all bother? For me it's as simple as Jabba "winning the debate" and "taking out opponents" is another fantasy of him, not different than the fantasy the shroud is the real shroud of a real Jesus who really resurrected. The fact that what comes after the latter use of shroud is collectively shared by many is just a matter of having a modicum of common sense and how a real personal concoction would be regarded by the rest of the society.

The matter is you all already know that. I wonder which is the mechanism that makes you find replying Jabba's nonsense today is more attractive than not replying at all, when the only rational approach is just insisting in Jabba replying previous question he avoided before moving to the next step.

Well, masochism?

The fascination of shooting fish in a barrel?

.... I don't really know.

Perhaps there are no other opponents here. - Even Kumar seems to be gone.

Hans
 
Which ones do you find particularly effective?

I was wondering the same thing. The first two comments start with "I haven’t read this paper yet" and "I’m not a chemist", but he apparently finds this compelling.
 
Monza,
- There are lots of arguments against the professionalism of that paper/editorial. See
http://shroudstory.com/2015/09/04/e...-and-samperi-on-rogers-2005-article/#comments.

Jabba,
Shroudstory.com is not a peer reviewed journal, and many of the critics there are not scientists. You're not a scientist. You have presented no credible evidence supporting a 2,000 year old shroud.

If you were capable of objective, logical, and critical thought processes, what would you accept as the reasonable verdict for authenticity?
 
- Also, one way of looking at my wish to have one spokesperson for the con side at a time is like a boxer asking to fight only one opponent at a time. You guys seem to think it's appropriate for all of you to get in the ring with me at the same time...
- I'm happy to take on any of you -- but, just one at a time.


What possible reason could you have to think that everyone except you is on one side of this question? Each person has his/her own individual take. Each has issues he/she considers most important.

Where would we all meet to elect this spokesperson? We don't live together in one big house. And what method of debate would we use to choose our spokesperson. Would we have to divide into exactly two sides, pick a champion and have them debate who should debate you? Would each side have to split into two sides and each pick a champion to debate who should debate debating you?

You ask for considerations that not only do you not give others, but that are impossible to give.

Answer a question, any question. But don't attempt to lecture people on how they should ask.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom