Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, you are: if you're relying on the idea Hugh posted, then you are assuming the existence of blood on the shroud; the only evidence you have of torture is the lack of potassium, which is adequately explained if there is no blood.

To be fair, Jabba is addressing my scenario, where I concede, for the sake of argument, that there is blood in the shroud. So "you haven't established there is blood" is not being fair.

But let's go to the claim. Again, even if we accept the assertion that lack of potassium indicates torture, the argument is that the person who made the shroud would not have used blood from a tortured being. IWhat are the odds? I don't know...what are they? It's a weak argument from incredulity, that's all.

And that is even granting all the premises. That's the best evidence.


Jabba, What you are doing is trying to sneak-by with the insinuation that the only likely source of blood from a traumatized being is a certain 1st century victim of crucifixion.

Don't think we can't see through that ludicrous proposition.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
- I'm not begging the question. I'm answering the question. The question I'm currently answering is how the stains being blood would support the claim of authenticity.

My Dear Mr. Savage:

Here is the step you are missing:

Even IF you were able to demonstrate that there was, in fact, actual human blood on the sized and gessoed surface of the CIQ; and,

Even IF you were able to demonstrate that the blood was in an unusual state of traumatic hemolysis, sequestering the expected levels of KCl (and other salts) that would be found in human blood; and,

Even IF the blood were an atypical color for hemolysed blood and blood serum; and,

Even IF the blood were applied to the surface of the CIQ in ways that adhered to the principles of fluid flow, and capillary action, and adsorption, and gravity...

You WOULD NOT EVEN HAVE BEGUN to indicate, in any way, the AGE of the blood.

Unless and until you provide positive evidence that the blood is ~2000 years old, on a cloth that is ALSO ~2000 years old, the question of "authenticity" is moot.

Do you ever intend to provide such evidence?

Through it all, I remain,

Determinedly yours, &ct.
 
- I'm not begging the question. I'm answering the question. The question I'm currently answering is how the stains being blood would support the claim of authenticity.

And your attempt at connecting the presence of blood to the age of the cloth has been suitably addressed by several people. Your ongoing refusal to acknowledge any of the responses constitutes begging of the question.

Quit stalling and address your critics.
 
pgwenthold
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?

The image MUST come from Middle Ages or later since the image on the cloth cannot be older than the cloth itself. They teach you this in first year undergrad archeology right after they tell you no one carries a bullwhip or wears a fedora. The image has a terminus post quem of 1290 CE.
 
And, even if it was blood, why does that make it 2000 years old?

By the magic of "McCrone was wrong." That is, McCrone says the stains are not blood. McCrone says the cloth is only 700 years old. If McCrone is wrong about the blood, then he might also be wrong about the 700-year age. Therefore the must be 2,000 years old, because the critic was proven wrong.

I shouldn't have to explain all that's wrong with the line of reasoning in the paragraph above, but apparently I and several others must -- only to be dutifully ignored by Jabba.
 
Well, I guess, for the sake of argument, one could say that a forger would not have known that 'tortured blood' was chemically different from 'non tortured blood' and would not have bothered using 'tortured blood'.
Assuming it is blood, and it lacks potassium IFF it came from a tortured person.

Quoting myself as devils advocate, kinda want to see someone address this.
 
Of course any competent forger would use blood from a torture victim: how else would you describe someone who has been crucified?

Hey, let's make it simple - how does Jabba know that the cloth isn't just a burial cloth for someone who was crucified in the middle ages?

I can think of lots and lots and lots and lots of reasons, but the problem is that they apply just as easily to it being a burial cloth from 2000 years ago. Actually, being a burial cloth from the middle ages is a lot more consistent with the facts that a burial cloth from 2000 years ago.
 
Quoting myself as devils advocate, kinda want to see someone address this.

Unfortunately for the "authenticist" argument, in vivo hemolysis appears to increase serum potassium levels, as lysis releases intercellular KCl into the plasma.

http://www.biochemia-medica.com/2011/21/79

In other words, if, arguendo (and only arguendo) the stains on the CIQ were, in fact, actual human blood, and the actual human had, in fact, been "tortured" to the point of traumatic hemolysis, the stains should show a higher concentration of KCl. (Think of it this way--hemolysis destroys the red blood cells, and leaves the hemoglobin vulnerable to oxidation and degradation--but it does not, it cannot, remove or destroy elements from the blood aggregate.)

Further--and this bears repeating--none of that has the slightest bearing on the age of the hypothetically hemolysed "blood".
 
Further--and this bears repeating--none of that has the slightest bearing on the age of the hypothetically hemolysed "blood".

Or of the cloth it was shed upon. We're still waiting for that point to be addressed, apparently.

...Why is this thread still alive?
 
Of course any competent forger would use blood from a torture victim: how else would you describe someone who has been crucified?

Also, self-flaggelation wasn't exactly unknown of back in the times. While self inflicted, i would still count that as torture. Not to mention the generally widespread use of torture (compared to today). It should have been rather trivial to procure blood from someone who was tortured to death, if need be.

Also, the idea that artists themselves go to great lengths to make stuff isn't that new either. Heck, even nowdays you have artists that implant all kind of stuff into their bodies for the sake of art.

Greetings,

Chris

ETA: That is, of course, to say that even if one grants the presence of real blood, and that the chemical composition of it indicates torture, it proves exactly nothing w.r.t. the authenticity if that tablecloth.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately for the "authenticist" argument, in vivo hemolysis appears to increase serum potassium levels, as lysis releases intercellular KCl into the plasma.

http://www.biochemia-medica.com/2011/21/79

In other words, if, arguendo (and only arguendo) the stains on the CIQ were, in fact, actual human blood, and the actual human had, in fact, been "tortured" to the point of traumatic hemolysis, the stains should show a higher concentration of KCl. (Think of it this way--hemolysis destroys the red blood cells, and leaves the hemoglobin vulnerable to oxidation and degradation--but it does not, it cannot, remove or destroy elements from the blood aggregate.)

Further--and this bears repeating--none of that has the slightest bearing on the age of the hypothetically hemolysed "blood".

Ah!. Thanks for responding. SCIENCE ROCKS!
 
Evident'y torture also eliminates carbon from the blood. McCrone's EDX spectra of the colorant particles showed no carbon above background.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Unfortunately for the "authenticist" argument, in vivo hemolysis appears to increase serum potassium levels, as lysis releases intercellular KCl into the plasma.

http://www.biochemia-medica.com/2011/21/79

In other words, if, arguendo (and only arguendo) the stains on the CIQ were, in fact, actual human blood, and the actual human had, in fact, been "tortured" to the point of traumatic hemolysis, the stains should show a higher concentration of KCl. (Think of it this way--hemolysis destroys the red blood cells, and leaves the hemoglobin vulnerable to oxidation and degradation--but it does not, it cannot, remove or destroy elements from the blood aggregate.)

Further--and this bears repeating--none of that has the slightest bearing on the age of the hypothetically hemolysed "blood".


Well done, sir.
 
- I'm not begging the question. I'm answering the question. The question I'm currently answering is how the stains being blood would support the claim of authenticity.

We are still waiting for that important bit highlighted above.
 
Since TH Loy's suggestions in the 1990s, the literature seems to have gone quiet about how easy it is to radiocarbon date blood, but if the shroud is stained with any, then it could provide an independent re-assessment of the medieval age of the Shroud. Unfortunately, as with the 1988 dating, any ancient artefact could be contaminated with medieval material (hence the controversy about the cinnabar), while it would be difficult to explain any 1st century material as contamination of a medieval product. If Charles Freeman is correct, and the entire cloth was covered with some sort of size, probably in an organic medium, then a medieval dating of a number of particles of that could be diagnostic, although extracting them would present, I think, currently insuperable difficulties.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom