Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
pgwenthold
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?

False. The blood used does not have to originate from "a tortured creature" at all. It could even be the blood of the artist himself. Or an animal. Anyone can bleed. The notion you are trying to propound is that the artist would have to collect blood from torture victims and it simply is not so.

That you would glom onto that little nugget tells us more about you than the artist.
 
pgwenthold
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?

How does one tell the difference between tortured blood and non tortured blood?
 
pgwenthold
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?

Approximatley 100%. They (the butchered animals) typically had their throats cut.
 
Last edited:
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?


Jabba, you have yet to establish that there is blood on the shroud. Even if you could do that, it isn't evidence for authenticity because blood ha always been available. Blood has also been available without torture. Even if it as only available as a result of torture you would still have nothing beyond an argument from personal incredulity here. How many levels do you want to fail on?
 
pgwenthold
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?

You tell me. You think it was low?
 
Blood/What difference does it make?

Ah, I see: in addition to the other fallacies, Jabba is begging the question.
- I'm not begging the question. I'm answering the question. The question I'm currently answering is how the stains being blood would support the claim of authenticity.
 
pgwenthold
- Apparently, there was lots of torture during that time -- but, what's the likelihood of a middle ages artist using the blood of a tortured creature to paint these particular stains?
I don't think that it was apparently, a quick bit of googling seems to show otherwise. On the big assumption that it was blood, why does it have to be from someone who was tortured. And, even if it was blood, why does that make it 2000 years old?
 
- I'm not begging the question.


Yes, you are: if you're relying on the idea Hugh posted, then you are assuming the existence of blood on the shroud; the only evidence you have of torture is the lack of potassium, which is adequately explained if there is no blood.

The question I'm currently answering is how the stains being blood would support the claim of authenticity.


No, you are not. Your argument from incredulity doesn't remotely show that blood in the shroud would be evidence for authenticity.
 
I don't think that it was apparently, a quick bit of googling seems to show otherwise. On the big assumption that it was blood, why does it have to be from someone who was tortured.


Jabba has previously claimed that an artist who faked the shroud must have been a psychopath. He never backed that claim up either, or explained how it was evidence for authenticity.
 
- I'm not begging the question. I'm answering the question. The question I'm currently answering is how the stains being blood would support the claim of authenticity.

No you're not. You are bogging down in irrelevancies. The presence of blood does not support a 2000 year old CIQ.

Period
 
Yes, you are: if you're relying on the idea Hugh posted, then you are assuming the existence of blood on the shroud; the only evidence you have of torture is the lack of potassium, which is adequately explained if there is no blood.

To be fair, Jabba is addressing my scenario, where I concede, for the sake of argument, that there is blood in the shroud. So "you haven't established there is blood" is not being fair.

But let's go to the claim. Again, even if we accept the assertion that lack of potassium indicates torture, the argument is that the person who made the shroud would not have used blood from a tortured being. IWhat are the odds? I don't know...what are they? It's a weak argument from incredulity, that's all.

And that is even granting all the premises. That's the best evidence.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How does one tell the difference between tortured blood and non tortured blood?

It is the sidonist special pleading that the lack of KCl in the "blood" stains on the sized and gessoed surface of the CIQ "might be" due to traumatic hemolysis (from being tortured). Of course, this completely ignores the effect of such hemolysis on blood color, and blood viscosity, and so on, which must then be addressed with more special pleading...

None of which has any bearing on the age of the "blood" stains.
 
Last edited:
Yes, you are: if you're relying on the idea Hugh posted, then you are assuming the existence of blood on the shroud; the only evidence you have of torture is the lack of potassium, which is adequately explained if there is no blood.

To be fair, Jabba is addressing my scenario, where I concede, for the sake of argument, that there is blood in the shroud. So "you haven't established there is blood" is not being fair.

But let's go to the claim. Again, even if we accept the assertion that lack of potassium indicates torture, the argument is that the person who made the shroud would not have used blood from a tortured being. IWhat are the odds? I don't know...what are they? It's a weak argument from incredulity, that's all.

And that is even granting all the premises. That's the best evidence.

Well, I guess, for the sake of argument, one could say that a forger would not have known that 'tortured blood' was chemically different from 'non tortured blood' and would not have bothered using 'tortured blood'.
Assuming it is blood, and it lacks potassium IFF it came from a tortured person.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Of course any competent forger would use blood from a torture victim: how else would you describe someone who has been crucified?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom