David Mo:
1) I think you misunderstood what I was saying. No authenticist thinks that the image was formed as a result of wrapping the Shroud closely around the face and body, and the image forming from the contact between the two. As GlennB comments, "because if it was wrapped around his head and the image received by touch it would look silly." Indeed it would, and authenticists are not as silly as some non-authenticists would like them to be.
2) I think the trickles of blood in the hair should be a real problem for authenticists. Gilbert Lavoie, with an ingenious experiment detailed at
https://www.shroud.com/pdfs/ssi20part4.pdf, thinks that the blood actually trickled down the cheeks, and contacted a closely wrapped Shroud that way, and then the Shroud somehow straightened itself out somewhat, whereupon the image was formed by some form of action at a distance. Most authenticists are no more convinced of this than most non-authenticists. Another explanation is that the hair was so matted that fresh blood from renewed irritation of puncture wounds forced itself through the hair trickled down the matted surface. That's another rather weak explanation, to my mind, but it has been proposed. I don't know of any other ideas.
3) I have given three possible reasons why a crucified man might not have been buried lying flat on his back, rigor mortis, burial 'arrangements' (possibly involving a hundred pounds of myrrh and aloes), and the nature of the burial chamber, such as a head 'shelf'. None of these is particularly eccentric, and they all provide, I think, not unreasonable explanations.
4) The authors of the radiocarbon paper acknowledged certain anomalies and proposed sensible explanations for them. Had the three samples come from three completely different cloths, it is unlikely that they would have considered the cloths to have been proved contemporaneous.
Kid Eager, sorry, I did omit a set of quotation marks in error. Here is the entire passage, cut-and-pasted from the paper:
"The spread of the measurements for sample 1 is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted.
More quantitatively, to establish whether the scatter among the three laboratory means was consistent with their quoted errors, a X2 test was applied to the dates for each sample, in accordance with the recommended procedure of Ward and Wilson
13. The results of this test, given in Table 2, show that it is unlikely that the errors quoted by the laboratories for sample 1 fully reflect the overall scatter. The errors might still reflect the uncertainties in the three dates relative to one another, but in the absence of direct evidence on this, it was decided to give the three dates for sample 1 equal weight in determining the final mean, and to estimate the uncertainty in that mean from the scatter of results." [The '13' after 'Ward and Wilson' is an endnote reference to their paper.]
MRC Hans:
1) Thank you, but I do not see any upper arms in photos of the Shroud. They are completely obscured by the 1532 burn marks. Perhaps you could post a picture in which you point out where you see the arms?
2) I think we differ about the definition of evidence. I have been using the word to mean the basic observations and experimental results that are largely indisputable by both sides. It becomes evidence for one side or the other depending on the interpretation or the value placed on it. For example, the shroud is woven in a 30 thread per cm, 3/1 chevron twill. In itself, this evidence does not 'favor' anybody. It is what it is. An authenticist might compare it to the fine woven silks of ancient Damascus; a non-authenticist might compare it to medieval north european woollen textiles. They could discuss, indeed they have discussed, the relative likelihoods of the Shroud being ancient or modern, but the bare facts of the matter are available to all.
3) "It is irrelevant for assessing the authenticity of the shroud. You are mixing up things." Well, that's excellent, isn't it? This thread needs a bit of stirring up, don't you think? You don't want to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud', I don't want to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud', in fact nobody on this site wants to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud'. Let's discuss it from a 'religious and philosophical' point of view instead, why not?
Slowvehicle:
1) It is an authenticist point of view that dislocation of the shoulders, or the nasal cartilage for that matter, does not deny the prophesy saying that no bone should be broken. Apart from that I agree with your comments that too many complications have to be brought in to account for the different kinds of blood-flow, pre- or post-mortem, liquid or remoistened, whole or haemolysed, and so on. To me they all look dribbled on with a pipette.
2) Thanks for the John Henry reference. I'd never heard of him.