John Jones
Penultimate Amazing
Yes, you are: if you're relying on the idea Hugh posted, then you are assuming the existence of blood on the shroud; the only evidence you have of torture is the lack of potassium, which is adequately explained if there is no blood.
To be fair, Jabba is addressing my scenario, where I concede, for the sake of argument, that there is blood in the shroud. So "you haven't established there is blood" is not being fair.
But let's go to the claim. Again, even if we accept the assertion that lack of potassium indicates torture, the argument is that the person who made the shroud would not have used blood from a tortured being. IWhat are the odds? I don't know...what are they? It's a weak argument from incredulity, that's all.
And that is even granting all the premises. That's the best evidence.
Jabba, What you are doing is trying to sneak-by with the insinuation that the only likely source of blood from a traumatized being is a certain 1st century victim of crucifixion.
Don't think we can't see through that ludicrous proposition.
Last edited by a moderator: