Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hey, guys:

I stumbled across this obscure link that may explain some things for Jabba:

http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blog..._still_a_fake/

I'm pretty sure that this is brand new information because I've never seen it posted in this thread before. Granted, I only read every eleventh post and, even then, I only read the first three and a half words.

- Pizza
- the .45 long slide with laser sighting

Wow.

I wish someone had shared this with us before...think of the time and hassle we could have saved.

Thanks!
 
Chickens with hands to hold the scissors. Invisibly cutting for the invisible mend.

Nibbling delicately on a brain cookie, one suddenly turned to the other and said "I think I left the iron on."

"That's odd", responded the second chicken, "as you have no clothes upon which to use your iron."

"Hmmm... Good point. A mystery for the ages, most certainly. Speaking of which, pass the invisible needle and thread."

"Bother! I seem to have misplaced it. I'll be back..."

ETA: conclusion 1.1.4: chickens have hands, and don't always play euchre. Good chickens *never* play Canasta, on account of thir inability to incorporate upside down question marks into their worldview. They literally cannot even say the word.
 
Last edited:
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"/Banding

Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.
3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...
Monza,
- Try http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf.
- Couple of quotes:

(Figure 17) To help clarify this issue, we examined in detail the area of the C14 specimen on the
radiographs. An irregular band of threads with increased radiodensity and extending variably
about 5/8 inch (1.7 cm) into the Shroud fabric is noted immediately adjacent to much of the
length of the seam that borders the frontal MC. In a close-up view of the area where the Raes
sample and the single C14 sample were taken, irregularities in some of the weave pattern can be
noted on the Shroud fabric adjacent to the seam. (Figure 18) There is significant variability in the
radiodensity of both warp and weft threads in this area. Some of the threads angulate, and the
continuity of a few seems to be broken. This area is denser and the 3:1 herringbone weave
pattern is much less obvious than in the nearby body of the Shroud fabric.
5
Our conclusion is that the radiographs are strongly suggestive of significant alterations in the
threads and weave of the Shroud fabric in the area from which the C14 specimen was taken, thus
casting major doubts on the validity of the radiocarbon dating

- Still trying to focus on the regularity of the banding, I can't be sure that the Wangers are referring to the bands in our inquiry. Maybe, that doesn't matter...

Conclusions
On studying the radiographs of the Shroud made in 1978, details of the seams and threads can be
seen. It appears that the side seam was put in as a tuck, and that near the two missing corners
there are variations in weave patterns and in thread densities which suggest that these two areas
had been damaged and then repaired in some way. Examination of the site of the C14 single
sample indicates that at least part of the sample was taken from one of these repaired or altered
areas.
 
Monza,
- Try http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf.
- Couple of quotes:

(Figure 17) To help clarify this issue, we examined in detail the area of the C14 specimen on the
radiographs. An irregular band of threads with increased radiodensity and extending variably
about 5/8 inch (1.7 cm) into the Shroud fabric is noted immediately adjacent to much of the
length of the seam that borders the frontal MC. In a close-up view of the area where the Raes
sample and the single C14 sample were taken, irregularities in some of the weave pattern can be
noted on the Shroud fabric adjacent to the seam. (Figure 18) There is significant variability in the
radiodensity of both warp and weft threads in this area. Some of the threads angulate, and the
continuity of a few seems to be broken. This area is denser and the 3:1 herringbone weave
pattern is much less obvious than in the nearby body of the Shroud fabric.
5
Our conclusion is that the radiographs are strongly suggestive of significant alterations in the
threads and weave of the Shroud fabric in the area from which the C14 specimen was taken, thus
casting major doubts on the validity of the radiocarbon dating

- Still trying to focus on the regularity of the banding, I can't be sure that the Wangers are referring to the bands in our inquiry. Maybe, that doesn't matter...

Conclusions
On studying the radiographs of the Shroud made in 1978, details of the seams and threads can be
seen. It appears that the side seam was put in as a tuck, and that near the two missing corners
there are variations in weave patterns and in thread densities which suggest that these two areas
had been damaged and then repaired in some way. Examination of the site of the C14 single
sample indicates that at least part of the sample was taken from one of these repaired or altered
areas.


Nope.

No, there is not.

“A close-up analysis of the pyrolysis mass spectra reported in the original paper [by Rogers] reveals that the differences found between the samples coming from different parts of the Shroud are just due to the presence of a contaminant with a long aliphatic chain. Except for the presence of the contaminant, the two pyrolysis-mass spectra look alike rather than different. Therefore, the pseudoscientific theory stating that the C14 sample might come from a ‘medieval invisible mending’ remains unsupported by evidence.” (See Thermochimica Acta 617 [2015]: 169–171.)
 
Last edited:
Monza,
- Try http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf.
- Couple of quotes:

(Figure 17) To help clarify this issue, we examined in detail the area of the C14 specimen on the
radiographs. An irregular band of threads with increased radiodensity and extending variably
about 5/8 inch (1.7 cm) into the Shroud fabric is noted immediately adjacent to much of the
length of the seam that borders the frontal MC. In a close-up view of the area where the Raes
sample and the single C14 sample were taken, irregularities in some of the weave pattern can be
noted on the Shroud fabric adjacent to the seam. (Figure 18) There is significant variability in the
radiodensity of both warp and weft threads in this area. Some of the threads angulate, and the
continuity of a few seems to be broken. This area is denser and the 3:1 herringbone weave
pattern is much less obvious than in the nearby body of the Shroud fabric.
5
Our conclusion is that the radiographs are strongly suggestive of significant alterations in the
threads and weave of the Shroud fabric in the area from which the C14 specimen was taken, thus
casting major doubts on the validity of the radiocarbon dating

- Still trying to focus on the regularity of the banding, I can't be sure that the Wangers are referring to the bands in our inquiry. Maybe, that doesn't matter...

Conclusions
On studying the radiographs of the Shroud made in 1978, details of the seams and threads can be
seen. It appears that the side seam was put in as a tuck, and that near the two missing corners
there are variations in weave patterns and in thread densities which suggest that these two areas
had been damaged and then repaired in some way. Examination of the site of the C14 single
sample indicates that at least part of the sample was taken from one of these repaired or altered
areas.

Good Morning, Mr. Savage, and happy Sunday.

You appear to be continuing to ignore this:
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/

Might you explain why?
 
From that same paper that Jabba just cited:
There has been great controversy and difference of opinions and observations. For instance, Jackson, Propp and Fornof in 1999 stated that viewing the C14 sample area on transmitted light photographs disproved the hypothesis that the Shroud was rewoven in that area, or that on other observations there were no “alien threads intruding into the radiocarbon sample.” (Ref.: Jackson et al, 2000) Again, after examining the Shroud during the conservation activities of 2002, Flury-Lemberg reported in Sindone 2002 (Ref.: Flury-Lemberg, 2003) that concerning the hypothetical reweaving of the 16th century, “there is no doubt that the Shroud does not contain any reweaving.

This is equivocal evidence at best. Is this all you've got?
 
Last edited:
Jabba's Whanger is no less ridiculous to day than it was the first time he whipped it out in front of us all. Shameless
 
Jabba,

Look up these two words:

Speculation

Evidence

Try to understand the difference.

Hans
 
Well, Jabba's has shown to be so to speak an aircraft with a very low ceiling and in addition his delay tactics waiting for the shroud to be two thousand years old are very evident. I'd rather dally with the barons munchausen in those sites he goes in search for scriptwriting.
 
So what is the image on the shroud physically composed of?

STURP summarizes its findings on this question:
No pigments, paints, dyes or stains have been found on the fibrils. X-ray, fluorescence and microchemistry on the fibrils preclude the possibility of paint being used as a method for creating the image. Ultra Violet and infrared evaluation confirm these studies...

The scientific concensus is that the image was produced by something which resulted in oxidation, dehydration and conjugation of the polysaccharide structure of the microfibrils of the linen itself. Such changes can be duplicated in the laboratory by certain chemical and physical processes. A similar type of change in linen can be obtained by sulfuric acid or heat. However, there are no chemical or physical methods known which can account for the totality of the image, nor can any combination of physical, chemical, biological or medical circumstances explain the image adequately.
https://www.shroud.com/78conclu.htm
 
STURP summarizes its findings on this question:

https://www.shroud.com/78conclu.htm

STURP is a group of people who really really want the shroud to be authentic.

No in-depth analysis has been made of the image on the shroud, since the church has not given much access to it, so whatever anybody says is, at best, extrapolations from insufficient data.

What we do know is that the cloth is 800 years old.

Hans
 
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.
3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...


Regarding number 5, I asked if you agree with the logic. You may someday provide evidence against one of the previous points, but I just want you to let us know if you agree with the logic laid out?

If you get some time, you may want to review this link as it addresses some important issues.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom