Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
I forget nothing. If Hugh wishes to contradict me by bringing evidence for authenticity, he is welcome to do so. Indeed, that's all we've been asking of authenticists since the beginning.

But it seems harsh to ask Hugh to bring evidence he doesn't believe in, to support of a claim he's not making.

"Undocumented history" was Jabba's evidence. It generated nothing more than a laugh.
 
"Undocumented history" was Jabba's evidence. It generated nothing more than a laugh.
I remember this. But Hugh describes a man, his friend, who is by profession a man of science and reason. According to Hugh, this man has seen a preponderance of evidence in favor of authenticity.

Call it "undocumented history", as Jabba does. Call it Bible stories. Whatever you call it, Hugh's friend has seen *something*. I'd like to know what it is, but I'm not yet to the point of asking Hugh to present it.

As long as Hugh is content to merely explain his friend's reasoning (such as it is) I'm content to say his friend seems like a dunce (profession notwithstanding).

If Hugh decides to *defend* his friend's reasoning or conclusions, then it will be time to put up or shut up.
 
The upper arms are parallel. With the upper arms parallel, there is no way, on an average human body, that the hands could be in the position shown. Note that the upper arms are visible on both side images, indicating that they were supposed to be parallel with the thorax also.
No. The upper arms are not visible on either the ventral or the dorsal image, and cannot be said to be parallel.

You seem to agree that the image doesn't match what one would expect of a dead body lying flat on its back. Rigor mortis, mattresses, beds of spices, etc. are attempts to explain why this is so. It's possible that the body of a crucified person may have undergone cadaveric spasm or rigor mortis, but do we know that it actually happened in this case?
Yes. I do agree that the image could not have derived from a man lying flat on his back. There are plenty of good reasons for why a 1st century Jewish man could have been buried in a more distorted position without involving any peculiar circumstances.

Can you cite the paper in question, and quote here an example of "exactly the same logic" that you find in that paper? I am very curious to see what you mean by this.
The radiocarbon dating paper published in Nature ("Radiocarbon Dating of the Shroud of Turin") acknowledges that the The spread of the measurements for sample 1 [the Shroud] is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted." In order to establish whether this unexpectedness could be quantified statistically, "to establish whether the scatter among the three laboratory means was consistent with their quoted errors, a X2 test was applied to the dates for each sample, in accordance with the recommended procedure of Ward and Wilson 13." The X2 test showed that the difference between the samples was statistically significant, which should not occur in samples from the same material. The resolution was to assume that "The results of this test, given in Table 2, show that it is unlikely that the errors quoted by the laboratories for sample 1 fully reflect the overall scatter." The quoted errors were therefore discarded, and a more satisfactory error range derived from the average and spread of the three overall measurements alone.

I remember this. But Hugh describes a man, his friend, who is by profession a man of science and reason. According to Hugh, this man has seen a preponderance of evidence in favor of authenticity.
I don't want to individualise any particular person's convictions, but my point was slightly different. Authenticists have no different evidence than non-authenticists, in terms of the observations and experimental results related to the Shroud. Where they differ is in the interpretation they put on that evidence, and the conclusions they draw from it. An observation or an experimental result is not 'in favor of' any point of view, and one of the most interesting aspects of Shroud research is that perfectly reasonable people - and not necessarily those with a Christian or Atheist axe to grind - can come to such different conclusions.
 
"Perfectly" reasonable people are going to be able to provide well reasoned arguments for their positions.
 
......

The radiocarbon dating paper published in Nature ("Radiocarbon Dating of the Shroud of Turin") acknowledges that the The spread of the measurements for sample 1 [the Shroud] is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted." In order to establish whether this unexpectedness could be quantified statistically, "to establish whether the scatter among the three laboratory means was consistent with their quoted errors, a X2 test was applied to the dates for each sample, in accordance with the recommended procedure of Ward and Wilson 13." The X2 test showed that the difference between the samples was statistically significant, which should not occur in samples from the same material. The resolution was to assume that "The results of this test, given in Table 2, show that it is unlikely that the errors quoted by the laboratories for sample 1 fully reflect the overall scatter." The quoted errors were therefore discarded, and a more satisfactory error range derived from the average and spread of the three overall measurements alone.

.....

Here's a link to a reprint of the referenced paper, so that one may search for the claimed quotes in that paper:

https://www.shroud.com/nature.htm
 
Last edited:
[..]

I don't want to individualise any particular person's convictions, but my point was slightly different. Authenticists have no different evidence than non-authenticists, in terms of the observations and experimental results related to the Shroud. Where they differ is in the interpretation they put on that evidence, and the conclusions they draw from it. An observation or an experimental result is not 'in favor of' any point of view, and one of the most interesting aspects of Shroud research is that perfectly reasonable people - and not necessarily those with a Christian or Atheist axe to grind - can come to such different conclusions.

The above sounds like something from the Post-Modernist Generator. http://www.elsewhere.org/pomo/

Good luck with that.
 
Jabba wants to be allowed to say that anything that isn't actually incompatible with authenticity is evidence for it.

If Chewbacca lives on Endor, that goes in his pro-authenticity pan.
Chewbacca just visited Endor. He lives on Kashyyyk. << yoinks evidence out of authenticity pan and nerdily places it in medieval forgery pan while pushing up his glasses with his index finger >> :jedi:
 
Yes. No authenticist thinks that the Shroud image was made like that, nor ever has, although it is a common presupposition among non-authenticists that they do.

I absolutely disagree. When the sindonists ask for a replica of the shroud they demand an artifact with the same microscopic features of the Shroud in its present state. See the criticism against Garlaschelli. For example: https://www.shroud.com/pdfs/thibault-lg.pdf
 
Hugh Farey (Yesterday 2:08):

My (obvious) claims are very easy to refute: show it! Garlaschelli and Borrini’s experiment was an easy way to show that the trickles of blood of the Shroud are unnatural. I have challenged many times the sindonists to show something similar with the stains of blood in the back of the head. Without answer. No complex theories, no sophisticated mathematics nor expensive devices are needed. Just a bit of realism.

Here my question, Hugh. Do you know any plausible answer to my request?

Your answer matter much to me, Hugh. Thank you.
 
No. The upper arms are not visible on either the ventral or the dorsal image, and cannot be said to be parallel.

:confused: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9b/Full_length_negatives_of_the_shroud_of_Turin.jpg

Yes. I do agree that the image could not have derived from a man lying flat on his back. There are plenty of good reasons for why a 1st century Jewish man could have been buried in a more distorted position without involving any peculiar circumstances.

Plenty, but had the cloth been wrapped around a body, the image would have been much different. This is the problem: The image does not match the narrative of a shroud, but nicely matches the narrative of an artefact.

The radiocarbon dating paper published in Nature ("Radiocarbon Dating of the Shroud of Turin") acknowledges that the The spread of the measurements for sample 1 [the Shroud] is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted."
*nipped for brevity*
The quoted errors were therefore discarded, and a more satisfactory error range derived from the average and spread of the three overall measurements alone.

The conditions for a C14 analysis were less than optimal. The fabric had a lot of pollution from people touching it, dust, candle soot, etc. Although the samples were cleaned prior to testing, a slightly higher scattter than usual is not unexpected.

Authenticists have no different evidence than non-authenticists, in terms of the observations and experimental results related to the Shroud. Where they differ is in the interpretation they put on that evidence, and the conclusions they draw from it.

Not true. There is a very real differende in the objectivity of the evidence.

An observation or an experimental result is not 'in favor of' any point of view,

It is in favor of a theory.


and one of the most interesting aspects of Shroud research is that perfectly reasonable people - and not necessarily those with a Christian or Atheist axe to grind - can come to such different conclusions.

That might be interesting from a philosophical, psychological, or theological POV, but it is irrelevant for assessing the authenticy of the shroud. You are mixing up things.

Hans
 
Yes. I do agree that the image could not have derived from a man lying flat on his back. There are plenty of good reasons for why a 1st century Jewish man could have been buried in a more distorted position without involving any peculiar circumstances.

"Plenty of good reasons"? What reasons? I don't know any case of a Jewish sepulture (nor any other place) where the corpse was buried in this peculiar position. The position of the corpse is not arbitrary in religion. It is strongly linked to worship traditions. Do you can show some example of this strange position in a Jewish burial? Has the question been posed to an expert?
ADDED: The unique reason to imagine such a strange way to place the corpse is the sindonist need to explain a "natural" position of the hands and the footprint. This is to say, an ad hoc explanation to anomalies of the image. This is to say, to explain an anomaly with more anomalies. A typical feature of the pseudoscience and myth.


I don't want to individualise any particular person's convictions, but my point was slightly different. Authenticists have no different evidence than non-authenticists, in terms of the observations and experimental results related to the Shroud. Where they differ is in the interpretation they put on that evidence, and the conclusions they draw from it. An observation or an experimental result is not 'in favor of' any point of view, and one of the most interesting aspects of Shroud research is that perfectly reasonable people - and not necessarily those with a Christian or Atheist axe to grind - can come to such different conclusions.

A priori neutralism. This is a superficial view over the opposite fields. You can say that some scientists think the Earth is flat and others do not; or some people believe in the fairies while others do not, etc. I repeat: one doctor against nine medicine men. You choose
 
Last edited:
The radiocarbon dating paper published in Nature ("Radiocarbon Dating of the Shroud of Turin") acknowledges that the The spread of the measurements for sample 1 [the Shroud] is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted." In order to establish whether this unexpectedness could be quantified statistically, "to establish whether the scatter among the three laboratory means was consistent with their quoted errors, a X2 test was applied to the dates for each sample, in accordance with the recommended procedure of Ward and Wilson 13." The X2 test showed that the difference between the samples was statistically significant, which should not occur in samples from the same material. The resolution was to assume that "The results of this test, given in Table 2, show that it is unlikely that the errors quoted by the laboratories for sample 1 fully reflect the overall scatter." The quoted errors were therefore discarded, and a more satisfactory error range derived from the average and spread of the three overall measurements alone.
Sorry, you have answered to the sindonist intepretation of this subject in other forum. Are you arguing against yourself? Have you changed your position?

NOTA BENE: The difference of material is not the unique possible cause of the dispersion in the X2 test. (Underline is mine). This test only indicates that the dispersion is not fortuitous. The material is not the only possible factor. A hypothesis in this sense has to be supported by empirical evidence and this is not the case with the "invisible mending" theory. YOu are not supporting the papist-comunist-masonic conspiration of Fray Bruno, I suppose.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, you have answered to the sindonist intepretation of this subject in other forum. Are you arguing against yourself? Have you changed your position?

NOTA BENE: The difference of material is not the unique possible cause of the dispersion in the X2 test. (Underline is mine). This test only indicates that the dispersion is not fortuitous. The material is not the only possible factor. A hypothesis in this sense has to be supported by empirical evidence and this is not the case with the "invisible mending" theory. YOu are not supporting the papist-comunist-masonic conspiration of Fray Bruno, I suppose.

I think we may be in agreement on this point...

I may be a bit dense tonight, as it's post a 2014 shiraz, but after reading the article I'm having trouble locating the claimed quotes within the article - or perhaps I'm confusing Hugh's inline commentary with the quoted snippets.

Call me suspicious, but I'm having a "your article doesn't say what you claim it does" moment (as suggested by my oblique comment further up-thread).
 
:confused: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9b/Full_length_negatives_of_the_shroud_of_Turin.jpg



Plenty, but had the cloth been wrapped around a body, the image would have been much different. This is the problem: The image does not match the narrative of a shroud, but nicely matches the narrative of an artefact.
<snip>

Hans

The only way I can see the image being made from a person, is if the person was this one. That would also explain the small gap between the top of the head in the front and rear views.
 
Chewbacca just visited Endor. He lives on Kashyyyk. << yoinks evidence out of authenticity pan and nerdily places it in medieval forgery pan while pushing up his glasses with his index finger >> :jedi:


Jabba will put that in the pro-authenticity pan because, since it is irrelevant, it is compatible with authenticity.

He's using the Chewbacca defence.
 
Eh? No. you have confused my statement of the authenticist position (that a man in rigor mortis had his hands brought together for burial, whereupon an image was created by contact, vapours, radiation or a miracle) with my disclaimer (I think there was no body at all and the shape of the image depended entirely on the whim of the craftsman who painted, rubbed or imprinted it).

Onk? No.

You have personalized a general reference ("..if one is to indulge...") into a personal reference.

Someone who opines that the "shroud slouch" is caused by the shape of the spine due to cadaveric spasm, or cataleptic paroxysm, or rigor, must deal with the fact that, were the trunk in rigor, the extremities would have been, as well. If such a great deal is made that "the lamb" would have had "none of his bones broken", it is hard to think that those preparing the HJ's body would have broken, or dislocated, the shoulders. Further, the chemical reactions that cause rigor also congeal blood and arrest flow...making the anti-gravity blood representations even more problematic. It is is just another example of the as hoc, piecemeal nature of the special pleading in which many "authenticists" indulge.


I'm not familiar with John Henry's typewriter, and it doesn't appear on Googling. What is it?

"This is the typewriter that John Henry used to win the race with the steam drill in the Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel."

You do realize that John Henry was a parti-mythical figure, right?

"But look: This Royal Standard Portable Typewriter has unusual wear on the "H" and the "J" keys, indicating that John Henry owned it!"

You do realize that Legend says John Henry used a hammer, in the 1890s; that the Royal Standard Portable was not manufactured until 1922; and that the Brookly-Battery Tunnel was dug in 1950, right?

"Well, you can't depend on the legends too much...I want this to be the tool JH used to defeat the evil machine and defend the rights of workers everywhere...look at the wear on the casing! Those have got to be drill marks!"

<snip for focus>
 
Last edited:
Blood/What difference does it make?

Jabba,

Yes, one step at a time. You keep jumping around which is why I asked my question. You brought up the topic of determining the age of the shroud. You said that you would do this by starting with the blood. So I asked how does the presence of blood help to determine the age of the shroud. Discrediting McCrone doesn't help to put a date to the shroud.

There should be nothing to track down. Since you decided to start with the blood you must know why you decided to start here.

I'll ask again. How does the presence of blood help to determine the age of the shroud?

Thank you.
- Yeah. That was my first step.

- McCrone's testimony has been used as a significant part of the evidence against authenticity and a 2000 year age. But, McCrone insisted that there was no blood on the shroud -- and if there is blood on the shroud, there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony...
- Then, there is evidence/weight in the authentic/2000 yr pan (the STURP results for instance), and as the inauthentic/700 yr claim looses weight the tilt of the scale would change in the direction of authenticity/2000 yrs. Not that the tilt would now favor authenticity/2000 yrs -- just that the shift would be in that direction.

- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature. How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?
 
Last edited:
-
- Next, if there is blood on the Shroud, it appears to be from a tortured creature. How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?

Um, what?

What is the difference between the blood of a tortured creature and that of a non-tortured creature?

ETA: BTW, I have to ask, are you suggesting that there was no torture in the middle ages? Dude, the middle ages are the golden ages of torture!
 
Last edited:
...there is reason to withdraw at least some general credit (and weight) from McCrone's testimony.

No. "General credit" is not a concept in evidence-based argumentation.

[A]s the inauthentic/700 yr claim looses weight the tilt of the scale would change in the direction of authenticity/2000 yrs.

Asked and answered. You cannot make a "preponderance of evidence" argument with nothing in the affirmative evidence pan. You're still stuck trying to undermine other people's evidence and mistakenly calling that evidence in favor of your belief.

How likely is it that a medieval artist would use the blood of a tortured creature to paint Jesus' blood stains?

Very. Even in medieval times it was common sense that nothing appears better like a substance than the substance. Even human blood would have been easily accessible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom