Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...
So what is this "evidence" of yours?
 
So you're still parroting the Whanger nonsense, despite it being debunked repeatedly.

ALL of the pro-authenticy arguments have either been debunked long ago, or they're untestable speculation. There is nothing out there.

Hans
 
ALL of the pro-authenticy arguments have either been debunked long ago, or they're untestable speculation. There is nothing out there.

Hans

But . . . but . . . they haven't been debunked to Jabba's satisfaction yet. /whine
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"/Banding

Just to bring this full circle, our recent conversation started by discussing the purpose of the C14 testing. 1)You admit that this test was performed on a sample in order to determine the age of the shroud. 2) There is no evidence that the sample was not representative of the shroud as a whole. 3)In fact, the evidence indicates that the sample area was indeed part of the original weave of the shroud. 4a)The three independent labs measured the age of the sample to be ~1260-1390 AD, 4b)ergo the shroud linen was made ~1260-1390 AD. 5)Do you agree with this logic?

Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.
3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...

Regarding number 5, I asked if you agree with the logic. You may someday provide evidence against one of the previous points, but I just want you to let us know if you agree with the logic laid out?

If you get some time, you may want to review this link as it addresses some important issues.
Monza,
- I'm not sure that I currently understand your question, but I now suspect that I didn't understand it before. I now suspect that the "ergo" is the key word. You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is probably true.)
- I'll now go to the link you suggested...
 
Monza,
- I'm not sure that I currently understand your question, but I now suspect that I didn't understand it before. I now suspect that the "ergo" is the key word. You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is probably true.)
- I'll now go to the link you suggested...

At last! It's a miracle out of scripture!
 
Monza,
- I'm not sure that I currently understand your question, but I now suspect that I didn't understand it before. I now suspect that the "ergo" is the key word. You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is probably true.)
- I'll now go to the link you suggested...

So, since you are agreeing to this:
the shroud linen was made ~1260-1390 AD.

we're done, right?
 
I might have missed it but I wonder whether someone here has already seen this article apparently published by Nature last month: www.nature.com/articles/srep14484#s1

I does not allow to draw any conclusions. Furthermore the fact that Giulio Fanti is again involved in this research and has provided the samples makes me doubt about how serious this could be.
 
...the fact that Giulio Fanti is again involved in this research and has provided the samples makes me doubt about how serious this could be.

conversely, it clears any doubt for me :thumbsup:
I'll be back

ETA: RLCCS (relic low-cost country sourcing) to India in late Middle Ages?
 
Last edited:
In my opinion, the shroud dates before the carbon dating tests' proposed date of c. 1290 AD. This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century. According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.

The Turin shroud came to early 14th century Turin from Lirey, France, from a French Crusader treasury. It's probably no coincidence that over a century previously the Crusaders were recorded as taking the shroud from Constantinople, which was occupied by the French.

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.

A few months before his death, Rogers submitted an article describing his findings to a peer-reviewed journal and it was published less than two months before Raymond Rogers died.[8] The essential conclusion of the article is that the radiocarbon datings were accurate, but because the samples were from cloth that was not part of the original Shroud, they are irrelevant regarding the age of the image area.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymo..._radiocarbon_14_dating_of_the_Shroud_of_Turin

Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.

shroud-map.jpg
 
Monza,
- I'm not sure that I currently understand your question, but I now suspect that I didn't understand it before. I now suspect that the "ergo" is the key word. You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is probably true.)
- I'll now go to the link you suggested...


Yes, I'm not trying to confuse the situation. I'm pointing out that the logic is pretty simple. There is a mathematical property that says if A = B and B = C, then A = C. If the sample was dated to the 13th century, and the sample is representative of the shroud, then the shroud is dated to the 13th century. In fact, the basics of this logic were the reason the C14 testing was performed in the first place.

Back to our summary....


1)You admit that this test was performed on a sample in order to determine the age of the shroud.
Jabba> Yes.

2) There is no evidence that the sample was not representative of the shroud as a whole.
Jabba> No. There is some evidence.

3)In fact, the evidence indicates that the sample area was indeed part of the original weave of the shroud.
Jabba> So far, mostly, it does.

4a) The three independent labs measured the age of the sample to be ~1260-1390 AD,
Jabba> No. There is still room for doubt.

4b) ...ergo the shroud linen was made ~1260-1390 AD.
Jabba> You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is probably true.)

5)Do you agree with this logic?
Jabba> I basically agree.


For #2, it would be nice to see this evidence especially in light of the link I included in my previous post.

For #4a, note that this says nothing of where the sample was taken from, if it was a patch, etc. It only states that the 3 labs tested the sample they were given and came up with a result, and that these 3 results were in general agreement. If there is doubt here, you need to address what it is. Do you doubt the ability of the machines to measure C14, the calibration, the cleaning process used, something else?

For #4b and #5, I don't understand the equivocation.
 
This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century. According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.

This is a highly speculative opinion, to put it gently.
 
In my opinion, the shroud dates before the carbon dating tests' proposed date of c. 1290 AD. This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century. According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.

The Turin shroud came to early 14th century Turin from Lirey, France, from a French Crusader treasury. It's probably no coincidence that over a century previously the Crusaders were recorded as taking the shroud from Constantinople, which was occupied by the French.

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.



Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.

http://greatshroudofturinfaq.com/images/shroud-map.jpg

Unless you have EVIDENCE to show the C14 result is wrong, the shroud is a 14th century fabrication.

Hans
 
In my opinion, the shroud dates before the carbon dating tests' proposed date of c. 1290 AD. This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century. According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.

The Turin shroud came to early 14th century Turin from Lirey, France, from a French Crusader treasury. It's probably no coincidence that over a century previously the Crusaders were recorded as taking the shroud from Constantinople, which was occupied by the French.

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.



Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.

[qimg]http://greatshroudofturinfaq.com/images/shroud-map.jpg[/qimg]

Unevidenced claims and a completely unnecessary map of Europe and the Med. do not make a very convincing argument.
 
In my opinion, the shroud dates before the carbon dating tests' proposed date of c. 1290 AD. This is because the history of the shroud can be traced earlier to Constantinople in the 12th century. According to many records, Constantinople had a shroud that matches the description, and according to the Hungarian Pray manuscript illustration of that Byzantine shroud, the cloth itself had the same weave and the unique pattern of holes in the middle.

The Turin shroud came to early 14th century Turin from Lirey, France, from a French Crusader treasury. It's probably no coincidence that over a century previously the Crusaders were recorded as taking the shroud from Constantinople, which was occupied by the French.

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.



Still, this does not rule out that the shroud was made as a forgery in the 6th century or earlier, when Constantinople acquired the shroud from Edessa.

shroud-map.jpg

That sounded hollywoodesque, not scientific, because it's a nice story and nothing else. Just a single evidence of that (which is not a non-sequitur per se, like it would be evidence of a Constantinopolitan shroud) like, for instance, documentation showing a matching description and describing accurately the same pattern of holes. Then, provided those documents we might discus its value as evidence.
 
<respectful snip for focus>

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.

<respectful snip for focus>

You may have missed this:

http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
 
I

The best way I see to explain the carbon dating of c. 1290 is to say that either (1) the cloth sample for the dating was taken from part of the cloth that was interwoven from the repair patch we know was made at that time (this was the explanation of Raymond Rogers, who reversed his position on his original 1290 dating of the shroud), or else
(2) the chemical, burning or heating process that created the image on the shroud or that occurred in the medieval fire affected the carbon dating of the image.


The best way to explain the c. 1290 AD date is that the Shroud was made around 1290 AD. In fact that is the only way to explain if you want to use science. If you want to call it a miracle- fine- then it could have been woven by angels, the 14C transmutated, and it brought to Earth in 30 AD by God to wrap his only Son.

My point? I still don't understand why some have to go to such incredible lengths to negate the enormous mass of actual evidence that the Shroud is not authentic, just to be able to conclude that the "evidence" proves the miracle of Christ's death snd resurrection. If it was a miracle then why try to prove it happened using science? Especially if all the actual science strongly indicates that "This is not the clothe you are looking for."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom