Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
- Yeah. That was my first step.

- McCrone's testimony has been used as a significant part of the evidence against authenticity and a 2000 year age. But, McCrone insisted that there was no blood on the shroud -- and if there is blood on the shroud, there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony...


...about there being blood on the cloth.

Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature

How can you tell?
 
Last edited:
- Yeah. That was my first step.

- McCrone's testimony has been used as a significant part of the evidence against authenticity and a 2000 year age. But, McCrone insisted that there was no blood on the shroud -- and if there is blood on the shroud, there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony...
- Then, there is evidence/weight in the authentic/2000 yr pan (the STURP results for instance), and as the inauthentic/700 yr claim looses weight the tilt of the scale would change in the direction of authenticity/2000 yrs. Not that the tilt would now favor authenticity/2000 yrs -- just that the shift would be in that direction.

- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature. How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?

For the 100th time, the presence or absence of blood doesn't support a 2000 y.o. shroud.

Butchering an animal isn't something the beasts particularly enjoy, but this torture palaver is just another case of Jabba wasting peoples' time and insulting their intelligence with irrelevancies.
 
Last edited:
Hey Jabba, My mother-in-law likes to travel to the holy land. She also likes to make a blood pudding called dinagoong in the Philippines. If she came back with a bolt of linen from Jerusalem, and spilled some dinagoog on it, would that make it 2000 years old?
 
- Yeah. That was my first step.

- McCrone's testimony has been used as a significant part of the evidence against authenticity and a 2000 year age. But, McCrone insisted that there was no blood on the shroud -- and if there is blood on the shroud, there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony...
- Then, there is evidence/weight in the authentic/2000 yr pan (the STURP results for instance), and as the inauthentic/700 yr claim looses weight the tilt of the scale would change in the direction of authenticity/2000 yrs. Not that the tilt would now favor authenticity/2000 yrs -- just that the shift would be in that direction.

- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature. How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?

"appears" to whom?

What type of *creature*? Are you thinking human, or something else? If human, do you have anyone specific in mind?
 
- McCrone's testimony has been used as a significant part of the evidence against authenticity and a 2000 year age. But, McCrone insisted that there was no blood on the shroud -- and if there is blood on the shroud, there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony...

Hardly significant. Part of the evidence, sure. No it means that he was wrong on that account.

- Then, there is evidence/weight in the authentic/2000 yr pan (the STURP results for instance), and as the inauthentic/700 yr claim looses weight the tilt of the scale would change in the direction of authenticity/2000 yrs.

No. At best you might detract a little weight from the con side, but you add none to the pro side.

Not that the tilt would now favor authenticity/2000 yrs -- just that the shift would be in that direction.

No, as explained above.

- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature.
Evidence for that?


How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?

Not unlikely. That was the age of both torture and self-torture.

Hans
 
Hey Jabba, My mother-in-law likes to travel to the holy land. She also likes to make a blood pudding called dinagoong in the Philippines. If she came back with a bolt of linen from Jerusalem, and spilled some dinagoog on it, would that make it 2000 years old?
This, jabba is the question you should answer
 
- Yeah. That was my first step.

- McCrone's testimony has been used as a significant part of the evidence against authenticity and a 2000 year age. But, McCrone insisted that there was no blood on the shroud -- and if there is blood on the shroud, there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony...
- Then, there is evidence/weight in the authentic/2000 yr pan (the STURP results for instance), and as the inauthentic/700 yr claim looses weight the tilt of the scale would change in the direction of authenticity/2000 yrs. Not that the tilt would now favor authenticity/2000 yrs -- just that the shift would be in that direction.

- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature. How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?

My Dear Mr. Savage:

It seems to me that you are trying to make the argument that, if you could prove that Dr. McCrone was mistaken about the presence of blood on the CIQ, you could therefore dismiss every other piece of Dr. McCrtone's testimony.

Were this...novel...approach correct, would that not mean that, since you were mistaken as to the probity and evidentiary value of the conjectures on the M&A paper, and addendum, every other piece of what you say can and should be dismissed?

Of course, that is merely a hypothetical example, because you have yet to take the least step toward indicating that there is, in fact, actual blood as part of the representational image, presented without wrapping distortion, on the sized and gessoed surface of the manifestly medieval linen of the CIQ.

When do you intend to present your evidence that there is, in fact, actual blood on the CIQ?

Were you to be successful in that, when do you intend to demonstrate how the presence of blood says anything about the age of the CIQ?

Please get tot the actual evidence.

Through it all,

I remain forensically yours &ct.
 
- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature. How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?


An argument from incredulity stacked on top of an unsupported assertion and a hypothetical.
 
- Yeah. That was my first step.

- McCrone's testimony has been used as a significant part of the evidence against authenticity and a 2000 year age. But, McCrone insisted that there was no blood on the shroud -- and if there is blood on the shroud, there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony...
- Then, there is evidence/weight in the authentic/2000 yr pan (the STURP results for instance), and as the inauthentic/700 yr claim looses weight the tilt of the scale would change in the direction of authenticity/2000 yrs. Not that the tilt would now favor authenticity/2000 yrs -- just that the shift would be in that direction.

- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature. How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?

This is so screwed up it's not even wrong. Would McCrone not doing his test to begin with support a 2000 year old age? Since we've carbon dated the cloth, if there is blood it must have been added in the medieval period. It's not just unlikely that the blood got on the cloth before the medieval period; it's impossible for the blood to have been put on the cloth before the medieval period. Remember superposition; the image on the cloth cannot be older than the cloth.
 
David Mo:
1) I think you misunderstood what I was saying. No authenticist thinks that the image was formed as a result of wrapping the Shroud closely around the face and body, and the image forming from the contact between the two. As GlennB comments, "because if it was wrapped around his head and the image received by touch it would look silly." Indeed it would, and authenticists are not as silly as some non-authenticists would like them to be.

2) I think the trickles of blood in the hair should be a real problem for authenticists. Gilbert Lavoie, with an ingenious experiment detailed at https://www.shroud.com/pdfs/ssi20part4.pdf, thinks that the blood actually trickled down the cheeks, and contacted a closely wrapped Shroud that way, and then the Shroud somehow straightened itself out somewhat, whereupon the image was formed by some form of action at a distance. Most authenticists are no more convinced of this than most non-authenticists. Another explanation is that the hair was so matted that fresh blood from renewed irritation of puncture wounds forced itself through the hair trickled down the matted surface. That's another rather weak explanation, to my mind, but it has been proposed. I don't know of any other ideas.

3) I have given three possible reasons why a crucified man might not have been buried lying flat on his back, rigor mortis, burial 'arrangements' (possibly involving a hundred pounds of myrrh and aloes), and the nature of the burial chamber, such as a head 'shelf'. None of these is particularly eccentric, and they all provide, I think, not unreasonable explanations.

4) The authors of the radiocarbon paper acknowledged certain anomalies and proposed sensible explanations for them. Had the three samples come from three completely different cloths, it is unlikely that they would have considered the cloths to have been proved contemporaneous.

Kid Eager, sorry, I did omit a set of quotation marks in error. Here is the entire passage, cut-and-pasted from the paper:

"The spread of the measurements for sample 1 is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted.
More quantitatively, to establish whether the scatter among the three laboratory means was consistent with their quoted errors, a X2 test was applied to the dates for each sample, in accordance with the recommended procedure of Ward and Wilson
13. The results of this test, given in Table 2, show that it is unlikely that the errors quoted by the laboratories for sample 1 fully reflect the overall scatter. The errors might still reflect the uncertainties in the three dates relative to one another, but in the absence of direct evidence on this, it was decided to give the three dates for sample 1 equal weight in determining the final mean, and to estimate the uncertainty in that mean from the scatter of results." [The '13' after 'Ward and Wilson' is an endnote reference to their paper.]

MRC Hans:
1) Thank you, but I do not see any upper arms in photos of the Shroud. They are completely obscured by the 1532 burn marks. Perhaps you could post a picture in which you point out where you see the arms?

2) I think we differ about the definition of evidence. I have been using the word to mean the basic observations and experimental results that are largely indisputable by both sides. It becomes evidence for one side or the other depending on the interpretation or the value placed on it. For example, the shroud is woven in a 30 thread per cm, 3/1 chevron twill. In itself, this evidence does not 'favor' anybody. It is what it is. An authenticist might compare it to the fine woven silks of ancient Damascus; a non-authenticist might compare it to medieval north european woollen textiles. They could discuss, indeed they have discussed, the relative likelihoods of the Shroud being ancient or modern, but the bare facts of the matter are available to all.

3) "It is irrelevant for assessing the authenticity of the shroud. You are mixing up things." Well, that's excellent, isn't it? This thread needs a bit of stirring up, don't you think? You don't want to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud', I don't want to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud', in fact nobody on this site wants to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud'. Let's discuss it from a 'religious and philosophical' point of view instead, why not?

Slowvehicle:
1) It is an authenticist point of view that dislocation of the shoulders, or the nasal cartilage for that matter, does not deny the prophesy saying that no bone should be broken. Apart from that I agree with your comments that too many complications have to be brought in to account for the different kinds of blood-flow, pre- or post-mortem, liquid or remoistened, whole or haemolysed, and so on. To me they all look dribbled on with a pipette.

2) Thanks for the John Henry reference. I'd never heard of him.
 
[...]

3) "It is irrelevant for assessing the authenticity of the shroud. You are mixing up things." Well, that's excellent, isn't it? This thread needs a bit of stirring up, don't you think? You don't want to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud', I don't want to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud', in fact nobody on this site wants to 'assess the authenticity of the Shroud'. Let's discuss it from a 'religious and philosophical' point of view instead, why not?

[..]


Would you mind explaining this bit of apparent petulance? I can't tell if you are actually quoting another person, or using scare quotes to obfuscate.
 
Last edited:
David Mo:
.......
4) The authors of the radiocarbon paper acknowledged certain anomalies and proposed sensible explanations for them. Had the three samples come from three completely different cloths, it is unlikely that they would have considered the cloths to have been proved contemporaneous.

Kid Eager, sorry, I did omit a set of quotation marks in error. Here is the entire passage, cut-and-pasted from the paper:

"The spread of the measurements for sample 1 is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted.
More quantitatively, to establish whether the scatter among the three laboratory means was consistent with their quoted errors, a X2 test was applied to the dates for each sample, in accordance with the recommended procedure of Ward and Wilson
13. The results of this test, given in Table 2, show that it is unlikely that the errors quoted by the laboratories for sample 1 fully reflect the overall scatter. The errors might still reflect the uncertainties in the three dates relative to one another, but in the absence of direct evidence on this, it was decided to give the three dates for sample 1 equal weight in determining the final mean, and to estimate the uncertainty in that mean from the scatter of results." [The '13' after 'Ward and Wilson' is an endnote reference to their paper.]
.......

Thank you for clearing that up - your previous post had intermixed editorialising with partial quoting without apparent distinction. Very confusing.
 
Thank you for clearing that up - your previous post had intermixed editorialising with partial quoting without apparent distinction. Very confusing.

Intentional obfuscation engaged in by authenticists. It is par for the course.

Authenticists only engage here because their preferred echo chamber is defunct.
 
Jabba's the only authenticist here and he was here long, long before the other site shut down.

Ward
 
Hey Jabba, My mother-in-law likes to travel to the holy land. She also likes to make a blood pudding called dinagoong in the Philippines. If she came back with a bolt of linen from Jerusalem, and spilled some dinagoog on it, would that make it 2000 years old?

Actually, it doesn't matter.

She could, of course, tell everybody that it's a holy relic and make a fortune out of visitors - after all, that was likely to have been the point behind the Turin shroud...
 
David Mo:
1) I think you misunderstood what I was saying. No authenticist thinks that the image was formed as a result of wrapping the Shroud closely around the face and body, and the image forming from the contact between the two. As GlennB comments, "because if it was wrapped around his head and the image received by touch it would look silly." Indeed it would, and authenticists are not as silly as some non-authenticists would like them to be.

I was not speaking of “wrapping closely”. I was speaking of an alternative: or the image was in contact with the body or it was floating over the body.
The latter implies a miracle. Cloths don’t float in the air naturally. The first alternative implies that the cloth is in contact with some parts of body. See this examples, please: https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-...AAAAAAAABNg/UnmqfSDmd-4/s400/jacjumperret.jpg, https://sombraenelsudario.files.wordpress.com/2013/01/becario.jpg?w=665&h=852, https://shroud.wikispaces.com/file/view/manikin1.jpg/30123235/388x222/manikin1.jpg. It implies also that the cloth partially wraps the body. First of all, these models don’t avoid the deformations caused when the fabric would be spread. Secondly, the cloth and the body will be in contact with the cloth, specially in those points where the body rests on a slab or other surface. If you are speaking of a big amount of species and balsams (se above in your comment) all the body will shrink into it and the whole back of the corpse would be in contact with the cloth. This is incompatible with the image of the Turin Shroud.

2) I think the trickles of blood in the hair should be a real problem for authenticists. Gilbert Lavoie, with an ingenious experiment detailed at https://www.shroud.com/pdfs/ssi20part4.pdf, thinks that the blood actually trickled down the cheeks, and contacted a closely wrapped Shroud that way, and then the Shroud somehow straightened itself out somewhat, whereupon the image was formed by some form of action at a distance. Most authenticists are no more convinced of this than most non-authenticists. Another explanation is that the hair was so matted that fresh blood from renewed irritation of puncture wounds forced itself through the hair trickled down the matted surface. That's another rather weak explanation, to my mind, but it has been proposed. I don't know of any other ideas.

I was not speaking of Lavoie’s hypothesis. I was speaking of the blood trickles on the back of the head. These are simply impossible.
And I was asking for an experimental ( and visual) demonstration of the process of formation of these trickles.
Your answer eludes the problem.

I postpone our discussion in these points. I don’t like to disperse the debate.
 
Would you mind explaining this bit of apparent petulance? I can't tell if you are actually quoting another person, or using scare quotes to obfuscate.
Yes indeed. The quotation was from MRC Hans's previous comment, in which he suggested that investigating the different views of authenticists and non-authenticists was irrelevant for assessing the authenticity of Shroud, and that I was mixing things up. I'm not wholly sure what he meant by mixing things up, but if he meant that this thread was about assessing the authenticity of the Shroud, then a quick browse though the last thousand comments or so will demonstrate to anybody that he is mistaken, and if he thinks that I am confusing a more psychological overview of what authenticists think with the entertaining (to some) sport of Jabba-bashing, then he is correct. Way back in December 2011, the OP was an open-ended query about whether anybody could see the images in various photos (at http://www.missionoftheshroud.com/miracle-photos/miracle-photos.html) identified by a group called Mission of the Shroud. I joined in April 2013, as an authenticist interested in non-authenticist views, and was persuaded of the non-authenticist position. However, even then the site was mostly dedicated to Jabba-bashing, so I joined shroudstory to try to maintain an objective attitude to the interpretation of the evidence. For a couple of years I have kept a watching brief on this thread, on the off-chance of gleaning new ideas, but there haven't been any, so with the demise of Shroudstory, I thought I'd try and introduce some.

Um, what?
What is the difference between the blood of a tortured creature and that of a non-tortured creature?
I guess Jabba is referring to the lack of potassium found in the 'bloodstains' by the STuRP investigators. Although this is often used as evidence that the stains are not blood at all, it could mean that they are actually made of haemoglobin which has haemolysed (burst out of its red corpuscles) and blended with the plasma, leaving the potassium behind in the corpuscle membranes. This is supposed to occur in cases of severe prolonged trauma such as torture. For what it's worth, the only literature I can find on the subject suggests that extracellular potassium is increased rather than decreased after haemolysis, but I could be mistaken. Alan Adler, who was a porphyrin specialist, in his paper "The Origin and Nature of Blood on the Turin Shroud" (at http://shroud.com/pdfs/ssi43part4.pdf), says:
"But a torture, scourging and crucifixion leading to shock — that would produce a tremendous hemolysis. In less than 30 seconds, the hemolyzed hemoglobin will run through the liver, building up a very high bilirubin content in the blood. If that blood then clots, the exudate forms, and all the intact cells with hemoglobin stay behind, only the hemolyzed hemoglobin goes out along with the serum albumin which binds the bilirubin. So what one ends up with on the cloth is an exudate which has an enhanced bilirubin index with respect to the hemolyzed hemoglobin. You now mix bilirubin which is yellow-orange with methemoglobin in its para-hemic form which is an orangey-brown and you get blood which has a red color.
In fact, we have been able to simulate this spectrum in the laboratory by the process described above. This very strongly suggests that the blood stains are of a man who was severely beaten. No one would have ever dreamed, when we first started doing the analysis, that the chemistry would provide corroborating evidence to what the pathologists concluded long ago about the Shroud figure. The blood has no cells, is very low in potassium, and has the right colour and composition for the blood of a man who was severely flogged and crucified. This is entirely consistent with the forensic evidence."
 
David Mo:

2) I think the trickles of blood in the hair should be a real problem for authenticists. Gilbert Lavoie, with an ingenious experiment detailed at https://www.shroud.com/pdfs/ssi20part4.pdf, thinks that the blood actually trickled down the cheeks,

Something more. The "ingenious" Lavoie's experiment is irrelevant to explain (1) the formation of blood trickles; (2) the transfer of the marks of blood to the cloth from the forehead; (3) the formation of trickles in the back of the head.

The experiment is restricted to the supposition of the position of the frontal blood marks under the the assumption that the cloth was placed on the face, first, and then was flattened while floating impulsed by a miraculous force.

I don't think this is "ingenious" but rather fantastic.
 
Last edited:
Something more. The "ingenious" Lavoie's experiment is irrelevant to explain (1) the formation of blood trickles; (2) the translation of the marks of blood to the cloth from the forehead; (3) the formation of trickles in the back of the head.

The experiment is restricted to the supposition of the position of the frontal blood marks under the the assumption that the cloth was placed on the face, first, and then was flattened while floating impulsed by a miraculous force.

I don't think this is "ingenious" but rather fantastic.
You're quite right, of course. The 'blood in the hair' problem has not been satisfactorily explained by authenticists, even to themselves. But I do think the Lavoie experiment was clever - all that cutting holes in the Shroud and painting the blood through them on to the volunteer; I loved it. But I didn't agree with the conclusion any more than you do.
 
Blood/What difference does it make?

...
ETA: BTW, I have to ask, are you suggesting that there was no torture in the middle ages? Dude, the middle ages are the golden ages of torture!
pgwenthold
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom