Monza,
- I'm not sure that I currently understand your question, but I now suspect that I didn't understand it before. I now suspect that the "ergo" is the key word. You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is probably true.)
- I'll now go to the link you suggested...
Yes, I'm not trying to confuse the situation. I'm pointing out that the logic is pretty simple. There is a mathematical property that says if A = B and B = C, then A = C. If the sample was dated to the 13th century, and the sample is representative of the shroud, then the shroud is dated to the 13th century. In fact, the basics of this logic were the reason the C14 testing was performed in the first place.
Back to our summary....
1)You admit that this test was performed on a sample in order to determine the age of the shroud.
Jabba> Yes.
2) There is no evidence that the sample was not representative of the shroud as a whole.
Jabba> No. There is some evidence.
3)In fact, the evidence indicates that the sample area was indeed part of the original weave of the shroud.
Jabba> So far, mostly, it does.
4a) The three independent labs measured the age of the sample to be ~1260-1390 AD,
Jabba> No. There is still room for doubt.
4b) ...ergo the shroud linen was made ~1260-1390 AD.
Jabba> You're saying that given #s 1, 2, 3 and 4a, 4b is true. If that's what you're saying, I basically agree. (I would just say that 4b is
probably true.)
5)Do you agree with this logic?
Jabba> I basically agree.
For #2, it would be nice to see this evidence especially in light of the link I included in my previous post.
For #4a, note that this says nothing of where the sample was taken from, if it was a patch, etc. It only states that the 3 labs tested the sample they were given and came up with a result, and that these 3 results were in general agreement. If there is doubt here, you need to address what it is. Do you doubt the ability of the machines to measure C14, the calibration, the cleaning process used, something else?
For #4b and #5, I don't understand the equivocation.