Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Monza,
1. It's just saying that if repairers could actually get away with near-invisible repair otherwise, they could probably get away with it re the banding also. But so far,
2. Does sound like there would be nothing deliberate about it -- which seems to obviate John's suggestion.

- I just asked John if he has a comeback...
- You brought up other sub-issues. I'll try to deal with them next unless you direct me otherwise.

http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
 
I liike that he claims the 14C date was skewed by in influx of neutrons from the corpse that converted 14N to 14C. Linen is essentially cellulose or CHO(n) where (n) is a large integer. Would there have been enough nitrogen in the fabric to create the 14C by neutron activation of 14N? Is there any evidence that this elevated neutron flux existed? Why are no other elements on the shroud transmutated?

Because quantum. And Jeebas. Reasons.
 
I believe it's time for sub issue 1.1.3.

So far we have agreed that chicken live on brains, are dinosaurs in skinny suits, eat dark matter, and cause El Niño. They also pronounce "potato" incorrectly.

I will graciously ignore some of the twaddle in response to my prior posts, because that is an integral part of my debating method.

Without and further ado, to point 1.1.3. Which I will type slowly so that Slow posters can keep up.

The more cautious amongst you may have noticed that you rarely see fire engines, clowns, and earthworms in close company. Be that as it may, the rabbits are know to prefer euchre and this is the connection to artificial insemination of geese. Geese have beaks too, just like elephants and chickens. Consider the implications. Double dissolution. You put your left hand in, you put your left hand out, you're right back where you started from. Stupid person.

ETA - I'll be back

¡Canasta!
 
Hypothesis: There is an inverse correlation between the frequency of Jabba posting and the fun this thread provides.
Facts: Kid Eager. Very little Jabba.
QED
 


In your linked comment I found this gem of convoluted thinking:

We should realize the importance of not making the common a priori presupposition of naturalism, so that we not automatically rule out anything that is beyond the laws of science as we currently understand them, so that we can follow the scientific evidence where it leads.


"Let's not make the mistake of approaching this scientifically"
 
Carbon Dating Doubts/"Invisible Re-weave"/Banding

Just to bring this full circle, our recent conversation started by discussing the purpose of the C14 testing. (1) You admit that this test was performed on a sample in order to determine the age of the shroud. (2) There is no evidence that the sample was not representative of the shroud as a whole. (3) In fact, the evidence indicates that the sample area was indeed part of the original weave of the shroud. (4) The three independent labs measured the age of the sample to be ~1260-1390 AD, ergo the shroud linen was made ~1260-1390 AD. (5) Do you agree with this logic?
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.
3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...
 
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.
3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...

Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

1. Why the change in subject? This is not how you claim "effective debate" must go.

2. Why do you continue to ignore this:
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
 
Last edited:
Good Morning, Mr. Savage:

1. Why the change in subject? This is not how you claim "effective debate" must go.

2. Why do you continue to ignore this:
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/


OMFG!!! You mean there is evidence at the CIQ isn't authentic at http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/

Has anybody alerted the press, or the Vatican???!!!!eleventy11

Is this the right URL?
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/turin_shroud_still_a_fake/
 
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.

No, there is not.

“A close-up analysis of the pyrolysis mass spectra reported in the original paper [by Rogers] reveals that the differences found between the samples coming from different parts of the Shroud are just due to the presence of a contaminant with a long aliphatic chain. Except for the presence of the contaminant, the two pyrolysis-mass spectra look alike rather than different. Therefore, the pseudoscientific theory stating that the C14 sample might come from a ‘medieval invisible mending’ remains unsupported by evidence.” (See Thermochimica Acta 617 [2015]: 169–171.)
 
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.
3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...

Unholy mother of hell!! You didn't stop at the first Q/C!!

End of the world, folks!
 
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.

You haven't presented any. At this juncture, I would normally provide links that you won't follow, logic you won't understand, evidence you won't examine, and arguments you won't read, but what is the point?

The brick-wall metaphor thing comes into play with every post you make.
 
Last edited:
Monza,
.
1. Yes.
2. No. There is some evidence.
3. So far, mostly, it does.
4. No. There is still room for doubt. I have more evidence to consider. See below.
5. See above.

- http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/marben.pdf
- Note especially Figure 7.
- Note also http://s254.photobucket.com/user/AlwaysTomboy/media/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png.html.

- At this point, looks like the backing cloth is responsible for at least some of the banding.
- But certainly not obvious why banding on the backing cloth would show up better when filtered by the shroud itself...

Jabba, this is huge. If you have evidence, don't keep it to yourself.
 
Hey, guys:

I stumbled across this obscure link that may explain some things for Jabba:

http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blog..._still_a_fake/

I'm pretty sure that this is brand new information because I've never seen it posted in this thread before. Granted, I only read every eleventh post and, even then, I only read the first three and a half words.

- Pizza
- the .45 long slide with laser sighting
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom